Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no one needs this (TW Nazis)

29 replies

BelleMarionette · 28/01/2023 20:48

I went into an antique shop today, as I find them fun to browse.

I was shocked to see an array of nazi memorabilia, a lot of it with swastikas. Some of it was framed.

I wonder, who would buy this, and why? It makes me very uneasy, as I don't see this having any appeal, except to a neo-Nazi. Who else would display framed nazi memorabilia in their house?!

Aibu for thinking this shouldn't be sold? I also feel uneasy that a profit is being made from this, given the circumstances. Should ex-nazis be able to make money from selling their nazi items? Surely not..

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CoalCraft · 29/01/2023 06:36

In secondary school I had a friend who's dad collected memorabilia from both world wars, all sides. So I'd go to her house and there'd be swastikas on the living room, alongside pieces of uniform, weapons, and even like little squares of metal from planes or tanks. The thing he was most fond of was a tin box that was apparently a first aid kit from the Russian army.

He was otherwise a completely normal dude as far as I could tell apart from being a complete anorak. He was clearly delighted his daughter had brought home a new friend he could bore to tears showing off his collection. First time I went round he waited till I asked about all the stuff (who wouldn't?), then enthused about it for twenty minutes while his wife and daughters stood in the background shaking their heads and apologising.

So I guess people like that might buy it.

palelavender · 29/01/2023 05:36

For what it's worth, I was somewhat taken aback to find Nazi helmets etc for sale in an antiques shop I patronized. (It was not in the UK but possibly brought back by our soldiers too.) I asked the owner who bought it. In his words, "They are all sad little old men." I think that pretty much sums it up.

peaceandpotato · 29/01/2023 05:08

No one should profit off it

MissTrip82 · 29/01/2023 04:08

Never know why people repeat meaningless statements like ‘so we learn never to let it happen again’ when in fact genocide has happened repeatedly since WWII.

Also find it vanishingly unlikely that these items are routinely being purchased by good people who simply want a reminder not to commit genocide on their mantelpiece. Much more like they’re being purchased by dickheads who think it’s funny, or people who just happen to be ‘fascinated’ by the era and perhaps find it’s not entirely at odds with their own ideology.

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/01/2023 01:11

I'm not that bothered about it. War memorabilia is highly sought after. I doubt many actual Nazis are benefiting financially and modern fascists don't need to display swastikas to show others that they are cunts.

History should not be hidden away.

Poonicorn · 29/01/2023 01:03

I'm conflicted about this as in my gut I don't see anything wrong with someone buying a historical artefact. As long as you're not glorifying it for what it stands for. I always find it interesting to see war memorabilia in museums - of all sides - and don't see any difference in someone buying an item of historical interest for themselves.

Displaying it around the house would obviously be distasteful but having it in your possession as an item of historical interest I can't see the harm.

If we destroy history then we can't learn from it.

KenAdams · 29/01/2023 00:55

Is this the shop in the New Forest? Lymington I think.

TigerQueen89 · 29/01/2023 00:54

@OldTinHat aw that’s so cool!

Yeah exactly, for heavens sake it’s the least worst crime that can occur during a war right? See what the Red Army did in when they advanced on Berlin, or rather don’t it’s too disturbing….

OldTinHat · 28/01/2023 23:45

*They all 'took'

OldTinHat · 28/01/2023 23:44

TigerQueen89 · 28/01/2023 21:18

@BelleMarionette

Yeah it’s pretty grim and gives me the chills.

Where was this shop by the way? Not in Europe Im assuming.

That said, I have a slight connection to Nazi memorabilia. Both my granddads fought in WWII and were at D-Day. The one who was in the Desert Rats, my Mum’s Dad, saw action in Europe (he was too young for North Africa) and he bought back two SS ceremonial daggers after the war ended. He had them stored in a cupboard in his study until he was burgled in the 1980s and they were stolen along with a load of my Grandmas jewellery. All this was before I was born so I never saw them we, assume they ended up America and sold on there. Imagine there’s where a lot of it it.

My DGF was a Desert Rat in the North Africa Campaign under Montgomery in WWII. They took all 'souvenirs'.

Dotcheck · 28/01/2023 23:41

peaceandpotato · 28/01/2023 21:59

Should be illegal

Why? It is posting like historical artifices without identifying with the ideology it represents.

JackieDaws · 28/01/2023 23:38

BelleMarionette · 28/01/2023 22:21

No, but interesting to hear there are more places selling this.

There's a market stall in Greenwich that sells nazi memorabilia. It's behind the indoor market across from the church.

Also, I saw some in La Rochelle last summer.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 28/01/2023 23:30

You cannot make accurate scale models of WW2 aircraft now be because Germany bans the display of the swastika.

