Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think they NEED to teach car maintenance at school?

392 replies

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 28/01/2023 15:50

Today my car tyre popped on a piece of metal left in the middle of the road, and I had no idea what to do.
I've been driving since I was 17 and I'm in my 30s and never had an accident touch wood or anything wrong with my tyres.
I instantly panicked as it happened in the middle of a giant hill and knew I couldn't do it there, thankfully a really kind man ran out and helped it be pushed to the side & changed my tyre for me.

I had no idea how to do it, or what a space saver tyre really was! Luckily I got it home driving very slowly & onto my drive and have my breakdown cover coming out next week to change the tyre.
But I just had no idea about any of it. Im aware I sound like a helpless woman, but im usually quite independent but this knocked me for six!

AIBU to think they need to teach car maintenance in school rather than pushing maths (which lets face it isn't anywhere as important) onto students till they turn 18?

OP posts:
Sirzy · 28/01/2023 17:00

I think some people forget that most learning doesn’t take place at school and that people, especially adults are free to learn new things whenever they want

Justalittlebitduckling · 28/01/2023 16:59

Why is everything the responsibility of the school? Parents should be teaching their kids these kind of life skills.

MrsHamlet · 28/01/2023 16:58

If I'm busy teaching car maintenance and how to apply for a mortgage, are parents going to teach the finer points of poetry analysis? No. Thought not.

Spectre8 · 28/01/2023 16:57

So many videos on YouTube, why don't you just warch one and do it on your car so you know how.

I learnt how to properly paint walls. Learn thos to pull up my laminate flooring without damaging it so I could sort out my subfloor, put new underlay down and refit my floor. Saved tons of money this way.

Floralnomad · 28/01/2023 16:51

Just pay for breakdown cover . I’ve been driving for 40 yrs and can change wheels and do basic maintenance - my dad taught us back in the day .

Flossflower · 28/01/2023 16:48

Treeeeeeee · 28/01/2023 16:15

Ofcourse maths is much more important than changing a tyre. Maths is required in later life, and quite frankly the general public have too low an ability to understand maths as it is. For the car I can just pay for the AA and for someone else to fix it.

Good answer

NumberTheory · 28/01/2023 16:48

You know, you don’t have to just choose math or car maintenance. It’s perfectly possible to learn maths and how to change a tyre. I did both when I was a teenager, along with how to replace bulbs, check and change the oil, wiper blades, coolant, etc.

Since then I’ve used the maths a lot more than the car maintenance. Even with driving maths has been useful to understand the best finance deal, which vehicle is likely to be cheaper to run, whether the milege my company offers is likely to cover the actual cost of driving for them, what the best route was for a complex journey, etc. And the math has been useful in all sorts of other areas of life too.

PuttingDownRoots · 28/01/2023 16:48

I WAS taught in Sixth Form. Local council scheme... give sixth form girls the basic skills to get themselves out of trouble (such as a flat tyre on a country lane at night with no mobile signal)

A month afterwards... I helped my uncle change the flat on a strangers car we were driving past

Since then...
Route 66 in the US. No mobile signal, no other cars passed in the time it took
Car alerted me to falling tyre pressure... visual inspection showed nail, I was able to put spare on and take it to the repair shop (alone, DDs helped)
Car alert for plummeting tyre pressure on A1. DH and I changed it on hard shoulder. Took wheel to repair shop.

For something so relatively straightforward it seems pointless waiting for breakdow if you can sort it yourself.

If not schools... add it to driving syllabus and test along with stuff like oil checks and topping up screen wash.

Needmorelego · 28/01/2023 16:48

@CaptainMyCaptain I would have happily dropped science and French to do this.
I wasn't interested in science and wasn't very good at French...but they were compulsory. I got rubbish grades in both. Waste of my time, waste of my teachers time.
That's my point....far to many subjects are compulsory for GCSE when really it could be cut down and teens could actually do other things instead.
But the current system is all about academic success and nothing else.

