Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
GoldilockMom · 28/01/2023 20:29

And the club, who have a safe guarding obligation towards the child, need to nip the protest in the bud
OP said the parents were protesting she didn’t say it was towards the child, it may well be towards the staff who haven’t taken this incident seriously enough. OP May not see this child’s behaviour towards other kids - he may well be upsetting more people than OP realizes.

Pupinski · 28/01/2023 20:29

Can I applaud you, OP, for being a caring member of this sporting community. I'm quite gobsmacked at some of the responses here about a child. I hope they have a more positive attitude towards their own kids...

Talapia · 28/01/2023 20:27

AmyDudley · 27/01/2023 16:56

He'd been told not to skateboard in the building: he skateboarded in the building and someone was seriously hurt. At 12 he is old enough to know he needs to do as he is told, he chose not to. he's shown himself to be untristworthy when it comes to obeying rules, next time he decides to do something he has been told not to do someone could be injured even more seriously, those potential victims have a right to feel safe at the sports club. Also if he is allowed to continue to be a member and does something else stupid, the club will find itself in a tricky situation regarding liability when they know this boy is a risk.

I may seem harsh but I feel the rights of people using the club not to get injured by a badly behaved child take priority over the privilege of said child to continue at the club.

I agree with this.

The club may have no choice but no expel him due to insurance or potential litigation.

I would think at the very least, suspension for a set time, some kind of work to support the he injured.

Actions have consequences. He now knows why that rule is in place and has to accept the appropriate consequence.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 20:24

Whatwhatwhatnow · 28/01/2023 20:22

He has been punished by the people in charge.
I don't support vigilante action. The parents need to trust the staff.
Therefore regardless of my opinion I think the parents should not protest.

And the club, who have a safe guarding obligation towards the child, need to nip the protest in the bud.

The matter has been dealt with and a group of adults publicly harassing a child would be appalling behaviour.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:24

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 19:08

I agree with whoever it was upthread that said adults participating in this ‘protest’ should be banned from the club (assuming they get a warning first).

OP, you should let the club know of the apparent protest in advance, so that it can be nipped in the bud.

Good point. After all, it's a sports club where they would be penalised on the pitch for disagreeing with the decision of the ref. Why is it OK for them to disagree with the decision of the club authorities? Especially when it's intermixed with a distinct whiff of lynch mob behaviour directed at a child.

Whatwhatwhatnow · 28/01/2023 20:22

He has been punished by the people in charge.
I don't support vigilante action. The parents need to trust the staff.
Therefore regardless of my opinion I think the parents should not protest.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 20:21

SammyScrounge · 28/01/2023 20:15

It is rare for people to band together to protest about a child. They clearly know this boy and are angered by him. I suspect there is a lot more bad behaviour, whether inside or outside the club, than is being admitted.

If we’re just making stuff up, I’ll randomly suggest the child is black and the would-be protestors are all BNP members.

In reality, the cancel-culture inclined in this thread would also want to ban the boy, and they have no facts other than those presented by the OP. Some people are just like that, these days.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 20:18

wmch · 28/01/2023 20:08

Of course he should be expelled. He could have killed her. He has persistently had to be disciplined in the past, and yet chose to ride his skateboard, when he knew it was forbidden. He's a danger to other people.

He has been involved in one accident (where he behaved recklessly) and there is nothing to suggest he has ever previously jeopardized anyone else’s safety. Your response is ridiculously disproportionate.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:18

SkippyKangeroo · 28/01/2023 19:05

If this 12yr old doesn't get punished, his entitlement - already through the roof due to him ignoring basic health and safety and general courtesy rules - will be dangerous and out of control.

He doesn't need mollycoddling and understanding, he needs consequences to his selfish, dangerous behaviour.

It was a totally avoidable accident, it only just barely fits into that description. He knew it was reckless behaviour but did it anyway.

What a bizarre post. 12 year olds sometimes do utterly stupid things. That doesn't make them entitled . No-one is suggesting this boy needs mollycoddling. He simply needs a punishment that is actually proportionate to all the circumstances, and it's reasonable to believe that that is what the club has imposed. You've whipped yourself up into a pretty ludicrous froth out of, really, nothing.