XenoBitch · 28/01/2023 23:12

I used to go out with a guy whose dad collected war memorabilia, and he had a few Nazi pieces. Nothing that would scream EDL or Neo-Nazi to anyone really. He died suddenly, and the bomb squad was called to his flat as he had hundreds of shells, bombs and guns too (all deactivated obviously, but the person who found him didn't know that).

smooththecat · 28/01/2023 23:07

Many European countries it would be illegal.

EzzieM · 28/01/2023 23:05

I can see why someone originally swiped them from Germany but I disagree with the shop selling them. Should go to a museum or be destroyed.

TigerQueen89 · 28/01/2023 22:50

@BelleMarionette also, I meant to say another motivation for taking trophies is that it’s a big FU to the enemy that have probably killed a lot of your friends in the preceding years. It’s all part of the psychology of war.

TigerQueen89 · 28/01/2023 22:44

@peaceandpotato yeah I agree

TigerQueen89 · 28/01/2023 22:43

Really? England I’m surprised they’re allowed to sell that stuff here.

Yeah, I assume that’s how the majority of this type of stuff made it out of Germany/Austria in the fist place. They were trophies after all - you’ve just won the war, you want some trinkets from the enemy you’ve just defeated as a reminder of what you’ve done and where you’ve been.

Here’s what wiki says:

“In more recent times, it has been common for soldiers to return home with souvenirs, such as enemy weapons and flags, while larger military items captured in battle, particularly weaponry such as machine guns and artillery pieces, became the property of the state to which the soldiers responsible for the capture belonged.”

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_trophy

Armies are, by and large, made up of young men. They love nicking stuff when no one’s looking. I would have done it at that age probably. In 1945 my grandad was 21 turning 22. The urge to lift these fascinating objects would have been irresistible.

I found another interesting article about it www.bbc.com/news/magazine-20532761.amp

I also remember my grandad had a framed ‘thank you’ letter written in English from a Burgermeister of a town his regiment had liberated in 44 or 45 - I think it was in Belgium or Holland? It was on his desk. I’m so old now I can’t remember, I read it as a kid. I was impressed. Don’t know why he had it, he was the tank driver of his tank, that was his job in his unit, so I’m not sure if he was ever given more of leadership role at any point, but that’s a nice keepsake to have from the war. Nicer than those daggers, just not as valuable or floggable.

Don’t know if my Dad’s dad took anything. He was on HMS Belfast and was a little bit older as he was born during the First World War. Maybe being a more mature he thought he was above all that! Or probably didn’t have the same opportunity being in the navy. I’ll ask.

As to what motivates people to collect them now, not 100% sure but they’re probably not the type of people you’d want to be stuck next to at a dinner party! On the low, they probably revere authoritarian regimes from history and “strong men” I assume. And it is always men that want this stuff isn’t it. Can’t imagine they are many women who go in for collecting it as a hobby.

BelleMarionette · 28/01/2023 22:21

KitBumbleB · 28/01/2023 22:01

Hungerford?

No, but interesting to hear there are more places selling this.

OP posts:
KitBumbleB · 28/01/2023 22:01

Hungerford?

peaceandpotato · 28/01/2023 21:59

Should be illegal

2ManyPjs · 28/01/2023 21:56

Sadly there's a market for them amongst your EDL types.

If a shop owner was happy to sell these then I wouldn't give him/her my custom at all. Either burn them or send to a museum.

growgrowinggrown · 28/01/2023 21:52

I know someone who is a bit of a local history buff, he buys up odds and sods like this as he feels he has a duty for them not to end up in the wrong hands.

A large selection of his bits are donated to museums and exhibitions which I think is a thoughtful thing to do.

I feel they serve a purpose of reminding us to never let history repeat itself, especially now.

When I was young my grandparents would tell me stories, we would see the old boys with their medals on for Sunday best or at the remembrance walks etc. As that generation slowly leave us I think it's important that we can feel a tangible connection in some way of what they fought for.

BelleMarionette · 28/01/2023 21:36

TigerQueen89 · 28/01/2023 21:18

@BelleMarionette

Yeah it’s pretty grim and gives me the chills.

Where was this shop by the way? Not in Europe Im assuming.

That said, I have a slight connection to Nazi memorabilia. Both my granddads fought in WWII and were at D-Day. The one who was in the Desert Rats, my Mum’s Dad, saw action in Europe (he was too young for North Africa) and he bought back two SS ceremonial daggers after the war ended. He had them stored in a cupboard in his study until he was burgled in the 1980s and they were stolen along with a load of my Grandmas jewellery. All this was before I was born so I never saw them we, assume they ended up America and sold on there. Imagine there’s where a lot of it it.

The shop is in rural England.

I hadn't considered that allies might have looted them. I do still wonder who would buy them.

In terms of remembering history, there are lots of ways to do that. I can see these items in museums, of course, but I do wonder why anyone would want a personal collection.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread