Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want to be around bereaved MIL anymore

757 replies

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 10:02

This is probably going to make me sound like the worst person in the world but here goes.

FIL died eighteen months ago, it was quite sudden and he was relatively young (65).

MIL is now very depressed. I do feel very sorry for her because FIL was basically her whole world. She doesn’t have any other family, doesn’t have many friends, doesn’t drive, and is retired. She used to spend most of her time with FIL. So it is really sad.

She recently came to stay. This was actually my suggestion as I know she is bored and lonely and I thought it would cheer her up. Unfortunately it was a disaster. She was in a terrible mood with DH because he asked her to get the train (he used to pick her up and drive to ours but it’s a six hour round trip). So she barely spoke to him or me for the first 24 hours. She didn’t want to go out anywhere so she sat and watched daytime TV for six hours (this is not an exaggeration). She cried a lot of the time and turned most conversations round to FIL.

She is clearly depressed but won’t go to the doctor or have counselling. She is in a terrible place but she won’t accept any help and is very rude to DH. She refused to say goodbye to him, again because she was unhappy about having to get the train. At the end we were both completely exhausted and fed up and the kids were a bit confused by the whole thing.

I had suggested to DH that we should invite her to stay again in March but I’ve just said I think we should abandon that idea because I don’t think I can face it again. However, I also feel like a terrible person because she is obviously very sad. I don’t know what the answer is really. But I have my own issues with work, family illness, kids etc and I just don’t think I can face this on top.

OP posts:
Stunningscreamer · 29/01/2023 18:10

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 15:11

@Stunningscreamer Some people are naturally more anxious. I think finding ways to help her manage the train journey would be good. But I would not just dismiss her anxiety as if it is not real.

What is she doing to help with her anxiety? Has she asked for help with the journey?

Good for you if you would use your annual leave to regularly do six hour trips to pick someone who is fit and healthy up. Some people have to balance what they do for their fit and healthy parents with their obligations to themselves, their wives and their children. It doesn't give the parent the right to sulk and be rude to them in their own house. Funnily enough her anxiety didn't stop her actually getting the train, did it? The best way, in fact the only way, to address your anxiety is to face your fears. Giving into it effectively makes it worse.

HamBone · 29/01/2023 18:10

Some people certainly deal with bereavement better than others. Some people are also more emotionally dependent than others- the MIL sounds like a dependent sort of person, tbh. She was clearly v. reliable on her DH and feels totally lost without him. Gradually, she’ll need to find her feet and as I said upthread, I think her son would be best placed to visit her alone and talk to her about practical ways to help her.

MissWings · 29/01/2023 18:09

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy

No, you don’t get to say your grief was worse than someone who lost both of their parents. I’m sorry but you just don’t. Or maybe yours is the “all encompassing” type. That’s not true you’re just deciding to wallow in it more than someone else who takes a more grateful and proactive approach.

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 18:09

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune So you are basically saying if someone is bereaved it is fine to cry once or twice after they have died, and then a small sadness at important occasions. But otherwise you should appear to everyone else as if you are totally normal.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/01/2023 18:09

Is her son supposed to give up all of his annual leave to pander to a woman who is perfectly able and capable of grabbing a train?

This is the sort of thing I had in mind when saying it's important to look at the longer term, bigger picture. Nobody denies the impact of losing a much loved spouse and it's absolutely right that MIL's supported, but IME input has to be balanced so that "don't want to" doesn't become "can't", with more and more falling to OP/DH as the years pass

While this is undoubtably a traumatic time for MIL I've found there can be a risk of infantalising the bereaved, and that could be damaging - not least for MIL herself

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 18:08

@Stunningscreamer You are right. The son and DIL can tell her they want nothing to do with her until she is happy again. They do not have to do anything for her.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/01/2023 18:07

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 17:42

What you’re really saying is ‘let’s leave you to get on with it until you’re easier to deal with’.

Basically, yes, unless or until she can articulate something that will actually help her to move forward and create a new life for herself.

