Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want to be around bereaved MIL anymore

757 replies

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 10:02

This is probably going to make me sound like the worst person in the world but here goes.

FIL died eighteen months ago, it was quite sudden and he was relatively young (65).

MIL is now very depressed. I do feel very sorry for her because FIL was basically her whole world. She doesn’t have any other family, doesn’t have many friends, doesn’t drive, and is retired. She used to spend most of her time with FIL. So it is really sad.

She recently came to stay. This was actually my suggestion as I know she is bored and lonely and I thought it would cheer her up. Unfortunately it was a disaster. She was in a terrible mood with DH because he asked her to get the train (he used to pick her up and drive to ours but it’s a six hour round trip). So she barely spoke to him or me for the first 24 hours. She didn’t want to go out anywhere so she sat and watched daytime TV for six hours (this is not an exaggeration). She cried a lot of the time and turned most conversations round to FIL.

She is clearly depressed but won’t go to the doctor or have counselling. She is in a terrible place but she won’t accept any help and is very rude to DH. She refused to say goodbye to him, again because she was unhappy about having to get the train. At the end we were both completely exhausted and fed up and the kids were a bit confused by the whole thing.

I had suggested to DH that we should invite her to stay again in March but I’ve just said I think we should abandon that idea because I don’t think I can face it again. However, I also feel like a terrible person because she is obviously very sad. I don’t know what the answer is really. But I have my own issues with work, family illness, kids etc and I just don’t think I can face this on top.

OP posts:
pucelleauxblanchesmains · 30/01/2023 18:59

People are saying "she can't be like this for the next 30 years". No, of course she can't. But do you not think that maybe you can feel like this at 18 months and eventually it will pass? Or do you have to be "gracious", the "good" kind of widow straight away or that's it and the rest of your life will be the same>

Shefliesonherownwings · 30/01/2023 18:56

OP I haven’t read all the replies although I have read yours. I agree with you that it’s not fair for her to be so rude and ignore your husband even in the depths of grief so I think not wanting her to stay again is fair.

But I just wanted to offer a slightly different perspective re the train. I agree there is nothing wrong with asking her to get the train if she is fit and able to do so. However, speaking from experience when I suffered a horrible loss I found I had huge anxiety about being in public places. It wasn’t something I was expecting to deal with as part of my grief as I’d always commuted into London and had no issues with being in busy areas. But after my loss the idea of getting a train or on public transport filled me with anxiety.

I can’t really explain why but when you suffer a loss you do tend to be on high alert subconsciously and kind of operate at state of heightened anxiety in case something awful happens again and being in busy places, such as public transport can feel too overwhelming. It’s part of the brains coping mechanism. Three years on I’m better with public transport although it doesn’t come as easily as it used to.

So that may be something she is experiencing and having done the journey she may have found it really overwhelming and a kind of sensory overload. If you feel able
to, I’d ask her if that was something she felt, in a nice way of course because it is hard to admit when you’re struggling with seemingly normal tasks. That might not have anything to do with it obviously but just wanted to offer my views.

Wally1983 · 30/01/2023 18:50

In a very similar situation with my FIL, it’s been 2years for him and unfortunately it has got no better, in fact if anything worse.
He has family, he drives, he has friends, he “keeps himself busy” yet the grief and depression (yes it is depression) is worse than ever. Won’t accept help as such though I believe him to be on antidepressants (I don’t think they work…or he doesn’t take them!!!!) and it is truly heartbreaking to watch.
it peaked recently when he was rude to several members of the family and they had stern words with him as he would’ve had it been them to him. I think he got a bit of a shock but accepted what was said.
i don’t have any answers I’m afraid but know you have my sympathies. You are not wrong for asking her to take the train, spend time with you and I think that needs pointed out to her xx

Sleepdeprived42long · 30/01/2023 18:50

OP you’re getting a hard time here. My mum died 10 years ago and my dad was the same as your MIL. It was draining for everyone around him. Eventually I had to say go to counselling and I put some distance between us-it got so bad it was really impacting on my own mental health. Even now, he’s not exactly easy to be around-everything still very negative. But it’s difficult to know now whether that would have happened anyway. I don’t think your MIL behaviour can totally be blamed on grief to be honest.

wordler · 30/01/2023 18:37

I feel for you OP - I understand your worry and frustration with how the last visit went. It would probably be easier for you if you were dealing with a DM rather than MIL because you'd probably have a closer bond which would allow you to both meet her in her grief when needed - and also push a little harder for finding ways to help her move forward.

