Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want to be around bereaved MIL anymore

757 replies

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 10:02

This is probably going to make me sound like the worst person in the world but here goes.

FIL died eighteen months ago, it was quite sudden and he was relatively young (65).

MIL is now very depressed. I do feel very sorry for her because FIL was basically her whole world. She doesn’t have any other family, doesn’t have many friends, doesn’t drive, and is retired. She used to spend most of her time with FIL. So it is really sad.

She recently came to stay. This was actually my suggestion as I know she is bored and lonely and I thought it would cheer her up. Unfortunately it was a disaster. She was in a terrible mood with DH because he asked her to get the train (he used to pick her up and drive to ours but it’s a six hour round trip). So she barely spoke to him or me for the first 24 hours. She didn’t want to go out anywhere so she sat and watched daytime TV for six hours (this is not an exaggeration). She cried a lot of the time and turned most conversations round to FIL.

She is clearly depressed but won’t go to the doctor or have counselling. She is in a terrible place but she won’t accept any help and is very rude to DH. She refused to say goodbye to him, again because she was unhappy about having to get the train. At the end we were both completely exhausted and fed up and the kids were a bit confused by the whole thing.

I had suggested to DH that we should invite her to stay again in March but I’ve just said I think we should abandon that idea because I don’t think I can face it again. However, I also feel like a terrible person because she is obviously very sad. I don’t know what the answer is really. But I have my own issues with work, family illness, kids etc and I just don’t think I can face this on top.

OP posts:
Cocochat · 29/01/2023 12:49

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 12:04

I’m interested in all the perspectives on this thread and I understand lots of different angles but I just can’t get my head around this.

Why is not reasonable for her to get the train? She is 64 and physically fit, it takes two hours and one of us meets her at the station/drops her off on the way back (and as above DH actually met her part of the way this time). We helped her to book the tickets and talked through the journey with her, although it’s not particularly complicated. We both work full time and she is retired.

Millions of people in their sixties and much older get trains every single day.

As a one off DH probably will still drive her (e.g. at Christmas when she will have lots of luggage etc) but I just don’t see the issue most of the time.

I agree with you OP.

My dm was separated at 46 and had to use public transport as she couldn’t drive.
My dm is 87 now and has only just started to struggle a bit on her own on train journeys.
At Christmas my db put her on the train and dsis met her at the change point and accompanied her on the rest of the journey.

Your mil is just used to being driven everywhere. The sooner she gets used to public transport the better.

Thankgoditsfriday1 · 29/01/2023 12:48

Could you arrange a weekend break together? Somewhere between the two locations. The neutral ground and with things to do that don't involve tv or the burden on you to entertain may make it more enjoyable for all.

ZenNudist · 29/01/2023 12:47

Yikes you are getting a hard time OP.

i am a fan of being supportive but i also think people have to help themselves.

I don't think refusing to see her is the solution. Offer to have her over in March but say that if she is going to not speak to DH then she needs to rethink. Dh needs to say he appreciates she is grieving but so is he and it made the last visit difficult and unpleasant. Tough love time over the train issue. It is the height of selfishness expecting your dh to drive her. Absolutely ridiculous because its perfectly possible for a 65 year old lone female to get a train, many do. Am I right that it's a 6 Hr drive there and back and dh does that twice? Or is it 6 hours in total driving vs 4 hours total on the train? Either is unacceptable.

7eleven · 29/01/2023 12:44

pattihews · 29/01/2023 12:34

OP, I think you sound reasonable and sympathetic. I suffered a really traumatic bereavement (the kind where a policeman turns up at your door in the early hours and boom, life as you knew it is gone) and I went through a long period of grief and mourning. Three years before the grey began to lift, five years until I felt I was back functioning fully again. So I can empathise with your OP.

I can remember how difficult it was to get out and socialise again, even with supportive friends and colleagues. But even though it was a strain, even when I was very low, I managed not to be an arsehole. I wasn't much fun, but I could see that people's intentions were good and it would never have dawned on me that it was okay to be rude or demanding. And sometimes I'd even find myself having a laugh and forgetting things for a while and would go home feeling better.

If your MIL is unable to control her feelings even in the presence of her GC and unable to show you or her DS basic gratitude for what you can offer (she didn't have to take up the offer of the visit) then I'd suggest:

a) she's clinically depressed and needs help from a GP and probably a therapist
b) from what you've said she's a dependant, narcissistic sort of person and always has been, but FIL acted as a shield. If she can't drive she will have to get used to public transport. I'm 61. I drive and sometimes I use the train.
c) that she's one of those people who get stuck in the grieving process. Again, something that probably needs a counsellor or a group to help shift.
d) she is looking to your DH to take over his father's role and he needs to hold his boundaries. He has you and the DC to think of.

