Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don’t want to be around bereaved MIL anymore

757 replies

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 10:02

This is probably going to make me sound like the worst person in the world but here goes.

FIL died eighteen months ago, it was quite sudden and he was relatively young (65).

MIL is now very depressed. I do feel very sorry for her because FIL was basically her whole world. She doesn’t have any other family, doesn’t have many friends, doesn’t drive, and is retired. She used to spend most of her time with FIL. So it is really sad.

She recently came to stay. This was actually my suggestion as I know she is bored and lonely and I thought it would cheer her up. Unfortunately it was a disaster. She was in a terrible mood with DH because he asked her to get the train (he used to pick her up and drive to ours but it’s a six hour round trip). So she barely spoke to him or me for the first 24 hours. She didn’t want to go out anywhere so she sat and watched daytime TV for six hours (this is not an exaggeration). She cried a lot of the time and turned most conversations round to FIL.

She is clearly depressed but won’t go to the doctor or have counselling. She is in a terrible place but she won’t accept any help and is very rude to DH. She refused to say goodbye to him, again because she was unhappy about having to get the train. At the end we were both completely exhausted and fed up and the kids were a bit confused by the whole thing.

I had suggested to DH that we should invite her to stay again in March but I’ve just said I think we should abandon that idea because I don’t think I can face it again. However, I also feel like a terrible person because she is obviously very sad. I don’t know what the answer is really. But I have my own issues with work, family illness, kids etc and I just don’t think I can face this on top.

OP posts:
SheldonsShoulder · 29/01/2023 19:06

My father died a few years ago when he was 61 and my mother has coped by keeping busy and socialising. She has done her best not to dwell on how unfair it was to lose him at quite a young age when everyone around her still has their husband. Life isn’t fair and she accepts this.

Although the past few years have been challenging, I think her personal resolve to try and make the best of life has showed. She puts a cheerful face on to make happy memories with my children even when she doesn’t feel her best. Every few months she takes the three hour train journey to visit my sister and hasn’t once demanded she be driven there and back.

But she’s also suffered a lot of bad health in her life and her attitude to that has always been the same. She’ll have days where she just sits and cries then the next day she’ll find something else to distract her and shift the focus.

I feel the OP is being unfairly criticised. Refusing to speak to your son for 24 hours after he’s invited you into his home to spend time with his family, is passive aggressive behaviour and selfish. We must all be extra patient and understanding of someone who’s grieving but that doesn’t mean they get a free pass when they treat you so disrespectfully.

Her son is grieving too but it sounds like the OP’s mil is consumed with thoughts of herself and won’t do anything to help herself either. I don’t think you can help someone who doesn’t want to help themself. I’d go visit her in the future but stay nearby instead of with her.

magicthree · 29/01/2023 19:05

Maybe losing your father is not as bad as losing your spouse but it has still been awful for him.

Wtf - there is no "maybe" about it! My friend lost her parents and her six month old baby (they knew from birth they would lose her), but when her husband died in an accident she said she had no idea of the grief that would cause. FIL wasn't old, and it was sudden - MIL shouldn't be expected to be over it by now. You cannot possibly understand how she feels.

ClareBlue · 29/01/2023 19:02

There's very few of us who haven't suffered grief at some stage. It is part of being a human that is still alive and everyone deals with it differently. But it doesn't give a free pass to be horrible to others or think it gives you entitlement because nobody else could possibly understand. There is no hierarchy of it is worse for me than you. Unfortunately most of us very much understand what grief is. My mother was widowed tragically twice before she was 45 which has of course had a lasting life long effect, but never acted like the OP is describing. Adult relationships are not unconditional, even family relationships, and I think the OP is being reasonable from what they describe.

Inyournewdress · 29/01/2023 19:01

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 17:59

Personally I think losing a child is the unthinkable but that’s just my opinion.

I was waiting for someone to say this. Typical MN.

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy sorry but I don’t really follow your thought process. You can measure the grief of other people losing their parents etc and confirm that the loss of a spouse is worse, but when someone says the loss of a child is worse it’s just ‘typical mumsnet’.

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 18:56

@ancientgran Some women seem to be sad for a bit, then happier after their husbands died. I have seen this as well. Obviously not everyone's relationship is the same.

