Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Biggest dilemma of my whole life - Please help

158 replies

Purplecastle · 27/01/2023 22:35

Please help me with my biggest dilemma of my life.

We live in the UK the last 12 years but we are not from the UK. Both myself and my husband come from an Eastern European country and are both well educated and gain very good salaries, together we hit above 6 digit salary. We have British passports and 2 DCs, 3 and 1 years old.

Our parents live back in our home country and we have no other siblings.

We like our lives here, we are well established, we bought our house, we have our car, we are balanced. We live in a nice area and our kids will go to good schools.

Our parents are between 60-75 years old (all 4 of them).

We are at a stage that we have to decide whether to return back for them or not. They are not willing to come and live in the UK and I don't blame them as they are in retirement and have their friends and life back in our home country.

If we stay here we will be financially better and our kids will have a better education.
If we go back we will just about make it financially as a good school there in only a private school.
If we go back would be to be close to our parents at their final years and our kids to grow with their grandparents.
If we stay here our parents will either end up in an elderly house with noone close to them and if they accept to come and live in the UK we won't be able to afford a good elderly care and support for them as it's so expensive.
If we go back our kids will be more citizens of our home country (which is where we feel we belong - at home we speak our home country language) and if we stay here we will raise up British people, which is absolutely fine, but it's not us in a way.

What would you do? Please help as my mind is split between parents and kids and I am totally exhausted....

YABU - Stay in the UK
YANBU - Go back to your home country

OP posts:
HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 28/01/2023 11:01

@Mirabai

First of all 60-75 is young.

It's really not. 60 is not 'young!' And 75 most definitely isn't! Shock Why do people say this kind of thing on here? Confused

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 28/01/2023 10:58

This IS the problem when people move away, even to another part of the UK 100s and 100s of miles away, and it's even worse when they move to another country. Whilst it's OK for a few years and everything seems good; when elderly/infirm parents need help and support, they don't have it, if their adult children have moved out of the country/100s and 100s of miles away.

There is another side to this too; I know a few people whose parents (aged 50-55 or so,) moved to another country, and these people I know now have no parental support with their children. I know people think they're doing the best thing, moving for 'better opportunities' or 'sunnier weather,' but you really are leaving your family and loved ones behind. In many cases, you are leaving the relationship behind, because you cannot have a proper relationship when you are in different countries. Not in the majority of cases anyway.

Personally, I would move back to be with them, but I can tell you don't want to. A tricky situation. I don't envy you. I really have no suggestions. This is an almost impossible situation.

WinterFoxes · 28/01/2023 10:56

It is a tough decision but I would always make it by looking at what you are offeirng the next generation, not the previous one. What is the best choice for your children?

Maybe tioo, ask what is the best for yourselves? Do you want to grow old and die in UK or back in your home country?

Remember nothing is set in stone. You can go over for several holidays so your children get to know their family and counrty of origin really well. You could move back once your children are at uni and your parents are more elderly. At 60/70 they still have a good decade or more left if their health is good.

Go and visit them soon. That might ease your anxiety. Take DC. Chat with everyone about what they most want and look at all the compromises and accommodations that can get you close to the best of both worlds. If it were my decision, ultimately DC's future would be the priority here.

pizzaHeart · 28/01/2023 10:51

OP you’ve said that your parents are not willing to come and live in UK. Buy is it possible legally? I’ve heard that you can’t bring parents in UK from another country unless you can prove that you have sufficient funds to support them, they need care and care in UK is cheaper then care in their country, something like this, I haven’t investigated it myself, just heard from friends so not sure if it’s 100% true.

Bertha21 · 28/01/2023 10:46

What is your gut feeling? Where do you feel is home? What kind of lifestyle do you want your children to have? Similar to your own or different? Your children are young and you don’t need to rush. But as they get older they will become settled with friendships etc. I don’t live near to family as they all moved with retirement. I think they would like us to follow but I won’t do that. As where we live has more career opportunities etc.

Mirabai · 28/01/2023 10:45

First of all 60-75 is young, you can hold off the decision for at least 5 years.

If it’s a country bordering the Ukraine eg Poland I wouldn’t go back right now.

BuddhaAtSea · 28/01/2023 10:34

Depends where ‘home’ is: if it’s Poland and you have daughters, no, I wouldn’t, for example.
(abortion is illegal in Poland, they are staunch catholics).

Schooling system in the UK is different from Eastern Europe, both have major faults, but I wouldn’t say one is better than the other. You yourself know, educated in EE, move to the UK, hard work get you a good job etc. So you won’t deprive your children of much.

Childcare, back home you probably have 2 years maternity leave, grandparents to look after the kids when you go back to work. Here you earn more, but nursery full time per child is £1900.

