Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To apply for bursary at an independent school?

137 replies

expokittens · 27/01/2023 21:29

Household income is just over £70K. We have two cars on mortgage, go on holiday 3 times a year (but we try to make them budget hols), like to go to the theatre a lot and eat out. House mortgage £1200 pm.

The school charges £7K per term.

Anyone in a similar situation who was successful with their bursary application? Would they look at our spendings and turn us down?

OP posts:
GogoGobo · 29/01/2023 10:22

Purely anecdotal - but a friend's daughter was on a bursary - 50% - and they took her out of school 2 years in a row for a ski holiday in term time.
The school cancelled the bursary.
We have our son in a school with very deep pockets, and I think they give very generous bursaries to those for whom a public school education would not otherwise be available.
It doesn't stop very wealthy parents taking the piss though!

If you pay fees, you have to trust that the bursar is doing their job, and really guarding that bursary fund for those in need.

Our earnings were probably borderline at the point of sending DS to a fee paying school, but as time has gone on - we have pushed back retirement age and I also returned to work full time to ensure we could keep up with the fees. We have a house which needed a major refurbishment but we have spent 8 years doing it bit by bit, rather than borrowing more to do it all in one go and using up house equity. I guess that's our back up plan in case we hit a major bump in the road.
Hardly big sacrifices in the grand scheme of things, but we have put school fees second only to our mortgage and anything that happens after they have been paid, is a plus!

POLLYprosecco1 · 29/01/2023 09:12

That’s absolutely shocking … Do you not actively go out and seek promising candidates by interacting with local state schools? Or is it that the state schools around you are reluctant to engage? Children I know well have benefitted from years of full bursaries at prep and public schools

@RandomersAssociation The previous poster just said that it is her focus for this coming year.

I can think of a million things you could do to let parents know it’s a possibility.

This was what my post was about and you attacked me for it?? I was merely letting my fil know that private education was a possibility and I got rebuffed due to their lack of knowledge and inverse snobbery against the private system.

The sheer hypocrisy of your rantings makes me laugh! 😂

Shoogly · 29/01/2023 08:23

safeplanet · 29/01/2023 05:38

In the same way that non-dom status is legal but unreasonable. It's wanky to be a taker.

You're comparing applying for a bursary to non-dom status? ok..

Wine had been drunk. It was really just a clumsy illustration that having the ability to have or apply for something doesn't mean it's the "right" thing to do.

safeplanet · 29/01/2023 05:38

In the same way that non-dom status is legal but unreasonable. It's wanky to be a taker.

You're comparing applying for a bursary to non-dom status? ok..

RandomersAssociation · 29/01/2023 01:27

We didn’t get a single bursary application last year and we have plenty of provision for them.

That’s absolutely shocking … Do you not actively go out and seek promising candidates by interacting with local state schools? Or is it that the state schools around you are reluctant to engage? Children I know well have benefitted from years of full bursaries at prep and public schools - I can think of a million things you could do to let parents know it’s a possibility.

snowtrees · 29/01/2023 00:40

In my area full bursaries are below £30k None above £50k

POLLYprosecco1 · 29/01/2023 00:31

Anyway, apologies OP for digressing, and good luck with your own application. Definitely worth a shot!

Merryoldgoat · 29/01/2023 00:28

The least privileged in society barely know about bursaries, and then when they do, generally, they are reluctant to apply.

This is very true. We didn’t get a single bursary application last year and we have plenty of provision for them.

A focus for the coming year is to publicise the availability and see if we can up our applications.

POLLYprosecco1 · 29/01/2023 00:28

Thanks @RandomersAssociation . Sadly you do not know anything about my sister-in-law, her views or her background. I have not told her how to raise her child, merely pointed out an option to my father in law that is available to my niece in the future which got rejected. There’s nothing ‘lazy’ about using the ‘inverse snob’ terminology because this, and lack of knowledge of the private education system,
is the truth in this instance. I would love to help ‘broaden’ my niece’s horizons now and be more active in her upbringing but she is 300miles away and I have 4 young children of my own.

But it‘s odd that you are even insinuating that her horizons do need ‘broadening’ now at 7yo by virtue of the fact that I simply said she lives In a council flat????

Merryoldgoat · 29/01/2023 00:26

I assess bursaries as part of my job.

Your income would not preclude you from an award however we look at a year’s worth of expenses and the equity in your home.

if you spend highly in certain areas then any offer would be based on you bringing spend down to more reasonable level.

We would also have an expectation that you would both be working full time if your child is that old with no younger siblings.

Shoogly · 29/01/2023 00:14

safeplanet · 28/01/2023 23:49

@Shoogly I don't understand why it's unreasonable to apply for something if you fulfil the criteria?

In the same way that non-dom status is legal but unreasonable. It's wanky to be a taker.

RandomersAssociation · 29/01/2023 00:10

The least privileged in society barely know about bursaries, and then when they do, generally, they are reluctant to apply.

Yes. I’ve been saying this repeatedly on MN for considerably more than a decade. (You have no idea how much we agree on this.)

Nevertheless - it’s a bit … lazy, surely, to dismiss your SIL’s objections as nothing more than ‘inverse snobbery’? You say you’re not close? How would you like it if someone you see occasionally, who lives 300 miles away, turns up claiming to know better than you do how to bring up your child?

I’m not saying you’re wrong to be interested in your niece’s prospects. But you can’t expect your SIL to respect your pov if you … think she isn’t entitled to one because she lives in a council house on benefits.

