Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My son thinks that children were evacuated during the pandemic

233 replies

Jourdain11 · 27/01/2023 21:06

Today my DS7 was learning about World War 2 in 'topic' and they covered evacuees. Apparently he stuck his hand up, "Oh, so they were sent away from London to the country to keep them safe? Just like we were in the lockdown?"

The teacher said that, no, children were not evacuated during lockdown. And he was quite incredulous that neither his teacher, nor any of his classmates, could remember this mass evacuation.

I have explained that he was not evacuated - he stayed with his grandparents for around a month (not in the country). But he is sure in his own mind that he was in fact evacuated for the duration. "Maybe for about a year."

I suppose he was only 4 at the time. But it got me to thinking that a lot of youngish children must have some fairly weird memories of Lockdown Britain!

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 29/01/2023 08:14

MarshaBradyo · 29/01/2023 08:07

Whenever a striking group say we worked through pandemic it shows to me the divergence in experience.

There were groups denied work at that time, denied livelihood, socialisation and education. So the flip side cost was massive. There was an example of this in pp with a dh whose industry was shut for a long time and the mh impact of that. The idea that the cost was taken by those who kept working isn’t correct.

The cost and damage to the shut industries and decrease in socialisation was huge. Too much imo

For me, a better way of looking at it is there were different costs.

Personally I'd have gladly done my job outside the home if it meant my DC could've got access to schooling, and I hated trying to manage homeschooling and working simultaneously. There are other people who did work outside the home who were afraid, overworked, burned out and would've gladly gone on furlough and weathered the 20% drop. Still others were furloughed and struggled with the loss of wages, routine etc whilst being paid to sit at home. So much depends on personal circumstances.

tornadoinsideoutfig · 29/01/2023 08:09

Jourdain11 · 27/01/2023 21:53

The 6 or 10 o'clock news the day lockdown "proper" was announced. The BBC beeps went slower and they announced (with bullet points): "You must STAY AT HOME... You must not meet people ... You must not go to work unless you CANNOT WORK FROM HOME... You must not leave your home unless it is ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY... And now we will cross to Westminster where Laura Kuenssberg is standing around outside pointlessly and for no discernible reason."

It felt very claustrophobic. Like the world got smaller and further away at the same time. I remember thinking there must have been a lot of people who felt absolutely desperate when that announcement was made. I just felt numb! It does seem very unreal now.

I'm glad I don't have a TV licence! I never experienced any of that. I just loved that there was no traffic going to and from work and the empty streets, we went out for long walks every weekend and hardly saw anyone at first.

MarshaBradyo · 29/01/2023 08:07

Whenever a striking group say we worked through pandemic it shows to me the divergence in experience.

There were groups denied work at that time, denied livelihood, socialisation and education. So the flip side cost was massive. There was an example of this in pp with a dh whose industry was shut for a long time and the mh impact of that. The idea that the cost was taken by those who kept working isn’t correct.

The cost and damage to the shut industries and decrease in socialisation was huge. Too much imo

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 29/01/2023 08:00

Beezknees · 29/01/2023 06:43

I didn't feel any sense of solidarity during lockdown. It's a rose tinted view of looking at it. I'd never felt so alone in my life.

Nor were we all in it together.

Lockdown for some people meant being trapped in unsafe or unsuitable housing. Stuck in with abusers who now had much greater opportunity to harm them. Overcrowded in temporary accommodation. Stuck in mouldy damp flats breathing in spores in the freezing cold of January and February 2021 because stay the fuck at home. We certainly weren't all in that together and solidarity for people in these positions was rather thin on the ground too.

But I know there are people who did think this, and they didn't come up with the idea by themselves. It's not like the media or political mainstream were telling them otherwise at the time either. Much better for the general narrative to gloss over this sort of inconvenient point.

PuttingDownRoots · 29/01/2023 07:34

Looking back... one the bizarrest things was how suddenly some people declared that 7 (or even younger) was old enough to be left at home alone while you went to the supermarket. (Actual suggestion I got... leave my 7&8yos playing on the village green for the two hours it would take to drive to the supermarket, queue and shop and drive home... so the neighbours could supervise them out the window!)

Its rather reassuring to see the threads worrying about a teenager (no SEN) being alone for a few hours or should a 10yo walk the 5 minutes to school alone.

