Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breast feeding in baby change room

184 replies

CreativeCreature · 28/01/2023 20:41

Today, our local supermarket has one baby change room. DD desperately needed changing before it became a whole outfit change. Lady was in there 45mins breast feeding, I had to use disabled toilet & change DD. AIBU to think she was selfish?

I knocked on more to check she was okay, she came to the door shouting she’d only just started feeding her baby & slammed the door. She was then in there for another 30 mins. So a total of 45 mins.

OP posts:
Nicecow · 29/01/2023 05:39

That is a long time to be breastfeeding, but first in, first serve. I can only assume she couldn't do it in public for some reason as no one would want to be stuck in a room for that long BF anyway.
What would you have done if there were two others waiting after her to feed? Or if there was no changing room? Or if all the toilets were out of order? I think you're lucky if this is such a problem that has caused you enough stress to want to post about it, and I award you ... Biscuit

mummyh2016 · 29/01/2023 05:26

Thank you to the poster who suggested holding a baby at the same time as changing a tampon, it did bring a smile to my face during these early hours.
Have you actually done this before? Not only since giving birth can I not insert a tampon using one hand but even if I could what happens when I inevitably get blood on my hand which tends to happen on heavy flow days?

atoxk · 29/01/2023 03:26

It's hard being first time mum if you are awkward. After a bit you get on board just feeding anywhere. But same as changing kid, most changing bags have a mat included, not ideal but just crack on changing them in normal toilet . Same as using a disabled loo. If there's another option use that, but if you have kids and pram then use it. And don't feel guilty if it's keeping you and kids safe

pinkunicorns54 · 29/01/2023 03:24

If it was me, I'd have probably invited you in to change your baby whilst I fed - if I knew I would be using the room for a long time.

But tbh, I find the thought of feeding a baby where people change nappies / go to the toilet a bit gross. So I would have used the cafe with a nice cuppa!

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 29/01/2023 03:07

I think the root problem here is that for some reasons she feels the need to feed in a toilet. It’s a shame and has a knock on effect.

NewShoes · 29/01/2023 02:23

I would have been annoyed, too. It’s far too long to be taking up the only available baby change space. I would have fed the baby in the cafe or the car, it would have felt selfish to know that other mums needed to use the room but I was taking it over for the best part of an hour.

ZiriForEver · 29/01/2023 02:15

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:50

Mental experiment: What if disabled mother needed to breastfeed her baby. Would it be ok for her to do it in disabled toilets (for 45 minutes)?

I don’t think breastfeeding in the disabled toilet is OK. Here, the mum is entitled to be in there and were she using the toilet then the fact that another disabled person has to wait is very unfortunate but no more than that. If she’s not using the toilet but co-opting it for a different purpose then that creates an accessibility issue.

That being said, my experience is that disabled people are generally very mindful of the need to ensure the accessibility of their facilities to other disabled people (it’s our work that got these facilities installed in the first place). So I don’t imagine that this scenario would arise very frequently.

Makes sense.

Than I don't understand why in the first half of this thread I see suggestions that mum repurposing baby change for feeding (and blocking it when other people might need it) is ok and in the second half repurposing accessible toilet for changing is wrong. In both cases it is somehow related, but blocking the designated activity.
(This isn't specifically aimed at Fitz)

oakleaffy · 29/01/2023 02:00

Puppers · 28/01/2023 21:18

It's not weird at all.

Some women are new to breastfeeding and nervous. Some babies - especially new ones - are fretful during feeds and it's less stressful with privacy. Some women have had bad experiences when feeding in public and been challenged. Some women have a crazy oversupply that is difficult to manage and can be messy. Some women forget to wear breastfeeding friendly clothes before leaving the house and find that they can't feed the baby without flashing much more flesh than they'd like/would be allowed in public (done this several times with dresses). Some babies are extremely wriggly and loud and nosy and attract unwanted attention.

There are dozens and dozens of reasons why a breastfeeding mother may choose privacy and none of them are weird.

Completely agree..Some mothers need privacy.
A draped scarf often draws more attention than just feeding without a muslin.
Saw a brave mother feed on the bus the other day..Extremely discreetly, one wouldn't have known unless one had fed oneself.

WineDup · 29/01/2023 01:56

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:42

Whos space is it?

I’ve already answered this. Disabled toilets are required to be provided under the Eq. Act. Baby changing spaces are not. That space may be multi-purpose but it has one sole legal designation, for a disabled person. The shop is in the wrong by designing it so as to make mums think they have the right to override a legally designated space.

There is an additional disabled toilet next door, which does not have a permanent changing bench nor does it have an armchair. It does have a pull down changing table.
This door has a wheelchair on it and a baby changing mat.

Fortunately most places I go have multiple options for disabled toilets - my local Asda has at least 7, presumably 10? the two I’ve mentioned above, one large cubicle in the downstairs girls toilets, a single cubicle upstairs and a larger cubicle within the main girls toilets, a single one in the cafe and a large cubicle in the girls loos in the cafe. I presume each of the men’s blocks also has a larger one but I’m not sure.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:50

Mental experiment: What if disabled mother needed to breastfeed her baby. Would it be ok for her to do it in disabled toilets (for 45 minutes)?

I don’t think breastfeeding in the disabled toilet is OK. Here, the mum is entitled to be in there and were she using the toilet then the fact that another disabled person has to wait is very unfortunate but no more than that. If she’s not using the toilet but co-opting it for a different purpose then that creates an accessibility issue.

That being said, my experience is that disabled people are generally very mindful of the need to ensure the accessibility of their facilities to other disabled people (it’s our work that got these facilities installed in the first place). So I don’t imagine that this scenario would arise very frequently.

Manicwithmoney · 29/01/2023 01:45

PlinkyPlonk1 · 28/01/2023 21:10

It's weird that she didn't just sit in the cafe to feed the baby. If she felt that odd about people looking, she could get a muslin from the shop to help cover up.

This. I can't understand why you wouldn't prefer to cover yourself and feed somewhere comfortable and hygienic over feeding in a changing facility that I assume doesn't have a chair.

That aside. It's really a problem for the supermarket.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:42

Whos space is it?

I’ve already answered this. Disabled toilets are required to be provided under the Eq. Act. Baby changing spaces are not. That space may be multi-purpose but it has one sole legal designation, for a disabled person. The shop is in the wrong by designing it so as to make mums think they have the right to override a legally designated space.

WineDup · 29/01/2023 01:41

SleepingStandingUp · 29/01/2023 01:18

Great plan, but if I have my baby I'm my left arm and my tampon in my right, where the hell do I put left baby's twin??

Most shops have accessible toilets rather than disabled, so they have the changing board etc in too. Rightly or wrongly people aren't going to piss themselves or put young babies on a dirty floor over quickly using a disabled toilet

You give the left baby’s twin your tampon to hold and you hold left baby in your right hand, duuuh.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:39

@WineDup As I said, I knew you would. Lucky ol’ you that disabled people campaigned for decades to get themselves something that you can simply nick.

WineDup · 29/01/2023 01:39

ZiriForEver · 29/01/2023 01:34

I understand the disabled loo argument. Place designated for disabled people.
But surely the same logic applies on the baby change. It is for changing babies. Taking it away for 45 minutes isn't fair on people who need to change their babies.

Mental experiment: What if disabled mother needed to breastfeed her baby. Would it be ok for her to do it in disabled toilets (for 45 minutes)?

Our Asda has a weird room which is bizarrely multipurpose. It’s for a designated fixed baby changing area, not a pull-down changing mat. They provide nappies, wipes and nappy sacks. In the corner, there is a comfortable armchair, presumably for feeding a child. There is also a fully functional disabled access toilet with grab rails and an emergency chord.
Whos space is it?

ZiriForEver · 29/01/2023 01:34

I understand the disabled loo argument. Place designated for disabled people.
But surely the same logic applies on the baby change. It is for changing babies. Taking it away for 45 minutes isn't fair on people who need to change their babies.

Mental experiment: What if disabled mother needed to breastfeed her baby. Would it be ok for her to do it in disabled toilets (for 45 minutes)?

WineDup · 29/01/2023 01:33

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:28

As you say, most of them are called “accessible” toilets, and they are for anyone who can’t access the toilet. Which I can’t do when I have my baby.

Didn’t bother to read the rest of my paragraph where I pointed out that the new accessible wording is accompanied with a sign saying “not all disabilities are visible”. The purpose of the name change was to widen the use of the facility to other disabilities, not just wheelchair users. Accessibility refers to the ability of a disabled person to access services. It does not refer to the ability of a mum to get a pram into a cubicle.

Plus, in almost every place I go, the baby changing table is inside the accessible cubicle. So it clearly is a space designed for parents to take young children too

I report every single place I see doing that, because they are breaching the provisions of the Equality Act, rendering a facility that is required to be accessible for disabled people inaccessible to them due to mums taking prams in there. It’s because the shops don’t understand their obligations, not because that’s what is intended.

I don’t know why I’m bothering arguing with you as you’re clearly going to carry on until your baby is old enough and then you’ll no longer care, but this behaviour is abhorrent and you should be ashamed of it.

Even if I remove my child from his pram, I still can’t use a normal cubicle, because he is unable to stand while I pee/change my tampon. As soon as my child can stand unaided, I’ll use the cubicle. Until that time, I cannot access the toilet without leaving my child unattended. Which I’m not willing to do, obviously.

If my son has shat from his knees to his shoulders, Ashe does approximately three times per day, then I’m going to go where I can change him asap - which is the baby changing table inside the disabled toilet.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:31

im sure there are countless more, but honestly, people with young babies do need to use the disabled toilet if there is nowhere else that they can change their baby.

No, they need to campaign for their own spaces. Nicking disabled facilities is a choice.

WineDup · 29/01/2023 01:28

WineDup · 29/01/2023 01:23

As you say, most of them are called “accessible” toilets, and they are for anyone who can’t access the toilet. Which I can’t do when I have my baby.

Plus, in almost every place I go, the baby changing table is inside the accessible cubicle. So it clearly is a space designed for parents to take young children too.

Places I’ve been very recently where the baby changing table is in the disabled toilet:

-Asda
-Matalan
-Aldi
-morrisons
-my local hospital
-starbucks
-costa
-TGI Fridays
-Wetherspoons

im sure there are countless more, but honestly, people with young babies do need to use the disabled toilet if there is nowhere else that they can change their baby.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:28

As you say, most of them are called “accessible” toilets, and they are for anyone who can’t access the toilet. Which I can’t do when I have my baby.

Didn’t bother to read the rest of my paragraph where I pointed out that the new accessible wording is accompanied with a sign saying “not all disabilities are visible”. The purpose of the name change was to widen the use of the facility to other disabilities, not just wheelchair users. Accessibility refers to the ability of a disabled person to access services. It does not refer to the ability of a mum to get a pram into a cubicle.

Plus, in almost every place I go, the baby changing table is inside the accessible cubicle. So it clearly is a space designed for parents to take young children too

I report every single place I see doing that, because they are breaching the provisions of the Equality Act, rendering a facility that is required to be accessible for disabled people inaccessible to them due to mums taking prams in there. It’s because the shops don’t understand their obligations, not because that’s what is intended.

I don’t know why I’m bothering arguing with you as you’re clearly going to carry on until your baby is old enough and then you’ll no longer care, but this behaviour is abhorrent and you should be ashamed of it.

WineDup · 29/01/2023 01:23

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:20

Disabled toilets aren’t like disabled parking spaces, they are for anyone who needs extra space/supports. I used one post section myself because I needed to use the hand rails to get myself off the toilet, I wasn’t disabled but I needed the adaptation. Similarly those with anxiety about public toilets can use disabled toilets.

Why do you think it’s called a bloody disabled toilet if you don’t need to be disabled to use it? Christ alive.

Even on the toilets now called “accessible” and not “disabled”, there’s additional signage saying, “not all disabilities are visible”. It’s very clear who these things are for and it’s not mums and babies.

Honestly, the entitlement. I’m used to mums nicking the facilities but denying that they’re there for those with disabilities in the first place is a new one on me.

As you say, most of them are called “accessible” toilets, and they are for anyone who can’t access the toilet. Which I can’t do when I have my baby.

Plus, in almost every place I go, the baby changing table is inside the accessible cubicle. So it clearly is a space designed for parents to take young children too.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:23

SleepingStandingUp · 29/01/2023 01:18

Great plan, but if I have my baby I'm my left arm and my tampon in my right, where the hell do I put left baby's twin??

Most shops have accessible toilets rather than disabled, so they have the changing board etc in too. Rightly or wrongly people aren't going to piss themselves or put young babies on a dirty floor over quickly using a disabled toilet

There’s a third option: campaigning for your own bloody facilities.

I realise that you can’t be bothered because the ideal facilities already exist and it’s easier to just nick them and then argue that disability somehow includes having a baby, but one can dream.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:20

Disabled toilets aren’t like disabled parking spaces, they are for anyone who needs extra space/supports. I used one post section myself because I needed to use the hand rails to get myself off the toilet, I wasn’t disabled but I needed the adaptation. Similarly those with anxiety about public toilets can use disabled toilets.

Why do you think it’s called a bloody disabled toilet if you don’t need to be disabled to use it? Christ alive.

Even on the toilets now called “accessible” and not “disabled”, there’s additional signage saying, “not all disabilities are visible”. It’s very clear who these things are for and it’s not mums and babies.

Honestly, the entitlement. I’m used to mums nicking the facilities but denying that they’re there for those with disabilities in the first place is a new one on me.

SleepingStandingUp · 29/01/2023 01:18

SarahAndQuack · 29/01/2023 00:57

Are you disabled? If you are, you are entitled to use the disabled loo.

Otherwise, you hold the baby while you pee and change your tampon, don't you?

Great plan, but if I have my baby I'm my left arm and my tampon in my right, where the hell do I put left baby's twin??

Most shops have accessible toilets rather than disabled, so they have the changing board etc in too. Rightly or wrongly people aren't going to piss themselves or put young babies on a dirty floor over quickly using a disabled toilet

comfyshoes2022 · 29/01/2023 01:13

I never breastfed in public, but I think it’s unreasonable to breastfeed in a space other people might need to use for 45 minutes. If it took me that long to do a feed, I would try have a different plan in terms of where I went, what I brought with me in terms of covers, etc.

At the same time, I’ve changed many nappies on the ground on my portable changing pad, and that’s never a big deal.