Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if junior football is nepo baby land?

32 replies

Goldenboot · 29/01/2023 13:09

Son age 11 is reasonably good at football. Always been in top team at v competitive school. Not pretending he’s premier league but people have suggested he goes down academy route at times. As a family we have had too much going on to really pursue it. For many years he played in an informal team which is not part of a league.

We are foreign, didn’t grow up here so have probably not done the research required or got the inside knowledge about the politics of junior football!

It seems to be nearly impossible to navigate the trial dates etc and different teams locally.

He outgrew the non-league team a while ago but we only just found a club for him to join a few miles away quite recently.

From the moment he joined, there was a bit of a lingering vibe of resentment that an ‘outsider’ had got in while others who had been in team didn’t make it this year to match squad.

There have been a couple of snide comments from the assistant coach that DS is at independent school. We laughed it off and have done nothing but thank this coach and others for their help and time. DH has driven half an hour out of his way many times to give lifts to other boys etc when others didn’t step up who lived closer so it is not like we are not trying to help. Signed up to help at stalls on open days etc.

Several weeks ago, it transpired that this coach had lost the registration card for DS so we had to provide all the info again. He was not allowed to play for several matches.

It happens. I have ADHD so I can relate to losing things!

But now I’m wondering if there is a bit of an attempt to block DS? All three coaches have got their sons in the match squad. One of the coach’s son is good, the others are really below par. Their sons seem to get more games than others. By the way, this team has won nearly all their games this season when DS is playing but are in the bottom division which most of the parents didn’t even realise.

It is clear to nearly all the other parents that DS is one of the top 3 players but he has got man of the match once, other quite terrible players have had it several times.

I would like to think it’s because they’re trying to be inclusive but the poor judgement calls and lack of strategic direction says otherwise.

We paste on smiles and encourage the others and play it down with our son. He is always humble as I have drilled into DC that no one likes a boaster and that he is privileged and must never rest on his laurels. He can always do better.

DH was very sporty (Was on course to being pro in another sport before injury blew him off course). Basically, he is very tough on DS but he is dismayed at the treatment of DS and one or two other good players.

I am trying to encourage DH to become a coach as he could do better for the whole team not just DS but suspect he will not be welcomed!

Is junior football always so political? What are we doing wrong? I haven’t let any of these thoughts be known to other parents so am venting here as I know how bad it can sound said out loud.

We will trial him for other clubs but is there any point if all junior football teams are full of coaches and their nepo babies getting favorable treatment or inverted snobbery towards indy school kids?

Has anyone got good experience of junior football at this age (tweens/early teens)?

Should we push for an academy or hope he is discovered somewhere by scouts or is he too old?

I am very worried that he’s showing a real aptitude for rugby (top player in his year at school that favours rugby) and both of us are not keen due to DH disastrous injuries from this at top level.

Football feels far safer.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
trustingsurvivor · 12/07/2023 05:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

RedHelenB · 30/01/2023 07:30

My ds plays football and honestly he knows how good all his age group and year above and below are and so do his friends. And the coaches of the various teams. As he gets known boys will ask him to join their team
You do seem to be coming across a bit like your son is too good for the team, even if he is he will still be learning at the team he's st. Let him see the season out, and then look at attending some training sessions over the summer at teams that are higher up in the division. If he's as good as you think he'll be snapped up.

Toddlingturtle · 30/01/2023 07:27

RLScott · 29/01/2023 23:23

Lowering the tackle height is beyond silly. It means putting your head/neck in the path of oncoming thighs running at you.

A collision based sport with a greater emphasis on size than ever, rugby is exceptionally dangerous. The increase in bulk size over the last two decades (kids downing protein shakes and constantly hitting the gym) makes collisions mini car crashes. Most of the growing number of lawsuits deal with players who have played in this era (players in the late 30s/early 40s)... older players from before this era are largely healthy as they were more normal sized thus the impact was far less severe than it is now.

Besides becoming more dangerous to play, rugby is also much less enjoyable to watch as the increased bulk now makes 30 players on the field far too many. The game is unrecognisable from the one I grew up watching. There’s now no star players (household names) as it’s a lot harder for individuals to stand out now with the game being much more physical/brutish and attritional with much less space to make line breaks.