SammyScrounge · 28/01/2023 20:15

Yeahrightthen · 27/01/2023 17:39

There is a certain number of parents who are not happy, and are intending to protest, boycott tomorrow

Then they are disgusting and should be ashamed of themselves.

Who the fuck are these people? Adults no less who should know better! Have none of them ever made a mistake as a child? I’d have no qualms telling them exactly what I thought of them.

It sounds like you live in some kind of village of the damned OP? Adults braying for a 12yr olds blood? Disgusting.

And I’d hedge a bet it’s more to do with who this boy is (ie “not really one of them”) than the accident itself.

It is rare for people to band together to protest about a child. They clearly know this boy and are angered by him. I suspect there is a lot more bad behaviour, whether inside or outside the club, than is being admitted.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:13

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 19:01

“several” reprimands for arguing with the ref, when he’s only been there a year isn’t good

plus the patchy attendance

as for his parents not being there or at matches- they could be working, looking after younger kids etc. it doesn’t mean they are bad parents.

OP says they don't attend or support him, and that members of his family are troublemakers. It would be incredibly unlikely that supportive parents would never turn up.

Why are you so determined to put this boy in the worst possible light, even to the point of being so selective about the information available?

wmch · 28/01/2023 20:08

Of course he should be expelled. He could have killed her. He has persistently had to be disciplined in the past, and yet chose to ride his skateboard, when he knew it was forbidden. He's a danger to other people.

Flamingogirl08 · 28/01/2023 20:05

KettrickenSmiled · 28/01/2023 19:57

I'm not disputing whether punishment is appropriate or not, I'm disputing that it was purely an accident.

But if you don't get the analogy, no worries, I'm sure there's going to be quite enough nasty-minded comment on this thread without me adding to it by needling a perfectly sensible PP. 😀

NB the fact I don't consider it an accident doesn't make me one of the "hang draw & quarter" brigade that will inevitably be calling for frothing vengeance.

Fair enough. You know you're right, no point arguing with somebody who is actually being quite reasonable as well.

I actually don't know why I've been so invested in this thread, it's all gone a bit nuts 🤣

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:04

SherlockStones · 28/01/2023 18:15

He's not being sent to prison, he is being shown that actions have consqeuences. If he were to be expelled then so be it.

The amount of soft touches in here, I despair

The club's decision was that he should not be expelled. They know way more about the background circumstances than anyone on this thread. So I trust you accept that whatever penalty they did impose falls into the "So be it" category?

Cileymyrus · 28/01/2023 20:04

The driving analogies don’t work.

there’s a reason we don’t allow 12 year olds to drive. They don’t have the emotional and intellectual maturity to control several tons of metal.

if you are driving, you are deemed old enough to make adult decisions and be able to foresee the consequences of speeding, or reversing without looking, or whatever. Punishment is based on the driver having the competency to make those decisions.

a 12 year old doesn’t have the same maturity. As in this case, he knows he shouldn’t be skating indoors, but would a 12 year old think it through past smooth floors and not consider if someone popped up or stepped into their way? Probably not.

a skateboard is not a car. We don’t licence skateboard or restrict their use to adults because they aren’t the same.

Doggate1 · 28/01/2023 20:03

You know you go to prison AS punishment and NOT FOR punishment right?
Mistakes happen and some people think more than others BUT they shouldn’t define you … he didn’t mean to hurt anyone .. it was unfortunate…

KettrickenSmiled · 28/01/2023 20:02

Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 19:56

^^ This! Best post on this thread.

I did some training on unconscious bias recently. A trainer gave a scenario, said it was a script for a play, and asked us to write down who we would cast as protagonist, antagonist etc. Turned out there were some very apparent biases that became quite obvious when the actors/actresses faces were pasted onto a storyboard.

If the OP is the casting director, the notes we have so far are:
Protagonist: 12 year old kid. Parents not interested. Skateboards. Minor rule-breaking.
Antagonist: Grandmother. Still working, so in her sixties but looks closer to 70. Suffers broken arm.