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 18:55

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 18:49

I didn’t say the grief is worse, I said it’s different. The loss of your parents is expected in the normal course of everyday life. I lost my dad to cancer and I’m watching my mum slowly die in front of me with vascular dementia, so you don’t get to tell me I don’t understand or that I’m ‘wallowing’ (fucking awful term) because I’ve asserted that the loss of your life partner is all consuming. And please, do tell, what is a more ‘grateful and proactive approach’ to losing someone you love. Ridiculous post.

I lost both my parent suddenly. It has been very difficult.
But I agree the loss of someone you spent every day with is different. It changes your whole life.

ancientgran · 29/01/2023 18:55

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 17:52

By the way how do you know it is the worst experience of her life?

Because I’ve been through it myself. Losing your life partner is not comparable to anything else. You not only lose the person, you lose your way of life, your shared memories, the protection and comfort of their love and the world becomes a much harsher place as a result. 18 months is a very short time to deal with everything that the loss of a life partner brings and the overwhelming sense I get from the OP is that they think MIL should be further forward than she is. Grief is a process, and everyone is different. How would you feel if you had to step out into a world that no longer contained the most important person in your life, and start all over again in trying to rebuild ?

So you clearly know it was the worst experience of your life, that doesn't mean it was the worst experience of her life. It might have been but for example someone up thread mentioned losing a baby and I'd say losing a child would be worse for me. My GM never stopped grieving her dead child till the day she died over 40 years later. She was lovely and kind and thoughtful, she would buy us Christmas presents but we never saw her at Christmas, no one did. Her child died at Christmas and she knew she would be so unhappy that week and being a thoughtful person she didn't want to spoil it for anyone else.

How would I feel? Well I'd be upset but I wouldn't want to upset my children so if I was having a bad week, like Gran at Christmas, I wouldn't see people. I certainly hope I wouldn't keep going over details that distressed one of my children to that child. That seems an ideal thing to talk to a counsellor about, I'd feel free to talk about it to someone who wouldn't be distressed.

I was in a local tearoom's garden one day. A group of older women were chatting at the next table and one was telling them about her husband's death, seemed like it was the first time she'd seen them since the death or at least the first time she'd been able to spend time with them and talk about it. As it went on there was so much "oh it's so awful" "oh poor you" "how will you cope" and eventually she must have had enough of it and said, "Well the good thing is I don't have to cook if I don't want to." Total silence and then she added, "If I don't feel like cooking I just have a boiled egg, couldn't have done that when he was alive." A silence that felt very long ensued and then more normal chat started. I did admire her, from her earlier comments she was clearly grieving and very sad but she wasn't prepared to go into some extended pity party with them. She certainly shut that down.

Nalaaslan · 29/01/2023 18:54

My Dad died suddenly around 18 months ago. We were all shell shocked and Mum relied on me a lot in the early days. 18 months on and she does nice things with friends often, but she is absolutely grief stricken and often has days where she doesn’t see the joy in life anymore. It’s all part of grief, yes I find it incredibly hard especially with young children…but she’s my Mum and I love her so much plus she dealt with all my crap growing up 💐

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 18:53

A lot of men get into another relationship with a woman quickly so do not have to deal with doing new things. Women are far less likely to do this.

MissWings · 29/01/2023 18:50

@smileladiesplease

Massive difference between stiff upper lip and over burdensome, selfish behaviour for months on end. It’s not an excuse to drain the soul out of people and many people don’t actually.

Inyournewdress · 29/01/2023 18:49

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 15:10

@Inyournewdress I take your point. But there have been some really nasty comments on this thread.

Yes, I can imagine although I haven’t RTFT. I am sorry it’s been upsetting, anyone who dismisses the grief of others is absolutely wrong x

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 18:49

MissWings · 29/01/2023 18:09

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy

No, you don’t get to say your grief was worse than someone who lost both of their parents. I’m sorry but you just don’t. Or maybe yours is the “all encompassing” type. That’s not true you’re just deciding to wallow in it more than someone else who takes a more grateful and proactive approach.

I didn’t say the grief is worse, I said it’s different. The loss of your parents is expected in the normal course of everyday life. I lost my dad to cancer and I’m watching my mum slowly die in front of me with vascular dementia, so you don’t get to tell me I don’t understand or that I’m ‘wallowing’ (fucking awful term) because I’ve asserted that the loss of your life partner is all consuming. And please, do tell, what is a more ‘grateful and proactive approach’ to losing someone you love. Ridiculous post.