Physical activity is obviously good, but no sane parent with a choice of sports would put their kid anywhere near modern rugby.

I agree. I am amazed people are still encouraging their kids to play rugby. My kids London independent hasn’t played rugby for years and there are other independent schools (Highgate / city) who don’t play and other schools should be following in my opinion.

SnowyPetals · 30/01/2023 06:15

Grassroots football relies on parent volunteers to function. They are not angels and they are not perfect - of course their main motivation to give up all this time is because their own son is interested, and no, they don't always pick man of the match perfectly etc. If you think your DS is too good for the team (which loads of parents do, by the way, makes managing the team a right PITA at times) then seek out other opportunities.

YetiTeri · 30/01/2023 05:53

I'm agog at all the resentment against coaches children in this thread. Do people have any idea how much time goes into being a VOLUNTEER football coach? There should be some perks over the parents who rock up on matchday and seeth about their PFB on the sideline not getting everything their way.

OP academics are highly competitive, and kids are picked up from a very young age. It's unlikely your DS will be able to stroll into one now. Contact all the clubs near you, ask if there will be trials. Look on the FA website, all tables and results are published - you'll see the level each team is at. Other parents have already done that graft that's how they know what teams are the best. Probably the parents in your DS's team do know which league they're in but they know they're in the right league for the kids.

YerAWizardHarry · 29/01/2023 23:50

My DSS just turned 7 and the favouritism is honestly a bit sickening even at his age. Coaches son getting off with murder constantly, very little in the way of sportsmanship (literally just shoots at goal whenever he has the ball). DSS hasn’t noticed quite yet but I think he will soon…

RLScott · 29/01/2023 23:44

Goldenboot · 29/01/2023 21:58

Thanks @edwinbear. Will those rules make it a lot safer? I’m really worried/paranoid about the link between dementia and MND and rugby.
DS is the only one who tackles in his team and annoyingly, while he lacks the killer instinct in football, he seems to throw himself literally into rugby. He is definitely built more like a footballer though so am worried about what happens when they play big name schools who will literally source pupils from around the world to join their schools and teams.

Per previous, avoid rugby like the plague.

While rugby is getting more dangerous (as the plethora of lawsuits taken out by players who are only in their 30s/40s will testify), football is the complete opposite with it being safer than previous.

Heading is now minimal (if not nonexistent) at youth level (no spending 30 minutes doing heading practice, nor having a ball tied to a rope and jumping up to head it repeatedly as Geoff Hurst did). The game is overwhelming played on the ground now.
Any minimal heading there is, the balls are much lighter and aerodynamic (also no water soaked heavy balls that were akin to heading a brick).
Players are now also far more protected by referees from tackles than previous.

Messi has gone through almost two decades without a serious injury. That could have never have happened in the generations before him (Maradona was hacked repeatedly as you got away with a lot without being penalised).

Goldenboot · 29/01/2023 23:28

Thanks @OneMomentPlease. The parents at the club are fine. They’re a nice bunch really. Nobody shouts at the coaches or kids. The coaches do not seem mean. It’s just not overly friendly and a bit sort of passive-aggressive/aloof. They are not overly fussed on DS and seem to highlight players who don’t actually put in the effort. Had to chuckle when one coach - whose son is probably the worst in the team for messing around and skills - said ‘ooh your DS is actually getting quite good now thanks to being in this team’. Er… They also don’t seem to tell the kids which matches are more important eg there was a crucial one this weekend and while the parents were aware, this didn’t necessarily get filtered down to the children. Interesting that rugby is a friendlier sport despite being ‘posher’. It’s definitely not the same where I come from and football is seen as much more mellow.

OP posts:
RLScott · 29/01/2023 23:23

edwinbear · 29/01/2023 22:18

www.englandrugby.com/news/article/rfu-council-approves-lowering-of-the-tackle-height-across-community-rugby-in-england-2023

@Goldenboot statement from the RFU above, but essentially, they are lowering the tackle height to below the waist, specifically to combat the issues regarding head injuries and concussion. There has been huge debate about it over the last couple of weeks and the communication from the RFU has been pretty poor. However, this is something that was introduced in France in 2019 and the overwhelming evidence is that it has made the game much safer. We had a kid from France join our U14 team this season and Dad is very much in favour - the kid is also a fantastic tackler.