I think it's easier to chivvy your Mum into a bit of fresh air and trip to the cafe than a MIL.

I know there was a lot of resistance and anger from her re the train journey but don't forget that was the first time she'd had to do it. She was jolted out of her comfort zone while feeling vulnerable. But that's the sort of thing which will get easier with time.

I'd keep offering the visits - maybe alternate with DH going to her (for shorter ones where he can see what help she needs around the house etc) - every time she takes the train it will get easier - and it will be a regular break from sitting at home alone in front of the TV.

When she visits I'd aim for 1-2 outings where you just don't take no for an answer. Sunday lunch which involves a short walk. Church? Drive and get an icecream with the DGC, etc.

And at least once a trip try to meet her where she is with her grief without trying to change the subject - let her talk it out, hug her.

I think the progress is going to be slower than you'd hope but I think you will see changes.

JanuaryBlues2023 · 30/01/2023 18:36

She clearly is depressed you or her son could maybe contact the GP expressing your concerns and suggest an appointment about something else this may or may not work.

You could gather some information about various sources of support, groups or activities that she maybe interested in. But unfortunately you can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink.

65 is young enough for her to be able to get the train. My MIL now refuses to get the train but she is mid 80’s and this is only a recent thing.

Could your DH maybe go down and visit her for a shorter visit maybe two or three days on his own and see how that goes or could they (DH and her) arrange to meet somewhere for the day or a few hours say an hour train journey from her home and a shorter drive for your DH.

mylifestory · 30/01/2023 18:33

I know someone exactly like this who i used to work with, world revolved round her husband, he did everything for her. She admits its been a steep learning curve for her to pay bills etc. She's very lonely in the evenings bt does try to an extent. She volunteers for a day, used to be at vats rescue as she likes them, now at a charity shop bt she alzo did before losing husband.

She also has no friends and Never wanted to know her hubbys family and kids from before they were married. She has no kids of her own either. She has spotted a lady like her on her rd, not sure if she still speaks to her tho. She also has a bit of a sharp tongue and easily offends. I know another work colleague she saw all the time who now refuses to have anything to do with her.

She wont leave her immediate area which is one im working on as its not like her bt a casualty of losing her husband. They used to go to Cornwall and Brighton for holidays bt now nothing.

What I notice most is not that Yr mil shd talk to other widows bt any ppl of her own age. If she wont help herself, u do it for her. Sign her up for magazines of local things, there she be an over 55s group locally run by council etc who do outings locally or further away. Find their leaflet and send it to her. There's bound to be lots of groups local to her similar, find them for Yr own sanity. Even saga holidays catalogue, send her it. Don't let her know it's from u! Get hubby to stay with her for no more than 2-3 days, he can make it clear how it's obvious to u all that she doesn't enjoy coming to u so ur trying this instead. Don't ask if she wants hubby to visit, just tell her! And book yrself a long holiday abroad at Easter so she knows she has to fend for herself in that time as ur all away.

Most of all, don't make yrself so available to her, she will find someone else even to moan to. I keep telling my own mum that she needs to talk to ppl of her own age as she depends on me for everything 24hrs a day urgh!!

Vickythevan63 · 30/01/2023 18:33

Ah Op, I think you are getting a hard time here.

A close friend of mine was widowed very suddenly last year, only late 50s, no children to lean on. She is obviously devastated, but has never, as far as I know, taken her grief out on friends or family (brothers, nieces, nephews) who have rallied around to support her.

She has had some counselling and now going to a bereavement support group. She knows it is early days but at least is trying to help herself.

As for the travelling by train, my mum was widowed mid seventies and travelled by train (3 in total) at least one way when visiting us until her last 80s. She could drive but gave up the car after dad died and would never have driven outside her local area anyway.

I am almost 60, and can’t begin to understand how a fit and healthy 64yr old would not travel on trains! Especially if being picked up at the other end and help with tickets.

