Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To NOT leave rented house when I said I would?

769 replies

WaitingForLifeToGetEasier · 29/01/2023 12:11

Been in current rented house for 9 years. Landlord is a company with 30+ properties.

Tenancy is generally renewed every year as LL puts rent up.

Last year, less than 6 months into our latest year long tenancy agreement, an estate agent contacted me out of the blue saying he'd been instructed to sell the property so I needed to agree to a time for them to value and take photos as well for viewings.

I was shocked as LL has not said anything and it transpired that the letting agent has added a 6 month break clause into the tenancy agreement. There had never been one In previous agreements and I wasn't made aware.

I made it clear i was not going to allow anyone in the property until the end of the agreement and if the landlord wanted to sell, I'd leave at that time.

Tenancy is up in early March. I had expected to get a Section 21 in early January but nothing.

We have been looking but properties are either not available anymore or agent doesn't get back to us so have not found a property yet. Rents seem to have gone up £3-400 a month which is going to be impossible.

Not sure if LL is just expecting us to leave or what but I am not intending to leave in early March and will stay as long as possible - await section 21 etc.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 17:08

I said I wasn't allowing access but would try to move out by end of contract (this March). Nothing more said.

Ah, so you've told them you'd move out. That's why they haven't served the S21, they think you're going willingly once the contract expires. Once they realise you've changed your mind, they'll issue it then. So hold fire until it arrives.

LindorDoubleChoc · 29/01/2023 17:08

Prime example of why you shouldn't post every question in AIBU 😁.

EmmaDilemma5 · 29/01/2023 17:08

FWIW OP, I totally agree with you.

Mass landlords are greedy and absolutely shouldn't be profiteering off property the way they are. Its legal, but it's morally corrupt.

I'm sorry you're in this situation. A friend of mine is in a similar one currently and I have nothing but empathy for the stress these landlords are causing.

There needs to be much more regulation. There's no good reason for mass landlords and it definitely has caused lack of secure housing for millions of families. It's shameful. Unfortunately, it won't change as many of our politicians, and their funders, have a lot to gain from it.

Chin up and keep doing what you have to do to give your family a roof over their heads.

WaitingForLifeToGetEasier · 29/01/2023 17:04

Just to clarify, no break clause enforced. Tenancy was renewed from last March to this March (was that really not clear?).

I was contacted by a random EA last August, 5 months into new tenancy, telling me the LL wanted to put the property on the market straightaway and wanted access for valuation and viewings. I responded that I had a 12 month contract so what we he on about. He said LL had a 6 month break clause in current tenancy and wanted to sell now. I told him to sling his hook, LL got arsey and I said I wasn't allowing access but would try to move out by end of contract (this March). Nothing more said.

I had read previous contracts and no mention of a break clause before as usually used for new tenants in case there were issues at the beginning of tenancy. No reason to put one in for a long-standing tenant as been there for years with no issues. I didn't even push for essential repairs or maintenance (apart from front door) as worried about LL giving notice so did most myself. Hence having to wait 2 years for something expensive that the LL agreed he was responsible for then leaving it.

Of course my mistake not going through most recent tenancy renewal with a fine tooth comb but didn't think I had to. Just checked dates and rent amount. It was 30 pages long! LL obviously sneakily put that in as he had intended to sell during the new tenancy period but should have been honest about that before renewing rather that blindsiding me with an estate agent contacting me with no preamble.

That was disgusting behaviour not me staying on until I'm given legal notice to quit!

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 29/01/2023 17:04

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:58

I'm not disagreeing with you! But WaitingForLifeToGetEasier didn't say it was a one-off phone chat!!! Everyone's assumed that. I'd be amazed if the agent of a professional landlord didn't put them wanting to evoke the break clause in writing!

It doesn’t matter if it was on the phone or by letter. Telling her the landlord wants to invoke the break clause does not give the OP notice to quit. They still need to provide her with a date for quitting, which has not been mentioned at all. And to be within the requirements of the law they’d have to issue a S21.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 17:01

Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 29/01/2023 16:59

I didn't say the op was 'wrong'.
She asked for OPINIONS - Am I being unreasonable?
I answered her question that yes, in my opinion, she is; as did many other posters.

How is she being unreasonable? For not leaving a home she hasn’t been asked to leave?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 17:00

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:58

I'm not disagreeing with you! But WaitingForLifeToGetEasier didn't say it was a one-off phone chat!!! Everyone's assumed that. I'd be amazed if the agent of a professional landlord didn't put them wanting to evoke the break clause in writing!

