Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want to be around bereaved MIL anymore

757 replies

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 10:02

This is probably going to make me sound like the worst person in the world but here goes.

FIL died eighteen months ago, it was quite sudden and he was relatively young (65).

MIL is now very depressed. I do feel very sorry for her because FIL was basically her whole world. She doesn’t have any other family, doesn’t have many friends, doesn’t drive, and is retired. She used to spend most of her time with FIL. So it is really sad.

She recently came to stay. This was actually my suggestion as I know she is bored and lonely and I thought it would cheer her up. Unfortunately it was a disaster. She was in a terrible mood with DH because he asked her to get the train (he used to pick her up and drive to ours but it’s a six hour round trip). So she barely spoke to him or me for the first 24 hours. She didn’t want to go out anywhere so she sat and watched daytime TV for six hours (this is not an exaggeration). She cried a lot of the time and turned most conversations round to FIL.

She is clearly depressed but won’t go to the doctor or have counselling. She is in a terrible place but she won’t accept any help and is very rude to DH. She refused to say goodbye to him, again because she was unhappy about having to get the train. At the end we were both completely exhausted and fed up and the kids were a bit confused by the whole thing.

I had suggested to DH that we should invite her to stay again in March but I’ve just said I think we should abandon that idea because I don’t think I can face it again. However, I also feel like a terrible person because she is obviously very sad. I don’t know what the answer is really. But I have my own issues with work, family illness, kids etc and I just don’t think I can face this on top.

OP posts:
AnnieSnap · 30/01/2023 22:58

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy I absolutely get what you are saying. You are completely right that antidepressant medication can defer the grieving process, but that they are excellent drugs when appropriate. I speak as an expert in Mental Health. I wasn’t going to post that point (because on here those who believe they know don’t listen) until I saw you being challenged in a disrespectful way. I expect the brickbats to come my way now.

buffydavis · 30/01/2023 22:56

Highdaysandholidays1 · 30/01/2023 19:56

I am a widow. I don't ignore people for 24 hours or wail every day or bring every conversation around to my dead husband. I'd probably like to do some of those things but I don't because it would be horrible for those around me, I have kids, I have to work (if MIL was employed she wouldn't have 18 months off work or be allowed to be rude to colleagues), it's just not possible to live that life endlessly.

I honestly don't know anyone in my family who acts like this and many of us have lost life partners. I know people who have become depressed, lonely and so on but most have gone to bereavement 'clubs', counselling, written, moaned to the odd friend, gone on antidepressants, it's the fact she's not doing any of it and it's getting worse that's so problematic.

I don't equate this with a lost temper on a one-off, this is a more profound issue, which probably was there prior to the grief, it sounds like she had few friends and made her husband her whole life and now he's gone she has no idea how to Iive, but ultimately she either has to rebuild herself or over time everyone will move away from her, people won't stay around to be ignored, wailed at and depressed for many years because pretty much everyone loses someone (parent, partner, good friend, god forbid child) at some point and so you have to end up preserving your own sanity.

Nicely put.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 30/01/2023 22:44

LovePoppy · 30/01/2023 22:34

Dude, you have no freaking idea what others have gone through. None.

Im sorry for your loss, but get off your high horse.

Not on any high horse, just commenting on a public forum from personal experience - as is everyone else. Problem is that some posters aren’t actually reading what people write - they misunderstand, confer their own interpretation and try to call them out. And to tell someone who has been through the loss of a life partner that they have no idea what others have been through is fucking ridiculous. Grow up.

LovePoppy · 30/01/2023 22:34

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 30/01/2023 21:14

I said I wouldn’t return to the thread but how dare you. I know how anti depressant medication works as I have been treated for depression on and off for thirty years and some medication takes away the ability to feel anything, which is not helpful with the grieving process - at some point you have to deal with it head on. I suggested that medication may not be helpful to MIL at this point because she was already 18 months in and possibly dealing with a second onslaught of grief brought about by the realisation and acceptance of her situation - which is a perfectly natural stage of grief and has to be faced.

Take offence all you want - I never ever suggested that people on medication were not dealing with their trauma. I said I had refused it and why. I don’t need to do research I’ve lived it. This is a fucking awful thread and this is yet another indication that some posters have very little idea of the natural grieving process.

