Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not understand this recent trend of giving baby girls male names?

304 replies

LaLuz7 · 29/01/2023 10:40

James, Ryan, Dylan...

I can't wrap my head around the idea of purposefully choosing a very traditionally male name for a girl.

Why would you? What message are you trying to send? Why don't you ever see it done the other way around (female names for boys)?

I personally feel that if I had gotten a male name it would have made me feel like my parents really wanted a boy and were disappointed in me. It would feel almost spiteful and it would give me inadequacy feelings.

My other gripe with this is that it doesn't sit well with me from a feminist perspective. By giving girls male names (but never ever the other way around) you are perpetuating the idea that masculinity as a trait is desirable and valuable above femininity.

Can someone explain it to me?

OP posts:
Swingingonastar77 · 29/01/2023 13:22

YABVU -you may not understand it but it literally has nothing to do with you what other people name their child!

CoalCraft · 29/01/2023 13:21

It's fine to call your daughter James if you'd be equally happy to name your son Sarah.

TheMoth · 29/01/2023 13:21

Reugny · 29/01/2023 13:18

I know men and women with the other spelling so you only know if they are a man or woman if you meet them.

And that's without all the flourishes to make the names different.
Lesleigh
Lezlee
Lyndzi
Lindzi

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:18

It's not as simple as changing your name. By the time you're 18 it's a core part of your identity

People change their name all the time, or a variety of reasons, common or uncommon. If someone hates a core part of their identity they still have a choice.

The eye-rolling is at the people who are so idiotic as to not understand that shock-horror people can be called anything they choose to go by.

Reugny · 29/01/2023 13:18

TheMoth · 29/01/2023 13:05

Lesley/Leslie
Lindsay/lyndsey
Mackenzie - both
Stevie- both, but mainly girls
Tyler- both

I don't think in real life, people really think about it.

I know men and women with the other spelling so you only know if they are a man or woman if you meet them.

Swingingonastar77 · 29/01/2023 13:18

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:13

you are essentially screwing your daughter over to make a statement

No. The main problem is with the idiots who would criticise someone for having the 'wrong' name.

And if the daughter hates it she can change it. 'Screwing over' is very strong. Has anyone ever wailed they went through their whole life with the wrong name? Come off it.

Exactly this! Most schools today will quite happily call a child a different name if they want/choose.

Workbaseddrama · 29/01/2023 13:15

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:13

you are essentially screwing your daughter over to make a statement

No. The main problem is with the idiots who would criticise someone for having the 'wrong' name.

And if the daughter hates it she can change it. 'Screwing over' is very strong. Has anyone ever wailed they went through their whole life with the wrong name? Come off it.

Im sure any woman with a unisex or male name or a name with multiple variants of spelling can tell you of the many eye rolling moments they've had when explaining their name, or explaining the spelling

It's not as simple as changing your name. By the time you're 18 it's a core part of your identity

Swingingonastar77 · 29/01/2023 13:15

Lcb123 · 29/01/2023 13:10

It’s only society which seems a name ‘male’ or ‘female’, it’s not inherent. Who cares

Exactly!

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 29/01/2023 13:14

LaLuz7 · 29/01/2023 13:13

That's a whataboutism and really not a smart argument at all. Just because there are worse names to burden a girl with doesn't make these ones any more acceptable.

I'm not talking about worse names.

How many girls/women now absolutely hate being called Karen, for example? A name that was, until a few years ago, a perfectly normal, acceptable name for a woman. I hated my name growing up but it was a very common, normal girls name for the time.

I never use it as an adult and most people who meet me have no idea that it's my real name.

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:14

They can't change it until 16. That's a lot of years to be bullied and to live with a name you despise

The issue is with the bullies, not the name. IME schools call children their preferred name anyway, if they're sure, regardless of legal status.

CecilyP · 29/01/2023 13:14

Have you never heard of a boy named Sue?

Except life didn’t turn out well for poor old Sue!

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 29/01/2023 13:13

LaLuz7 · 29/01/2023 13:12

They can't change it until 16. That's a lot of years to be bullied and to live with a name you despise.

