Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner won’t allow me to see his phone

212 replies

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 00:04

i could see a notification flash up on my partners Apple Watch which looked like a females name … it took me about 10’mins to process it and when I asked him he said he didn’t know anyone with that name and it might be twitter notification (often random peoples tweets appear as notifications). I asked if he could show me his phone messaging history- not the messages just those he was messaging and he said no repeatedly. I said I couldn’t trust him as this was his one way to prove he hasn’t been unfaithful and if he can’t show me in the moment there and then then I’m not sure I can continue in this relationship. We have been together 1 year and are living together. AIBU?

OP posts:
monsteramunch · 29/01/2023 09:53

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 09:01

Yeh this is the issue I am having because I wouldn’t want to end the relationship if he hasn’t been unfaithful

Shouldn't your bar be higher than this?

I don't understand why people have cheating as their only dealbreaker.

You aren't a good match based on your multiple threads. Drugs, comments that make you feel shit and now a lack of trust re other women.

This relationship doesn't make you feel happy and secure. You don't properly trust him. That should be enough to end it.

Cocobutt · 29/01/2023 09:52

I would never allow my partner to go through my phone.
It’s my own private business.

He either trusts me or he doesn’t.

And if he thinks I am up to no good then he needs to leave, not blackmail me into not being allowed my own privacy.

If he refuses to give you his phone what will you do?
You obviously don’t trust him.

Bellalalala · 29/01/2023 09:52

If you think the demographic is too old to agree with you and you need agreement, not peoples opinions, then go post where you would find that.

Absolutely would not give my partner my phone to check. You either trust me or you don’t and if you don’t, the relationship is done.

If someone has to show proof to be trusted, that’s not trust. I couldn’t be doing with having to prove it all the time.

ilovesooty · 29/01/2023 09:49

You say that you can't believe people had "the audacity" to define this behaviour as abusive and controlling. I think that's quite telling in itself.

theGooHasGone · 29/01/2023 09:48

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 09:24

Thank you SO much! Quite honestly couldn’t believe people had the audacity to say that was abusive or controlling- surely I have a right to a peace of mind. And agreed about the sharing a bed thing - in a relationship you really should be able to share almost everything I believe and trusting each other enough to leave phones around
each other etc is what I want in a relationship. I often hear of other peoples relationships where they will just allow each other access to their phones because there is nothing to hide.

Sounds like you should leave this poor guy and get into one of those relationships instead then.

Absolutely insane, controlling behaviour. If you don't trust him there's no real relationship anyway. I also notice you're only responding to the very few posts who agree with you and ignoring the mountain of others who think you're totally unreasonable.

Joeylove88 · 29/01/2023 09:48

I do agree that people have a right to privacy with their phones because we do keep alot of things on them these days I.e emails, bank apps etc so it's not unusual to have them on us a lot of the time. But I also don't think that you sound abusive just for questioning your partner about a name you have never seen before. If it was me being asked by my partner who that person was I would be happy to tell them who the person was (friend, work colleague etc) maybe a brief description of the conversation unless it was confidential I think that's perfectly normal to ask as long as it's not done in a demanding way. I also don't think it's normal that people do take their phones literally everywhere with them like their lives depend on it (unless they are needed for specific reasons like emergencies etc). Sometimes I forget my phone and go out and yes it's annoying but I don't have a complete meltdown over it. Now I have a child though I must admit having my phone on me when I'm out feels more necessary. You and your partner should be able to be open and honest about other people in your lives without it being intrusive or needing to go into detail all the time.

NomadicSoul · 29/01/2023 09:46

Chaz5rascals · 29/01/2023 09:41

If your other posts are anything to go by I’d get out fast. He isn’t trustworthy, doesn’t seem to care about the relationship with his continued drug use and lying and I think that’s adding to your possibly already existing insecurities. It sounds toxic. As someone else said you definitely shouldn’t share a bank account or baby! I’d also be careful asking on here because lots of people want to show how secure they are by saying “I keep my phone private and would never ask to see my partners phone” but in reality if they had a gut feeling something was going on they would want proof before they walked away.

This basically. Well said.