MIL's an adult and there's nothing you can do if she continues to say no to all the helpful suggestions you make. With luck time will help her get through this, and you may be talking years yet.

What I might do in your circumstances is say that she was clearly very unhappy staying with you and that it unsettled the children, so you'd like to put March's visit on hold. That might seem unkind, but it could be the prod she needs to start to think beyond herself.

I might propose a visit to her, perhaps over Easter. Could you bear to stay with her? If not, how about renting an Airbnb near her home and just call in for an hour or two? Perhaps your DH could help with gardening or DIY (I know, not much of a break for him but needs must) and you could all take her out and about locally and perhaps get her back into the swing of things? Good luck. You sound like a thoughtful DIL.

Brilliant post x

HerReputationMadeItDifficultToProceed · 29/01/2023 12:43

This sounds a bit like my granny. My grandfather died suddenly (although he did have a heart condition, but the heart attack that killed him did come out of the blue). That was 20 years ago. She's never tried to help herself and as time has gone on our sympathy has worn thin. As you say @turquoisepenguin she often, even now, wants to talk at length about his final 48hrs and the things she did that she could have done differently to prevent his death. She didn't have many friends or much of a life outside of my granddad and wouldn't get any help outside of the family after he died. As such it was all put on my parent and aunts and uncles, all of whom had just lost their father. She's refused all mental health support and pushed everyone away (and actually been quite nasty to us over the years.) Often gets angry we don't seem to miss him "enough" when- with all due respect because I loved my granddad deeply- he was an 85yr old who had been unwell. It wasn't like he was cut down in his prime. She also gets very angry at important moments (weddings, births, graduations, anniversaries) that we are celebrating the thing and not as depressed as she is that our father/grandfather isn't there to see it. This attitude put a cloud over the births of my kids and my wedding and those of my siblings and cousins.

Basically, I hear you because you can't help someone who doesn't want to be helped. Hopefully your MIL will change and come round but you might be in for 20 odd years of this if our experience is anything to go by and you need to protect your own mental health and your kids mental health from it. Your DH should have a serious conversation with her about getting herself some support, but if she won't you can't make her and you may need to accept that and distance yourself.

7eleven · 29/01/2023 12:40

The pp saying it’s only been 18 months….how long until not speaking to someone for a day isn’t ok? 2 years?

3 years?

It’s never ok to behave like that.

RosesAndHellebores · 29/01/2023 12:40

@Movinghouseatlast the OP's MIL is not entitled to claim her state pension before the age of 66. She could have been working full-time and would have had to pick herself up to go back to work.

I can also see that her DH might have been at the beginning of his retirement and she is also grieving for theirnfree time together and what they might have done as well as for the bereavement.

Robinni · 29/01/2023 12:39

@turquoisepenguin I think you need to accept Mil as she is, complicated grief and all.

You are literally going to have no idea about any of her feelings until you either lose a parent or spouse yourself. It’s not relatable until you’ve been through it. A sudden death is particularly traumatic and 18m is a very short amount of time. It sounds like she may be having a delayed grief response/complicated grief and you can expect her to be quite messed up until about 5years have passed.

She doesn’t want to be on the train on her own as it reminds her that her husband - who should be with her - is dead. She has to sit on that train alone, watching other elderly couples together no doubt and thinking we should have been doing this together. Added to this she is probably having difficulties with day to day function due to the level of grief.

If she comes down one or other of you should pick her up and keep things the same. Alternatively go to her. Or you could book a week together as a family to go somewhere - this will go one of two ways, either she will find the new place/activities distracting and it will lift her, or she will retreat to her room and cry. Probably a mix of both. In any event you will have your own space, kids will be oblivious to worst of gran’s behaviour as they’ll be out doing things (and away from the room crying). It’s worth a shot. I would still pick her up though, she isn’t ready to be independent single woman yet. She’s exhausted and needs tlc.

Hesma · 29/01/2023 12:38

Can you go and stay with her in Match? That way you can always leave…

Movinghouseatlast · 29/01/2023 12:36

FrostyFifi · 29/01/2023 12:16

I realise two hours by train sounds fine to a younger, working age person, but perhaps it’s daunting for her

She's 64 and physically fit, how on earth would it be daunting?

Read a few posts on, the experiences of a bereaved person. It's emotionally daunting. That's 'how on earth' she could find it difficult

figmaofmyimagination · 29/01/2023 12:36

I don’t think you’re doing anything wrong, OP. You HAVE both put yourselves out to be there for her, and she’s chosen to be rude and ungrateful in return. Grieving someone you love dearly isn’t a free pass to be an arse to everyone else (and yes, i have experienced it, before anyone starts).

