Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think they NEED to teach car maintenance at school?

392 replies

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 28/01/2023 15:50

Today my car tyre popped on a piece of metal left in the middle of the road, and I had no idea what to do.
I've been driving since I was 17 and I'm in my 30s and never had an accident touch wood or anything wrong with my tyres.
I instantly panicked as it happened in the middle of a giant hill and knew I couldn't do it there, thankfully a really kind man ran out and helped it be pushed to the side & changed my tyre for me.

I had no idea how to do it, or what a space saver tyre really was! Luckily I got it home driving very slowly & onto my drive and have my breakdown cover coming out next week to change the tyre.
But I just had no idea about any of it. Im aware I sound like a helpless woman, but im usually quite independent but this knocked me for six!

AIBU to think they need to teach car maintenance in school rather than pushing maths (which lets face it isn't anywhere as important) onto students till they turn 18?

OP posts:
WhereDoesThisToiletGo · 28/01/2023 16:30

top tips for changing a tyre.
Use one of the mats from the car footwell to kneel on.
Loosen the nuts at least half way before lifting the car on the jack.
To untighten nuts, put the nut wrench on the nut in 2 o'clock position, then push it down with your foot. I've actually stood on a wrench with my full weight to Loosen a nut. (which is why you shouldn't jack the car up yet!
Iv hhad a flat tyre on the way to catch a flight - you don't always have time to wait for the AA!

(I also had flat tyre on my wedding car - I left that one for someone else to change!)

UsingChangeofName · 28/01/2023 16:30

Needmorelego · 28/01/2023 16:18

Actually....
I do think schools should do more life skills and community based lessons.
The GCSE years are all about exams, exams, exams. The amount of threads on here about the hours and hours of revision that need to be done. The amount of subjects that are compulsory - but really many teens aren't that interested in and it won't make a massive difference in their futures if they didn't do.
The GCSEs are 2 years. The final summer term is the exams so I won't count that so it's 10 half terms of around 6 weeks.
If schools did 6 week courses on things that are life skills (ie car maintenance) and also community based projects then that's 10 different 'life' experiences that 16 year olds will have when they finish school. Experiences that many don't get the opportunity to do out of school.
This wouldn't be about getting a GCSE. Not even about 'passing' the subject. It would be about learning useful things, having experiences and even having fun.
I know if something like this had been around when I did my GCSEs it probably would have been my favourite subject.

I think there is something in this.
Over 40 years ago, when my brother was at 6th form in a boys' grammar they did a "getting ready for living away from home at University" course - it included some stuff like how to wire a plug that you wouldn't need nowadays, but they made them all sew on a button, sew up a hem, cook a couple of meals, iron a shirt (life was more formal then), and had lessons (I guess they would be more PSME now) including stuff like knowledge about alcohol and drugs.

I can actually see the value in a term of 'adulting skills' at the end of school - teaching things like budgeting, understanding credit, cooking (incl things like storing food, freezing, not wasting, adapting recipes etc), First Aid, some basic DIY skills, and all the other things that people say "should be taught at school". Sort of like everybody (okay, well the men) had to do National Service back in the day.
For those who then choose to go to University, it would give a term for all potential students to apply with results in hand, and do away with all the 6th form angst of predicted grades.

I know it would never happen Grin but, if I ever get to rule the world, I might decide to impose it.

It's all very well saying "parents should......" but there are too many families where children don't have the parents who do - or, in many cases who can , and so the cycle continues.

SnarkyBag · 28/01/2023 16:26

madnessitellyou · 28/01/2023 15:53

No.

Secondary school aged children cannot drive. Some will never drive. At some point, people have to take responsibility for their own lives and knowledge and not rely on school to fill every single gap.

Yup all of this.

BamBamBilla · 28/01/2023 16:25

I actually did learn this at school. But it was the chosen technology subject that I did for GCSE instead of food tech/wood work/graphics or sewing. We changed tyres, took apart the engine of an old Vauxhall Astra, learned about breaks and the gear systems.

daisyjgrey · 28/01/2023 16:23

If you've been driving 15 odd years and have never bothered to learn how to change a tyre - to the point where you don't know what a space saving tyre is - then I'm afraid that's your fault.

Buy a can of tyreweld and keep it in the boot.

postitpatty · 28/01/2023 16:21

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 28/01/2023 15:58

Right fair enough, but who even teaches how to change a tyre?

Google is great but it's not a actual teacher in front of you teaching you. Not all of us are lucky enough to have a parent or loved one to teach us this skill.

YouTube is your friend. I've taught myself how to do alsorts of practical stuff watching YouTube tutorials. Saved myself a fortune!

Fluffygreenslippers · 28/01/2023 16:20

You can teach yourself if you’re that bothered imo. A lot of cars nowadays require a computer to diagnose issues and can’t be fixed by a hobbyist. My husband is a big biker and can fix his vintage bike but doesn’t have a clue about a modern racing bike for example.

A huge swathe of people don’t even learn what schools DO teach in the first place. I recall a notable example, a girl asking me ‘what’s the holocaust?’ barely a week after we had spent a term studying WWII.

Spiderplantation · 28/01/2023 16:19

Surely it's absolutely vital they teach children how damaging driving us and how urgent the need to find alternatives??!!

Nimbostratus100 · 28/01/2023 16:18

no "they" ( ie me!) dont need to and shouldn't

I dont know anything about car maintenance - I dont have a car and I never will

Most of my students probably wont, either, these days, and the ones that do, how do we know in advance what wort of car they well drive?

What car maintenance would cover the issues that cars drivers might face in the future? Anything we teach now will be obsolete by the time our students are adults

I dont have enough space to store the resources for the lessons I do teach. Or to seat all my students. Where is the space for car maintenance? Or the cars to practice on?