Dude, you have no freaking idea what others have gone through. None.

Im sorry for your loss, but get off your high horse.

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 22:33

Grieving is not depression. It may as someone suggested be traumatic grief though.

stacyvaron · 30/01/2023 22:31

It's impossible for those who haven't lived it to understand how someone can suck the life from the room. There is no silliness or joy or lightness if she's there and it takes a toll on all of you. She is DEPRESSED in addition to grieving, and refuses to help herself. She doesn't have to be a sunbeam, but she needs to take care of her depression as she would a heart condition or diabetes. You are doing her a disservice by supporting her current behavior.

PepperRed · 30/01/2023 22:18

I find it horrid that some are critical of you OP. You posted to try to find a solution to a terrible situation. You are being good and supportive to your DH and children and trying your best for your MIL.

Your MIL is very probably suffering from PTSD. She may be depressed. Depressed people are very very selfish. They can' help it. And they can sap the sympathy out of all around them. I do not see her behavior being 'just' grief. Grief is normal for her situation but not all consuming.
Yes, she can get the train. It will help her to adjust to her new reality. Yes, you need to set boundaries and be straight with her.

I lost my husband at 60. I was mostly able to put one foot in front of the other and keep going. Time does the rest and a willingness to live.

She will not get better tho if she does not find a way to change - doctor - medication - help group etc.

Crikeyalmighty · 30/01/2023 22:17

@Highdaysandholidays1 I've got a lovely 83 year old FIL (very youthful) with exactly your attitude and he's been widowed twice. We enjoy having him to stay for 3 days about every 5 weeks and he drives 3 hours to usas he prefers where we live as it has more'life' . We've been on holiday with him too and his view is he wants to cram in as much as he can.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 30/01/2023 22:03

logicisall · 30/01/2023 21:18

She only wants to cry, talk about FIL and watch TV, really.

I was widowed at 62. Grief is a process without short cuts, and we all experience it differently. Seven years on, I am only just starting to use the past tense when talking about DH. I was glad that I had no one to see the many days when I just cried, watched tv and wallowed in grief. I had to force myself to look at funny shows knowing that smiling/laughing fools the brain into a happier feeling. I was so concerned that I might be depressed that I attended a session with a counsellor who said that I was not depressed, just sad and grieving. I think that gave me permission to grieve as I wanted, in private. I used to warn friends if I was about to cry and everyone understood.

I know that your MIL isn't interested in support groups atm, but from a recommendation on the Macmillan Cancer website, I found out about www.way-up.co.uk. It is both an online group and local group meet-ups resource. I don't use it much anymore, but it was helpful to realise that how I was feeling wasn't unusual and there were lots of handholding and support, with people telling their experiences and offering advice. Why not show MIL the site and explore it together. It's a bit like MN for widows and widowers.

OP, I guess what I am trying to say is that it's ok to just let MIL do what she wants to, right now. It might be frustrating for you to see her like this, but at the same time she soon needs to realise that she is now alone and has to step up her independence even though every "first" will be scary.

The voice of reason. I was 59. I think contributors to this thread are not grasping that grief and depression are two different things. I found it very hard, and still do, to refer to my late husband in the past tense. The first time I had to utter the phrase, ‘my husband died’ was so hard I still can’t find the words to describe it nearly six years on. It’s interesting that you mention you watched comedy shows - I found myself taking comfort from sitcoms like Frasier and one or two other similar shows. They seemed familiar and friendly, and when I was at the stage where I couldn’t sleep without the TV on in the bedroom it was a comfort. Strange the things we do isn’t it ?

I well remember a second, really hard swipe of grief in my second year when it hit me that this was my life from now on and that I had to get on with it. My counsellor advised that this was part of the process, and the OP’s description of her MIL’s behaviour did make me wonder whether she is now at this stage because I was similarly affected. Acceptance is the hardest part I think - when you lose your life partner it takes a long time to come to terms with the impact on every area of your life and I think anger and frustration go hand in hand with the process of accepting things as they are, while you’re still longing for the life you lost.

