Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re blended family and finances

131 replies

lovemedough · 29/01/2023 06:32

My bf and I have been together 3 years ish, we bought a house together about a year ago. I have 2 kids that are with us 75% of the time, he has one kid who is with us maybe 25% of the time.

We are generally happy , kids get along all is good apart from issues around money.

We earn roughly the same but i get a decent amount of child support from my ex each month.

A couple of times per month, I take my kids on days out, sometimes a night away as well as weekends away plus a couple of holidays per year. He can't afford to do this. I can't afford to pay for him and his kid to join us.

He has complained about how divisive he finds the situation and how he feels it's unfair on his kid...

I don't want to give up my adventures with my kids, we have a great time.

Partner is terrible With money. ( always seems to have enough to go out with friends though ...)

So AIBU ?
Should I do less with my kids so I can afford to include partner snd step kid on some trips?

Or YABU
I shouldn't be expected to finance partner and step kid

OP posts:
mumyes · 29/01/2023 07:36

People prioritise what they want.

He's not prioritising going away with his kid.

End of!!

I would be hacked off just buying meals out / take aways EVERY time.

YANBU

NewNameFor2023 · 29/01/2023 07:36

I wonder if you need to discuss and agree a holiday pot. Maybe you both put in an extra £100 to the joint house bills, but that money is for stuff you do together.

i don’t believe it is right that the maintenance you get should cover his kid, it is for your kids from their dad.

Sleepless1096 · 29/01/2023 07:36

EmmaDilemma5 · 29/01/2023 07:33

Can you both put £50/month each in the joint pot for 1x big trip a month as a family?

Then you can take your kids out alone the rest of the time that your step child isn't around.

This is a good idea. Rather than expecting you to fund everything/ not go, why doesn't he set up a regular payment after payday every month to you to pay for fun stuff? Then he can't fritter away this money and he and his DC will get to come on trips too.

Dragonsandcats · 29/01/2023 07:36

What does he waste his money on? It’s stupid to need to do this, but I’d be tempted to go through both your accounts for the last 3/4/5 months, itemise every piece of expenditure and show him why he can’t afford to treat his child (assuming you’re funding a lot of the fun stuff yourself and not just through the maintenance payments). If he’s always shit with money maybe he just doesn’t see the impact of frittering his money away?

DogMumToo · 29/01/2023 07:35

I get maintenance for my children (and cb) which isn’t factored into our household budget. I also keep my kids expenses separate (eg school dinners, weekly activities, clothes etc.)

Tbf we do put a healthy amount into our joint account and this can cover some day away etc. so maybe you could agree to put x more in for a monthly treat?

Confusednewmum1 · 29/01/2023 07:34

I feel bad for his kid. But it’s ok as long as he never ever goes.

it can never look like dad got a new family who do x,y,d but never invite his kid.

does his daughter get equal in your home such as own room ect?

sorry it’s just horrible seeing step kids getting treated better materially, when they already have the benefit of having your daddy more than you.

She should be the one to get more since she doesn’t get her daddy 100%. Could the custody agreement be changed? If he had 50/50 then no child support for him to pay so more cash to make things even and no step kids seeing her daddy more than her.

lovemedough · 29/01/2023 07:34

EmmaDilemma5 · 29/01/2023 07:33

Can you both put £50/month each in the joint pot for 1x big trip a month as a family?

Then you can take your kids out alone the rest of the time that your step child isn't around.

I suggested that yesterday actually! He said he couldn't afford it. ( then told me he was going to a festival with his friends in June Envy)

OP posts:
Ameadowwalk · 29/01/2023 07:34

Wow, putting 100k on a joint mortgage after two years together when you have two kids was one hell of a risk. Especially with someone who added zero.
I am not sure what to add to this. It is an unequal situation to start with. It’s going to end up causing bitterness and resentment because you have different priorities when it comes to money.

Dashel · 29/01/2023 07:34

I am relieved to read your update that the £100k deposit is protected.