She’s made it clear she hasn’t had a s21and that she’s had no more contact since August.

NumberTheory · 29/01/2023 17:00

FlairBand · 29/01/2023 16:29

Without a S21 the timing of the eviction was not FORMALISED. It has clearly been identified otherwise we wouldn’t be having this discussion.

Being rude doesn’t make you right.

What date do you think OP was informally given to leave the property?

She wasn’t given a sate in August, simply told that there was a break clause and that the LL wanted to sell.

March is when the regular 12 month tenancy is up, but the law is clear that the end of an AST contract term is not presumed to be a requirement for a tenant to quit. The contract automatically becomes a rolling month to month tenancy and the landlord can then issue a S21 at any time to provide the tenant with the statutory notice to quit.

OP informally told the agent she would move in march if the landlord still wanted to sell. But that’ doesn’t mean that OP has to leave the place with no notice if they don’t come back to her until Feb 28th saying the LL still wants to sell. She’s still reasonable to expect the regular notice the law requires.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 17:00

*in time not in town

Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 29/01/2023 16:59

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 15:49

Is ANYONE gonna answer the question I’ve asked loads of ‘How has the OP been given notice’

I didn't say the op was 'wrong'.
She asked for OPINIONS - Am I being unreasonable?
I answered her question that yes, in my opinion, she is; as did many other posters.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:59

Also: all these gibbering wrecks saying call the estate agent to check you aren’t being kicked out “I couldn’t live like that with that kind of worry”.

If they didn’t serve a s21 by early January, they haven’t had enough time to serve her notice in town for the break clause. Even if she did ask them - it’s too late now to them to go head with it in time for early March. It would be the world’s most pointless phone call.

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:59

Ballcactus · 29/01/2023 16:58

I don’t think they understand 😁

Show me the line where OP said the agent PHONED her. She said he CONTACTED her.

curlymom · 29/01/2023 16:58

Just because the LL has a lot of properties doesn’t make them nasty and money grabbing. It’s their business and maybe they need to sell for financial reasons.
it was up,to you to read the agreement before signing and see the six month break clause which is quite normal for assured short hold tenancies. You await a section 21 and this will enable you to get on the council list so you won’t be homeless. Perhaps get in touch and ask the landlord

I would just get ready to move if I were you. Hope you find somewhere

Ballcactus · 29/01/2023 16:58

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:56

She said the agent called her.

The LL HASN’T given notice. That can only be done by issuing a s21, not having a chat, informal or otherwise.

Do you understand?

I don’t think they understand 😁

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:58

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:55

The only way to invoke a break clause is

  1. for LL to issue a s21 2 months before the date
  2. for tenant to give their notice to quit a month before the date
If neither of these things happen, the break clause is not ‘invoked’.

Do you REALLY think the OP is in a good position to leave based on one unrecorded chat 6 months ago that has never been re-addressed? Do you think the LL fully expects no rent after February and to be able to walk into an empty home saying “Ah good! She remembered!” 🤣

I'm not disagreeing with you! But WaitingForLifeToGetEasier didn't say it was a one-off phone chat!!! Everyone's assumed that. I'd be amazed if the agent of a professional landlord didn't put them wanting to evoke the break clause in writing!

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:56

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:54

Where does OP say it was an informal chat? She doesn't specify how the agent contacted her, but if he outlined the break clause was being invoked in an email, that was the LL giving notice.

She said the agent called her.

The LL HASN’T given notice. That can only be done by issuing a s21, not having a chat, informal or otherwise.

Do you understand?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:55

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:52

I get what you're saying, but when the agent contacted OP in August that was them invoking the break clause. As OP hasn't told them she's refusing to move now, does that not suggest the LL hasn't issued the S21 because he thinks she's amicably agreed to leave when the tenancy is up in March? The break clause notice was clearly given in August – PP are assuming it wasn't in writing and the agent just called up for a chat, but OP hasn't said that.

The only way to invoke a break clause is

  1. for LL to issue a s21 2 months before the date
  2. for tenant to give their notice to quit a month before the date
If neither of these things happen, the break clause is not ‘invoked’.

Do you REALLY think the OP is in a good position to leave based on one unrecorded chat 6 months ago that has never been re-addressed? Do you think the LL fully expects no rent after February and to be able to walk into an empty home saying “Ah good! She remembered!” 🤣

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:54

Ballcactus · 29/01/2023 16:51

ignore everyone saying you’ve already been given notice and to leave- you don’t count an informal chat with a letting agent as notice to leave. Formal notice is a sec21 and they can’t do anything until that has been served, and equally you’ve done nothing wrong until it’s served and expired.