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 18:48

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 18:40

Grief and depression are not the same thing. And at 18 months it’s perfectly acceptable for her to still be grieving. I refused anti depressants after my husband died because they would only have delayed the grieving process. What would be the point of them now - all they would do is delay realisation and acceptance of her situation, which usually happens in the second year. It’s not that she’s not willing to try any form of support, she’s just not ready. Forcing the issue will make things worse, and counselling will only help if she’s ready engage with it fully and to face and work through issues that may be painful. From what you’ve said previously it doesn’t sound as though she’s anywhere near ready for this. And I would have thought her GP is the best person to distinguish between grief and depression.

Is there a point at which she “should” be ready? Genuine question. I know grief has no timeline so if she is still at home on her own crying after two years is it then ok to insist she goes to the GP? After five years? Ten years?

OP posts:
smileladiesplease · 29/01/2023 18:46

Exactly her point she's saying how she felt but may not be how others feel.

Everyone grieves differently surely no one needs to be told this?

Craftycorvid · 29/01/2023 18:45

It sounds really tough to know what to do for the best. Someone who just doesn’t seem to be doing anything to support themselves but who at the same time is clearly distressed makes for terribly tough company. We want to help and we are constantly thwarted. Eventually we back away. You absolutely shouldn’t feel you own life has to be on hold in order to help your mum-in-law, and having boundaries is also reasonable. A couple of things…. She might have an idea of what happens when a parent is bereaved ie all the adult children look after the parent, so she may be struggling with the fact that life goes on for you. She will be grieving the future she thought she would have, and she may have some negative ideas about therapy, too. She might think the subtext is ‘hurry up and cheer up’ which is not, of course, what you are saying at all. Some information about how sharing her pain with people who understand it might be less lonely. She sounds paralysed and unable to decide what comes next. An aunt of mine was bereaved in her 60s and my mum found it very hard to get through to her, as she got stuck in the anger of the unfairness of it all. Stages of grief can be mis-applied as if they arena formula, when they are actually stages we can move in and out of and sometimes back to. What happens when you talk about FIL? Can you do things like invite her to share happy memories and photos, for example? Suggest memory boxes and other ways to connect with the love she shared with him. You may feel less burdened if you can help her do something with her feelings.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/01/2023 18:44

She is not willing to try any form of support ...

Yes, that's the impression I got, OP
Again, nobody's suggesting she goes stampeding to groups, classes or whatever straight away - especially when it's something she's never done - but to resist absolutely everything quite so completely, and to wish to rely only on you two, seems unfortunate

Using the train example I liked OutForBreakfast's idea about doing the journey with her rather than picking her up as requested - a sort of half way house if you like, involving support but not enablement
Would something like this help her, do you think, or could it just lead to an insistence she can't possibly do it alone in future?

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 18:43

Rhondaa · 29/01/2023 18:32

'She is not willing to try any form of support, either online or face to face, and she doesn’t want counselling or anti depressants. She also doesn’t want to start any new hobbies/projects etc. She only wants to cry, talk about FIL and watch TV, really.'

So. What.

Talking about fil and watching TV sounds ok to me.

I guess we just have to agree to disagree on this. You can tell me I just don’t understand and I don’t get it because I haven’t lost my spouse. And you’re right, I haven’t.

But I don’t think it’s a good idea to spend the majority of the week sitting alone at home watching TV and crying, and only being able to speak about one topic which is your spouse’s death. Including when you go to visit your only son and grandchildren. I won’t change my mind on that.

And if she does want to do this for the rest of her life then that’s her choice but I’m not sure we have to facilitate it.

OP posts:
smileladiesplease · 29/01/2023 18:42

LovelySausage

Yes spot on. I thought this hiding your real feelings/stiff upper lip/don't bore people with your real grief had honestly been consigned to history.