I found WayUp about two weeks after I lost my husband and for me it was a life saver. I found a lot of support and stayed with it for about 3 years - I went to one or two of the meet ups when I felt strong enough and found those really helpful too. I’ve suggested that the OP visit the site because I think it would be helpful for all of them. As you will know the people on there are at different stages of the journey and experiencing different types of loss, so there’s a wealth of experience and I think it’s more appropriate than the frankly, sometimes combative atmosphere of MN. I think the OP’s MIL and her DH will find it helpful and hopefully the OP will too, as it may give her the tools she needs to help her family through it all.

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 21:59

@RoseThornside If she is very anxious about using the train she is not going to go on leisure journeys by train without more support.

RoseThornside · 30/01/2023 21:53

A 2 hour train journey for a retired person as opposed to a six hour drive (3 hours there, 3 hours back) for a full-time working parent? She's being selfish here, and that is because she has never been the driver. She can blank out the 3 hours your DH has already been driving before he gets to her because she can.

Don't back down on this OP. Keep having to stay, yes, but using the train will eventually give her some independence even if she can't see it now. She might visit other places on the train, you never know.

PuzzledObserver · 30/01/2023 21:50

I’d like to encourage OP to adopt the both-and approach.

BOTH: Mil is really hard to be around and it’s draining when she apparently shows no inclination to do any of the things that might help her work through her grief (NOT get over FIL’s death or get back to normal, because she never can. But she can accept and develop a new normal, which will be different to the previous normal, and will (eventually) have its own kind of joy and purpose)

AND: She needs love, compassion, support and time to do what she needs to do.

Could your DH talk to her and say something like, look mum, I can see you’re really struggling - and I miss Dad too - but last time you came it didn’t seem like it did you any good at all. What can we do differently? Could we maybe plan to go out for a coffee/take the kids to the park/ just go for a walk when you’re here?

I dunno. I don’t think personally you should feel guilty that you feel negatively towards her. Being around someone who is depressed and passive is really hard work. But it’s very unlikely she’s suddenly going to find the will to start joining groups or going to counselling. It’s going to take a lot of coaxing - and that needs patience.

Simplelobsterhat · 30/01/2023 21:27

savethatkitty · 30/01/2023 21:20

How is it a 6 hour round trip when the train takes 2 hours? 2 hours there + 2 hours back = 4hours. Does traffic add another 2 hours to the journey.

It's really not unusual for trains to be quicker than car (although I guess op may not have factored in getting to the station.) But even if it too slightly longer, it's still a retired person traveling one way in a day, not someone who works full time travelling two ways in one day, so I think the exact time is irrelevant.

Untitledsquatboulder · 30/01/2023 21:24

savethatkitty · 30/01/2023 21:20

How is it a 6 hour round trip when the train takes 2 hours? 2 hours there + 2 hours back = 4hours. Does traffic add another 2 hours to the journey.

Are you serious? You know that trains can be quicker than cars over long distances right?

ManchesterGirl2 · 30/01/2023 21:23

savethatkitty · 30/01/2023 21:20

How is it a 6 hour round trip when the train takes 2 hours? 2 hours there + 2 hours back = 4hours. Does traffic add another 2 hours to the journey.

Trains can go at 120 miles per hour.

savethatkitty · 30/01/2023 21:20

How is it a 6 hour round trip when the train takes 2 hours? 2 hours there + 2 hours back = 4hours. Does traffic add another 2 hours to the journey.

logicisall · 30/01/2023 21:18

She only wants to cry, talk about FIL and watch TV, really.

I was widowed at 62. Grief is a process without short cuts, and we all experience it differently. Seven years on, I am only just starting to use the past tense when talking about DH. I was glad that I had no one to see the many days when I just cried, watched tv and wallowed in grief. I had to force myself to look at funny shows knowing that smiling/laughing fools the brain into a happier feeling. I was so concerned that I might be depressed that I attended a session with a counsellor who said that I was not depressed, just sad and grieving. I think that gave me permission to grieve as I wanted, in private. I used to warn friends if I was about to cry and everyone understood.

I know that your MIL isn't interested in support groups atm, but from a recommendation on the Macmillan Cancer website, I found out about www.way-up.co.uk. It is both an online group and local group meet-ups resource. I don't use it much anymore, but it was helpful to realise that how I was feeling wasn't unusual and there were lots of handholding and support, with people telling their experiences and offering advice. Why not show MIL the site and explore it together. It's a bit like MN for widows and widowers.