Where does OP say it was an informal chat? She doesn't specify how the agent contacted her, but if he outlined the break clause was being invoked in an email, that was the LL giving notice.

Bodgejobvendors · 29/01/2023 16:53

FlairBand · 29/01/2023 16:47

Please refer me to it.

My point is it doesn’t exist. You’re inventing your own legal process. But then you seem to think the law is but one option of many.

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:52

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:46

This

I get what you're saying, but when the agent contacted OP in August that was them invoking the break clause. As OP hasn't told them she's refusing to move now, does that not suggest the LL hasn't issued the S21 because he thinks she's amicably agreed to leave when the tenancy is up in March? The break clause notice was clearly given in August – PP are assuming it wasn't in writing and the agent just called up for a chat, but OP hasn't said that.

Ballcactus · 29/01/2023 16:51

ignore everyone saying you’ve already been given notice and to leave- you don’t count an informal chat with a letting agent as notice to leave. Formal notice is a sec21 and they can’t do anything until that has been served, and equally you’ve done nothing wrong until it’s served and expired.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:51

NumberTheory · 29/01/2023 16:41

You don’t “issue a break clause”. The break clause is included in the contract. It’s inclusion does not mean the contract stops at the “break”. It’s a break clause because it allows one or both parties to “break” the contract under certain conditions. It doesn’t require them to. A landlord would still need to take the normal steps for terminating and issuing notice, such as issuing a S21. The break clause would simply have allowed them to do so before the regular contract date. If the don’t do this, the break clause simply isn’t used and the contract remains at its initial 12 month date. And the Landlord would still need to issue a S21 if he wants them to leave.

I’m actually really embarrassed for the people insisting a break clause terminates a tenancy.

If it’s a 12 month tenancy with a break clause after six months, and the definition of a break clause is ‘to terminate the tenancy’, I wonder what people think the point of a break clause is? If the other six months is never going to happen?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:49

Inkpotlover · 29/01/2023 16:38

The break clause means the landlord is ending the tenancy agreement early, which will be in March. It's what OP signed, only she's saying she didn't realise.

You're also assuming it was an informal approach, but OP doesn't actually say how the agent contacted her.

No, it gives the option to end early formalised by a s21 notice

OP says in her OP the agent Calle she’s on the phone. HTH.

FlairBand · 29/01/2023 16:48

WaitingForLifeToGetEasier · 29/01/2023 16:44

You do come across quite vindictive and spiteful OP. Why do you keep mentioning the fact your LL is a millionaire and how you’ve paid off his mortgage? All completely irrelevant. Why didn’t you get a mortgage and buy your own house if you don’t want to “pay off someone else’s mortgage?” Maybe be grateful to the LL for providing you with somewhere to live? After all if you couldn’t get a mortgage and you’re not eligible for social housing where would you be without private LL’s (who take all of the financial risk)??

Landlords are getting out in droves partly bc of this mentality - and I don’t blame them. The government aren’t building nearly enough houses to meet demand, rents are rising astronomically as demand massively outstrips supply.

@FlairBand

We did have our own house but had to sell and rent 15 years ago due to DH getting made redundant along with most of our town so had to sell up and move away, me having a medical condition that meant I couldn't work for 3 years and having a DC with a disability (born before all that I might add) which became more difficult to manage when he became school age meaning long periods out of school so I couldn't go back to work for many years.

If greedy bloody BTL landlords, like mine, hadn't hoarded properties decreasing availability and increasing prices together with charging astronomical rents, we may have been able to save and afford to buy another property years ago!
^
Grateful that I'm paying off a rich landlords property? Landlords should be grateful there are people like me renting their properties so they can end up with hundreds of thousands of pounds in their pockets for virtually zero work, while we're left constantly worried that we will be left homeless at their whim.

Also ridiculous to say LLs face financial risk and they can charge astronomical rents as an argument!

I care as much as about my LL's finances as he cares about mine and will not move for as long as legally possible.^

Why are you addressing that response to me? I didn’t write what you quoted.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 16:48

Butterfly44 · 29/01/2023 16:35

Presumably you signed the latest agreement that had the clause. So you're in no position to not leave.

You go on about the millionaire LL, but so what. You're paying rent whether it's to him, someone else, or say towards a mortgage just like anyone else would do. It's a monthly expense.

You should start looking for somewhere to move to.

She literally IS in a position to not leave because she hasn’t been asked to.

People think a break clause is a legal instruction to leave, which is ludicrous, because it would defeat the object of its intended purpose 😂