A few years ago my 88-year-old neighbour knocked on my door to tell me the horrifying news that her 55-year-old son had unexpectedly passed away. She sat at my kitchen table and said "I promised myself I wouldn't cry!" as she shed a few tears. He was the light of her life but she pulled herself together and said "I guess that chapter of my life is over," and continued to be part of the community band (she was a lifelong trumpet player), continued to garden, smilingly came over to play with my then-puppies, went on outings with her sister and otherwise lived her life until she died at age 94. She didn't sit in her chair and mope.

Some old friends gave her a big 90th birthday party; she was sad that her son couldn't be there but she was a smiling and gracious honoree and seemed to have a good time sharing memories of her entire life. But then she had a lot of friends, hobbies and other interests.

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 18:06

MissWings · 29/01/2023 17:45

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy

So it’s a get out of jail free card then because it’s “all encompassing”. No that’s just another way of saying you’re self obsessed and you haven’t got the capacity to think about anyone else but yourself. How long can it be “all encompassing” for?….5,10,15 years? At what point does that person take responsibility for their emotions and how they also think of others?

I am specifically talking about “normal bereavements” here. Losing a spouse is within the realms of normal. Losing a parent is also within the realms of normal. I am not referring to people who lose children because that’s not within the realm of normal. Kids shouldn’t go before you.

Certainly in “normal” bereavement circumstances then people can grieve for as long as they see fit but they should expect some consequences and boundaries if they try and drown everyone else around them with their own misery. It is quite possibly to be self aware even in the midst of grief but there are some “all encompassing” individuals who have no degree of self reflection or awareness on how their grief is actually affecting other people. At the core it can be incredibly selfish.

There is a reason that many people die within 12 months of their partner dying.

A spouse dying that you have most of your adult life with is normal. It is also for many (although not all) people devastating. That is why your risk of dying within 12 months of your spouse dying soars.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 18:06

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/01/2023 18:01

Personally I lost both parents, a grandmother, a beloved aunt and a close friend in a brief four-year span, while also finding out that my only sibling had advanced cancer (she was age 52 at the time.)

I actually contributed a chapter to a book that my workplace was producing, about 75 pages, in the three months after my mother died. I would not recognize that if I saw it, don't remember what I wrote and have zero desire to read it, but I fulfilled the commitment and apparently adequately so as it was published commercially with little editing. I did it because I didn't want to let the others down despite my immense grief.

I hold far more than an inkling about bereavement as do many others on this thread and quite frankly it is possible to grieve privately and quietly without insisting that others' lives also be dominated by it. It is quite possible to continue to be polite and considerate of others while deeply grieving.

And while I empathise with your loss, it doesn’t include that of a spouse. Entirely different animal.

Stunningscreamer · 29/01/2023 18:05

Rhondaa · 29/01/2023 16:50

'Some people take responsibility for their own mental well-being. Other people expect other people to pick up the pieces.'

Very noble but some people are simply unable to 'take responsibility for their own wellbeing' at certain stages such as bereavement, that is where the understanding and patience of supposed loved ones comes in you see.

You can't just expect people to give up their own lives indefinitely though. You just can't. The OP and the DH have been supportive. They've listened to MiL repeatedly, they've had her to stay, he's gone to pick her up. She can't just hand over her life to someone else to resolve.

They've been understanding and patient. MiL has refused to take any steps whatsoever to make her life better and to come to terms with her loss: counselling, medical support, seeking the support of other bereaved people. Nothing. No one is expecting the MiL to just get over it. But equally she can't expect everybody else to sacrifice themselves for her. The fact she quite easily has cut people out of her life suggests that she has always been someone for whom everything has to be on her terms or nothing.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 18:04

MissWings · 29/01/2023 17:53

@ancientgran Exactly. If no one has the monopoly on grief then why does her grief trump her sons?