Rightsraptor · 30/01/2023 18:31

There's a lot of nonsense on here about the train.

Your MIL is not old at all, she is younger than me, and I would never expect to be picked up and taken home again. If it's a matter of heavy suitcases, I imagine you could arrange to provide a dressing gown/raincoat/toiletries so she doesn't have to lug everything around with her, or she could maybe keep some things at yours if convenient.

It could be that the train, for your MIL, represents not being cared for and that's the prism she's looking through. She needs help to get out of this state of mind, she can't spend the rest of her life (maybe 30 years?) doing this Queen Victoria deep in grief thing. Yes, she will always grieve the loss of her husband and at some point, we hope, the grief will be incorporated into her life and she can pick things up and carry on.

Indulging her in this state isn't helpful to her (not that I'm suggesting you are inclined to indulge her in it). I think the old days of set mourning periods were probably helpful, so a wife would officially be in mourning for her husband for one year (in the UK at least) then after that, everyone would expect a corner to have been turned. Just a corner, not 'got over it', not 'forgotten about him', but just feeling you can carry on.

Best of luck, OP.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 30/01/2023 18:27

my step dad was like this when mum died. I finally had to tell him that I would support him however I could, and would always continue to, but that I could not support him by myself and he needed more people in his life to help him. Whether it be friends, professionals, etc. that was his choice, but it was also affecting me (I had to point out that I had also lost someone close to me, although obviously a different relationship than his) and I had to work out how to stay able to support him while also caring for myself. The kind of behaviour you describe is not normal after 18 months.

NarkyNarwhal · 30/01/2023 18:23

Sounds awful for everyone. Could you stay in an Air BnB or similar near her home? Then make the visit about helping in practical ways eg DIY, visiting the garden centre etc. And maybe help support enquiries to eg WI. Is your MiL on FB? Could she connect with other youngish widows that way? I have to say I sympathise with her re the trains, they are absolutely bloody awful atm and it can’t have been an easy journey for her. Not suggesting your DH provides a taxi service for 6 hours but at least by staying near her it will cut the driving by 50% and potentially ensure she’s in a better mood.

Mumarch · 30/01/2023 18:15

I'm so sorry. This is very difficult for you and your family. I'm not a great one for pandering to people though, so I would suggest laying some ground rules for her visits. Yes, she's depressed but she is also behaving in a very immature and spoiled manner (expecting to be picked up is a childlike level of dependence). The ground rules will have to be agreed with your DH and presented gently and kindly to her - in person, not in writing as that can be shocking. Does she have other children? If so can you agree something with them too? And I do also want to resolve you from any guilt you might feel at finding this difficult and anything in your own life making it worse for you. Even if you didn't have other issues, this is difficult. She is only middle aged too, not elderly. She could have a whole other life - education etc...

Jackandjamie · 30/01/2023 18:00

It’s hard work trying to help someone in that position, but it sounds like she really needs you all. Is there something you can do to help her while she’s at home? Contact anyone around her who can visit or even local charities? Don’t stay away from her when she needs you most x

Dixiechickonhols · 30/01/2023 17:58

What a difficult situation. Does DH know any of her friends. I wonder if he spoke to them they’d be supportive.
Train sounds very reasonable. A 6 hour drive isn’t. DH accompanying her for part way sounds sensible until she finds her feet. If not has she money for a taxi like an airport transfer service.
You can research and suggest all the groups and classes but if she won’t engage there’s little you can do.
I suspect what will happen is dh will pull back and limit seeing her for his own wellbeing. He’s grieving his father.
My mum was widowed suddenly at 59. She has made her own life and travels on train and buses. But she was independent before.
She had a neighbour who had never lived alone also bereaved and my mum acted as an unpaid companion to get her up and running - this lady had never shopped alone, paid a bill, got a train etc. A paid companion for mil would do that it’s not just care agencies provide but again she’d need to be agreeable.

Soothsayer1 · 30/01/2023 17:57

wentworthinmate · 30/01/2023 17:51

Not much to add to comments except that I used to have a MIL like this and after many years of this behaviour we decided she was attention seeking. Nothing we ever did or said helped and she lost all her friends over her attitude. People would actually avoid her if they saw her out. In the end she only had contact with one of her four children who could stand her going on about her loss.