Zombiemama84 · 29/01/2023 09:44

My ex did this…he was cheating.
i had reason to be suspicious as caught him messaging other women before and this was the behaviour at the time. Some people are like that with their phone all the time - my ex wasn’t so in the tImes he was guarding it I had reason to be suspicious. He was very defensive when I asked him too. My partner now would happily show me and I would do the same we are very open, phones left lying around, know each other’s password but dont feel the need to look. Both been cheated on but trust each other completely haven’t let previous experiences drag on into our relationship.

Chaz5rascals · 29/01/2023 09:41

If your other posts are anything to go by I’d get out fast. He isn’t trustworthy, doesn’t seem to care about the relationship with his continued drug use and lying and I think that’s adding to your possibly already existing insecurities. It sounds toxic. As someone else said you definitely shouldn’t share a bank account or baby! I’d also be careful asking on here because lots of people want to show how secure they are by saying “I keep my phone private and would never ask to see my partners phone” but in reality if they had a gut feeling something was going on they would want proof before they walked away.

Calphurnia88 · 29/01/2023 09:40

I'm mid 30s. No idea what you would glean from that, but I think your behaviour is controlling and I wouldn't accept it from my partner.

BridieConvert · 29/01/2023 09:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JustFrustrated · 29/01/2023 09:39

Also "younger" here, no I wouldn't show DH my phones because he saw something. I'd explain what it was, unpick why he felt uncomfortable and then decide if I should show him my phone.

My phone IS an extension of me. It has my bank accounts, my financial information, my notes, my shopping lists, my emails, my orders, my messages, my photos, my medical history ....

So no one has free access to it. Not my kids, not DH, no one but me. And I extend that to other people.

I'd need far more than "oh I saw briefly a notification that made me uncomfortable" why does someone elses piece of mind override mine? It doesn't. Not when I know I'm not doing anything I shouldn't.

I'm more likely to lock DHs phone/computer when it's left unlocked than pick it up and look through it.

You need to leave this relationship

GlassBunion · 29/01/2023 09:39

I'm with @Fairislefandango .

Honestly, you don't trust him and you never will.
Just end it .

ilovesooty · 29/01/2023 09:38

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 09:12

Yeah I have a feeling the younger demographic would be responding differently to this

I'm old. I wouldn't put up with anyone asking to see my phone.

Since you don't trust him anyway the relationship sounds dead.

NomadicSoul · 29/01/2023 09:38

saraclara · 29/01/2023 09:22

It still doesn't make sense though. You say you'd be doing something wrong in having a conversation that your partner couldn't see. So if you have a friend message you in great distress, you only give yourself two choices a) not to continue the conversation because it needs to be kept from your partner or b) have the conversation but allow a situation where your DH can see it.

That seem strange to me. When c) have the conversation and respect the friend's privacy, is surely the right thing to do.

How is me talking to a friend in great distress something I should hide from my partner? Actually, if that did happen, I'd almost certainly tell them so I could get their advice as to how to respond.

But okay, If someone did message me, "please don't share this with anyone, but..." then of course I would respect that. I was a trained counsellor in a previous life, so I understand that aspect. It's never happened to me though. There's still nothing to stop me saying to my partner , "ah, sorry, something has come up that I need to deal with, that I've been asked to keep private, excuse me for a minute'.

However, in my original post I was referring to doing things on my phone that I was hiding from my partner, and I was thinking of things like having an affair or looking at porn or gambling or whatever it was that I wouldn't want them to see as if been hiding it from them.

I was not saying " no one can talk to their friends about sensitive and delicate subjects in their phones as that's wrong". I am talking about me and my relationship with my phone and my partner. I did so as I thought it might help the OP who a lot of people seemed to be having a go at. From what I can tell (and yes it's "just" her side, he sounds like someone she should get the hell away from as quickly as possible.

BridieConvert · 29/01/2023 09:37

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 08:56

Yeh this is what I mean- I do not mind if my partner read through my messages or looked at my notifications and I would like to reiterate I WAS NOT demanding to go through his phone - I simply asked if he could show me himself the WhatsApp screen with his recent chats so I could glance at who he has been messaging so I can have clarity. But no apparently I’m abusive

THIS IS NOT NORMAL.
What would the next step be if you weren't satisfied with that because you didn't see this name - go into the archived chats, ask him to open every other possible messaging app to "put your mind at ease"?
And it IS controlling.