I have been in the UK for 30 years now. I’m a foreigner, both here and ‘back home’. I have a grown up DD who doesn’t speak my language. I’ve got transferable skills, and properties in both countries and we spend most of our free time on continental Europe. So me moving back home would be a doodle. As I’m growing older, I’m more and more tempted. I keep thinking it’s the good old sunken fallacy at play, but I’ve built a life here in spite of all etc etc etc, to give it all up….but also, there is a reason why I left in the first place….

I genuinely don’t know what the answer is, I don’t have a good relationship with my parents, so I suppose that makes it easier for me. But if you do, I would go home.

PeachesPudding · 28/01/2023 10:27

Prioritise your children and their future.

LaCerbiatta · 28/01/2023 10:26

My situation is similar except we're 12 years into your future. We stayed, our children are 12 and 17 and our parents 75 to 85 and luckily all in good health. Only difference is that we both have one sibling living close to them which gives us peace of mind.

It's not easy to think that in maybe 5 years their needs will be different and it will be really difficult not to be there, but with the ease of working from home we know we can go often and spend 1 or 2 weeks there with them not only spending quality time but also offering support.

One of the things we always struggled the most with our decision to stay is to deprive both our parents and our children of a close relationship but with frequent holidays and leaving them there in the summer I feel they have a closer relationship than many British people I know who visit the grandparents a lot less.

No easy solution but staying can work out OK.

Echobelly · 28/01/2023 10:25

I'd agree with those who said to think foremost of your kids, for whom staying here is probably best.

Lovetotravel123 · 28/01/2023 10:22

I think I have some understanding of the issues. My mother was also from an Eastern European country and so I understand the cultural view of looking after elders. However, my own father here in the UK is very ill and even though I am only half an hour away from him I still can’t really look after him 24/7 because I have a child and a job. So, even if you move it is unlikely that you will have the time to care for them. Could they buy in some live in care? Then, when you visit them on ‘holiday’ you can really enjoy your time together.

Outfor150 · 28/01/2023 10:20

As the U.K. has the worst level of happiness in Europe, that would indicate moving back would be better.

thewinterwitch · 28/01/2023 10:19

Stay here for now, and if and when an elderly parent actually needs you, consider your options then.

RudsyFarmer · 28/01/2023 10:16

Go with what will give your children the potential for the best and happiest life. I’m afraid my kids always take priority.

Hellybelly84 · 28/01/2023 10:14

Exdpisatwat · 28/01/2023 09:24

I think if elderly parents require care from their children in old age, then they need to be prepared to slot into the children's lives. My dad lived on the other side of the UK to me and fully expected me to pull my dc out of school, give up my home, and move across the country into his house to care for him. He lived in a ha home, so when he passed we would have been homeless. I let him know he was welcome to move in with me but he didn't want to as he had lived in that house for over 30 years. It was an absolutely heart wrenching decision and I felt terribly guilty but in the end it was the best for my family.

My parents would never expect this and I definately would never expect it of my children. Your Dad should never have put that pressure and guilt on you.

JoyPeaceHealthz · 28/01/2023 10:11

Would you not have a better standard of living if you returned to your home country now?

Enough to have an easier life? If you sold your house in the UK would that not enable you to get a good hold on a property in your home country?

I am from another EU country and lived in London for 15 years and anybody who moved from London to my home country (where property is expensive) would still have power in the property market.

I was sad to leave London as it felt like the centre of the universe at the time and I bought in to that, but now I'm back home, I'm really glad.

WisherWood · 28/01/2023 10:09

I have something of this dilemma except in my case it's my parents who moved away from the UK. They're now elderly and very isolated and I would love them to come back to the UK but for various reasons they refuse. Or at least, they refused when they were well enough to make the move. Now they don't have the energy to make an international move but want to be nearer their children. I'm not going to move though because, as hard as it may seem, I think what is happening is a result of their decisions. Of course, this doesn't apply to you.

I think in part, ask yourself how your parents will cope without you. Are they somewhere rural, with poor services, where they rely on being able to drive? In which case they will struggle. Or are they more city centre, with good public transport and services, in which case they're well placed and you will be able to get to them reasonably quickly if you need to.

I would also take into account the fact that the UK is in decline and is not a good place to be. I think even with a change of government this will continue, because the majority of politicians are too spineless to tackle the problems and too in thrall to the nastiest right wing elements. So leaving the UK, when you have a good alternative, may well be the right thing to do.

One thing to try is to make the decision. Decide you are definitely moving back. See how this sits with you. Relief? Terror? Dread? Elation? Now go the other way and see how you feel. Then do whichever one sits better.

BookWar0m · 28/01/2023 10:08

SirTarquinasTrevelyan · 27/01/2023 23:11

We are at a stage that we have to decide whether to return back for them or not. They are not willing to come and live in the UK and I don't blame them as they are in retirement and have their friends and life back in our home country.

