Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breast feeding in baby change room

184 replies

CreativeCreature · 28/01/2023 20:41

Today, our local supermarket has one baby change room. DD desperately needed changing before it became a whole outfit change. Lady was in there 45mins breast feeding, I had to use disabled toilet & change DD. AIBU to think she was selfish?

I knocked on more to check she was okay, she came to the door shouting she’d only just started feeding her baby & slammed the door. She was then in there for another 30 mins. So a total of 45 mins.

OP posts:
fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 12:40

WineDup · 29/01/2023 12:23

What do you suggest, places pull baby changing tables out of disabled toilets? as you say, they are accessible toilets for anyone who needs to use them as they cannot access a toilet. What’s your definition for “disabled”?

What do you suggest, places pull baby changing tables out of disabled toilets?

Yes, I’d absolutely suggest that. If that then creates a problem for mums, they can campaign to sort that problem out.

as you say, they are accessible toilets for anyone who needs to use them as they cannot access a toilet.

At this point you are wilfully misunderstanding me, as I have never said that. They are accessible for anyone who, by reason of a disability, cannot access a standard toilet. Not anyone who can’t fit their pram into a cubicle. That’s not a bloody disability.

What’s your definition for “disabled”?

There’s one in section 5 of the Equality Act - suggest you go and read that.

WineDup · 29/01/2023 12:23

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 12:08

@Scottishskifun It doesn’t need to say that they have to be provided for that sole use because that’s inherent in the concept of being provided. If you provide a disabled toilet but then say “oh it can also be used by a mum if she wants to spend an hour in there changing her baby and reading a book”, then you’re no longer providing a disabled toilet. You’re providing a toilet that can be used by disabled people as long as there’s not a mum in there. That’s not what the Eq Act sets out.

I don’t know why so many shops do this (I suspect it’s not made clear in planning applications that they intend to discharge their obligation to provide disabled access by providing a multi-purpose space). But I really hope that one of them gets sued. It’s the only way that these facilities are going to be left for the people who they’re for and not used as conveniences by everyone else.

What do you suggest, places pull baby changing tables out of disabled toilets? as you say, they are accessible toilets for anyone who needs to use them as they cannot access a toilet. What’s your definition for “disabled”?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 12:08

@Scottishskifun It doesn’t need to say that they have to be provided for that sole use because that’s inherent in the concept of being provided. If you provide a disabled toilet but then say “oh it can also be used by a mum if she wants to spend an hour in there changing her baby and reading a book”, then you’re no longer providing a disabled toilet. You’re providing a toilet that can be used by disabled people as long as there’s not a mum in there. That’s not what the Eq Act sets out.

I don’t know why so many shops do this (I suspect it’s not made clear in planning applications that they intend to discharge their obligation to provide disabled access by providing a multi-purpose space). But I really hope that one of them gets sued. It’s the only way that these facilities are going to be left for the people who they’re for and not used as conveniences by everyone else.

Scottishskifun · 29/01/2023 11:57

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 11:36

@Emmamoo89 And you’ve since complained to the store/business, right? You’ve started a campaign because you realise that it’s not ok to just use facilities that aren’t for you? You’ve recognised that the way to get the facilities you need is campaigning, (like disabled people did for decades, only to find that now they have them they’re back to square one because mums keep nicking them)? Right?

Disabled toilets are often also the changing space for babies. The equality act states that provision must be provided but not that it is sole use.
If it was illegal then pretty much most places in the UK would be breaking the law and wouldn't receive planning permission in the first place.

It's clearly a cause close to you but having a go at parents because they are using either a baby change in the designated area or in the rare example of the OP who had to briefly change a baby on the floor.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 11:36

@Emmamoo89 And you’ve since complained to the store/business, right? You’ve started a campaign because you realise that it’s not ok to just use facilities that aren’t for you? You’ve recognised that the way to get the facilities you need is campaigning, (like disabled people did for decades, only to find that now they have them they’re back to square one because mums keep nicking them)? Right?

Emmamoo89 · 29/01/2023 10:07

Nosleepforthismum · 29/01/2023 05:58

I think she was being a bit selfish tbh and I wouldn’t have stayed in there to feed my child if I knew another mum was outside waiting to change hers.

Not being selfish at all.

goinggoinggonee · 29/01/2023 10:06

I've never minded feeding and someone coming in and changing their baby. When DD was abjt older if someone came in with a smaller baby I'd stand and feed so they could sit down.

Emmamoo89 · 29/01/2023 10:06

fitzwilliamdarcy · 29/01/2023 01:02

@WineDup I don’t know how many more times this can be said - there is no reason that is good enough for using a disabled toilet. Not a pram, not being over a size 12, not having a tampon in, not the baby change being in there - nothing.

Disabled facilities are legal provisions. They were fought for for decades and are for the sole use of those with disabilities. They are not there for the convenience of mums. If you want facilities for mums, campaign for them. You won’t, because being inconvenienced is a temporary state for most mums, so they think: why should I bother? But the disabled person spends a lifetime with endless generations of new mums nicking their facilities rather than campaigning, bedside it’s only temporary.

This drives me absolutely bananas. You are being let down by lack of facilities, but that does not give you the right to steal somebody else’s.

I had to use a disabled toilet to change my sons bum because the other toilet didn't have a changing table.

shard5 · 29/01/2023 10:03

24hrmilkbar · 29/01/2023 08:20

Was meant to quote @shard5

That sounds similar to what I saw.
I think there should be similar set ups everywhere.
Large shopping centres included. In a smaller scale obviously but it was so refreshing to see.

gogohmm · 29/01/2023 08:53

Yes selfish, why couldn't she just feed her baby in the cafe?