What should I take out of the curriculum to accommodate this unnecessary, expensive and useless subject? Not maths, which most students need to get a job.

So you want people without any knowledge of cars to chuck away their teaching resources, buy some old cars, chuck out the chairs and tables in some classroom, and teach something they know nothing about to a bunch of children who will never use that information, when any of them that do become drivers will be perfectly capable of finding out the relevant, up to date information for themselves, as and when they need it.

This is one of the crazier "Schools NEED to teach...." ideas

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 28/01/2023 16:18

If driving was on the curriculum then I’d say basic car maintenance should be part of the subject, but it isn’t so no. Schools don’t have the capacity to teach everything that may one day be useful, same as ‘they need to teach mortgages and bills’. I always think no to that too. I’ve seen how to look after dogs should be taught in schools here, no to that as well.

Eatentoomanyroses · 28/01/2023 16:18

Jesus. How many hours do you think there are in the school day? People have no concept of what schools are trying to get through in a day

MissWings · 28/01/2023 16:18

@Hingey

Depends on your learning style. I’ve never learnt a thing off YouTube. Usually the annoying fucking American accent is enough to put me off within five seconds flat.

Needmorelego · 28/01/2023 16:18

Actually....
I do think schools should do more life skills and community based lessons.
The GCSE years are all about exams, exams, exams. The amount of threads on here about the hours and hours of revision that need to be done. The amount of subjects that are compulsory - but really many teens aren't that interested in and it won't make a massive difference in their futures if they didn't do.
The GCSEs are 2 years. The final summer term is the exams so I won't count that so it's 10 half terms of around 6 weeks.
If schools did 6 week courses on things that are life skills (ie car maintenance) and also community based projects then that's 10 different 'life' experiences that 16 year olds will have when they finish school. Experiences that many don't get the opportunity to do out of school.
This wouldn't be about getting a GCSE. Not even about 'passing' the subject. It would be about learning useful things, having experiences and even having fun.
I know if something like this had been around when I did my GCSEs it probably would have been my favourite subject.

Marblessolveeverything · 28/01/2023 16:18

When I got a car I went to an evening class for a few weeks learning the basics. Most my friends had their dad /mum show them. I wouldn't like it in secondary school education but it could be added on to driving lessons.

The problem is now the tyres are too difficult to remove by hand you need a machine and issues need to be diagnosed by a computer.

But basics is up to you as an adult to learn e.g. how to change a fuse,plug, turn water cock off. Catch a rodent, hang a picture, etc it's just life as an adult. This is an overhang of spoonfed learning - identify your learning goal and engage.

Hingey · 28/01/2023 16:16

Right fair enough, but who even teaches how to change a tyre?

Basically every single life skill I have like changing tyres, wallpapering, knitting, hanging really heavy mirrors, highlighting my hair etc I've learned on Youtube. Have you never heard of it OP? Grin

flumposie · 28/01/2023 16:16

No. It's getting ridiculous now. Whatever next?

redbigbananafeet · 28/01/2023 16:16

And people wonder why kids manage to leave school without being able to read and write. There's already enough crap in the curriculum we don't have time to teach without mechanics being added!

Treeeeeeee · 28/01/2023 16:15

Ofcourse maths is much more important than changing a tyre. Maths is required in later life, and quite frankly the general public have too low an ability to understand maths as it is. For the car I can just pay for the AA and for someone else to fix it.

PeekAtYou · 28/01/2023 16:15

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 28/01/2023 15:58

Right fair enough, but who even teaches how to change a tyre?

Google is great but it's not a actual teacher in front of you teaching you. Not all of us are lucky enough to have a parent or loved one to teach us this skill.

I'd watch YouTube tbh

You could argue that it might be helpful in the theory test but it's not up to schools to teach stuff like this. Most kids would assume that they were going to call the AA as they are the professionals.

RecordsTurning · 28/01/2023 16:15

madnessitellyou · 28/01/2023 15:53

No.

Secondary school aged children cannot drive. Some will never drive. At some point, people have to take responsibility for their own lives and knowledge and not rely on school to fill every single gap.

This. When I learnt to drive, I got someone to teach me some basic stuff about cars, including how to change a tyre. And I got breakdown cover. Schools can’t be responsible for everything.

CecilyP · 28/01/2023 16:15

No. You can learn how to change your tyre laboriously with the Jack in your car. Or you can call the AA or similar who will come out with a super duper jack unlike anything you’re ever likely to own and change it in a jiffy!

Pssspsss · 28/01/2023 16:14

Car to the garage. 🤦‍♀️

Pssspsss · 28/01/2023 16:13

Use your initiative. When you take your car garage ask them to show you what to do if it happens again. I reckon they’ll be pleased to help you learn how to do this.

MissWings · 28/01/2023 16:13

@amylou8

Same. This is what I pay the RAC for. I’ve had two popped tyres over the course of my life and that’s what I’ve always done. I would never want to do it myself, it’s just not something I could do even if I was taught. Just not for me. I was on the way to work and I work for a teaching agency, I rang them and they said can you not just change it yourself?

erm no I fucking can’t.

shard5 · 28/01/2023 16:12

It doesn't have to be a parent teaching you a skill and definitely not a teacher. Can you imagine a teacher having a class of 30 standing around a car and trying to teach a class how to fill up the oil and change a tyre.
How is this even practical?
whose car would they teach on?
Where would this lesson take place?
When will people start taking responsibility for their own choices????
You want to drive a car? Take some responsibility in learning the basics about keeping it in working order! Have some numbers saved for mechanics/ garages!
If you think you're adult enough to drive a hunk of metal around, be adult enough not to blame your teachers when you break down and don't know what to do!