I would hang fire on the March visit for now- see how you feel nearer the time. Maybe research some community activities near her that aren’t grief relates- church coffee morning? U3A? Volunteer opportunities etc? - and send them througj to her once in a while. Ultimately she is going to have to make some decisions about how she wants her life to look now.

Keep being there for you as you can be, but set the boundaries you need to and keep in mind that ultimately it IS her responsibility to choose how she wants to live and be now.

WinedropsOnMoses · 29/01/2023 12:35

I feel so sorry for her.I also feel so sorry for your poor husband. He's grieving too. Were your kids close with her?

Agree there is no timeline for grief. My dad lost my Mum when she was just 55. They were together since teenagers.Even in the early stages, his main concern was my siblings and I, as well as his grandchildren. 9 years later, he's still grieving and has never recovered the 'jolliness' he was famed for. The thought of meeting someone else seems alien to him.

But he remains the kindest, most selfless person I've ever met and has never behaved in the way you describe. I would echo what PPs have said, in the kindest way she needs to look at her behaviour and get some help for all of your sakes.

pattihews · 29/01/2023 12:34

OP, I think you sound reasonable and sympathetic. I suffered a really traumatic bereavement (the kind where a policeman turns up at your door in the early hours and boom, life as you knew it is gone) and I went through a long period of grief and mourning. Three years before the grey began to lift, five years until I felt I was back functioning fully again. So I can empathise with your OP.

I can remember how difficult it was to get out and socialise again, even with supportive friends and colleagues. But even though it was a strain, even when I was very low, I managed not to be an arsehole. I wasn't much fun, but I could see that people's intentions were good and it would never have dawned on me that it was okay to be rude or demanding. And sometimes I'd even find myself having a laugh and forgetting things for a while and would go home feeling better.

If your MIL is unable to control her feelings even in the presence of her GC and unable to show you or her DS basic gratitude for what you can offer (she didn't have to take up the offer of the visit) then I'd suggest:

a) she's clinically depressed and needs help from a GP and probably a therapist
b) from what you've said she's a dependant, narcissistic sort of person and always has been, but FIL acted as a shield. If she can't drive she will have to get used to public transport. I'm 61. I drive and sometimes I use the train.
c) that she's one of those people who get stuck in the grieving process. Again, something that probably needs a counsellor or a group to help shift.
d) she is looking to your DH to take over his father's role and he needs to hold his boundaries. He has you and the DC to think of.

MIL's an adult and there's nothing you can do if she continues to say no to all the helpful suggestions you make. With luck time will help her get through this, and you may be talking years yet.

What I might do in your circumstances is say that she was clearly very unhappy staying with you and that it unsettled the children, so you'd like to put March's visit on hold. That might seem unkind, but it could be the prod she needs to start to think beyond herself.

I might propose a visit to her, perhaps over Easter. Could you bear to stay with her? If not, how about renting an Airbnb near her home and just call in for an hour or two? Perhaps your DH could help with gardening or DIY (I know, not much of a break for him but needs must) and you could all take her out and about locally and perhaps get her back into the swing of things? Good luck. You sound like a thoughtful DIL.

Candymay · 29/01/2023 12:34

There’s a lot of mention here of various support groups and whilst I agree they can be helpful it makes me think of a time before there were support groups. There was hopefully family and friends and a network of people to listen, accept and be kind. Now it seems like op is saying ffs can you not find someone else to take your troubles out on? Good times only for us.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 29/01/2023 12:33

I understand OP. I'm going to be blunt, my MIL ended up being selfish and forgetting her own children were grieving too

And it sounds like that's what's happening here. It's not ok that she expects to continually retraumatise one of the other bereaved people.

giroux321 · 29/01/2023 12:32

I lost my mother 31 years ago...I still grieve. It is all fine and dandy to say " I can't imagine doing such and such" but if you have never lost a partner, who was your world, as it sounds like he was, then you have zero to say about it. Grief ebbs and flows and can hit all of a sudden. There are many stages to grief and she could be in the anger/blame one. It sounds to me like she needs her family, ie:you, to listen with compassion as she processes! It may well be repetitive and get old but if you put yourself in her shoes then I bet you would hope to have your family be there for you no matter what. Time will definitely be helpful and 18 months is NOTHING! If she is going over the last moments wondering what she could have done as well, it sounds like she is blaming herself for not recognising any signs that might have been there and wishing she had. That is a hard burden to carry. I think asking her to take the train isn't out of order. I think that sometimes, just having people about to "sit" with you is helpful. So I say, for now, put aside your thoughts on it and give her love and understanding, even if she is rude. Kill it with kindness and let her process, listen, give her access to resources like groups etc but it is up to her to decide if she wants to get involved. She might at a later date and then will have the information she needs at her fingertips.

