Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To NOT leave rented house when I said I would?

769 replies

WaitingForLifeToGetEasier · 29/01/2023 12:11

Been in current rented house for 9 years. Landlord is a company with 30+ properties.

Tenancy is generally renewed every year as LL puts rent up.

Last year, less than 6 months into our latest year long tenancy agreement, an estate agent contacted me out of the blue saying he'd been instructed to sell the property so I needed to agree to a time for them to value and take photos as well for viewings.

I was shocked as LL has not said anything and it transpired that the letting agent has added a 6 month break clause into the tenancy agreement. There had never been one In previous agreements and I wasn't made aware.

I made it clear i was not going to allow anyone in the property until the end of the agreement and if the landlord wanted to sell, I'd leave at that time.

Tenancy is up in early March. I had expected to get a Section 21 in early January but nothing.

We have been looking but properties are either not available anymore or agent doesn't get back to us so have not found a property yet. Rents seem to have gone up £3-400 a month which is going to be impossible.

Not sure if LL is just expecting us to leave or what but I am not intending to leave in early March and will stay as long as possible - await section 21 etc.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Notanevillamdlord · 29/01/2023 14:27

Op: A simple phone call to the agency tomorrow should tell you all that you need to know.

Why speculate when a mere phone call can clear up the confusion?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 14:26

@Autumntimeagain

OP why the hell do you think that somehow your convenience trumps the house owners rights ??

House owner doesn’t have a legal right to do viewings. Tenant has a legal right to refuse viewings. That’s way

Are you deluded in some way ?

Lol, ironic from someone who has made up tenancy laws in their head

It doesn't matter one single iota whether your landlord is rich or poor, the house belongs to them !

They have decided to stop leasing the property, and can do what they like with it ffs because it's theirs !

They really can’t. There are laws and processes to follow.

You’re welcome.

Everyonehasavoice · 29/01/2023 14:26

Aurorabored · 29/01/2023 14:21

If it’s a fixed term tenancy, they can’t use a section 21 until the fixed term tenancy ends in early March.

A section 21 must be issued at least 2 months before the LL wants his property back.

It can be issued during tenancy period.
If it isn’t then technically a new tenancy agreement cannot take place as you’d have to issue a new tenancy agreement with the section 21 or the tenant is basically living in the property without a tenancy agreement.

If a section 21 is issued now LL has to wait 2 months

Dagnabit · 29/01/2023 14:25

To sum up the thread -
OP - AIBU?
Lots of posters - Yes, YABU.
OP - You’re all thick and batshit!

Scirocco · 29/01/2023 14:25

I'd suggest that communication mighty be important here. Speak with your letting agent and/or landlord. Find out what the current situation is, if they expect your tenancy agreement to end and when, and if needed, whether they're able to advise of any suitable alternative properties within your budget. If you can't afford the current market rates for renting, you need to urgently get this information from them so that you can find out what your options are re: social housing, relocating, etc. Once you've got that information, speak with Shelter and your local Housing services.

You might need to stay until formally evicted in order to be considered for social housing, but even in that scenario, communication and maintaining civil relations will be important - you'll still need references after all!

It might be worth asking Shelter about your position on allowing viewings, to make sure that's a hill you really are prepared to die on. I don't know the specific legalities for wherever you are, but refusing might be using up some goodwill you might want to reserve for later when you might really need it.

ReneBumsWombats · 29/01/2023 14:25

I've read all OP's posts but I can't see details of when this new clause was inserted. If it was before you signed - ie, you signed it and just missed that it was now there - then it's hard to see how you could argue against it, sneaky as it is. Would it have done you any good if you'd spotted it and contested it? Presumably he'd have just evicted you sooner.

I'm not without sympathy but forcing your own eviction is only going to harm you in the end. It won't be anything more than a minor inconvenience for him.

Knoblauch · 29/01/2023 14:23

boboshmobo · 29/01/2023 14:05

@Knoblauch I'm far from thick , the op stated in one post that she may have missed a letter .
I've never rented in my life so wouldn't know this ..

Obvs didn't read the whole thread , who even ever has time for that anyways 🤷‍♀️

I didn't say you were thick. Plenty of people on the thread are being thick though, and spouting incorrect information.

If you don't know what you're talking about, best not to advise incorrectly.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 14:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@FrodisCapering in what way has she had notice?

uhtredsonofuhtred1 · 29/01/2023 14:22

Itsnotalternateuniverses · 29/01/2023 13:44

The current waiting times for eviction noticed being granted through the courts is about 18 months. The liklihood of injunctions / evictions being granted at the moment is miniscule.

Not in my area, it's about 6 to 8 weeks if this is the first hearing. If there's already been a heating it's 10-14 days (not working days either!)