If this woman actually had the capacity to be self aware she and her son could support one another. That’s what a lot of families do, they come together in their shared grief and support one another. One party doesn’t trump the other in terms who gets to be the “saddest”. That’s a fragmented approach and usually an entitled one.

My mother in law lost her 91 year old mother last year and believe you me. No one and I mean no one is allowed to express grief other than her. None of her siblings are allowed to grieve, none of the grandchildren and not her surviving aunt. She refuses help and support but then told all her family on Christmas Eve including her grandchildren that she was suicidal and ready to die. My husband gently encouraged a conversation about how she might think about being grateful she got to have her mother around for so long. He was met with hostility and rage. It’s all just allllllllll encompassing you see.

The whole family is now sick of her.

Yet another example that you haven’t grasped it. She hasn’t the capacity to be self aware because she’s grieving the loss of her husband, and 18 months is nothing - a drop in the ocean - where that kind of grief is concerned. She’s not competing to see who’s the saddest, and she’s not ‘entitled’ - she’s grieving !! Your mother in law lost her mother last year - not very long -and yet you are castigating her for grieving. In the depths of my grief for the loss of my husband, if someone had suggested being grateful for having him around for so long I’d have hit them !!

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/01/2023 18:01

smileladiesplease · 29/01/2023 17:15

Reading some of the responses it's clear many have not the smallest inkling of what grief can do to some people. It's been 18 months ffs educate yourselves. Not so much you op I think you are trying very hard to help her but some responses are very harsh and lacking in understanding

Personally I lost both parents, a grandmother, a beloved aunt and a close friend in a brief four-year span, while also finding out that my only sibling had advanced cancer (she was age 52 at the time.)

I actually contributed a chapter to a book that my workplace was producing, about 75 pages, in the three months after my mother died. I would not recognize that if I saw it, don't remember what I wrote and have zero desire to read it, but I fulfilled the commitment and apparently adequately so as it was published commercially with little editing. I did it because I didn't want to let the others down despite my immense grief.

I hold far more than an inkling about bereavement as do many others on this thread and quite frankly it is possible to grieve privately and quietly without insisting that others' lives also be dominated by it. It is quite possible to continue to be polite and considerate of others while deeply grieving.

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 18:01

A child dependant on you yes. An adult child that is not part of your day to day life no.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 17:59

MissWings · 29/01/2023 17:57

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy

A death of a spouse would certainly hit you hard but again it doesn’t necessarily get the monopoly on all other types of grief.

Personally I think losing a child is the unthinkable but that’s just my opinion.

Death touches us all at some point. Losing spouses and parents and siblings will affect us all at some point. We don’t all necessarily lose children before we die and I think that is the hardest.

Personally I think losing a child is the unthinkable but that’s just my opinion.

I was waiting for someone to say this. Typical MN.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 17:57

Greensleeves · 29/01/2023 17:52

On the face of it, nobody is going to respond to your post with "of course she should be allowed to be as rude and difficult as she likes" - but there are a couple of red flags in your post which make me think that things are not quite as one-sided as all that.

You say that she watched daytime TV for six hours - you make quite a big point out of that. Why is that such a big no-no for you? She's still quite recently bereaved, and depressed. Grief is exhausting. Was she hurting anbody by wanting to curl up in front of the telly rather than go out? Did you make your disapproval as obvious to her as you have in your OP? Because I found it rather sanctimonious and lacking in empathy.

You say that she spent a lot of the time crying. This indicates that not only is she depressed - hence the holing up in front of the TV and the low energy/lack of enthusiasm for wholesome pursuits - but that she is still very much in the raw early stages of grief. Any input from you/DH which comes across as trying to move her on before she is ready, or critical of the depth and pace of her grieving, is naturally going to be met with anger and hurt. You found her rude, uncooperative and negative. I wonder what she would say about you, if we could ask her.

It does also seem an odd time to have decided that she should travel by train, if she is used to being picked up. As a recently bereaved older person who, as you say, doesn't have much involvement with the world beyond the lifelong companion she has lost, this will have felt very daunting to her, and she was probably very hurt that her loved ones either couldnot see this, or did not consider it worth exercising a bit of patience and consideration over.

