Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To NOT leave rented house when I said I would?

769 replies

WaitingForLifeToGetEasier · 29/01/2023 12:11

Been in current rented house for 9 years. Landlord is a company with 30+ properties.

Tenancy is generally renewed every year as LL puts rent up.

Last year, less than 6 months into our latest year long tenancy agreement, an estate agent contacted me out of the blue saying he'd been instructed to sell the property so I needed to agree to a time for them to value and take photos as well for viewings.

I was shocked as LL has not said anything and it transpired that the letting agent has added a 6 month break clause into the tenancy agreement. There had never been one In previous agreements and I wasn't made aware.

I made it clear i was not going to allow anyone in the property until the end of the agreement and if the landlord wanted to sell, I'd leave at that time.

Tenancy is up in early March. I had expected to get a Section 21 in early January but nothing.

We have been looking but properties are either not available anymore or agent doesn't get back to us so have not found a property yet. Rents seem to have gone up £3-400 a month which is going to be impossible.

Not sure if LL is just expecting us to leave or what but I am not intending to leave in early March and will stay as long as possible - await section 21 etc.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
HikingforScenery · 29/01/2023 15:20

Do you have a link to any upcoming tenants’ rights please?

afinishedkiss · 29/01/2023 15:20

Or he could let her know what he wants to do since it’s him who apparently wants to change things…

It affects her more, why live in limbo? Absolutely ridiculous.

Nocutenamesleft · 29/01/2023 15:20

WaitingForLifeToGetEasier · 29/01/2023 14:01

Also clearly stated in the tenancy agreement that I only had to allow valuations and viewings in the last 2 months of the tenancy. Last August there was another 7 months of the tenancy to run.

So you’ve to allow viewings from
now then really?

Bluebird32 · 29/01/2023 15:18

OP you're doing the correct thing. They haven't served you formal section 21 notice so you haven't received notice to leave by law. As long as you continue paying your rent past March it automatically turns into a rolling contract which is perfectly valid. If they want to serve you notice they can but they haven't yet. I would just keep quiet for now and see if anything comes through the door. If they're actually expecting you to leave in March I'm sure they'll get back in contact. If you don't hear anything then carry on living there and paying rent.

Not sure where all the outrage is coming from in the replies. Probably because you've posted this on a forum full of middle class people who have probably never had to rent in their life and have no understanding of what it's like to be a tenant.

HowcanIhelp123 · 29/01/2023 15:18

Ok, so you haven't had a section 21 and you haven't given notice? Of course you don't move out. You've not legally broken the contract, so they could turn around and say contract never ended so you're stuck paying double rent for your notice period. Housing market isn't like it was, they may have changed their mind about selling.

Newjobformoremoney · 29/01/2023 15:18

Hi OP.
I'm confused, you had a chat on the phone, you haven't been formally asked to leave from what I can tell? You don't in fact know he is selling?
I get the coin toss, but surely ringing the estate agency and get clarity on the uncertainty is going to help? Unfortunately its the landlords property and he can choose to sell, and once you get an idea of next steps you can then make a plan, all of this is just drama!
The real people to be pissed at is the government. They have let the housing situation get totally out of hand.

Newlifestartingatlast · 29/01/2023 15:17

Charley50 · 29/01/2023 14:42

In most parts of the country it is well documented that it home ownership is increasingly out of reach due to the inflated cost of housing, not because young people spunk all their money on Latte. And OP has 2 children (?) so cannot start at the bottom of the ladder now.

I actually looked at cost of living recently, and trends back to 1940s
Itisvery true that the cost of housing has massively outstripped wages. And rental have gone up at same rate- the big difference is prior to 1980 the largish proportion of renters were in council houses with low rentals- the selling of council houses is what drove up private r natal costs and numbers and buying costs.

but, the cost of food as a proportion of income is massively lower than t was in 1980 and pre then. It is only in last 18 months post brexit that it has been increasing, and as a % of income it is still lower than in 1960s .

similarly the cost of fuel is lower % of income than it was right up to point North Sea natural gas conversion in 1970s. Even since then costs of heating and cooking and hot water have been massively lower than since 1980s. It is only in last 12 months that costs have gone up to that same proportion as in 70s and now, more recently higher.

interest rates have, and still are, at a 100 year low since around 2010. So the cost of borrowing is much more affordable even now. Interest rates have average just over 7% for last 100 years even taking this last 15 years of very low rates into account

The poster isn’t just arguing about a few lattes. The point is that human progress means we do have more stuff, and replace stuff more frequently than we used to. In many cases because companies themselves deliberately aim to make us replace stuff , and it can’t be fixed by a chap n a shop around the corner. But we do have more stuff. The average gen x will have tv, subscription, laptop, mobile at minimum and expect to replace those very 3 years. Only 30 years ago you probably only had a Tv and radio and both were going strong after 10 years. The technology revolution costs people a lot

