Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop going to church

60 replies

MeghanThyStallion · 28/01/2023 21:17

I've been attending church and being an active member of the congregation for the last 18 years. In that time, I've become part of a community of wonderful, interesting people. However, I've also had several bad experiences that have sapped my faith and enthusiasm. I can't remember the last time I actually enjoyed going to church. I go because I had a very strong faith and promised to bring up my DC in the church.

The DC are now asking to not go any more and I'm wondering what's the point. WIBU to give everyone a lie-in on Sundays instead?

OP posts:
Patineur · 29/01/2023 08:45

MeghanThyStallion · 28/01/2023 21:34

I wouldn't go of it wasn't for the DC. I like the music, but that's it.

Well, there's your answer. You only do it for the DC, they don't want to do it any more. So stop. There's no point wasting your time. If you want to, you can still follow the tenets of the faith without turning up at a building once a week for a ceremony that you dislike.

WandaWonder · 29/01/2023 08:44

To me church is for people who choose to go and that includes children, they can go when they are older if they choose too

MuggleMe · 29/01/2023 08:42

I see church as restaurants, they all serve God but some are family friendly, some fine dining etc. You don't stop going out, you move. Don't forget church is about community too. You can get a lot from videos and live stream services but that personal connection is important, but possible to get without attending a traditional Sunday service.

Squamata · 29/01/2023 08:39

I'm not religious but had a religious upbringing.

We were taught that God is everywhere, anything that values creation is an act of worship - singing, walk in the country, volunteering etc.

I think you could never go to church again but find a spiritual practice of your own that gives you some of what you want. And join a choir for the singing!

If I were ever to go to church I'd go for quakers or unitarians, I think their approach to women is much more egalitarian. Most churches have deep, deep misogyny embedded in their thinking even if they claim to be modern in outlook.

Debtknell · 29/01/2023 08:35

Babdoc · 29/01/2023 08:09

I had a look at Mystery worshipper (thanks to all PPs who recommended) but couldn’t find anything for my area (rural Scotland).

JoonT, scientists can’t even explain how our universe exists at all, given that the Big Bang broke all the laws of physics. We Christians regard that as God’s moment of creation.
And OP wants a community of fellow worshippers, not a sterile atheist assembly. God does not get “angry” over minor details, He willingly suffered agonising death for us. He would simply be sad if OP felt so unwelcome in her church that she became estranged from Him. Any annoyance would be felt towards the church that was driving away His people.

Did you miss that the OP says she no longer believes any of this , and therefore your attempt to describe the mental processes of a supposedly omniscient, omnipotent deity tutting in annoyance at an unfriendly or unpleasant church putting off his worshippers, or dying sacrificially in a curious echo of numerous other dying-and-resurrected gods, is irrelevant?

MeghanThyStallion · 29/01/2023 08:30

We're not going this morning. I feel like I'm bunking off school.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 29/01/2023 08:18

God probably doesn’t exist. Don’t feel bad for no longer going.

Snarf23 · 29/01/2023 08:16

Have a break and time to reassess your faith and what you want from going to church. You can always decide later you want to try another or actually you feel better by not going to any at all. Faith is very personal.

Babdoc · 29/01/2023 08:09

I had a look at Mystery worshipper (thanks to all PPs who recommended) but couldn’t find anything for my area (rural Scotland).

JoonT, scientists can’t even explain how our universe exists at all, given that the Big Bang broke all the laws of physics. We Christians regard that as God’s moment of creation.
And OP wants a community of fellow worshippers, not a sterile atheist assembly. God does not get “angry” over minor details, He willingly suffered agonising death for us. He would simply be sad if OP felt so unwelcome in her church that she became estranged from Him. Any annoyance would be felt towards the church that was driving away His people.

JoonT · 28/01/2023 23:41

I regard all religion as man (and I mean man) made nonsense, so I’d say have a lie in instead. There are 100 billion galaxies, each containing 100s of billions of stars and planets. Our planet (a tiny speck of dust in the vastness of space) is 13 billion years old, and had seen countless species come and go before we appeared (just 200,000 years ago). Homo sapiens nearly went extinct too, and probably will, sooner or later.

Considering all that, I very much doubt ‘God’ will be angry if you stop going to a particular building on a particular day. Personally, I find infinitely more beauty and truth and comfort in great literature and art. Why not stay home and read Dickens or Jane Austen instead? Or go to an art gallery and look at a few Monets and Pissarros and Vermeers.

Tilllly · 28/01/2023 22:59

Change church. Stat!

I'd be horrified at that sort of pressure- bloody disgusting

We've had a few people leave ours over the years, and a few come in from other churches. A church should be about faith, yes, but also welcoming, hospitality, community

Go visit a few, see where you feel comfortable

lifeinthehills · 28/01/2023 22:36

cloverz · 28/01/2023 22:09

Babdoc, there is the Mystery Worshipper!

www.shipoffools.com/mystery-worshipper/

I haven't seen that for years! Must check it out. It was fun.

mnahmnah · 28/01/2023 22:28

Alternatively - have you heard of the Sunday assembly? Like a humanist church service. No god. Inspirational talks and songs. Community. Often held in churches, but without the religion!

www.sundayassembly.org/

SarahAndQuack · 28/01/2023 22:22

I like Ship of Fools, but they never seem to do places near us.