It also means the game will become faster, more running, more passing, less kicking. My DS is fast, fit but quite slight, so plays on the wing, it sounds like your DS is similar? So for these boys, it will be a huge improvement, less so for the bigger, front/second row, especially those who are very tall and will struggle to get low enough to tackle the smaller kids round the waist. Our French dad says it took some adjustment for players/coaches/refs to adjust but he feels it was very much worth it for the improved safety.

Lowering the tackle height is beyond silly. It means putting your head/neck in the path of oncoming thighs running at you.

A collision based sport with a greater emphasis on size than ever, rugby is exceptionally dangerous. The increase in bulk size over the last two decades (kids downing protein shakes and constantly hitting the gym) makes collisions mini car crashes. Most of the growing number of lawsuits deal with players who have played in this era (players in the late 30s/early 40s)... older players from before this era are largely healthy as they were more normal sized thus the impact was far less severe than it is now.

Besides becoming more dangerous to play, rugby is also much less enjoyable to watch as the increased bulk now makes 30 players on the field far too many. The game is unrecognisable from the one I grew up watching. There’s now no star players (household names) as it’s a lot harder for individuals to stand out now with the game being much more physical/brutish and attritional with much less space to make line breaks.

Physical activity is obviously good, but no sane parent with a choice of sports would put their kid anywhere near modern rugby.

Youdoyoubabe · 29/01/2023 22:58

Football is a pretty bitchy sport. Rugby is more friendly really. More head injuries though.

OneMomentPlease · 29/01/2023 22:53

Head of Football at school will be able to tell you which local leagues and then clubs are the highest standards so that you can target those, it’s a minefield if you’re new to the area and everyone else seems to have an innate knowledge! The majority of leagues play on a Sunday so ok for school.

With the move to 11 a side, match length increases so more potential game time, but the main advantage is that teams have to take on new players (most 9 a side teams prob have 12ish in the squad and will increase to 15-16ish eg), so there will be lots of open trials at the end of this season (presuming he’s U12 now).

In terms of knowing if the team is right for him, maybe go and watch a match, see how the coach is with the kids, if they play the way your son wants to play, if the parents yell at the ref etc. You’ll get an idea of the culture. If he’s moving to a different league a new manager might consider letting him train with them whilst he’s still signed for the other club.

Also, a PP mentioned selective academies at grassroots level. A lot of premier clubs have these and they can be a useful way of seeing where your son fits relative to other keen players in the area, again there will probably be open trials.

I’m with you on the rugby/injuries, although people who know rugby tell me it’s no worse than football. Good luck!

edwinbear · 29/01/2023 22:32

archive.ph/ogtDn

Analysis from trials showing head to head contact per game falling from 9.5 to 3.5.

edwinbear · 29/01/2023 22:18

www.englandrugby.com/news/article/rfu-council-approves-lowering-of-the-tackle-height-across-community-rugby-in-england-2023

@Goldenboot statement from the RFU above, but essentially, they are lowering the tackle height to below the waist, specifically to combat the issues regarding head injuries and concussion. There has been huge debate about it over the last couple of weeks and the communication from the RFU has been pretty poor. However, this is something that was introduced in France in 2019 and the overwhelming evidence is that it has made the game much safer. We had a kid from France join our U14 team this season and Dad is very much in favour - the kid is also a fantastic tackler.

It also means the game will become faster, more running, more passing, less kicking. My DS is fast, fit but quite slight, so plays on the wing, it sounds like your DS is similar? So for these boys, it will be a huge improvement, less so for the bigger, front/second row, especially those who are very tall and will struggle to get low enough to tackle the smaller kids round the waist. Our French dad says it took some adjustment for players/coaches/refs to adjust but he feels it was very much worth it for the improved safety.

Goldenboot · 29/01/2023 22:16

I SO wish he was good at tennis or golf to see me through my retirement! Alas, it’s not happening 😅

OP posts:
Toddlingturtle · 29/01/2023 22:13

In my experience of academy and high level grass roots leagues that’s football. It’s less about the kids and often about the parents who shout the loudest. It’s a bit better when they’re a bit older but it’s very political and cliquey. It’s also amazing and a brilliant thing for them to do

Toddlingturtle · 29/01/2023 22:11

edwinbear · 29/01/2023 18:39

Honestly, if he’s at a private school, I’d prioritise rugby. Far less politics and the rules are changing next year to make it much safer.

So would I especially with all the long term terrible impact of rugby and the number of players with Mnd and other neurological conditions. Terrible sport. Stick to football.

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 29/01/2023 22:05

If he's good at football, I suspect he's more likely to be in the back row on the rugby pitch. Outside half should be a fairly safe position to play. 😉

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 29/01/2023 22:01

Go for rugby if he's good at it. It'll be far more disciplined, friendlier, and less shouty. There'll be the odd twat, but you get those everywhere. It feels scarier to watch, but it's more fun!

Goldenboot · 29/01/2023 21:58

Thanks @edwinbear. Will those rules make it a lot safer? I’m really worried/paranoid about the link between dementia and MND and rugby.
DS is the only one who tackles in his team and annoyingly, while he lacks the killer instinct in football, he seems to throw himself literally into rugby. He is definitely built more like a footballer though so am worried about what happens when they play big name schools who will literally source pupils from around the world to join their schools and teams.

OP posts:
Goldenboot · 29/01/2023 21:54

Wow so many tips and insights! Thank you. @RedHelenB I don’t think he would be noticed as they’re in a rubbish division so no one serious will be observing. There is a high chance he’s not good enough but I would like him to be in a team that’s more his level. How do you know in advance whether it will be a club where he gets on with the coaches etc? He’s very amenable and good natured. Certainly doesn’t get it from his stroppy mum!

And thank you for that lovely message @Murdoch1949 . That’s very kind.

Every bit of that advice is great @OneMomentPlease . Great advice to ask the school. They have a head of football who should know (though apparently they get annoyed if you prioritise club sports over Saturday school fixtures which begin in earnest next year!). What impact does moving to 11 a side have? New kids joining? More game time as more spaces to fill?

OP posts:
whirlyswirly · 29/01/2023 20:43

Ds is in his final year of all this and I was saying today that tbh I'm really glad.

The politics in his current club are exhausting. He just wants to enjoy playing. I'm sick of trekking around the county every Sunday for him to get 20 minutes match time some weeks.

Today we've had a load of argy bargy in the parents WhatsApp group so we'll soon be letting them know we're out. He's going to join his college team instead.

edwinbear · 29/01/2023 18:39

Honestly, if he’s at a private school, I’d prioritise rugby. Far less politics and the rules are changing next year to make it much safer.

Oodieoodieoodie · 29/01/2023 18:33

IME that coaches kids always get to play, that’s one of (few) perks… doesn’t make it right/fair though. I’ve seen amazing coaches on weaker teams, and rubbish ones on better teams… it’s awful when the coaches have favourites/least favourites… we’ve been on the end of it at times and just encouraged DC to do their best and pretend we haven’t noticed. I doubt they will want your DH involved if there’s already 3 coaches but might be worth an ask…

Murdoch1949 · 29/01/2023 18:28

I hope your son is really enjoying his football, you sound like very supportive parents. I am afraid that junior football is frequently full of nepotism, with coaches ' children rarely being dropped, often player of the week etc. It is true that the coaches give up their own time, but that does not give free passes to their children. If there is not another more suitable club for your son you will have to just continue as you have been. As your son is good, they will want to keep him in the side. Continue as you have been, supportive of your son & the club, cream always rises!

OneMomentPlease · 29/01/2023 17:46

Find a better club. At U13 they’ll be moving up to 11 a side so there’s lots of movement as teams have to increase squad size.

If he’s academy level the scouts will find him, but scouts are more likely to be at the matches of successful teams (cup winners etc).

It’s worth bearing in mind that lots of local soccer schools call themselves academies but have nothing to do with professional football clubs. Rule of thumb is that if you’re paying for it, it’s not an academy.

It’s also not typical that parents/coaches won’t be welcoming, it sounds perhaps your son is seen as a bit of a threat and they want to ‘keep him in his place’, it won’t be the same when he’s playing with boys of the same level.

You can also ask his school about trials for district football, probably too late for this year but will help you understand the process for next season.

Swipe left for the next trending thread