Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop going to church

60 replies

MeghanThyStallion · 28/01/2023 21:17

I've been attending church and being an active member of the congregation for the last 18 years. In that time, I've become part of a community of wonderful, interesting people. However, I've also had several bad experiences that have sapped my faith and enthusiasm. I can't remember the last time I actually enjoyed going to church. I go because I had a very strong faith and promised to bring up my DC in the church.

The DC are now asking to not go any more and I'm wondering what's the point. WIBU to give everyone a lie-in on Sundays instead?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cassiatwenty · 18/02/2023 23:55

Right, not every place is the same.

Where you feel the community, teachings resonate, people who are there are similar to you.

I had some experiences that almost put me off for good, but different places and cities have different vibes and people going there.

Wibblewibble1 · 29/01/2023 18:13

The book of jesus says he is not in buildings made of stone- god is everywhere and in everything if you have faith. You don’t have to sit in a building to have faith, you can pray from your front room if you choose to.

User0610134057 · 29/01/2023 18:10

Check out the I was a Teenage Fundamentalist podcast and Facebook group. May strike a chord?
it’s scary to stop going especially when it’s been such a part of your life but you don’t need anyone’s permission

DorisHatt · 29/01/2023 18:08

I stopped going to church a while ago and I still feel ambivalent about it and my faith. Lots of backstory - as there often is! It is good to talk about it.

GlassBunion · 29/01/2023 17:56

I only ask as my mum has struggled with her need to attend a church that basically makes you feel so bad if you don't attend. Yet she is disabled , frail and finds it very difficult to leave her home in order to 'fulfil' her religious obligations.

GlassBunion · 29/01/2023 17:53

May I ask, which Church do you belong to?

BurntOutGirl · 29/01/2023 17:44

MeghanThyStallion · 29/01/2023 14:46

@Cherryana I'm sorry you had a bad experience and I'm glad you're happy with your life now. I have no desire to attend another church. I don't like being taught that if I don't like something about church or the gospel, or find it difficult, then it's because I need more faith and patience. If something bad happens, it's either because I wasn't sufficiently in tune with what God's warnings, or it's a teaching experience.

I was told by a church going colleague that the reason my son has autism is because l didn't pray enough.

MeghanThyStallion · 29/01/2023 14:46

@Cherryana I'm sorry you had a bad experience and I'm glad you're happy with your life now. I have no desire to attend another church. I don't like being taught that if I don't like something about church or the gospel, or find it difficult, then it's because I need more faith and patience. If something bad happens, it's either because I wasn't sufficiently in tune with what God's warnings, or it's a teaching experience.

OP posts:
Cherryana · 29/01/2023 11:16

Hello, I understand. I truly believed, was in church leadership etc. For years, I found it sapping, support was one way, friendships were conditional or needy and I found the repetition so boring. I also came to question whether all the lovely thing in my life really had nothing to do with me. Also had to really look at the toxic state of my romantic relationship and the ‘stay no matter what’ messaging.

Since lockdown, I have not gone back.
To have full weekends is amazing.
I have not missed the passive and demeaning language- ‘it’s not me, it’s God working through m, I am nothing, you are everything’.
One person has tried once to contact me - after 17 years of regularly going and leading all sorts of stuff. Tells you everything about the depth of those relationships.

I now have time for things I want to do and have found a more grace filled, warm community in a different (non religious) volunteer thing I now do. I also went to counselling as I had to re-learn to trust my own inner voice instead of consistently dismissing it or thinking I was selfish or wrong to want things for myself.

It’s also not ‘go to another church’ - it’s an all pervading culture based on patriarchy and bypassing responsibility for yourself.

Lampzade · 29/01/2023 10:44

Op, you don’t have to leave your home to worship God.
You can worship God in your home.

Pythonesque · 29/01/2023 10:35

Like others I also suggest exploring other churches in your area. With older children/ teenagers, an evening service can be particularly practical. But most of all, if you are going to be part of a church, you need to be part of a community that will build you up not break you down.

I hope you can find somewhere that is right for you.

WhereIsMyRollingPin · 29/01/2023 10:15

OP I hope you are having a lovely morning. Some people get something out of going to a church on Sunday mornings (or another time, of course!) but there are so many lovely things you could do instead. Why not come up with a list with your DC and work through it.

Choconut · 29/01/2023 10:10

YANBU at all. The other nice people are equally free to leave, you are not responsible for them. Besides if they are genuine friends then you can see them outside of church.

BurntOutGirl · 29/01/2023 10:10

MeghanThyStallion · 29/01/2023 08:30

We're not going this morning. I feel like I'm bunking off school.

Just because you haven't gone it doesn't mean you can't use this time for Reflection and giving thanks for the positive aspects in your life.

Attending church does not make you a better person. The way you conduct yourself does.

PortiasBiscuit · 29/01/2023 10:07

I go to church because I am the youngest in the congregation and they need me. ( I am 58yo).
The pandemic destroyed the last of my teetering faith, there is no way this world is controlled by a benign omnipotent presence.

Beautiful3 · 29/01/2023 10:05

So you only go for the children, but they don't want to go either?! Take a break, enjoy some Sunday lie ins. Don't feel bad. God is everywhere, you can connect through prayer. Churches have man made rules which only seems to serve the men! I left a church years ago. I still love God and connect through prayer. I encourage my children to use prayer too. But I wouldn't allow a church to brain wash them.