Forestfever · 29/01/2023 07:11

God this thread had made me cry. I was heavily pregnant with two under four. My husband had to keep working. I wasn't sleeping and felt too tired to exercise. I missed my family terribly and my baby didn't meet my parents until she was nearly two months old. I drove 30 miles to deliver them milk just so they could meet her and I was devastated my other two couldn't come.

But the weather was amazing, we had fun in the sun and an Easter treasure hunt in the woods. My husband used to take the children to the supermarket just so I could I get some sort of break. That was so frowned upon but I'm pleased we did it so they could get out.

Beezknees · 29/01/2023 06:43

Inhibitor · 28/01/2023 23:24

Of course. I absolutely realise how lucky I was. Although, I worked all through lockdown (from home), I’m a lone parent and have a PDA ASC DD so it wasn’t all one long holiday. I was terrified of the virus, I remember washing every item from the supermarket, quarantining post and I pulled my kids out of school before lockdown was announced as I was aghast at the lax approach from the gov’t. I also watched the daily briefings and death toll announcements with dread and horror just like most of the world. But that doesn’t change the fact that I loved lockdown - principally because for the first time ever, there was no pressure to get DD to school and all the crap associated with school refusing. I didn’t bother with home schooling, instead letting them experience it as a unique time in history. But mainly, I felt like it would be a turning point in history and despite the awfulness, it gave me hope for humanity, proof that we can do what it takes to solve the huge issues facing the world. The sense of solidarity, us being in it together, the spontaneous surge of volunteering and mutual aid (which I also got involved with). Of course it didn’t last, but it was nice to cling to at the time. I’m not sure why a brief summary of my overall experience as positive means I’m insensitive or not appreciative of the vastly different experiences of other people.

I didn't feel any sense of solidarity during lockdown. It's a rose tinted view of looking at it. I'd never felt so alone in my life.

Inhibitor · 28/01/2023 23:24

memorial · 28/01/2023 22:41

I LOVED lockdown. Not the worry about the virus but just how life slowed down so much and we could just ‘be’. The lack of traffic noise, the bird song never sounded so loud before. The beautiful weather and having time for personal projects. I never wanted it to go back to normal and I naively thought that it would teach us what life is really about.
But you get that for some people this wasn't the case? Some of us couldn't be, we barely had time to breath. Our children did the best they could by themselves. One of mine will never be the same.
What I leant is that people are selfish cunts. When they thought they needed the NHS to save them they clapped now they don't give a shit and treat us like crap on their shoe # clapstoslaps.
My family my practice my life is forever damaged. So what did it teach me?

Of course. I absolutely realise how lucky I was. Although, I worked all through lockdown (from home), I’m a lone parent and have a PDA ASC DD so it wasn’t all one long holiday. I was terrified of the virus, I remember washing every item from the supermarket, quarantining post and I pulled my kids out of school before lockdown was announced as I was aghast at the lax approach from the gov’t. I also watched the daily briefings and death toll announcements with dread and horror just like most of the world. But that doesn’t change the fact that I loved lockdown - principally because for the first time ever, there was no pressure to get DD to school and all the crap associated with school refusing. I didn’t bother with home schooling, instead letting them experience it as a unique time in history. But mainly, I felt like it would be a turning point in history and despite the awfulness, it gave me hope for humanity, proof that we can do what it takes to solve the huge issues facing the world. The sense of solidarity, us being in it together, the spontaneous surge of volunteering and mutual aid (which I also got involved with). Of course it didn’t last, but it was nice to cling to at the time. I’m not sure why a brief summary of my overall experience as positive means I’m insensitive or not appreciative of the vastly different experiences of other people.

memorial · 28/01/2023 22:41

I LOVED lockdown. Not the worry about the virus but just how life slowed down so much and we could just ‘be’. The lack of traffic noise, the bird song never sounded so loud before. The beautiful weather and having time for personal projects. I never wanted it to go back to normal and I naively thought that it would teach us what life is really about.
But you get that for some people this wasn't the case? Some of us couldn't be, we barely had time to breath. Our children did the best they could by themselves. One of mine will never be the same.
What I leant is that people are selfish cunts. When they thought they needed the NHS to save them they clapped now they don't give a shit and treat us like crap on their shoe # clapstoslaps.
My family my practice my life is forever damaged. So what did it teach me?

MarshaBradyo · 28/01/2023 19:59

louderthan · 28/01/2023 19:35

Me too. Like you I was really, really hoping that we would learn from it as a society, that we would realise the damage that rampant consumerism is doing to the planet, stop driving everywhere and taking short-haul flights etc. Most of all I hoped we'd truly value key workers and realise that the most important jobs are the ones that keep society going, even if they're perceived as menial but no. Nurses using food banks. So much for the clapping now.

It’s difficult to value the public sector whilst hammering the private sector as funds are needed for the former.

I see it slightly differently in that I thought people would realise this seeing the situation now, even if they didn’t at the time.

Beezknees · 28/01/2023 19:55

louderthan · 28/01/2023 19:35

Me too. Like you I was really, really hoping that we would learn from it as a society, that we would realise the damage that rampant consumerism is doing to the planet, stop driving everywhere and taking short-haul flights etc. Most of all I hoped we'd truly value key workers and realise that the most important jobs are the ones that keep society going, even if they're perceived as menial but no. Nurses using food banks. So much for the clapping now.

I hate all this wishy washy crap. Most normal working class people don't have the luxury of worrying about all that. If you want to see change, you need to be badgering the people at the top, not expecting people who are struggling to get by to make all the changes.

Beezknees · 28/01/2023 19:50

BethFromThisIsUs · 28/01/2023 18:45

Well like I said above, for the industries who closed down completely eg hospitality, furlough was a no brainer. The issue was with industries such as mine who furloughed staff as a cost saving measure only. There was never any question of redundancies, they just didn’t want their poor performers to work from home and didn’t fancy paying for it. That to me is rewarding people for poor performance because the firm couldn’t be arsed dealing with it. The rest of us had to pick up their slack, while the CE emailed on a weekly basis to thank the furloughed for…who knows what really.

My firm’s profits in 2020-21 exceeded the profits in the previous year. There was no need for staff to be furloughed. I know my firm is not alone in taking advantage in this way.

To be honest it’s shocking that front line NHS staff had such an awful time while others were paid to stay home. I’m not saying it wasn’t necessary or that there was any other way, but the contrast is very stark.

That's not the fault of the employees though, it's the fault of the employers. Employees shouldn't be punished for doing what their boss tells them.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 28/01/2023 19:43

Lockdown was always going to exacerbate inequalities. I really don't understand how anyone thought it wouldn't. Fair enough if people enjoyed their personal experience of it, you have as much right to speak about how you felt as anyone else does, but the structural impact of this was all baked in.

louderthan · 28/01/2023 19:35

Inhibitor · 27/01/2023 22:04

I watched a documentary, maybe Explained on Netflix, about time, or more accurately, how we perceive time. It talked about our brains laying down ‘core memories’ (probably not what they’re actually called) that act as time stamps. We make more of these core memories when we’re younger so it distorts how we remember time periods when we were young. My DS remembers a particular few happy years where we lived in a certain house, except it was only 6 months! False memories are also a thing - they’ve done studies on how people remember major events like 911 and it turns out our memories are not so accurate.

I LOVED lockdown. Not the worry about the virus but just how life slowed down so much and we could just ‘be’. The lack of traffic noise, the bird song never sounded so loud before. The beautiful weather and having time for personal projects. I never wanted it to go back to normal and I naively thought that it would teach us what life is really about.

Me too. Like you I was really, really hoping that we would learn from it as a society, that we would realise the damage that rampant consumerism is doing to the planet, stop driving everywhere and taking short-haul flights etc. Most of all I hoped we'd truly value key workers and realise that the most important jobs are the ones that keep society going, even if they're perceived as menial but no. Nurses using food banks. So much for the clapping now.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 28/01/2023 19:14

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/01/2023 19:09

Thanks @MarshaBradyo

Yes he went back a few weeks into the second big lockdown.

More because of the ADHD than anything, but I think we qualified on two counts.

Exh was particularly rubbish in second lockdown because he decided he would have his house completely gutted and the kids couldn’t stay there at all. So didn’t stay from the Christmas to Easter.

In the first lockdown he did precious little - only had them a few nights here and there

What a dick.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/01/2023 19:09

MarshaBradyo · 28/01/2023 18:27

That is so tough. I hope you got a space in second one

You’re right you had very hard things to deal with

Thanks @MarshaBradyo

Yes he went back a few weeks into the second big lockdown.

More because of the ADHD than anything, but I think we qualified on two counts.

Exh was particularly rubbish in second lockdown because he decided he would have his house completely gutted and the kids couldn’t stay there at all. So didn’t stay from the Christmas to Easter.

In the first lockdown he did precious little - only had them a few nights here and there

WitchSharkadder · 28/01/2023 19:07

I don't think we should be berating people for whom lockdown was a fairly positive experience. Furlough, sunshine, peace and quiet, quality time with their children etc, if that's the situation that was forced upon them then you can't blame people for taking advantage.

Lockdown was full of highs and lows for me personally. I have extremely painful memories of my cousin's screams down the phone to me minutes after she had watched my uncle, her father, on a screen. And then not being allowed to attend his funeral myself.

My own sobs down the phone when I had to call the crisis team because my DS1 who has very complex SEN just stopped being able to cope when the winter lockdown was announced.

Perhaps the memory that is most vivid and surreal in my mind was my DS2's last day at school. He was year 11 and had been studying hard for GCSEs, then suddenly everything was cancelled. That last day, the teaching staff gave the year 11s a guard of honour as they walked out the gates and I watched with tears as all these 16 year olds walked out feeling completely bewildered and confused not knowing what their future held anymore.

I also remember glorious walks with my children through the fields in beautiful weather and how they were so happy in those moments.

The gratitude of my elderly neighbours when I shopped for them, the thank you treats they posted through my letterbox everyday and my continued lovely relationships with them.

The (probably morally wrong and I was slated on here at the time) long country drives I did at sunset every evening to calm my DS1 down as that was the only way to give him structure and routine to his day and settle him for bed. We bonded so much on those drives though and I wouldn't change them for the world.

It was such a strange and confusing time. Like others have said, I wish I'd have kept a diary but I just didn't have the time.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 28/01/2023 19:02

BethFromThisIsUs · 28/01/2023 18:45

Well like I said above, for the industries who closed down completely eg hospitality, furlough was a no brainer. The issue was with industries such as mine who furloughed staff as a cost saving measure only. There was never any question of redundancies, they just didn’t want their poor performers to work from home and didn’t fancy paying for it. That to me is rewarding people for poor performance because the firm couldn’t be arsed dealing with it. The rest of us had to pick up their slack, while the CE emailed on a weekly basis to thank the furloughed for…who knows what really.

My firm’s profits in 2020-21 exceeded the profits in the previous year. There was no need for staff to be furloughed. I know my firm is not alone in taking advantage in this way.

To be honest it’s shocking that front line NHS staff had such an awful time while others were paid to stay home. I’m not saying it wasn’t necessary or that there was any other way, but the contrast is very stark.

Obviously firms took advantage. It's just that it's much easier to identify that this happened than to come up with a way of doing it better, especially at first. Lockdown was never part of the pandemic planning which meant neither was furlough, so something really did have to be cobbled together very quickly in March 2020. There was no time and no resources to design or administer anything that wasn't broad brush.

As time passed, it became more theoretically possible to narrow the parameters of the scheme and tighten things up, but the resources for close monitoring have never been there. It would also never have been possible to tie furlough solely to business need, because furlough solely for childcare purposes needed to exist. Otherwise parents start cobbling together ad hoc childcare solutions that don't actually reduce contacts that much.

Ultimately, all of these things were baked in to a significant degree because lockdown required them. At best we could've made some efficiencies.

BethFromThisIsUs · 28/01/2023 18:45

Well like I said above, for the industries who closed down completely eg hospitality, furlough was a no brainer. The issue was with industries such as mine who furloughed staff as a cost saving measure only. There was never any question of redundancies, they just didn’t want their poor performers to work from home and didn’t fancy paying for it. That to me is rewarding people for poor performance because the firm couldn’t be arsed dealing with it. The rest of us had to pick up their slack, while the CE emailed on a weekly basis to thank the furloughed for…who knows what really.

My firm’s profits in 2020-21 exceeded the profits in the previous year. There was no need for staff to be furloughed. I know my firm is not alone in taking advantage in this way.