OP, I guess what I am trying to say is that it's ok to just let MIL do what she wants to, right now. It might be frustrating for you to see her like this, but at the same time she soon needs to realise that she is now alone and has to step up her independence even though every "first" will be scary.

Mischance · 30/01/2023 21:18

The idea of taking responsibility for one's own mental well-being is great on paper but when in the grip of a serious depression makes no sense at all. When I was in that state, just getting out of bed was beyond me, and all I wanted was to die. I had neither the physical nor emotional strength to take responsibility for anything at all.

AtticusFrost · 30/01/2023 21:16

A lot of anti depressants come with withdrawal when you stop them.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 30/01/2023 21:14

LovePoppy · 30/01/2023 20:55

...Thats not how medication works. You aren't a zombie. You feel what you feel, but it helps keep you moving so you don't get stuck in the lowest of the lows.

I fail to see how that's a bad thing.

I also take offense at your clear idea that people on medication are not dealing with their trauma. Do some research. Maybe meds wouldn't have been right for you but some people do really need them and they help.

I said I wouldn’t return to the thread but how dare you. I know how anti depressant medication works as I have been treated for depression on and off for thirty years and some medication takes away the ability to feel anything, which is not helpful with the grieving process - at some point you have to deal with it head on. I suggested that medication may not be helpful to MIL at this point because she was already 18 months in and possibly dealing with a second onslaught of grief brought about by the realisation and acceptance of her situation - which is a perfectly natural stage of grief and has to be faced.

Take offence all you want - I never ever suggested that people on medication were not dealing with their trauma. I said I had refused it and why. I don’t need to do research I’ve lived it. This is a fucking awful thread and this is yet another indication that some posters have very little idea of the natural grieving process.

BlazingFlames · 30/01/2023 21:14

I agree. The second year of being widowed can be more difficult than the first year.

Hopefully in the first year family and folk will be supportive and helpful to the widow/widower. However, this often drops off ( ' it's been a year, should be over it by now' ) but the widowed person starts to realise that 'this is all there is' and that there is nothing to look forward to.

Until you've lost your partner you have no idea what it's like, or how you will copy. Basically, it's sh*t.

I can also recommend WayUp, an on-line forum, if your MiL has IT skills.
way-up.co.uk/

You don't sound like a very nice person, so I am not surprised your MiL doesn't take any advice from you.

Salome61 · 30/01/2023 20:58

I was 59 when my husband died suddenly six years ago, and recognise your MIL's 'what ifs', her constant repetition is her shocked mind trying to accept the situation. I got home to find a man in my drive standing next to my husband who was face down on the lawn, he hadn't tried CPR, he'd just stopped his car and asked my neighbour to phone for an ambulance. It still haunts me that I might have been able to save him if I'd got home sooner, although I know the reality is that only 2% of cardiac arrest cases do survive.

These regrets are normal, but talking everything through with a counsellor helps.

It is so difficult being widowed, your whole future changes and you have to do everything yourself, on your own. Personally I feel very vulnerable.

Good luck, I hope your DH manages to persuade her that bereavement counselling would help.

FloraSpoke · 30/01/2023 20:56

Hadtocomment · 29/01/2023 12:09

I read previous thread on this I think. OP, you don't sound like the worst person in the world. You sound like a really nice and caring person in fact. You care a lot about how your DP is feeling and you care about your MIL too. It also must be hard seeing the effect of your MIL's grief on your DP. Of course you want to minimise that.

I'm no expert on grief and so please ignore if this is just rubbish. But I have had a friend who experienced a very sudden bereavement. One of the things that surprised me was after the initial shock and grief period, they became very angry. Kind gestures from others were interpretted badly. They seemed angry with anyone trying to do or so anything to help. My friend eventually came out of this again, but I wonder if it can be a common and understandable reaction particularly with a sudden and unexpected situation like this. You resent seeing others getting on with life when your own has been totally derailed. You're stuck in grief and other people trying to "make it better" must seem almost offensive even? I can't pretend to understand as I've not gone through it but I'm wondering if your MIL is behaving badly to your DH partly because she is feeling angry at the world - not at him really. But as part of her grieving and taking it out on him. I only say this because it might help you then be able to take a step back and not feel like either of you have done anythign wrong or that you have to take it on or even take it quite so personally? Perhaps it doesn't matter that she was cross about the train. Perhaps it's still good for her to be getting the train and doing something different and keeping on practising normal life skills even if she feels angry about it? Perhaps your DH can see her anger with him as not being at him but at the world? Perhaps this could allow you to keep going with the visits without letting them bring you two down?