Aurorabored · 29/01/2023 14:21

If it’s a fixed term tenancy, they can’t use a section 21 until the fixed term tenancy ends in early March.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 14:20

RunningFromInsanity · 29/01/2023 12:16

I think it’s a dick thing to do.
As long as you have been given the contracted amount of notice, why do you think you have the right to stay in someone else’s property?

I hate it when MN recommends staying until Sec 21, eviction etc.

She hasn't been given notice in the absence of a formal notice, has she? For all she knows, landlord no longer wants to sell.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 29/01/2023 14:20

The landlord could have informed you himself of his intentions. He chose not to and went along the formal route

FFS can people not read? THE LL HAS NOT GONE THE FORMAL ROUTE. THE OP HAS NOT BEEN GIVEN NOTICE TO LEAVE.

Malbecfan · 29/01/2023 14:18

OP, due to the nonsense so-called advice from many on here, can I respectfully suggest that you head over to MSE's Buying, Selling and Renting forum where there are knowledgeable posters who can help you.

I seem to remember from reading there that whilst your contract may state that you have to allow viewings in the final 2 months, your Common Law right to Quiet Enjoyment trumps that. As one erudite poster there used to type: "the contract could say I have to wear purple on Mondays, but it's completely unenforceable".

DeFacto · 29/01/2023 14:17

Odd thread, there seems to be some confusion about what an S21 actually is. An S21 is always served when a landlord wishes to reclaim a property. This is a legal requirement. The tenant then has two months to leave the property. If, by the end if that period, the tenant has not left, then the landlord can then enforce eviction through the courts.

OP has had no S21, therefore no formal notice to leave the property, any phone conversations etc are irrelevant.

In your position OP, I'd contact the agent for clarification, if the landlord wants you to leave, wait for your S21, then you have a definite timescale.

RichardMarxisinnocent · 29/01/2023 14:17

Yes there may be rights to refuse viewings, and play hard ball over paperwork, and refuse to leave until you're legally evicted and legally speaking that's your "right".

The OP is not waiting to be evicted before leaving. She hasn't been served notice to leave, thus not only does she not have to leave, she has no idea if the LL still want her to leave,and if she does leave without having had notice she will still be liable to pay rent.

Rosebel · 29/01/2023 14:16

If your landlord has multiple properties is there a chance he'll l rent you another one or is he selling all of them? I'd ask as this may be a possibility.
Are you on council house waiting list? The lists are long but if you are going to be homeless they usually will find you somewhere but they won't without the section 21. And if you leave before that they will say you've deliberately made yourself homeless.
It's fine for people to say just leave when you're supposed to but you can't leave if you've nowhere to go.

JudgeRudy · 29/01/2023 14:16

The landlord could have informed you himself of his intentions. He chose not to and went along the formal route. I'm not sure I would force someone to evict me however I would not be packed up and ready to go in March (unless you've found something else). I would just pay my rent as usual and see what happens, but ultimately you're gonna have to go. In the meantime I'd be looking hard for alternative accommodation including speaking with your letting agent who will (hopefully) know you have been a good tenant and be eager to keep you as a customer.

It's unfortunate, but it's your problem. Don't make it someone else's.

StalkedByASpider · 29/01/2023 14:15

Twillow · 29/01/2023 14:10

Blimey OP sounds like hard work.
Just because the landlord is wealthy doesn't mean you are entitled to try and screw him over. And as many people have said, you're cutting off your nose to spite your face because you'll end up without a reference.

I thought this. Initially I felt quite sorry for them, but they sound thoroughly unpleasant, entitled, and rude.

Of course she shouldn't make herself homeless by leaving without somewhere to go. But blaming the landlord for her failure to read the contract she signed and then being as obstructive as possible isn't going to help her, ultimately. Far better to check the situation and try to negotiate an extension than to destroy her chance of a good reference and make the move even more stressful.

HamBone · 29/01/2023 14:15

@justasking111 Based on your experience, would you then advise the OP NOT to follow up on the S21? I said the opposite, but you’re more knowledgeable.

My fear would be that it’s been issued and I’d missed it somehow. But perhaps it’s better not to.

Crikeyalmighty · 29/01/2023 14:15

@WaitingForLifeToGetEasier just tell the landlord May suits you more- it's unlikely they would sell and get all legal a through by May at the earliest - I would cooperate and try for a compromise even if you are peeved (as I would be if the 6 month break clause had been sneaked in without mention. ).

Everyonehasavoice · 29/01/2023 14:14

WaitingForLifeToGetEasier · 29/01/2023 13:48

Christ, it's amazing people come on here to reply to posts when they don't even have simple reading comprehension skills.

Don't know where you got November from? If you read my post I said an EA contacted me less than 6 months into current year long tenancy agreement which ends this March.

I was contacted last August to say LL was selling and informing me of the break clause that had been sneakily inserted, the day before we were due to go on a long saved for holiday which was totally ruined! I had assumed we were 'safe' until the following March and would never have booked a holiday if I'd thought we may have had to move in the next few months.