This. When I lost my husband I found that watching TV was a comfort. I watched crap soaps and American sitcoms - they took me out of myself for a while and I didn’t have to think about my own situation. When I was ready, I watched less and less and moved slowly back into the real world. A pp was suggesting that MIL needed a project - no understanding at all that 18 months is a very short time in which to come to terms with such a life changing event. Unless you have been through it, you can’t possibly understand it.

MissWings · 29/01/2023 17:57

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy

A death of a spouse would certainly hit you hard but again it doesn’t necessarily get the monopoly on all other types of grief.

Personally I think losing a child is the unthinkable but that’s just my opinion.

Death touches us all at some point. Losing spouses and parents and siblings will affect us all at some point. We don’t all necessarily lose children before we die and I think that is the hardest.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/01/2023 17:54

Crikeyalmighty · 29/01/2023 17:32

If I can just mention the 'wrenching every conversation round to the one sole topic' - that unfortunately is because in many cases they have nothing going on in life to talk about other than that. It is sadly a vicious circle.

Agree.

I have a co-worker who grew up with a terribly abusive father -- cruel, violent. It really sounds horrible. He never married and has one distant, alcoholic sister and as far as I can tell, one friend who is rather a mess.

He's a nice guy and can be witty but at age 66 EVERY single topic of chat somehow gets back around to "the time Dad pushed my face into my plate because I said I didn't want more gravy" or "the time Dad knocked mum over in the kitchen" or "we would have been shoved down the stairs if we'd asked Dad to take us on holiday."

He's had several years of therapy recently and seems a bit more at peace but cannot help himself from interjecting these traumatic events into the most benign conversations. "Quite a bit of rain we're having." Yes, Dad hated rain and used to get into a real temper when it did."

I often think if he had more of a life he wouldn't dwell so much. Have gently raised volunteer opportunities, part-time job opportunities (he's very kind and quiet and would make a great pet-sitter on Rover, for example; he loves animals, and could use the money), travel possibilities -- ANYTHING. He just goes to work, tends to his house (which he inherited from his parents; you'd think he'd want to live elsewhere instead of his childhood/teens years hellhole) and watches TV.

It's sad as I see people start to avoid him or drift away when he joins the conversation.

OP's MIL is going to end up like this if she doesn't look out.

smileladiesplease · 29/01/2023 17:53

I lost my much loved mum last year!

I know my grief snd loss although acute are no where to be compared to my dads loss of a wife lover friend and daily companion since 1955!!!

To compare the sons loss of a parent to a loss of a partner is utterly ridiculous

MissWings · 29/01/2023 17:53

@ancientgran Exactly. If no one has the monopoly on grief then why does her grief trump her sons?

If this woman actually had the capacity to be self aware she and her son could support one another. That’s what a lot of families do, they come together in their shared grief and support one another. One party doesn’t trump the other in terms who gets to be the “saddest”. That’s a fragmented approach and usually an entitled one.

My mother in law lost her 91 year old mother last year and believe you me. No one and I mean no one is allowed to express grief other than her. None of her siblings are allowed to grieve, none of the grandchildren and not her surviving aunt. She refuses help and support but then told all her family on Christmas Eve including her grandchildren that she was suicidal and ready to die. My husband gently encouraged a conversation about how she might think about being grateful she got to have her mother around for so long. He was met with hostility and rage. It’s all just allllllllll encompassing you see.

The whole family is now sick of her.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 17:52

ancientgran · 29/01/2023 17:43

Shouldn't the OP and her husband be entitled to think of his mental health? OP has said how hard it is for him to listen to her going over the events of his father's last few days, is he entitled to protect himself? How is it going to benefit anyone, even his mother, if she manages to pull him down into such a depression that he can't function? How about his timeline, this hasn't just happened to her.