Fairislefandango · 29/01/2023 09:32

Oh you're one of those posters! Serial threads about the same arsehole man, each one concealing the ongoing back-story so that posters can only comment as if it's a relatively minor isolated incident, allowing you to remain in denial about the screamingly obvious fact that you should have dumped this twat before even bothering to post your first thread about him.

Yes, demanding to see your partner's phone is unreasonable in any decent relationship. In yours it's completely pointless. You already know what he's like - stop turning a blind eye!

Mouse82 · 29/01/2023 09:31

tigger1001 · 29/01/2023 09:25

No I wouldn't. It would be massively triggering for me for my partner to ask to see my phone. And it would be him saying he didn't trust me. Relationship would be over.

I wouldn't either.
Mum use to snoop in my room and read my journal.

"No" is a complete sentence.
She says she only asked a few times, sounds like it was more than once if he kept saying no.

babeB · 29/01/2023 09:28

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 09:12

Yeah I have a feeling the younger demographic would be responding differently to this

Probably.

People are being obtuse. You have good reason to be feeling worried insecure with this guy taking drugs and looking at other women.

But people love a good pile on.

However you need to end it. This is no good and nothing will come of a relationship with such a infantile man.

Thighlengthboots · 29/01/2023 09:27

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 09:24

Thank you SO much! Quite honestly couldn’t believe people had the audacity to say that was abusive or controlling- surely I have a right to a peace of mind. And agreed about the sharing a bed thing - in a relationship you really should be able to share almost everything I believe and trusting each other enough to leave phones around
each other etc is what I want in a relationship. I often hear of other peoples relationships where they will just allow each other access to their phones because there is nothing to hide.

Where does your “peace of mind” end then? Should you have access to his Facebook, instagram, personal chats with friends and family, bank accounts, diary, work documents too? After all, if it’s for your peace of mind then it’s limitless isn’t it? If you are sure he’s cheating then you should check all of these things too surely?

mysticbob · 29/01/2023 09:27

Poor bastard. So what if glancing through the notifications isn't enough for you OP - what next? 'I've asked to put a tracker on his car to put my mind at rest, if he was innocent surely he'd let me?' You need to work on yourself and stop being so controlling.

MarchingGiraffes · 29/01/2023 09:25

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 09:24

Thank you SO much! Quite honestly couldn’t believe people had the audacity to say that was abusive or controlling- surely I have a right to a peace of mind. And agreed about the sharing a bed thing - in a relationship you really should be able to share almost everything I believe and trusting each other enough to leave phones around
each other etc is what I want in a relationship. I often hear of other peoples relationships where they will just allow each other access to their phones because there is nothing to hide.

Work on your own peace of mind. Placating you by showing you his phone is enabling you.

It won’t help.

tigger1001 · 29/01/2023 09:25

LilLilLi · 29/01/2023 09:22

Ok for all those saying they wouldn’t give their partners their phone.

If they had seen a flash of something and came to you and said, look I thought I saw something pop up and it’s made me feel uncomfortable would you reassure them and show them the message or not? I would, without question and then we’d both laugh about him being silly.

No I wouldn't. It would be massively triggering for me for my partner to ask to see my phone. And it would be him saying he didn't trust me. Relationship would be over.

Marmitelover93 · 29/01/2023 09:24

Thank you SO much! Quite honestly couldn’t believe people had the audacity to say that was abusive or controlling- surely I have a right to a peace of mind. And agreed about the sharing a bed thing - in a relationship you really should be able to share almost everything I believe and trusting each other enough to leave phones around
each other etc is what I want in a relationship. I often hear of other peoples relationships where they will just allow each other access to their phones because there is nothing to hide.

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 29/01/2023 09:24

You clearly don’t trust him, as if you did you wouldn’t think twice about a female name on his messages. If anyone demanded I show my phone I’d be refusing. Like others have said you need to end the relationship as it’s clear that you don’t trust him and if he’s very secretive with his phone then maybe you don’t trust him for good reason. It’s only 1yr in, this doesn’t bode well. Best thing is to sit down with him, tell him that seeing the message flash up has made you insecure as he’s very secretive with his phone. See what he says. Maybe time to end this relationship though and move on to someone you can trust