Same applies to literally any other name, though.

I knew someone who hated being called Olivia - really despised it. You wouldn't say that someone calling their daughter "Olivia" was wrong because of it, though.

LaLuz7 · 29/01/2023 13:13

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 29/01/2023 13:12

You can make that argument for lots of names, though.

Lots of people grow up hating their names, even though those names are seen, by society, as perfectly normal/acceptable for their sex.

That's a whataboutism and really not a smart argument at all. Just because there are worse names to burden a girl with doesn't make these ones any more acceptable.

OP posts:
ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:13

you are essentially screwing your daughter over to make a statement

No. The main problem is with the idiots who would criticise someone for having the 'wrong' name.

And if the daughter hates it she can change it. 'Screwing over' is very strong. Has anyone ever wailed they went through their whole life with the wrong name? Come off it.

Workbaseddrama · 29/01/2023 13:12

Lcb123 · 29/01/2023 13:10

It’s only society which seems a name ‘male’ or ‘female’, it’s not inherent. Who cares

Unless they use a word from a gendered language for a name then find a new rabbit hole to fall down...

LaLuz7 · 29/01/2023 13:12

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:10

YOU feel it doesn't matter and that's fine to hold that view. But just because you feel it doesn't matter doesn't mean it doesn't create issues for others

What issues? Really? If the person doesn't like their name they can change it?

They can't change it until 16. That's a lot of years to be bullied and to live with a name you despise.

OP posts:
whataboutsecondbreakfast · 29/01/2023 13:12

LaLuz7 · 29/01/2023 13:10

The issue is exactly right there in your comment. How many girls do you think would be perfectly happy to go through life being called James or Michael or Robert? I bet it's a very tiny minority. So you are essentially screwing your daughter over to make a statement...

You can make that argument for lots of names, though.

Lots of people grow up hating their names, even though those names are seen, by society, as perfectly normal/acceptable for their sex.

BungleandGeorge · 29/01/2023 13:10

Names which have different spellings according to sex are different to what OP is talking about. But what does it really matter, a name is a name. I’m not sure I’d personally want to be called a name that is a very popular and established name for the other sex only though.

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:10

YOU feel it doesn't matter and that's fine to hold that view. But just because you feel it doesn't matter doesn't mean it doesn't create issues for others

What issues? Really? If the person doesn't like their name they can change it?

Lcb123 · 29/01/2023 13:10

It’s only society which seems a name ‘male’ or ‘female’, it’s not inherent. Who cares

LaLuz7 · 29/01/2023 13:10

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:08

the adopting of names that clearly are male or clearly are female is being done to make a statement

It literally doesn't matter. Names / words have no fixed meaning through time and if the individual likes the name as they're growing up, what's the issue?

The issue is exactly right there in your comment. How many girls do you think would be perfectly happy to go through life being called James or Michael or Robert? I bet it's a very tiny minority. So you are essentially screwing your daughter over to make a statement...

OP posts:
JustDrama · 29/01/2023 13:09

What about Kerry? I always though it was a girls name and joined my place of work 20 years ago and there were 3, yes 3 males named Kerry. I didn't realise it was unisex

CecilyP · 29/01/2023 13:09

You don't say doctoress and doctor do you? So why do certain professions/jobs require you to distinguish between make and female?

No, but there has never been a job title of doctorsess, whereas females in the acting world have been called actresses from 1660 till around the 1990s.

Workbaseddrama · 29/01/2023 13:09

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:08

the adopting of names that clearly are male or clearly are female is being done to make a statement

It literally doesn't matter. Names / words have no fixed meaning through time and if the individual likes the name as they're growing up, what's the issue?

YOU feel it doesn't matter and that's fine to hold that view. But just because you feel it doesn't matter doesn't mean it doesn't create issues for others.

ThreeLittleDots · 29/01/2023 13:08

the adopting of names that clearly are male or clearly are female is being done to make a statement

It literally doesn't matter. Names / words have no fixed meaning through time and if the individual likes the name as they're growing up, what's the issue?