RosesAndHellebores · 29/01/2023 12:31

I can see this from two perspectives op.

Firstly MIL was widowed 16 years ago aged 70, when FIL died very suddenly. Ever since DH visited regularly, now at least monthly as she has Parkinsons and is elderly. She isn't the nicest woman in the world but nowhere near your MIL in the context of dependency. Until about three years ago, into her early 80s she visited 2/3 times a year by train. A 2.5 hour journey to King's Cross, then a tube and another train.

The last year or two she was able to travel before Covid she got a cab from King's Cross to DH's office. She lives 240 miles away door to door. A round trip is similar to your DH's about 7 to 8 hours. DH wouldn't do it, not least because it's 8 hours to collect and another 8 to return and about 1000 miles in all. We both work full-time and it would be exhausting. We are also both used to very long drives as we have a home in Southern France but those drives come with a bit of a break even if a short one. Despite being experienced long distanced drivers we wouldn't do it and I don't think realistically we could do it.

Secondly and what is saddest is that your MIL seems to have been entirely dependent on your late FIL. At 64 I find that extraordinary and wonder who disempowered whom. Did your MIL never get the train to town to see a gallery or exhibition or do some shopping whilst your FIL was working? Even MIL did that despite being more than 20 years older than your MIL. Thankfully she worked until she was 60 so was used to travelling to work and making decisions.

I'm a year younger than your MIL and feel she is being far too dependent too dependent and possibly has been for decades. I am devoted to DH and we have been together for 35 years. If anything happened to him I would be bereft. But I could also catch a plane, let alone a train, drive myself to see my children who I love deeply and at 64 will probably still be working. I would however be incandescent if one of the children suggested I needed to downsize because I couldn't manage the house or needed them to sort out odd jobs for me.

I think your DH needs to sit down with MIL and actually explain that a six hour round trip and in reverse is exhausting, eats into limited leave and amounts to x hundreds of miles. The entitlement around this is breathtaking.

Mischance · 29/01/2023 12:30

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 10:39

I’m very sorry for your loss, but I think your post here summarises the key difference. She has not grabbed any opportunities for help, she leans on my DH and one or two friends only.

Yes we have suggested Cruse and various other support groups but she won’t go, she says she’s not ready/can’t face the journey/it won’t help/she’s fine without it.

Both CRUSE and WayUp do not require her to go out. She can contact them on the phone and online. Is she talking with you all on WhatsApp or online? I have a Whatsapp group with all my DDs and we are chatting most days - they send me photos of what they have been doing.

64 really is young for MIL to be turning her back on life. She could have another 30 years yet.

LimeTreeGrove · 29/01/2023 12:28

Just to mention that anger is part of grieving. It's understandable as losing a husband early is very unfair!

whaaaa · 29/01/2023 12:26

Whether getting the train is daunting or not is nothing to do with age and instead to do with your general life experience. I live in a small town full of people of all ages who've barely ever left it. The nearest big city is an hour away but people talk as if it's the other side of the world. I doubt many on MN can relate to that.

LimeTreeGrove · 29/01/2023 12:26

It's a shame she won't try anti depressants. I lost my husband and found them helpful. I grieved for about 3 years. Not constantly. It came in waves. I found when I was with other people I was at my happiest. What is her reason for not giving anti ds a try?

Tamarindtree · 29/01/2023 12:25

Has this been posted before?

Candymay · 29/01/2023 12:24

bloodywhitecat · 29/01/2023 12:17

I was widowed almost a year ago and I am in no way ready to move out of my home either. Every day that passes feels like I am leaving DH further and further behind, I can't even bring myself to call him my 'late' DH because, to me, he's not. I am not ready for groups yet either. And I do want to rehash his last days over and over because I think I have some kind of trauma over how he died but I don't because I guess it's not socially acceptable. Life feels like constantly wading through treacle and I have no desire to wake up most days. The grief of losing a partner and the grief of losing a parent are equal but very, very different.

I am guessing that suddenly having to negotiate travel is a scary prospect for her. When my dad died my mum stopped being able to do the journeys on public transport that she had always managed before and, as a non driver she is now reliant on us picking her up. Once upon a time train stations were manned with staff who could help if you needed it but now they are often lonely places and can be confusing if you have trouble understanding all the information boards etc.

This is so eloquently worded. I’m so sorry for your loss. People being irritated or put out by being with a bereaved person sound so cold.

Jacopo · 29/01/2023 12:24

@bloodywhitecat 💐

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/01/2023 12:22

You’re expecting too much, too soon. Try to be a little more understanding.

Swipe left for the next trending thread