Could you offer to help him do a budget so he can workout how much he wants to spend on his dc and put aside for holidays and Christmas etc and then he can see what’s left for socialising?

It sounds like you are already pretty generous. How much does he spend on himself every month?

If he is ignoring suggestions on cheap days out it sounds like he is leaving you to step up in sorting out his child buying them clothes and taking them out

EmmaDilemma5 · 29/01/2023 07:33

Can you both put £50/month each in the joint pot for 1x big trip a month as a family?

Then you can take your kids out alone the rest of the time that your step child isn't around.

lovemedough · 29/01/2023 07:31

CalistoNoSolo · 29/01/2023 07:29

I think the maintenance is irrelevant. OP has her children living with her so her outgoings overall are higher. There is no way i would want to pay for an extra child just because its father is a feckless arse.

I'm not sure this financial set up is sustainable long term though - there will be a build up of resentment from each side and will cause major issues ahead. It's a shame you moved in together, especially knowing how bad your partner is with money.

What so I do? End a lovely, happy relationship because of one flaw?

That's not realistic. We are in love and happy.

This is the real world. People don't end relationships and walk away from people they love because of issues like this.

OP posts:
lovemedough · 29/01/2023 07:29

ArcticSkewer · 29/01/2023 07:29

Sorry .... why did you gift him half the house deposit? Don't you want your children to inherit that £100k some day?

Anyway, back to the question. What you do when his child isn't there is up to you, and I would do most of this stuff then, but if you are blended enough to give him £100k then you are blended enough to take his child out with you occasionally as well.

Sorry I didn't explain that properly! We have an equal shake in equity. The deposit is legally all mine!

OP posts:
lovemedough · 29/01/2023 07:29

Chilliee · 29/01/2023 07:26

Is he terrible with money or does he just not have enough of it? He has maintenance going out and you have a lot of maintenance coming in so your starting points are very different regardless of similar salaries. But then he has 1 child to fund 25% of the time and you have 2 kids 75% of the time so possibly a fair reflection.

If you are so happy and so in love and want to be together, it sounds like you are comfortable with money. Would it hurt to take him and his child every now and then as it sounds like you do an awful lot with your kids?

I'm just thinking if this post was the other way round and it was the man taking his kids out and leaving a woman at home with a child, the replies would prob jump on the man for being selfish!

That's a really good point!

I do pay for emails out, cinema etc and I treat his child to clothes and trainers when I do the same for mine but trips are so expensive right now and I can't do it all.

OP posts:
CalistoNoSolo · 29/01/2023 07:29

I think the maintenance is irrelevant. OP has her children living with her so her outgoings overall are higher. There is no way i would want to pay for an extra child just because its father is a feckless arse.

I'm not sure this financial set up is sustainable long term though - there will be a build up of resentment from each side and will cause major issues ahead. It's a shame you moved in together, especially knowing how bad your partner is with money.

ArcticSkewer · 29/01/2023 07:29

Sorry .... why did you gift him half the house deposit? Don't you want your children to inherit that £100k some day?

Anyway, back to the question. What you do when his child isn't there is up to you, and I would do most of this stuff then, but if you are blended enough to give him £100k then you are blended enough to take his child out with you occasionally as well.

Shoxfordian · 29/01/2023 07:27

He chooses not to spend his money on doing things with you or his kid; it’s all his choice

He doesn’t sound like a good partner tbh; being shit with money should have been a big red flag

Chilliee · 29/01/2023 07:26

Is he terrible with money or does he just not have enough of it? He has maintenance going out and you have a lot of maintenance coming in so your starting points are very different regardless of similar salaries. But then he has 1 child to fund 25% of the time and you have 2 kids 75% of the time so possibly a fair reflection.

If you are so happy and so in love and want to be together, it sounds like you are comfortable with money. Would it hurt to take him and his child every now and then as it sounds like you do an awful lot with your kids?