Orangesare · 29/01/2023 08:29

If it was a baby room for feeding and changing then she was fine. Not everyone feels comfortable feeding in a cafe or the car.
Personally I’ll whip a tit out anywhere and take the dirty looks, weird stares and comments but many other mothers can’t so they should be able to feed in peace.
I rarely change a nappy in a changing room. Buggy or car are the easiest places. I can do over a knee as well.

Sceptre86 · 29/01/2023 08:27

Why did you stay the 45 minutes? Could you not have gone to your car (unless you used public transport)? Did you have a pram with you that you could have changed baby in? Ideally she would have fed baby in a cafe leaving the one changing room to be used for its actual purpose. I'd have complained to customer services in the supermarket, they may well have suggested somewhere for you to change baby and saved you waiting so long.

Swiftswatch · 29/01/2023 08:27

WindscreenWipe · 29/01/2023 08:01

You must have very long legs.

Why would they have very long legs? You put the child at 90 degrees to you, not length ways along your legs.

Swiftswatch · 29/01/2023 08:24

Cotswoldmama · 29/01/2023 08:07

I think it was really selfish of her, she could feed her baby anywhere, you said you had to wait in the cafe. That would be the perfect place to feed a baby. You on the other hand can't change a nappy anywhere. If she doesn't like to feed in public I think she should be prepared with some sort of cover. I don't think shops should have provide areas to breast feed in because that makes it seem like they don't support breastfeeding anywhere but those areas.

So basically if she doesn’t feel comfortable feeding in public she should just stay home because private spaces shouldn’t be made available??

Of course a nappy can be changed in other place, there was a whole toilet space OP could have put a changing mat down on.

24hrmilkbar · 29/01/2023 08:20

24hrmilkbar · 29/01/2023 08:15

Victoria Centre in Nottingham has a set up like that and also some individual cubicles with toilets and baby change too, was absolutely amazed to go round the corner to see that though. Big wall of baby changing trays mounted on counters with sinks in between. Buggy parking and feeding cubicles, even has bottle warming.

Was meant to quote @shard5

Sparklybanana · 29/01/2023 08:18

She was selfish. Whilst it's not impossible to change a baby with a space, it's not ideal and usually frowned upon if you do it anywhere else - cafe table anyone?
It is easy to feed in a cafe.Grab a drink then either find a more private part, wear dual layers so you can feed discretely or use a covering (although I found these akin to a neon sign...). There are plenty of options for public feeding if you're not a "baps oot" kinda lady 🤣. Don't impact your choices on other parents though.

24hrmilkbar · 29/01/2023 08:15

Victoria Centre in Nottingham has a set up like that and also some individual cubicles with toilets and baby change too, was absolutely amazed to go round the corner to see that though. Big wall of baby changing trays mounted on counters with sinks in between. Buggy parking and feeding cubicles, even has bottle warming.

Cotswoldmama · 29/01/2023 08:07

I think it was really selfish of her, she could feed her baby anywhere, you said you had to wait in the cafe. That would be the perfect place to feed a baby. You on the other hand can't change a nappy anywhere. If she doesn't like to feed in public I think she should be prepared with some sort of cover. I don't think shops should have provide areas to breast feed in because that makes it seem like they don't support breastfeeding anywhere but those areas.

WindscreenWipe · 29/01/2023 08:01

Eastereggsboxedupready · 28/01/2023 21:05

Ime it is entirely possible to sit on a closed loo seat and change a nappy...
Needs must over the years and multiple dc. Never enough facilities
.

You must have very long legs.

Calphurnia88 · 29/01/2023 07:45

I breastfeed and in the first few months was really nervous about doing it in public.

There's still no way I would have used up the only baby changing facilties in a venue for 45 minutes to BF. I would've sat in a quiet corner of the cafe, or if that wasn't possible, the car.

MeinKraft · 29/01/2023 07:26

mummyh2016 · 29/01/2023 05:26

Thank you to the poster who suggested holding a baby at the same time as changing a tampon, it did bring a smile to my face during these early hours.
Have you actually done this before? Not only since giving birth can I not insert a tampon using one hand but even if I could what happens when I inevitably get blood on my hand which tends to happen on heavy flow days?

I can't even insert one whilst sitting down anymore. It's a whole palaver involving standing up and putting a foot up on something. Imagine doing that when holding a baby Grin

HiImTheProblemItsMe · 29/01/2023 07:24

I think neither of you are UR - you both wanted to use the facilities for their intended purpose. There should be, imo, separate feeding rooms and baby change spaces. You sometimes get this and other times they just plonk a plastic chair in the loo and call it a feeding / parent room. You could also have both slightly adjusted your behaviour - I've often done a nappy change in the buggy, laying it as flat as possible, or in the boot of the car. Also if I knew, or realised as I started, that my baby was settling in for a long feed, I'd move to the cafe or, again, car (I'm assuming you both had cars as you say supermarket). I've also found shops are more than happy to let mums feed in changing rooms if they aren't busy. Anyway, facilities for new mums are rubbish and I don't blame either of you for wanting appropriate spaces to change and feed your DC.

Kabalagala · 29/01/2023 07:14

YANBU. That's way too long to be in the baby change.
However, it is very unreasonable that we as a society make mums feel like they need to hide away to feed.

Nosleepforthismum · 29/01/2023 05:58

I think she was being a bit selfish tbh and I wouldn’t have stayed in there to feed my child if I knew another mum was outside waiting to change hers.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 29/01/2023 05:40

the supermarket was being unreasonable, not the other mum. they should put foldaway changing tables in both the main toilets so that parents can do nappy changes wherever. bf mums shouldn't have to stay at home for months and are reasonable to choose for themselves how much privacy they need so its not intrinsically unreasonable for her to use a provided facility for that long, it can take that long for a baby to get a proper feed, but there needs to be more facilities.

Swipe left for the next trending thread