Now, who are you casting in these roles?
Is the kid a Harry Potter 1 era Daniel Radcliff? A Billy Elliott era Tom Holland? A Home Alone era Macaulay Culkin? Or are you imagining someone else ... someone older, edgier, more 'delinquent' and less cute? If so, who would you get to play this kid, based on what you know from reading this thread? Does the story change if the Grandmother is played by June Whitfield, or Dame Maggie Smith, or Catherine Tate?

If you dismiss this as irrelevant, then you are arguing from a perspective clouded by unconscious bias.

😂👏👏

Great post, although you missed a trick for the Screaming Vengeance Squad with your Hogwarts ruminations - clearly the kid must be cast c/o Slytherin House. Wink

purpledalmation · 28/01/2023 20:02

fuck all to do with unconscious bias.

SammyScrounge · 28/01/2023 20:01

He cannot get off with saying it was unintentional because it was foreseeable, even to a 12 year old.

LoisLane66 · 28/01/2023 20:01

Everything else is irrelevant except the fact that he was told not to use the skateboard in the building and his choosing to ignore the warning, directly led to him knocking over the grandmother. He should be suspended for a year and have to give half of any pocket money to the grandmother each week, for the whole 12 month suspension.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:00

Cocobutt · 28/01/2023 18:10

leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building,

several minor reprimands.

Yes he should be removed because he continues to not follow the rules.

He was told no skateboarding and then carried on doing it.
He should be punished for this reason alone.

Yes, he should be punished. The question is, should the club automatically go to the most extreme punishment of expelling him permanently?

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 19:59

Patineur · 28/01/2023 19:56

Is there anyone on this thread who suggests the boy should not have a punishment that teaches him something? I don't remember seeing any posts saying that. Yes, there are several that say he shouldn't be chucked out permanently, but none are saying he should get away with little or nothing by way of punishment.

Yup, I don’t recall any posts saying he shouldn’t be punished, but certain posters don’t seem to perceive anything short of ‘cancellation’ as being punishment.

purpledalmation · 28/01/2023 19:59

So when he is 18 and just passed his test, is told not to drive round this car park as speeds of over 5mph are not allowed, but he does and kills a kid, is it also an accident?

Not a ridiculous analogy. He was told not to behave in a reckless way with his skateboard. He did anyway. He caused serious injury to someone.

And you're saying he shouldnt be punished? This could have been a lethal accident if she'd fallen and hit her head.

You do realise the owners of the sports club will now likely have to pay from their public liability insurance as the accident happened on their property? I'd be suing because the facility did not fully control one of its members.

KettrickenSmiled · 28/01/2023 19:57

Flamingogirl08 · 28/01/2023 19:49

Who said anything about no punishment?

If you did something in your car deliberately like speeding and caused an accident then you would receive punishment but wouldn't necessarily be banned from driving forever!

I'm not disputing whether punishment is appropriate or not, I'm disputing that it was purely an accident.

But if you don't get the analogy, no worries, I'm sure there's going to be quite enough nasty-minded comment on this thread without me adding to it by needling a perfectly sensible PP. 😀

NB the fact I don't consider it an accident doesn't make me one of the "hang draw & quarter" brigade that will inevitably be calling for frothing vengeance.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 19:56

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 14:13

Agree. This attitude seems to be more and more prevalent in society. No one is prepared to take personal responsibility for their actions and there is always a queue of people willing to find any excuse to blame someone other than the person who is actually responsible - in this case the child. Yes, he’s 12, yes he was careless and didn’t actually mean to hurt anyone. And probably, hopefully, he will learn from this experience. But I think the point is that if he had done as he was told in the first place no one would have been hurt. But hey - better to blame the victim for not expecting a skateboard to come at her inside a building, than actually apply a punishment to the child that actually teaches him something.

Is there anyone on this thread who suggests the boy should not have a punishment that teaches him something? I don't remember seeing any posts saying that. Yes, there are several that say he shouldn't be chucked out permanently, but none are saying he should get away with little or nothing by way of punishment.