Sadly many posters still seem stuck in this mindset but again I think most on here don't understand as they havnt yet dealt with all consuming grief (thankfully)

toomuchlaundry · 29/01/2023 18:41

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy you are talking about how it affected you. My DM didn't react in the same way as you when my DF died. She wanted to be as independent as she could be, and make a new life for herself as soon as possible, rather than just be at home on her own

BCBird · 29/01/2023 18:40

You feel how yiu feel. I understand itbis tiring being around her. Walking on eggshells not knowing what to sa etc. I can tell you frim experience that grief can be debilitating. My partner of 2 years died suddenly in tragic circumstances 14 months ago and I am struggling. We didn't live together,I drive I work in a time consuming job,have friends but do not want to do anything. Work is the only constant. I am telling you this because your mother in law's grief is probably ten fold. It is something you hopefully learn to.live alongside rather than something to get over.ot can feel like perpetual torture. Be patient.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 18:40

turquoisepenguin · 29/01/2023 18:27

Yes, it’s exactly that. She is not willing to try any form of support, either online or face to face, and she doesn’t want counselling or anti depressants. She also doesn’t want to start any new hobbies/projects etc. She only wants to cry, talk about FIL and watch TV, really.

I know I’ve been criticised earlier in the thread for mixing up grief and depression but to me it does seem pretty clear that this has gone past “normal” grief and is now depression.

Grief and depression are not the same thing. And at 18 months it’s perfectly acceptable for her to still be grieving. I refused anti depressants after my husband died because they would only have delayed the grieving process. What would be the point of them now - all they would do is delay realisation and acceptance of her situation, which usually happens in the second year. It’s not that she’s not willing to try any form of support, she’s just not ready. Forcing the issue will make things worse, and counselling will only help if she’s ready engage with it fully and to face and work through issues that may be painful. From what you’ve said previously it doesn’t sound as though she’s anywhere near ready for this. And I would have thought her GP is the best person to distinguish between grief and depression.

Rebel2023 · 29/01/2023 18:33

I think grief is so individual
If my dad had died first, my mum would have fallen apart. She didn't do any washing, cleaning, cooking, know how to put fuel in the car and definitely wouldn't have got a train alone
As it is, my mum died in summer. My dad is in a new relationship now and had just come back from 10 days away (5hr drive there and same coming back) and will happily cook/clean, do everything by himself
I'm not particularly happy he's in a serious relationship 6 months after my mums death (they were together 50 years) but I recognise it's helping him with his grief so..

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 18:32

CarolineHelston · 29/01/2023 18:21

I think in healthy relationship one person tries to empower the other, as well as caring for the other person.

None of us likes to think about death but everytime somebody dies at a relatively young age - and people get terminal cancer, they have fatal heart attacks - I ask myself how I would manage. I remind myself of earlier generations who lost partners just because some diseases were harder to cure, but also because of world wars.

I know that there are some practical tasks I would struggle with, but remind myself there are YouTube videos and online sites full of advice. I know that I'd be lonely but I also know that I have friends and interests, and that I'd need to keep going.

If people have relied on their partner to do absolutely everything and assumed that the other person is going to be around doing absolutely everything for ever, it's a pretty infantile attitude.

Which may sound heartless. Of course grief and loss are terrible things. But there can be a kind of selfish self-centredness too.

Nope. None of it. Doesn’t matter whether you were reliant on your partner or fully independent within the relationship. What’s ‘infantile’ is your suggestion that losing a life partner will feel better or worse depending on how reliant you were on them. It’s not only heartless to suggest that this may be at the heart of MILs issues but it’s irrelevant and has nothing to do with genuine grief. At 18 months in I would expect MIL to be self centred. She’s lost her life partner and the grief is all consuming - it’s well known that the second year after this kind of loss can be much worse than the first, as it can take this long for the full realisation of your situation to kick in and for you to even start to accept things as they are. No one - and I mean no-one on this thread has even considered this. You are approaching the loss of a life partner as a purely practical thing and I hope to god that you never find out that it’s not.

Rhondaa · 29/01/2023 18:32

'She is not willing to try any form of support, either online or face to face, and she doesn’t want counselling or anti depressants. She also doesn’t want to start any new hobbies/projects etc. She only wants to cry, talk about FIL and watch TV, really.'

So. What.

Talking about fil and watching TV sounds ok to me.

OutForBreakfast · 29/01/2023 18:27

bbgx · 29/01/2023 18:25

1) It reminds her that she never had to do it when her husband was alive
2)It's less time spent with someone - she travels alone
3)It's something she's got to organise and do when perhaps she doesn't feel she can face it
4)She might have been 'helpless' in her marriage and now she can't be

Very well explained. If I was the DH and this was my mother, I'd just do it, personally.

Personally I would do it for a bit but make it clear it is not for ever and work towards her in the future travelling alone.