Why are you at that stage at this point?
You parents are still relatively young (unless one or more is ill or infirm). You children are 3 and 1 - so you could (just throwing it out there) stay here until they are at an educational key point - so either before the eldest starts senior school or if you wanted to push it even further before the eldest starts the educational courses that lead to public exams at 16+ (or whatever the equivalent poins are in your home country).

I mean even if you left it for 5 years - your oldest parent would be 80 and the youngest just 65 - and your eldest child 8 years old.

That way you'd get a bit more time on a higher income.

I think really the answer to your dilemma lies in how close the relationships you and your DH have with your own respective parents - assessed separately and then looked at combined.

Life for most people these days is long - you yourself and your children can expect to live til at least 80 probably older. You only have one set of parents and if you are close to them and have a good relationship with them, you are unlikely to regret being with/ near them as their life comes to an end. A grandchild/grandparent relationship is great and life enhancing for both parties.

Personally I couldn't imagine choosing to be in a different country from my parents at that point in their lives but it's horses for courses. Not everyone is lucky enough to have strong close relationships with parents who were good parents.

I'd say if you are asking for advice, it tends to suggest you should move back at some point because if you were sure, you'd just decide to stay here without a question.

This might not be the reason OP is thinking but you would want to do it now whilst the children are still very young. It wouldn’t be fair on them moving them from the UK, permanently, to a very different country when they are older but not old enough to make a decision if they want to stay in the UK or go to the parent’s home country.

OP what are the prospects for your children as adults if you go back vs if you stay here? I think that should be priority over your parents who have a shorter life in front of them than your children.

Unless you were always thinking that your children will go and grow up in your home country.

queencactus · 28/01/2023 10:05

My experience is that parents may say in their 60's that they are happy for you to move to another country but fast forward 15 - 20 years and it can be a different story. I live close to parents in their 80's and feel a bit trapped. If we wanted to, we couldn't even move an hour away without it causing family upset. If you move to be closer to family you may also feel restricted, whereas staying in the UK would give you more freedom to stay here, or move to another third country.

Iygjky6 · 28/01/2023 10:05

I am East European and my impression is that Brits will tell you to focus on your kids whilst EEuropeans will also think of their parents as immediate family. We did something similar but in reverse, our parents were in the UK, we had moved to another European country. We came back once the kids were school age. I think that culturally there is more of an assumption that adult kids support elderly parents. And yes in Eastern Europe- 60 can be seen as old especially for women. Something else to think about is that your kids will be British, i.e. if you decide to leave when they are older, they won't follow you. So you might end up in the same position as your parents - separated from your kids

SirVixofVixHall · 28/01/2023 10:04

airforsharon · 27/01/2023 22:54

I think in your paragraph "If we go back.....not us in a way" you've actually made your choice - belonging, familiarity, contentment are so important, and i think sometimes overlooked when we strive for 'better' - more money, bigger house, career advancement.
I would say "heed your gut" on this.

I agree.
Your parents are fairly young and in good health by the sound of it, but I understand the desire to bring up your children in your own country.
Also, leaving it until an emergency forces a decision would be much more stressful. It is sensible to think of it now.
I have found, as I get older, that family connections have become more important, and not just the living ones, but the whole history and background of my family, where we come from, our language . I moved to be closer to my parents when my children were similar ages to yours, and I am very glad I did. My dc speak our language and have a sense of their community and cultural background.
It is good to weigh up all the pros and cons, but also to make a decision with your heart. Where will you all be happiest? All of you, as a family, including the older members ?
Good luck whatever you decide OP.

RealBecca · 28/01/2023 10:03

Id stay. From experience I know how torn you are but the facts are that your kids lives are here and they come first. Your parents are fine to decide to stay local but there are natural results from that.

You have kids so that they can have happy lives and noone wants to be a burden to their family. I would hope your parents would feel the same x

DesertRose64 · 28/01/2023 10:03

Hollyhocksauce · 27/01/2023 23:27

British ppl tend to not prioritise the welfare of elders as much as some other cultures, and they feel less duty towards them, so that will skew the responses here. I'm from a culture where duty towards parents is incredibly important, so in your shoes I would go back and allow your parents to have a relationship with their grandchildren in the last years of their life. It sounds like that really is 'home' to you anyway and there's more to life than money.

In a nutshell.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 28/01/2023 10:02

Another parent here who would not want my kids changing their life for me (mine are both adults), but I think for me the telling thing is your comments about your kids and wanting them to be in touch with your culture and grow up identifying as (home country) kids, not British.

I'd say: move for your kids, not for your parents.

If you have British passports, presumably you could return to the UK if you changed your mind.

However, think about what you would be going back for - is it to give help to elderly parents? If both set of parents died, would you still want to stay , or would you rather come back to Britain? If moving to Britain was a decision for financial reasons, have you established yourself with financial security i.e. achieved what you wanted?

midgetastic · 28/01/2023 10:02

I'm a parent
To see my children happy and fulfilled is the best thing
To feel I had hampered thier choices would be aweful