Whilst I agree I is extremely difficult for good wages youngsters to afford to buy, particularly in south, it is NOT true that baby boomers had it easy or were better off so could more easily afford to buy. Perhaps expectations were lower back then on what to give up to save for deposit - foreign holidays weren’t the norm, nor going to / coffee shops/ takeaways each week so stopping them altogether was easier.

we need to stop with the inter generational put downs . Every generation has its challenges. And it plays right into the hands of the politicians that create many of the real underlying issues generations are faced with - Tories selling off council,houses and then later giving tax brakes to private landlords, and now not building enough new affordable/ social homes. Labour whose idea to get 40% of school leavers into uni and leave them with debt and false expectations of high paying jobs . Brexit that’s caused inflation, supply chain issues etc. focus on that- not generation bashing

WyldeSwan · 29/01/2023 15:16

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:02

That’s not how the process works. Legally, if the LL wants her to leave he needs to serve a s21. The onus is on him as he wants her out.

If she leaves without one she’ll be liable for rent.

What aren’t you getting?

I think it matters quite a lot if the saying she was leaving was formal not. If that has been accepted as notice of her ending the tenancy, she will have to leave on the date agreed, otherwise the landlord can claim mense rent of double her normal rent until she does leave.

If not, she is quite entitled to wait for a S21 to arrive.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 29/01/2023 15:15

Crikeyalmighty · 29/01/2023 15:08

Surely though on a year to year contract your tenancy would be up in March anyway- the normal thing is around 8 weeks before the end of a letting year the agent contacts to ask if you will be renewing , if they don't offer this and you don't contact the agent either then it is presumed you will be not renewing and leaving at the end of that rental contract.

We've rented big houses for last 20 years and I've only once had a similar experience where agent contacted us to ask if we were renewing and we said yes but no contract actually arrived. We used it to our advantage as a better house came up and at the 15 month point told agent it would now seem to be a rolling contract and we were giving 6 weeks notice and leaving. Agent agreed they had cocked up, hadn't issued a contract and we allowed viewings and moved with no issue.

If no one does anything about ending the tenancy or renewing the contract it simply becomes a rolling tenancy, as yours did.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:14

GarlicCrackers · 29/01/2023 15:08

Actually….upon expiry of a fixed term tenancy, tenant could say a day before I’m leaving and that’s sufficient. It’s a term called effluxion of time and refers to the expiration of your contract term due to the passage of time rather than a specific action taken. IF the tenancy agreement does NOT say anything like "during the last two months of the fixed term you must tell us whether you intend to stay in the Property or leave at the end of the fixed term" then you are fine. They can't even have a clause that says you have to pay rent in lieu of notice.

We are exercising our right to leave the property under the effluxion of time. The Landlord and Tenant Act provides that a tenant is entitled to the right to leave a property upon expiry of the contractual term, meaning a periodic tenancy is not established. In this instance our liability ceases as long as we have properly vacated the premises before the end date of XX.

In reference to a notice period, there is no legal requirement to provide you with notice to vacate, and it would be unlawful to charge us rent in lieu as this would be covered under the unfair contract term rules which are part of the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

but that’s by the by as she doesn’t want to leave

YOU are leaving the property.

The LL still needs to serve a s21 if he wants the tenant to leave

SwishSwishBisch · 29/01/2023 15:14

@WaitingForLifeToGetEasier is there a reason you’ve not contacted the agent to find out what’s going on?
As you’ve explained it so far, you’re basically in the dark which must be very stressful but I can’t understand why you wouldn’t have asked for clarity on whether your LL still intends to sell given you’ve heard nothing since August!

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 29/01/2023 15:14

afinishedkiss · 29/01/2023 15:05

How do you know he is? How do you know that he hasn’t changed his mind?

Yeah, she really should contact and know where she stands shouldn't she?

Or he could let her know what he wants to do since it’s him who apparently wants to change things…

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:12

HamBone · 29/01/2023 15:07

@TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl What would you advise the OP to do? Sorry if you’ve already stated this upthread.

Personally, the uncertainty of not knowing what was happening would prompt me to contact the letting agent, I’d be eaten up with worry not knowing the full picture-but perhaps that’s not a good idea? Would you advise her to just wait for the S21?

Yes. Wait for the s21. Chances are it hasn’t been served because LL doesn’t want her outS

Wetblanket78 · 29/01/2023 15:10

Landlords only have to give you 6 weeks notice to leave the property. Tenancy agreement or not. But a lot of landlords are now scrambling to sell properties because of increasing interest rates. Won't be long before there's a crash and the price of properties will come tumbling down like like happened in the late 90's-early 2000.