By the way how do you know it is the worst experience of her life?

By the way how do you know it is the worst experience of her life?

Because I’ve been through it myself. Losing your life partner is not comparable to anything else. You not only lose the person, you lose your way of life, your shared memories, the protection and comfort of their love and the world becomes a much harsher place as a result. 18 months is a very short time to deal with everything that the loss of a life partner brings and the overwhelming sense I get from the OP is that they think MIL should be further forward than she is. Grief is a process, and everyone is different. How would you feel if you had to step out into a world that no longer contained the most important person in your life, and start all over again in trying to rebuild ?

Greensleeves · 29/01/2023 17:52

On the face of it, nobody is going to respond to your post with "of course she should be allowed to be as rude and difficult as she likes" - but there are a couple of red flags in your post which make me think that things are not quite as one-sided as all that.

You say that she watched daytime TV for six hours - you make quite a big point out of that. Why is that such a big no-no for you? She's still quite recently bereaved, and depressed. Grief is exhausting. Was she hurting anbody by wanting to curl up in front of the telly rather than go out? Did you make your disapproval as obvious to her as you have in your OP? Because I found it rather sanctimonious and lacking in empathy.

You say that she spent a lot of the time crying. This indicates that not only is she depressed - hence the holing up in front of the TV and the low energy/lack of enthusiasm for wholesome pursuits - but that she is still very much in the raw early stages of grief. Any input from you/DH which comes across as trying to move her on before she is ready, or critical of the depth and pace of her grieving, is naturally going to be met with anger and hurt. You found her rude, uncooperative and negative. I wonder what she would say about you, if we could ask her.

It does also seem an odd time to have decided that she should travel by train, if she is used to being picked up. As a recently bereaved older person who, as you say, doesn't have much involvement with the world beyond the lifelong companion she has lost, this will have felt very daunting to her, and she was probably very hurt that her loved ones either couldnot see this, or did not consider it worth exercising a bit of patience and consideration over.

ParallelParadise · 29/01/2023 17:50

Project

I've been through grief & I've helped other people through grief too

After time, people do need a project
Otherwise, the grief becomes all consuming !

If she has no friends or hobbies, she will need something. She cannot rely solely on her DS who lives 2 hours away.

ancientgran · 29/01/2023 17:47

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 17:44

No, there is no time limit and the family shouldn’t be expecting her to adhere to the expectation in their timeline. Yes, the OP’s husband has lost his dad. But he has a wife and family to comfort him. He’s not the one trying to come to terms with the loss of his whole way of life, and he’s not the one going home to an empty house. And if you think the loss of a parent is in any way comparable to the loss of your life partner, you’re in for a massive shock if it happens to you.

So you are judging how this man should feel and cope while telling us people shouldn't do that about his mother?

ancientgran · 29/01/2023 17:46

smileladiesplease · 29/01/2023 17:44

Does she need a project????

Utterly unbelivable the ignorance of the effects of grief.

Yes like people who can't understand a son's grief for his father. Utterly unbelievable that people have so little sympathy.

MissWings · 29/01/2023 17:45

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy

So it’s a get out of jail free card then because it’s “all encompassing”. No that’s just another way of saying you’re self obsessed and you haven’t got the capacity to think about anyone else but yourself. How long can it be “all encompassing” for?….5,10,15 years? At what point does that person take responsibility for their emotions and how they also think of others?

I am specifically talking about “normal bereavements” here. Losing a spouse is within the realms of normal. Losing a parent is also within the realms of normal. I am not referring to people who lose children because that’s not within the realm of normal. Kids shouldn’t go before you.

Certainly in “normal” bereavement circumstances then people can grieve for as long as they see fit but they should expect some consequences and boundaries if they try and drown everyone else around them with their own misery. It is quite possibly to be self aware even in the midst of grief but there are some “all encompassing” individuals who have no degree of self reflection or awareness on how their grief is actually affecting other people. At the core it can be incredibly selfish.