I do love the 'how warm was the welcome, how long was the sermon' format.

TomPinch · 28/01/2023 22:11

cloverz · 28/01/2023 22:09

Babdoc, there is the Mystery Worshipper!

www.shipoffools.com/mystery-worshipper/

Mystery Worshipper is ace!

jackstini · 28/01/2023 22:10

Am loving the idea of a TripAdvisor for churches @Babdoc

OP - it definitely sounds like this particular church is not right for you. You mention not changing denomination (not sure which it is) but is there another church if the same denomination but different attitude/atmosphere?

No issue to stop if it's what is best for you - but would you miss anything? (Or perhaps you already are)

A lady came to our (Methodist) church last week as she felt she could not continue as CofE but still wanted to worship

cloverz · 28/01/2023 22:09

Babdoc, there is the Mystery Worshipper!

www.shipoffools.com/mystery-worshipper/

Babdoc · 28/01/2023 22:04

OP, I have moved church a few times. It’s important to have one where you feel you fit.
I left one when the brilliant minister left for a senior role at head office, and was replaced by a grim curmudgeon who sacked the Sunday school teacher, preached that everyone was doomed to hell, and banned raffles (gambling!) and bottle stalls (alcohol!) from the church fete.
I moved to one in a different village 8 miles away, until their lovely minister retired, and was replaced by basically the vicar of Dibley, but without the humour.
I then attended my own village church where they had appointed an excellent lesbian feminist minister who was a fiercely intelligent, double qualified lawyer/priest with great taste in music and a wonderful sense of humour.
Then she moved north to a new parish, and was replaced by two dumbed down happy clappies. I am now investigating two possible churches, one in a village up in the hills, one in our nearest city 10 miles away, both with good recommendations.
Someone really should start a Tripadvisor for churches! Grin

WhereIsMyRollingPin · 28/01/2023 22:00

There at plenty of really lovely things you could do with your DC on Sundays, or you could all have a lie in.

I'm not a Christian but it doesn't sound as if many of the people at your church are either.

SarahAndQuack · 28/01/2023 21:56

I would definitely echo PP saying find a different church. Of course you could also just not go, and that's fine too. I can't imagine God minds. I do see where you're coming from in feeling you're abandoning the nice people in the congregation, but honestly, I think if church is not working for you, it's right to move on. Those nice people could move too, if they wanted.

FWIW my mum dragged us to church as children, and she didn't much like it, and we didn't much enjoy it, and looking back, I think she felt much like you: that she ought to keep going. But there was no nourishment in that church and nothing that was helping any of us to grow or challenge ourselves or feel fellowship, or anything like that. My mum and brothers aren't churchgoers now, but I am, and I am lucky to have found a lovely church which really makes me feel glad to be there. I am absolutely sure this is the better option, and not just selfishly (it's not that I'm saying church ought to be the religious equivalent of a naice spa break). I'm a lot more able to do things I think are ethically important in this context.

Plus, TBH, if your children prefer a lie-in it could well be they're tired teenagers and really need it!

DDivaStar · 28/01/2023 21:50

If ots the community you want there are many community groups and volunteer opportunities which might suit you better.

cloverz · 28/01/2023 21:50

MeghanThyStallion · 28/01/2023 21:33

The bad experiences: being expected to put up with an abusive husband for the sake of the children/our promise to God when we got married. Repeatedly being given service, teaching and leadership assignments that I couldn't do, either because of time constraints associated with being a single mum or because my mental health was so poor after escaping from said abusive marriage.

I just don't believe in any of it any more, but feel guilty about leaving all the nice people to the crazy/demanding ones.

That's not right or Christian. You don't have to go and that doesn't sound like a good environment for the kids either. You can still believe even if you don't attend church and no-one is going to punish you even if you've stopped believing.

There are a lot of very flawed clergy with questionable opinions and congregations with very archaic, misogynistic views. What you describe sounds like an evangelical church where old-fashioned gender roles are still considered the norm. Not all churches are like that. And not saying it is only evangelical churches, but that kind of advice is just not on...You'd be surprised how accepting and welcoming some churches can be! Finding one with a woman priest could be a start...

TomPinch · 28/01/2023 21:50

There have been long periods of time when I've gone to church just to worship God and have communion. No need to socialize with anyone.

That's true of your DCs too, although I've never forced mine to go.

mnahmnah · 28/01/2023 21:48

I would certainly stop going to that church. Take a break from it all. Reassess what you truly believe and if you want to be part of a church. If you do, find one that suits you better. You don’t have to change denomination, just find another CofE/catholic/Methodist church in the area

SaltanVinegar · 28/01/2023 21:46

Life’s too short, so spend your time how you like. The kids don’t want to go, and you say you don’t believe in any of it anymore. I can’t see a reason to stay.