To be honest it’s shocking that front line NHS staff had such an awful time while others were paid to stay home. I’m not saying it wasn’t necessary or that there was any other way, but the contrast is very stark.

MarshaBradyo · 28/01/2023 18:27

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/01/2023 18:20

Think trying to work ft and home school a six year old as a single parent was properly traumatic. I wish I could have taken away one of those elements- either be furloughed ( couldn’t be as public sector), not have to home school (( wasn’t counted as key worker in lockdown one, and Ds not yet thought to have ADHD), or have someone to share the load with.

If any of those things were different it would have been ok

That is so tough. I hope you got a space in second one

You’re right you had very hard things to deal with

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/01/2023 18:20

Think trying to work ft and home school a six year old as a single parent was properly traumatic. I wish I could have taken away one of those elements- either be furloughed ( couldn’t be as public sector), not have to home school (( wasn’t counted as key worker in lockdown one, and Ds not yet thought to have ADHD), or have someone to share the load with.

If any of those things were different it would have been ok

Beezknees · 28/01/2023 18:11

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 28/01/2023 18:04

I agree. I think there's a tendency to get annoyed with furlough but not examine the underlying reasons for it.

Part of this is people who think furloughed people were paid too much as well. The scheme could've been better refined with time, but there's no getting round the fact that if a government wants to pursue a lockdown, millions of people had to be paid enough to stay at home and go along with it. I'm not saying no savings could've been made but fundamentally it was impossible to do it on the cheap.

It's fine if people who criticise furlough were also critical or at least agnostic on lockdown, but there's a logic fail involved to slagging it off whilst also thinking lockdown was necessary. I've seen this quite a few times. Can't have lockdown without the costs.

Absolutely this. If people wanted a lockdown and all non key workers to stay home, then they needed to be subsidised for it. To tell everyone to stay home and not be paid is just ludicrous.

Iwantabloodypizza · 28/01/2023 18:04

LynetteScavo · 28/01/2023 17:09

I don't mention lockdown in RL because for me it was bloody brilliant. I probably long for a return to the first lockdown on a daily basis. DH has said a few times that it "saved" DD, and he has a point. I know so many people struggled though, and I completely understand why, so I don't talk about it. But I do want to put it out there that it wasn't hellish for everyone and I realise I was very lucky.

Yes, it was good for us too. I never say anything in real life either as there were people who struggled so much.

I had my third baby July 2020 and it was actually the best pregnancy and birth/post birth experience I’ve had. Empty hospitals, appointments that ran on time, staff were able to deal with patients rather than family members. I was on my own for my section and post birth but would have been anyway as dh had to look after the other two. But I am mindful never to say that as I know other women didn’t have a good experience.

My ds wouldn’t have been doing what he’s doing now. We moved just before lockdown and he hated his college. Being able to do the bulk of the course at home is what got him though and onto his degree.

My dd was 6/7 she only remembers it as fun.

None of us were affected badly by it.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 28/01/2023 18:04

Beezknees · 28/01/2023 17:49

That's just a stupid viewpoint though. Why be pissed off at those who were furloughed? They did not choose it. The government ordered businesses to close. So if people want someone to blame, blame the government for making those decisions.

I agree. I think there's a tendency to get annoyed with furlough but not examine the underlying reasons for it.

Part of this is people who think furloughed people were paid too much as well. The scheme could've been better refined with time, but there's no getting round the fact that if a government wants to pursue a lockdown, millions of people had to be paid enough to stay at home and go along with it. I'm not saying no savings could've been made but fundamentally it was impossible to do it on the cheap.

It's fine if people who criticise furlough were also critical or at least agnostic on lockdown, but there's a logic fail involved to slagging it off whilst also thinking lockdown was necessary. I've seen this quite a few times. Can't have lockdown without the costs.

MarshaBradyo · 28/01/2023 17:54

Beezknees · 28/01/2023 17:51

You could live that way if you wanted, that's the difference. If you really wanted to be isolated in that way, do a job where you can fully work from home, home ed your kids, do all your shopping online, don't visit anyone or have visitors.

I understand this. Those who enjoyed it can strive to replicate lockdown in many ways.

Those who loathed it had no choice, especially if it cost them in any way

Swipe left for the next trending thread