Chickenly · 28/01/2023 16:47

UsingChangeofName · 28/01/2023 16:30

I think there is something in this.
Over 40 years ago, when my brother was at 6th form in a boys' grammar they did a "getting ready for living away from home at University" course - it included some stuff like how to wire a plug that you wouldn't need nowadays, but they made them all sew on a button, sew up a hem, cook a couple of meals, iron a shirt (life was more formal then), and had lessons (I guess they would be more PSME now) including stuff like knowledge about alcohol and drugs.

I can actually see the value in a term of 'adulting skills' at the end of school - teaching things like budgeting, understanding credit, cooking (incl things like storing food, freezing, not wasting, adapting recipes etc), First Aid, some basic DIY skills, and all the other things that people say "should be taught at school". Sort of like everybody (okay, well the men) had to do National Service back in the day.
For those who then choose to go to University, it would give a term for all potential students to apply with results in hand, and do away with all the 6th form angst of predicted grades.

I know it would never happen Grin but, if I ever get to rule the world, I might decide to impose it.

It's all very well saying "parents should......" but there are too many families where children don't have the parents who do - or, in many cases who can , and so the cycle continues.

Schools teach food technology (i.e. cooking meals, food safety, etc), and textiles (i.e. sewing buttons). Wiring a plug is part of the GCSE physics specification. Drugs and alcohol awareness and safety is taught multiple times throughout school. Multiple DIY skills are taught in Resistant Materials, metal work and wood work or D&T. First aid is taught frequently in schools as off-one sessions but various aspects are also covered in Health and Social Care or the Biology curriculum.

Why do people insist on whinging that schools aren’t teaching things that they literally are teaching?

Spanielsarepainless · 28/01/2023 16:46

Or parents could. Or local garages run courses. Or driving schools?

Anamechangeisnotjustforchristmas · 28/01/2023 16:43

And how will schools fit in the skilled mechanics into their payroll budgets?

Rebel2023 · 28/01/2023 16:40

I speak to people daily who don't know how to top up washer fluid or check tyre pressure

Working on something at the minute where we do a drop in, you turn up and say "can you show me how to top up my washer fluid/how do I know when my car needs a service/what does that button do?" And we answer all your questions

WindscreenWipe · 28/01/2023 16:39

These threads are almost exclusively started by (and agreed with by) the people who didn’t pay any attention to any of the things that they were actually taught at school.

Fairislefandango · 28/01/2023 16:38

Ridiculous idea for all the reasons alreafy mentioned. If schools taught all the things that people on MN threads consider to be essential and outrageously lacking from the curriculum, kids would have to be at school 24/7 with no holidays!

handsoffate · 28/01/2023 16:38

My dad taught me basic car maintenance, including how to change a tyre, when I was 17 and starting to learn to drive. I’m surprised how many drivers don’t know how to tbh. Even if you’re not physically going to do it yourself it’s helpful to know the principle.

C8H10N4O2 · 28/01/2023 16:37

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 28/01/2023 15:50

Today my car tyre popped on a piece of metal left in the middle of the road, and I had no idea what to do.
I've been driving since I was 17 and I'm in my 30s and never had an accident touch wood or anything wrong with my tyres.
I instantly panicked as it happened in the middle of a giant hill and knew I couldn't do it there, thankfully a really kind man ran out and helped it be pushed to the side & changed my tyre for me.

I had no idea how to do it, or what a space saver tyre really was! Luckily I got it home driving very slowly & onto my drive and have my breakdown cover coming out next week to change the tyre.
But I just had no idea about any of it. Im aware I sound like a helpless woman, but im usually quite independent but this knocked me for six!

AIBU to think they need to teach car maintenance in school rather than pushing maths (which lets face it isn't anywhere as important) onto students till they turn 18?

Is this alongside or instead of cooking, diy, book keeping, budgeting, dressmaking, shelf putting up, sex ed and the million other "life skills" which the school curriculum is supposed to include? Which subjects do you propose are dropped to make room for them?

If only we had had a mass of online free resources telling us how to do everything from wiping our bums to building bombs complete with pictures and videos.

CaptainMyCaptain · 28/01/2023 16:37

madnessitellyou · 28/01/2023 15:53

No.

Secondary school aged children cannot drive. Some will never drive. At some point, people have to take responsibility for their own lives and knowledge and not rely on school to fill every single gap.

Agreed. What subject would they have to drop to do this.

greenacrylicpaint · 28/01/2023 16:37

yabu

they should know how to repair a bike tyre though and adjust bike brakes and gears.

tbh if you drive a car you are responsible for keeping it road safe and how to recover from situations you describe. either by paying a recovery service or learning how to under your own steam.

Iheartmysmart · 28/01/2023 16:36

My dad taught me basic car maintenance when I passed my test. His exact words were ‘no daughter of mine is going to stand at the side of a road waiting for someone else to do something she could easily do herself’. He was also a stickler for Sunday morning oil, coolant and tyre pressure checks no matter how hungover we were. Thanks dad!

silvermantella · 28/01/2023 16:35

no. I agree with all the other posters - it's very unlikely if you were taught aged 11-16 you'd even remember it 20 plus years later, many cars now are either too heavy/unwieldy/complex to change yourself, or don't include the correct kit (load of cars now just have that tyre inflate repair stuff in a can rather than a spare tyre). People 'having a go' at something they don't know how to do properly and don't have the right tools for, for the first time in a stressful situation is unlikely to have great results.

Basic car maintenance and very easy, non emergency repair (e.g. changing windscreen wipers) is easy to teach yourself from youtube or a book, for the result just get breakdown insurance/go to a garage.

MsRead · 28/01/2023 16:34

During my A Levels in a state secondary school they included a compulsory unit on carousel which included financial management and basic car maintenance and I forget the less useful units. Was during the mid 90’s and I did roll my teenage eyes at having to do these courses but they were very useful. I even summoned up the knowledge last year when a teen had a flat in the car park at school and I was able to help her, even down to the correct order to tighten nuts and of course driving slowly to the garage to get them checked ( I now live abroad so driving ages are lower than the UK).

I do agree that schools are being made responsible for things they are not responsible for, but this carousel unit was really good, although I wouldn’t have admitted it at the time. I also seem to remember although we had a tiny sixth form of 20, some parents became fairly animated about wasting learning time but the rather brilliant Head held her ground.

As a teacher now, yes these courses would be marvellous but we also have to consider that because the internet is so easily accessible etc.. a lot of these skills can be gained from watching YouTube.

Schools cannot do right for doing wrong and any learning time that is used for non curricular activity would gain ‘remarks’ from parents and probably an official complaint or two. Head teachers these days tend to bow very swiftly to what parents think and taking on another battle plus factoring in staffing, lesson time, resources are extra battles that I think only the bravest or most well funded school could even consider taking on. Gone are the days when a kindly woodwork teacher would allow his elderly Ford Escort to repeatedly have its wheels taken off, oil changed etc… and not every driver when they first start out can afford breakdown recovery.

noblegiraffe · 28/01/2023 16:33

Why is it whenever an adult encounters something that they can’t do, instead of learning how to do it they start going on about how it should have been taught at school. Like the point of school is to teach you everything you might need to know in life so that you can stop learning at 18.

Didn’t know how to get a mortgage - should have been taught at school

Didn’t know how to plan a dinner - should have been taught at school

Didn’t know how to do taxes - should have been taught at school

Didn’t know how to vote or what the different parties stand for - should have been taught at school.

With the wealth of internet resources out there these days there is no excuse in blaming school for your ignorance on a variety of topics.

Survey99 · 28/01/2023 16:32

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 28/01/2023 15:58

Right fair enough, but who even teaches how to change a tyre?

Google is great but it's not a actual teacher in front of you teaching you. Not all of us are lucky enough to have a parent or loved one to teach us this skill.

You don't need permission or formal education in school to learn practical skills. If you are competent enough to drive you must be competent enough to find out about basic car maintenance. Be proactive, stop being lazy and teach yourself!

For something as simple as changing a tyre look on youtube and then give it a go at home (you don't need to wait until you have a flat!). There should be a service/user manual with your car, have you read it? In ye olden days I learned from reading the car manual(s) that came with my first car!

Mangogogogo · 28/01/2023 16:31

Honestly if someone taught me to change a tyre at 13 years old by the time I was driving and then got my first puncture (probs like 2 years into driving?) there was no bloody way I’d remember it