GarlicCrackers · 29/01/2023 15:08

MaireadMcSweeney · 29/01/2023 12:53

And the contract does not expire at the end of the fixed term UNLESS either party serves correct notice, which neither has done, therefore by not moving out OP would continue to follow the terms of her contract.

Actually….upon expiry of a fixed term tenancy, tenant could say a day before I’m leaving and that’s sufficient. It’s a term called effluxion of time and refers to the expiration of your contract term due to the passage of time rather than a specific action taken. IF the tenancy agreement does NOT say anything like "during the last two months of the fixed term you must tell us whether you intend to stay in the Property or leave at the end of the fixed term" then you are fine. They can't even have a clause that says you have to pay rent in lieu of notice.

We are exercising our right to leave the property under the effluxion of time. The Landlord and Tenant Act provides that a tenant is entitled to the right to leave a property upon expiry of the contractual term, meaning a periodic tenancy is not established. In this instance our liability ceases as long as we have properly vacated the premises before the end date of XX.

In reference to a notice period, there is no legal requirement to provide you with notice to vacate, and it would be unlawful to charge us rent in lieu as this would be covered under the unfair contract term rules which are part of the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

but that’s by the by as she doesn’t want to leave

Crikeyalmighty · 29/01/2023 15:08

Surely though on a year to year contract your tenancy would be up in March anyway- the normal thing is around 8 weeks before the end of a letting year the agent contacts to ask if you will be renewing , if they don't offer this and you don't contact the agent either then it is presumed you will be not renewing and leaving at the end of that rental contract.

We've rented big houses for last 20 years and I've only once had a similar experience where agent contacted us to ask if we were renewing and we said yes but no contract actually arrived. We used it to our advantage as a better house came up and at the 15 month point told agent it would now seem to be a rolling contract and we were giving 6 weeks notice and leaving. Agent agreed they had cocked up, hadn't issued a contract and we allowed viewings and moved with no issue.

HamBone · 29/01/2023 15:07

@TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl What would you advise the OP to do? Sorry if you’ve already stated this upthread.

Personally, the uncertainty of not knowing what was happening would prompt me to contact the letting agent, I’d be eaten up with worry not knowing the full picture-but perhaps that’s not a good idea? Would you advise her to just wait for the S21?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:07

afinishedkiss · 29/01/2023 15:00

I think it is hilarious that people think she can stay. Yes she needs notice and that document but he IS selling and she WILL be out.

Eventually.

No one is denying that but she should stay put until formally served notice

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:06

afinishedkiss · 29/01/2023 14:58

How is she still out with no notice?
with no notice she’s absolutely not out…

She WILL be out. She WILL NOT be there long term and if he is selling she WILL be out. He wants her out, he has every right to want her out. Once her gives her the proper notification she WILL be out. So she is literally prolonging it in the hope that there are a sudden flurry of new houses to rent with reduced rental rates. Her best bet would be to contact him, ask him what the story is and get the necessary documentation. Then she knows where she stands.

But at the end of the day.....be in now or further on down the line...she is OUT.

Except she isn’t because no notice has been served

afinishedkiss · 29/01/2023 15:05

How do you know he is? How do you know that he hasn’t changed his mind?

Yeah, she really should contact and know where she stands shouldn't she?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:05

A s21 isn’t automatically served at the end of a tenancy agreement, it’s served when the LL wants the tenant out.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:04

deliciouschilli · 29/01/2023 14:55

The process is (in theory) when the tenancy ends (March) a section 21 is served. She will then have 2 weeks to leave the property. If she hasn't left an eviction order will be served.
This information is free for anyone to view on the "Shelter" website. I would advise OP contacts them and her landlord.

You are either making this up or you can’t read properly

Thats not the process, at all, not even close.

deliciouschilli · 29/01/2023 15:04
  • Two Months.
justasking111 · 29/01/2023 15:03

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 15:02

Court access is granted for essential repairs. Not to take photos to sell the place.
I wish there were not so many landlords who are totally ignorant of the law.

Are they landlords though?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:02

FlairBand · 29/01/2023 14:45

The title of the thread is quite literally:

AIBU NOT leave rented house when I said I would?

So she’s said she’s leaving, in response to having been asked. Formally or otherwise. Not sure why so many people seem to be unclear on what the AIBU is? If you’ve said you’re leaving then you should leave.

That’s not how the process works. Legally, if the LL wants her to leave he needs to serve a s21. The onus is on him as he wants her out.

If she leaves without one she’ll be liable for rent.

What aren’t you getting?