LL obviously wanted us to bear the stress and inconvenience of viewings and wasn't going to issue a section 21 until he's got a buyer.

I asked if he would reduce the rent for the viewings but he said No, there was no legal reason to do I told him I wouldn't allow access.

Rent has always been paid on time and house is immaculate. LL had done no general maintenance in 9 years and has constantly put off doing essential repairs. Front door locking mechanism went once so it couldn't be locked and was a composite door so couldn't drill a bolt in it. He was unbothered about us having to put heavy furniture in front of it (fire risk) for a week until I got a locksmith out myself and took it off the rent.

He's worth at least £50 million (in news). House has increased by £150k since we moved in and we've paid £140k in rent. Nice little earner huh!

OP
clearly you’ve had problems in the past with your tenancy but
your para 3
its your responsibility to check the tenancy agreement. Whether it’s convenient for you or not
Your para 4
landlord needs to issue a section 21,
Your para 5
LL doesn’t have to reduce rent to allow for viewings
Your para 6
All tenants should pay rent on time but equally LL should keep property well maintained, if the landlord is not doing this tenants should contact agency and suggest a rental reduction or do the work themselves and take the cost out of the rent. ( this usually does the job) but get agreement first.
Your para 7
irrelevant

justasking111 · 29/01/2023 14:14

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 29/01/2023 14:11

Yes there may be rights to refuse viewings, and play hard ball over paperwork, and refuse to leave until you're legally evicted and legally speaking that's your "right".

But on the other hand, if you are planning on renting again in the future, do you really want to get a reputation for being awkward and confrontational, constantly going on about how you "know your rights" and forcing your landlord to do the formal eviction?

It's like job hunting - what would you rather have on your CV as a reason to leave - negotiated an exit with prior employer, or fired?

To be honest if the tenants I'm trying to get out continue to pay their rent in a timely manner they'll get a good reference because that's what landlords are interested in

Teentrauma · 29/01/2023 14:13

Sounds like they were waiting to find a buyer before issuing the S21, given that sales typically take at least 2 months to go through. Shame they didn't explain that to you. Although, if you're refusing viewings, they're not going to get a buyer, so surprised they haven't gone ahead and issued the notice anyway. If no notice has been served at the end of the fixed term in March, it will roll over into a periodic tenancy where the landlord must still give you 2 months notice via a S21 but you only need give the Landlord 1 month. Have a chat with the agent and find out what the intentions are. The sales market is crap atm so they may give up on selling and offer to renew your contract (assuming you want to stay) so staying on the right side of them is a good plan. The lettings market is brutal at the moment with many applicants chasing few properties and rents being pushed up. It's so difficult for both tenants & landlords. Many landlords are wanting to sell up as all their costs are soaring too.

WaitingForLifeToGetEasier · 29/01/2023 14:12

ViridissimaVirga · 29/01/2023 14:06

I hate landlords

Really, @Babyroobs? All of them?

@WaitingForLifeToGetEasier I'm a LL, and you can wait for your LL to serve S21 notice, assuming you genuinely have had no written notice up to this point. However, all you are doing is postponing the inevitable. If he wants to sell, he will sell. He won't want a void (which is probably why he hasn't issued you with an S21 yet), but if he really is a millionaire (or multi millionaire, as his wealth seems to be inflated with every post), then he can cover that.

What I don't really get is why you haven't asked the agent exactly what's going on. The LL isn't going to have changed his mind since August, so you really need to be looking elsewhere. I think it's very petty of you not to allow viewings, because - again - it's not going to change anything about whether or not you can stay in the house. You do run the risk of not being given a decent reference, as a pissed-off LL could just say you were "obstructive" (rightly or wrongly, and depending on how nice or otherwise they are).

Other than that: being a millionaire is not a crime. Owning more than one property is not a crime. Most LLs are not remotely millionaires. I am a LL because I have no pension after having to give up my job for reasons not relevant to this thread. The OP's LL could be the richest man in the world, and he would still have a right to sell his own property.

In future, OP should also make sure she actually reads a tenancy agreement before signing it. There was nothing "sneaky" about introducing a break clause; it was there for her to see in black and white, had she chosen to read what she was signing.

How is it petty not to allow viewings? I work from home, have a disabled DC at home and another one with a life threatening health condition who needs regular hospital checkups.

Why should I have to deal with appointments for viewings and have strangers coming into my HOME for the landlords benefit when it wasn't even in my tenancy agreement?!

Batshit, seriously!

OP posts:
RichardMarxisinnocent · 29/01/2023 14:12

deliciouschilli · 29/01/2023 14:04

Your tenancy ends in March. If you do not leave you will be evicted. You will find it very difficult to rent without a reference or with a very bad reference saying you had to be evicted.
If you have a good record of renting for 9 years I would not destroy that.

Could you please explain why you think the OP must leave in March and will be evicted if she does not leave?

Swipe left for the next trending thread