I feel for all of you🙏
it sounds like she got trapped in a pit of grief & self pity and just couldnt climb out or be helped out? Imo, ultimately you have to protect yourself, some people just cant be helped. I dont mean to excuse her but I think people can get very stuck in their ways, like grooves in a record and they dont know any other tunes except that one miserable dirge😕

Mgi4243765 · 30/01/2023 17:52

There is an amazing group she could try but maybe ask her to watch this first.. group is freedom thinking and literally changed my life 🙏 good luck

wentworthinmate · 30/01/2023 17:51

Not much to add to comments except that I used to have a MIL like this and after many years of this behaviour we decided she was attention seeking. Nothing we ever did or said helped and she lost all her friends over her attitude. People would actually avoid her if they saw her out. In the end she only had contact with one of her four children who could stand her going on about her loss.

MojoDaysxx · 30/01/2023 17:14

Most of us will experience loss. Only, when it happens do you truly understand how raw and painful it feels. It's utterly devistating.

NotTheMrMenAgain · 30/01/2023 14:39

OP, what you’ve described makes me wonder if your MIL is suffering from traumatic bereavement.

I experienced a family member suffering through this after the sudden death of her DH - it was a living nightmare for her. Her personality changed as she was so angry and completely consumed by his death and what she might have done differently.

I didn’t realise it was ‘a thing’ until I discovered she’d made active plans to end her own life and I started grabbing all the help and support I could possibly find.

It’s related to PTSD - the brain is sort of stuck at the point of the death and can’t process it, which prevents the more usual course of grief progressing.

If I remember correctly, if the person is still experiencing symptoms like flashbacks, obsessive preoccupation, inability to move forward in grief etc after 18 months then it can be classed as traumatic loss and be treated similarly to PTSD.

www.cruse.org.uk/understanding-grief/grief-experiences/traumatic-loss/

If your MIL doesn’t want to take medication or have counselling then it’s very tricky. As mentioned, my relative was rock-bottom with arrangements made for the rehoming of animals and her suicide all planned before I was able to access help for her and she was desperate enough to take the meds.

Your DH may have to do some serious tough love with his DM and seriously push her. Show her the info on the Cruse website link, ask her if she recognises any of the symptoms, does it describe how she feels? She needs to see what she’s experiencing isn’t normal and it won’t just go away or get better by itself.

Best of luck.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 30/01/2023 13:58

ancientgran · 30/01/2023 09:55

OK so it is different but he could be feeling it more, his grief could actually be worse but you are constantly implying the loss of a partner is worse, the reality of grief when you have young children is you don't have the luxury of sitting doing nothing or being rude because you have to get on with it. What you have experienced is the loss of your partner and the loss of your parent, that is no way means you know how these people feel however much you seem to think you can judge.

People make all sorts of assumptions based on their own experiences, earlier on it was mentioned that losing a parent when you are a child is worse than when you are an adult, my experience was totally different and I was much worse when I lost a parent when I was in my late 40s than I was when I lost a parent when I was a child. That doesn't make me right, it was just how I was. I'm not unique as my husband also lost a parent when he was a very young child and he has no memory of it.

Sorry, I missed this. I am not implying that any form of grief is worse than any other, and I’m certainly not implying that the OP’s DH won’t experience the grief any less than his mum. What I said was that the impact on their lives will be different. And how am I judging ? I am commenting based on my personal experience, which is all anyone can do on a public forum. What you seem to be saying is that even though I’ve experienced both forms of loss, I don’t have a valid point of view.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 30/01/2023 13:37

Stunningscreamer · 30/01/2023 06:21

Not saying the actual words does not mean the inference is not there. You are comparing different levels of grief and implying one is worse than the other. And you are doing it over and over again and completely talking from your own experience as if this is the only way to be. It's ridiculous to suggest that society's or your particular perception of grief would change how you felt when someone died. The natural order of things does not change that for some people the loss of their parent could be so much worse. They may be completely emotionally and socially reliant on that parent in the same way you seem to have been with your late husband and the MiL in this case was. The MiL seems to be using her grief not so much as a way of adjusting to her new circumstances but as a stick to beat those around her.