I'm just thinking if this post was the other way round and it was the man taking his kids out and leaving a woman at home with a child, the replies would prob jump on the man for being selfish!

lovemedough · 29/01/2023 07:21

So, I pay slightly more each month on house bills as my kids are there more

We pay the mortgage equally, and have equal stake despite the fact that I put £100k deposit on the house and he put £0.

I pay for a cleaner as well as anything that needs buying for the house

If we have a takeaway or take all the kids to lunch etc, I pay.

I also pay for extras such a as Netflix, Spotify and I give all 3 kids weekly pocket money, pay for his kid's birthday party so she has the same as my kids... etc

I think the starting point is already pretty equal??

I am not tight with money at all. In fact, I'm trying to be less of a sap when it comes to money!

OP posts:
Ameadowwalk · 29/01/2023 07:13

lovemedough · 29/01/2023 07:04

He has a bit of debt
He pays child support
And I get a decent amount from my ex on top of my salary

Despite all this, he should still have some expendable income. he is just TERRIBLE with money.

He runs out each month !

Right okay, so you earn roughly the same but you have maintenance coming in and he has maintenance going out. So your starting points are different, probably to the tune of several hundred pounds. Plus debt repayments, which are his issue, but you are still actually not in the same position financially. You are much better off which is how you can afford holidays and he cannot. Even if he was good with money, you would still have more of it every month.

I get your point that he is spending money going out with friends and you are not. But you have your kids 75% of the time, he doesn’t.

I think there is a compromise here in that sometimes the days out do include his DC, otherwise this is going to eat away at your marriage. Are you paying bills equally? Or proportionately to the fact that you get more maintenance to pay for the fact that your DC are also there?

So I would work out proportionately how much better off you are a month and then budget to include his DC on that proportion of trips. It’s important to have time with your DC alone yourself as well.

lovemedough · 29/01/2023 07:04

Clymene · 29/01/2023 06:59

How come he earns the same as you and only has one child but has no money to take his kid out?

He has a bit of debt
He pays child support
And I get a decent amount from my ex on top of my salary

Despite all this, he should still have some expendable income. he is just TERRIBLE with money.

He runs out each month !

OP posts:
lovemedough · 29/01/2023 07:02

Babsexxx · 29/01/2023 07:00

No some people are just plain terrible with money but can’t see it, you need to point these things out we aren’t hard up but I definitely wouldn’t be wasting money going out down the pubs etc as it’s soo expensive now.

He isn’t prioritising his child he won’t like what you have to say but it needs to be said because it’s the truth. Especially if he’s getting so bitter we are all human and some times things really need to be black and white. I’d say something along the lines of “well I don’t go out as I prefer making memories with my children plenty of time for the pub and friends when there older!”

I do feel sorry for his child though.

I've done all that!
Nothing changes.

OP posts:
Babsexxx · 29/01/2023 07:00

No some people are just plain terrible with money but can’t see it, you need to point these things out we aren’t hard up but I definitely wouldn’t be wasting money going out down the pubs etc as it’s soo expensive now.

He isn’t prioritising his child he won’t like what you have to say but it needs to be said because it’s the truth. Especially if he’s getting so bitter we are all human and some times things really need to be black and white. I’d say something along the lines of “well I don’t go out as I prefer making memories with my children plenty of time for the pub and friends when there older!”

I do feel sorry for his child though.

Clymene · 29/01/2023 06:59

How come he earns the same as you and only has one child but has no money to take his kid out?

coopy10 · 29/01/2023 06:56

I would carry on doing what you're doing to be honest, because if he wanted to prioritise days out he would. No way would I start paying for him to join in as what incentive would there ever be for him to start paying his way. Agree also that your kids will value the time one on one with you without your boyfriend there.

lovemedough · 29/01/2023 06:53

Raindancer411 · 29/01/2023 06:50

No, you need time with just you and your children without him and his one. I would be a bit worried getting into a relationship with someone who isn't great with money to be honest.

The rest of the relationship is great though. We are really in love and the kids are happy.

I knew he was shit with money from very early on if I'm honest and apart from mortgage and bills, I insisted in separate finances.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread