Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Other parents just waiting to say told you so.

141 replies

NC2023 · 28/01/2023 15:30

Not sure what looking for. Maybe a good comeback or maybe just some insight/support.

My son was in a state school from nursery to year 2 and we decided to put him into private. We are by no means rich but can manage. Friends and parents of kids in the old school really tried to put us off by saying it’s a huge mistake and we are silly for doing so. I 100% feel it was, and still is the correct decision as the school has been given “requires improvement” in recent ofsted. I wasn’t happy at all with the school and other schools in catchment were no better so private was our decision.

what annoys me is one parent out of either “sheer concern” or most likely jealousy always brings up negatives of private school when we meet. I felt very uncomfortable last time we met as she questioned me what exactly is so different and I told her and her response was “well you could dothat yourself and all kids need in primary is a supportive parent”. She also keeps making a point her husband is very rich but they decided state school is better. I never bring up this topic of conversation but a handful of friends do every time. It’s really uncomfortable. I’m a very shy and introverted person so kind of feel it’s really awkward but others might think it’s just discussion.

I feel a few of them are waiting for DS to fail so they can say “told u so” or waiting for me to say private was a huge mistake and I’m regretting it. Every time I meet these few friends they make it into a discussion topic. I’m quite angry after each meet up.

OP posts:
Mysmallgarden · 28/01/2023 17:50

Pure jealousy I'm afraid. Private schools bring out the worst in many people. Move on, they're not your friends.

Boneweary · 28/01/2023 17:47

Devoutspoken · 28/01/2023 17:18

Some people don't agree with private schools, jealousy is not the reason

If you really oppose a friends personal or political views, then limiting contact is best. What isn’t acceptable is to keep bringing something like this up.

If someone said to me they didn’t agree with private schools, fine, but that’s different to watching and waiting for a child to be unhappy.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 28/01/2023 17:46

Say ‘you do you’

Justasec321 · 28/01/2023 17:45

NC2023 · 28/01/2023 15:35

Thank you for your responses. I did write a text to the friend after our meet up outlining I feel upset how she goes on about it every time but I didn’t send! I think it’s best to wait till someone brings it up again face to face. What can I actually say tho?

What do you say?"I know what you mean - it works for us for now1 Who knows what the future holds...more tea?"

Burgoo · 28/01/2023 17:41

Are they waiting to say that? Have they told you that they are? If not then you are just making assumptions. Unless you can mind-read. In which case don't give THAT curse to me!

Moveoverdarlin · 28/01/2023 17:39

I would just say ‘well we’re pleased with our decision’ then smile, raise your eyebrows, take a sip of your drink and say no more. They’re trying to goad you in to a debate about the pros and cons of private education, but just don’t entertain it.

Zone2NorthLondon · 28/01/2023 17:36

They’re not friends, they upset you and are mean spirited. Ditch them,find better pals

Dishwashersaurous · 28/01/2023 17:34

These people are not your friends.

Friends don't want people to fail.

They are people you used to have something in common with, and now you don't.

So stop seeing them.

Everyonehasavoice · 28/01/2023 17:33

My brother and SIL did this to us and even to my sons faces.
Loudly at parties so we could hear and everyone else

Its jealousy
Its no one’s business how you wish to spend your money, no one ever comments on people buying expensive clothes, holidays etc. why do people think they can do so on your choice of school.
I lost a lot of friends over our choice, clearly they were not true friends.

Don’t engage,

edwinbear · 28/01/2023 17:31

I’d just stop meeting up with them. If you really have to, ‘DS is thriving and we’re all very happy with the school’. On repeat, word for word, every single time it gets brought up.

Trianglesquarerectangle · 28/01/2023 17:29

I love people who tell you how rich they are, but that they don't do something. It's usually that many people would do given the chance. Of course, there are some where it is the case but they usually they are comfortable in that decision so they don't have to talk about it all the time.

That means that the reality is this person who is just plainly jealous that you have chosen to do what you do and wants you to change your mind.

I have a similar example. I moved my DC from one private school to another. The new one is much better in every way, and much more expensive meaning it was hard for a particular set of parents I know to replicate. I got told numerous times not to do make the change because "they" would never make that journey (it's 15 mins) and "they" felt "their" child would be unhappy there because it was different to where I was moving from. I told them every minute travelling was worth every penny and that their child was not mine.

MatildaTheCat · 28/01/2023 17:29

her response was “well you could dothat yourself and all kids need in primary is a supportive parent”.

You could shudder and say, ‘God, I know. Who can be arsed with all that bloody palaver? Far better to outsource it.’

Or just shrug in a vague fashion and say mildly that it seems to be working out quite well and who’s watching Happy Valley?

If this is a constant theme and they are parents from the old school it’s possible the friendship group has moved away from you as they perceive that you’ve left them by leaving the school.

LadyLapsang · 28/01/2023 17:27

You don’t have to justify your choice to anyone. If she raises it again, just tell her we’ll have to agree to disagree on this one. If she doesn’t give up, I would drop her.

Biscuitsneeded · 28/01/2023 17:24

Just say "we all make choices for our children - I wouldn't dream of judging other people's - but in this case DS wasn't thriving, and now he is, so we're happy with our choice."

You don't sound like the kind of person who made this choice in order to show off or feel superior to other people. But perhaps your friends have experienced people who have done similar and been less gracious about it. DS 1 had a little girl in his class who was struggling academically in a big, noisy primary full of high-achieving kids. Her parents took her out for Year 3 to a more gentle, private environment. No judgement at all from other parents. DS 2 had a little classmate whose parents did the same thing at the same age. The mother sent an email to nearly all the mums in the class to 'explain' the decision, along the lines of ' X and I were both privately educated, and we feel we benefited hugely from all the extra-curricular activities and social opportunities, so we've decided to give Penelope the same chance as we feel she will thrive with the sporting and musical activities on offer, and we're not happy with the jobshare teaching'. That one went down like a lead balloon, with its implied criticism of the 'doing its best' school all of ours went to and by extension our wisdom in continuing to send our children there - most of us didn't have a choice. THAT mother was the subject of some mockery for quite a while, and I still avoid her if I see her out - not because she sends her kid to private school, but because she exposed in that email what an unpleasant person she really was, and unfortunately confirmed a few prejudices in doing so.

FinallyHere · 28/01/2023 17:24

one parent out of either “sheer concern” or most likely jealousy always brings up negatives of private school

Think of a better reply, avoid 'discussing' the topic with her. Much better to shut it down with a 'we are very happy with our choices' She is clearly to some extend insecure about it, or wouldn't bother continuing to raise it

Lots of good suggestions on how to shut it all down upthread. I particularly like 'we prefer the parent group' :-)

oakleaffy · 28/01/2023 17:23

Nephew went to State secondary (SW London)
Detested it.
Was fortunate enough to have a wealthy grandparent to lift him out of a bullying disrupted class to a private one where he is thriving.
He’s lucky.

LeCarre · 28/01/2023 17:23

That’s rude and mean of your friends. I get thet they want to justify their own decisions but thet doesn’t mean they get to be mean.

Maybe stop seeing them - which may feel great! Or if you’re keen to keep the friendships for whatever reason, next time it comes up say “Guys, we’ve moved schools for a reason and we are very happy with our decision. If X school is working for you then I’m happy for you but it did not work for us. I’m a bit fed up of constantly being challenged on my decision though, it’s exhausting - and boring - can we please talk about something else?!

Arniesleftleg · 28/01/2023 17:23

I think you might need some new friends. Real friends wouldn't make you feel bad or uncomfortable about your choices, unless of course it was something detrimental to you which this very much doesn't sound like.

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 28/01/2023 17:18

"Why do you keep asking me about the same things?"
"He's happy and doing well thanks."
"Oh heck - I really don't want to talk about this AGAIN" - Quickly followed by a question on a completely different subject.
Don't sit near her - or find a reason to move away.
Don't meet up.

Devoutspoken · 28/01/2023 17:18

Some people don't agree with private schools, jealousy is not the reason

Emotionalsupportviper · 28/01/2023 17:17

Shunkleisshiny · 28/01/2023 15:33

Just tell them it's no one else's business how you choose to educate your own child, and how you spend your money.

This ⬆

Your child, your money, your choice.

I don't know why she's so intent on interrogating you every time. Just tell her it's getting boring,

oakleaffy · 28/01/2023 17:17

Some State schools are “Outstanding “, some Private schools are dire, but generally speaking , private schools have smaller class sizes, don’t have disruptive pupils in them.
I was moved from a Private to a State at 13 because stepmum doesn’t believe in Private schools - and it was an horrendous culture shock.
Absolutely detested it til streaming separated the class out at 14.

Just tell your friend to wind her neck in.

Dentistlakes · 28/01/2023 17:16

I would just be blunt with her and tell her that your choice of where to educate your child is none of her business. It doesn’t matter if she is against the idea of private education in principle. It’s still none of her damn business. Tell her to butt out and don’t socialise with her again.

AliceOlive · 28/01/2023 17:16

I think you flip it around and say “You’ve mentioned this so often. Are you concerned that someone else is judging your choices about how to educate your child?”

Say it kindly and you might be able to have a different conversation with her.

Alternatively, tell her that this topic has become tiresome and you aren’t interested in debating with her.

SpringtimeCherries · 28/01/2023 17:11

It’s really, really rude. Do you go around telling them they are making a mistake with their kids?

No.

Don’t be meek about this, be strong. It was your decision, if it’s a mistake it’s your mistake. But nothing to do with them so get a bit arsy with them next time when they bring it up ‘not this again… what is it about my kids school that you need to keep on bringing this up… ‘etc.