Well of course you can do what you want, I can't stop you (clearly as you are like a dog with a bone about it), but it doesn't mean it's right or fair.

I hope the many people disagreeing with you will ensure that the OP disregards your obsession with your view being the only one and that the OP should feel shamed into agreeing with you.

The words I said are the words I meant - if you wish to infer something else then that’s up to you. I am not ‘comparing’ different levels of grief or implying that one is ‘worse’ than the other - although quite a few posters actually have said this, including one who actually said that the death of a child trumps all, and I don’t see you calling them out. I have said clearly that as far as I’m concerned there is no hierarchy of grief, it’s different for everyone according to who they have lost - no one type of grief is ‘worse’ than any other, just different. The OPs husband has lost his father but he still has his wife and family for support. He’s grieving just as much as his mum, but his life won’t be impacted nearly as much as hers because she’s lost the life she had and has to rebuild it - there are stages of grief that are common to all, and the death of a life partner has a huge impact on the life of the person left behind. There are quite a few posters agreeing with this, and with the fact that 18 months is not very far into the journey.

Grief can turn around and hit you again even harder when you get to the acceptance stage - usually in the second year after the loss. From what the OP has said, it sounds as though MIL is going through that now - hence the weepiness and the bad behaviour. She’s realised the full extent of her loss, she’s trying to accept it and in the process she is lashing out because she’s angry. It’s a natural stage of grief. I have experience of this and a few pages back the OP replied to one of my posts and asked me how long is long enough - which is when I replied based on my own experience and made her aware, if she wasn’t already, that her MIL could be struggling for this reason. This is a public forum, all anyone can do is comment based on their own experience. And if you have actually read my posts you don’t appear to have understood them, because you seem to think that I have been - in your words - ‘completely emotionally and socially reliant’ on my late husband, despite the fact that I have never said that. What I DID say was that after he died it took me six months to get back in the car and driving again. That was because I experienced agoraphobia as part of the grief process - again, something that was explained to me during later counselling as perfectly natural and occurring frequently. That doesn’t imply that I was reliant on my late husband either emotionally or socially, so what are you talking about ? I lost my husband of 40 years in the space of a few days after a shock diagnosis - do you really think that anyone, not just me although you seem to have the knives out for me - can get over that and breeze back into normal life in a few months ? And as for me being obsessed - well, that’s your opinion. My view isn’t the only one - of course not, but having experienced the loss of a life partner, the loss of a parent and the imminent loss of another from dementia, who has spent the last 3 years fading in front of me, I think my view is a valid one. And to suggest that I am trying to shame the OP into agreeing with me - I have no words.

This thread has degenerated into a slanging match and I’m stepping back from it now because it’s not helping anyone. OP - a last piece of advice. A couple of posters including myself have recommended a bereavement support site called WayUp. It’s not just for those who have lost partners, it’s for anyone who has experienced loss. Your MIL will benefit from it, so will your husband, and so will you because you are trying to support them both. Please can I suggest that you give it a go because there’s a wealth of experience on there from those who have had different losses and are at different stages of their grieving process. They can support your MIL and your husband much better than MN because it’s a site dedicated purely to supporting the bereaved. They can also support you in supporting your family and give you a much better understanding of the grieving process, so that you know what to expect. I do hope things improve for you all soon.

smileladiesplease · 30/01/2023 13:32

I don't know anyone who thinks dying at 60 isn't taken far too young. Very odd post. As I said please don't say silly things like this in RL to adults as you may find yourself in a heap of trouble.

No idea what you mean by silly and sentimental it's facts. As you have now been told.

toomuchlaundry · 30/01/2023 13:31

@LavenderHillMob my DM moved into a retirement flat closer to us after DF died. The majority of residents are widows, some residents have also become widows whilst living there. They give each other support, and can discuss their late husbands in a way they probably can't with family

OutForBreakfast · 30/01/2023 13:30

@LavenderHillMob That was kind if you going with her to the shops initially.
I think OPs DH could go with his mum initially on the train so she could manage it by herself.

smileladiesplease · 30/01/2023 13:29

Bloodywhitecat

No that's so unfair for him and for you. Xx