Why not think about all the perfectly valid reasons why she might be reluctant to take such a step? And what might you do to broaden your niece’s horizons right now?

safeplanet · 29/01/2023 00:02

The least privileged in society barely know about bursaries, and then when they do, generally, they are reluctant to apply.

I agree with this, many aren't aware of what's available. Are private schools as socially inclusive as they should be? no. I just think that's a separate point to whether the OP should apply or not. After all the OP not applying is not going to change the system in any way.

Plenty of excellent London state primaries have roads surrounding them where it costs 1m plus for a house. Are those parents wrong for taking a school place from less privileged children who can't afford to live in the catchment?

POLLYprosecco1 · 29/01/2023 00:02

@RandomersAssociation and also when did I say that people in council houses are not capable of providing people with a supportive upbringing? My husband had a very supportive upbringing! You have literally taken my post and twisted it!

POLLYprosecco1 · 28/01/2023 23:58

@RandomersAssociation also - when did I call anyone stupid???

POLLYprosecco1 · 28/01/2023 23:52

@RandomersAssociation thank you for correcting me!

Of course it requires the whole family’s agreement and encouragement but sadly when I first mentioned it to them, the idea got rejected due to inverse snobbery. I’m not narrow minded - but just relating the facts. The least privileged in society barely know about bursaries, and then when they do, generally, they are reluctant to apply.

I went to private school and there was v little prejudice there against the children there who were on bursaries or assisted places. They were often indistinguishable.

Not sure why your tone is so aggressive towards my post. But I come from a frustrated stance knowing that private education could really benefit this little girl. For what it’s worth, I do get on with my sister-in-law but we are not close because we live 300 miles apart.

safeplanet · 28/01/2023 23:49

@Shoogly I don't understand why it's unreasonable to apply for something if you fulfil the criteria?

safeplanet · 28/01/2023 23:46

@purplerain100 why is it entitled to apply for something if you fit the criteria?

RandomersAssociation · 28/01/2023 23:41

(I do understand the child is your SIL’s daughter!)

RandomersAssociation · 28/01/2023 23:39

@POLLYprosecco1 - you mean it’s your SIL who you want to persuade?

Would it be impossible to write She is bright and articulate and lives in a council flat with both parents? Obviously we haven’t met your in-laws but are you not at all conscious of sounding, yourself, somewhat narrow minded and prejudiced? Or is it the law that anyone living in council housing in receipt of benefits must be incapable of offering their child a supportive upbringing?

I’m quite vociferous in wanting as wide a range of people as possible to comprehend the accessibility of large bursaries and their potential to enhance life chances. But I don’t think people are necessarily stupid and narrow minded if they don’t see it that way.

Moving a child from an un-moneyed background to an independent school really requires the support and encouragement of at least their whole nuclear family. You may need to make friends with your SIL first - and appreciate her point of view.

POLLYprosecco1 · 28/01/2023 23:14

I’ve been trying to convince my father in law to convince his daughter to put her 7yo forward for a bursary when the time comes. She is bright and articulate but lives in a council flat with both parents on benefits and will have very little prospects otherwise. Sadly, the family are prejudiced against private education and are very narrow minded in their (working class) views. These are the people bursaries should be given to, but people like this will rarely apply or even be aware of funded private school places. So I don’t blame OP for wanting to apply to better her child’s future and she might well be successful! Because the most deserving people will rarely bother. Sad, but true.

expokittens · 28/01/2023 21:41

Thank you, I understand those who feel against a household like us applying for a bursary and that's perfectly a valid point.

I will look into a few schools and at least have a go, if my son is keen. I haven't had the chance to speak to him yet as I'm new to this and need to research a little further.

I am ever so grateful for all your posts. Vat discussion is also interesting and it is certainly something we would have to keep in mind.

If we are not eligible for bursary I will also look into applying for a full time job, although I'm not sure how that might work out.

OP posts:
purplerain100 · 28/01/2023 19:04

@safeplanet I answered yabu based on my knowledge & experience. When we decided we had to move DD to private I went back to ft work & we forfeited our second holiday..it didn't cross my mind to look into what hand ours might have been available. Likewise I was delighted when a widowed friend's dd got a full bursary. I just don't understand this sense of entitlement some people have but I admire the OP's honestly about her situation.. & thanks for your delightful fury at mine!

Bunnycat101 · 28/01/2023 18:49

A lot of schools have their policies for bursaries published. Ideally you’d want to get the policy for the schools you’re interested but a quick Google brought this one up as an example which is really strict and also talks about releasing equity in a home.

Acknowledging that others might have a different view, the School considers that the following would not be consistent with the receipt of a bursary:
*Frequent or expensive holidays.
*New, luxury or superfluous cars.
*Investment in significant home improvements.
*second property/land holdings

But.. This one for instance at St Paul’s is surprisingly generous at higher income levels.

www.stpaulsschool.org.uk/admissions/bursaries-assistance-with-fees/bursaries-faqs/

WednesdaysNameIsFullOfWoe · 28/01/2023 18:31

expokittens · 27/01/2023 22:02

Thanks for your replies.

We have a DS in year 5 currently looking to apply to an independent school. He is very academic but we have no grammars around here and so thought an independent might be an option if we could get some help.

We are happy to cut back on holidays from now on but worried they might look at our previous spendings.

One of the marks in the “against” column when we were considering private school was that the fees which we would be paying weren’t paying only for our own children, but a chunk was to fund people like you.

It just seemed ridiculous that we were being asked to take money we’d worked for to in effect give to families who were still on a good wage, just a lower one than ours.

Still, of course, you have every right to apply.