I don't see anything wrong with reminding her gently if she is sending DH to conventry that it's not fair on him and he's grieving too, and leave it at that.

You don't say how long the visits are for. I think you need to be there too as otherwise it just sounds hellish for your DH who sounds like a really lovely and caring son, but who is also grieving and doesn't deserve the silent treatment.

I'd try and come up with a plan where you do see her but for shorter times. Perhaps drop in on the way somewhere else. Or stay elsewhere. Or stay for just one or two nights and then stay elsewhere. Or have her for just a couple of nights. (Two hours is a short train journey so she wouldn't have to stay for ages). Then when she's there, just carry on doing normal things. If she stays all day watching TV, then that's ok, just carry on with your own life and ask her if she wants to join in and if not, that's ok too. At least she's traveled to you, as even if she didn't enjoy it it keeps her doing things and interacting with the world. I do think that's important or she could end up becoming totally isolated and losing confidence about simple tasks.

The key thing I think is not to feel so guilty and accept that you can't "solve" this and that her anger isn't actually your fault . It doesn't sound like you have anything to feel guilty about. If you and DH can communicate gently but clearly about the silent treatment bit then that might be good, even if it's difficult. If not, I'd try to not take all of this anger so personally. DH is grieving too, but he does have you and his kids and is very supported emotionally so perhaps use that support not to have to feel so upset that his mother is taking things out on him. SHe doesn't have that day to day emotional support and is obviously very depressed and lost right now. I'd try and find ways to keep her connected to doing things, even if very mundane like getting the train, even if she doesn't thank you for it, and not expecting her to be any kind of fun for a while. You can gently point her towards helpful groups/forums. Is there any kind of telephone service where someone can phone her or she can speak to someone? That might be a less traumatic way to start if she can't face traveling to and from groups. But if she won't do it, there's little you can do but give her the info and a bit of encouragement.

Hopefully, she will start to emerge from this in time. In the meantime, expecting her to do something (like the train) I think could actually be good to keep her doing mundane practical things so that when she feels strong enough to maybe seek out more help, she'll be able to do so. So I wouldn't feel guilty and I'd keep on finding ways to keep doors and connections open and maybe encourage very small steps.

This. A kind response with sensible advice.

LovePoppy · 30/01/2023 20:55

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 18:40

Grief and depression are not the same thing. And at 18 months it’s perfectly acceptable for her to still be grieving. I refused anti depressants after my husband died because they would only have delayed the grieving process. What would be the point of them now - all they would do is delay realisation and acceptance of her situation, which usually happens in the second year. It’s not that she’s not willing to try any form of support, she’s just not ready. Forcing the issue will make things worse, and counselling will only help if she’s ready engage with it fully and to face and work through issues that may be painful. From what you’ve said previously it doesn’t sound as though she’s anywhere near ready for this. And I would have thought her GP is the best person to distinguish between grief and depression.

...Thats not how medication works. You aren't a zombie. You feel what you feel, but it helps keep you moving so you don't get stuck in the lowest of the lows.

I fail to see how that's a bad thing.

I also take offense at your clear idea that people on medication are not dealing with their trauma. Do some research. Maybe meds wouldn't have been right for you but some people do really need them and they help.

JammiDodgers · 30/01/2023 20:53

Movinghouseatlast · 29/01/2023 10:10

Turn it around and imagine it's you in her situation. Imagine one of your children who you have brought up telling you to get on a train when they have always picked you up. Imagine being grief stricken and needing support. If you can truly put yourself in someone else's shoes then you are better able to talk to them about issues and make compromises with them

She isn't gping to be over the death of her husband in 18 months.

Yes this .