Ncgirlseriously · 29/01/2023 09:47

I’ve never been a churchgoer, so I don’t have the experience of stopping going, but you shouldn’t feel obligated to do something that no longer helps you or makes you feel good.

And from the sound of it, you’re better off being out of that environment. You don’t owe anybody a reason to stop going, and imo any god worth believing in would understand that.

donquixotedelamancha · 29/01/2023 09:42

I think continuing to go to a church where you are treated in the way you describe is the same as remaining in any other abusive relationship. Well done on escaping you ex- use that experience to drive you to shore up your boundaries. You clearly have difficulty prioritising your own feelings.

The lovely people at the church will meet you for a brew if they are as lovely as you think.

Abhannmor · 29/01/2023 09:38

MeghanThyStallion · 29/01/2023 08:30

We're not going this morning. I feel like I'm bunking off school.

I was brought up Catholic. Haven't been to mass in years - apart from funerals etc. But I sometimes pop in alone , light a candle and say a prayer or just have a think.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/01/2023 09:31

MeghanThyStallion · 28/01/2023 21:34

I wouldn't go of it wasn't for the DC. I like the music, but that's it.

Your DC don't want to go, and from what you've described it's not a good place to take them anyway. Do some nice family activity in the real world instead maybe.

Babdoc · 29/01/2023 09:23

Patineur, no, Church of Scotland. But delighted to hear there are two such excellent ministers! Mine also served as a military chaplain in Afghanistan and was appointed chaplain in ordinary to the late queen - she was hugely talented. I miss her dreadfully - she’s a hard act to follow, for any minister.

LookItsMeAgain · 29/01/2023 08:56

I'm a lapsed RC. I used to go to mass twice each Sunday with my dad. We helped out doing the collection plate at the second. My dad was of the mindset that you couldn't attend mass and collect at the same service. It was his mindset (and the subsequent news of the abuse in the Catholic Church) that has put me right off ever going into a church again (except for weddings and funerals).

Go if you want to go. Stay home if you no longer believe or your faith is lapsing. It's entirely your choice.

SnoozyLucy7 · 29/01/2023 08:53

MeghanThyStallion · 28/01/2023 21:33

The bad experiences: being expected to put up with an abusive husband for the sake of the children/our promise to God when we got married. Repeatedly being given service, teaching and leadership assignments that I couldn't do, either because of time constraints associated with being a single mum or because my mental health was so poor after escaping from said abusive marriage.

I just don't believe in any of it any more, but feel guilty about leaving all the nice people to the crazy/demanding ones.

But it shouldn’t be like that. You don’t need permission to stop going. If these people are your true friends surely they would continue to be so even after you left the church?

If going is getting you down and is exhausting for you, what is the point of going? What do you get out of it then?

Some of these “promises” you made are toxic. Staying in an abusive relationship because you promised god, is a terrible reason, an outdated, awful and destructive belief.

You can still believe in god and not go to that church. Alternatively, there are so many other non religious organisations out there, that could wonderful for you. Your happiness and sanity is more important that pleasing this god.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 08:49

Babdoc · 28/01/2023 22:04

OP, I have moved church a few times. It’s important to have one where you feel you fit.
I left one when the brilliant minister left for a senior role at head office, and was replaced by a grim curmudgeon who sacked the Sunday school teacher, preached that everyone was doomed to hell, and banned raffles (gambling!) and bottle stalls (alcohol!) from the church fete.
I moved to one in a different village 8 miles away, until their lovely minister retired, and was replaced by basically the vicar of Dibley, but without the humour.
I then attended my own village church where they had appointed an excellent lesbian feminist minister who was a fiercely intelligent, double qualified lawyer/priest with great taste in music and a wonderful sense of humour.
Then she moved north to a new parish, and was replaced by two dumbed down happy clappies. I am now investigating two possible churches, one in a village up in the hills, one in our nearest city 10 miles away, both with good recommendations.
Someone really should start a Tripadvisor for churches! Grin

It's not a methodist church, is it? I think I may know your brilliant feminist minister.

ZenNudist · 29/01/2023 08:46

It would be a shame to throw out a life of faith for the sake if an obviously bad church. It sounds horrible. Mumsnet is majority atheist so asking here you pretty much know the answer you are going to get.

You say not interested in changing denominations but it sounds like you need to distance yourself from your present (former?) Church.

Plenty of lovely CofE methodist and Catholic churches that are nothing like your experience.

Even if you don't go to church any more I'd recommend finding someone of faith in the standard churches to debrief your what sounds like an evangelical church experience. I think it sounds quite traumatic.

Having a faith is an important dimension to life. I can't explain that except by personal experience (which will be scoffed at here). Try and remind yourself of what you got into your church for originally and think of your earlier relationship with God.

It is possible you are being called to a new faith experience if you are open to it. Don't let yourself be ground down by the bad church you currently go to.

I don't think a lie in on a Sunday morning is a worthy reason to throw away exploring something so life enhancing.

I'm up early for 9.30 mass but I have 1130 and 5pm options. I wouldn't not go and I wouldn't not bring my children up in faith but I accept they have to tread their own path eventually.

I think deal with your own faith issues and guide your kids but they will have to do the same.