Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
PoppyTries · 28/01/2023 22:10

Kangarude · 27/01/2023 17:12

I'm a grandmother and I'm 100% certain that I would return to my 'previous independence and function' I'm 58 Hmm

I accept that there needs to be consequence but I wouldn't want the boy expelling from the club

I’m 53 and keep an active lifestyle. Two years ago had a surgery which involved the breaking of a bone & I’m still healing and have stiffness, pain, limited movement, etc. You won’t know for certain unless it actually happens to you. The OP stated that the grandmother in question is probably a decade older than you.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:07

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 19:51

To be clear, he has ignored safety rules on precisely one occasion, and now he is being punished for that.

And rightly so, because that one occasion resulted in serious injury for someone. Had he not ignored the safety rules on that one occasion, it wouldn’t have happened. I think the poster was referring to the occasions he was reprimanded for arguing with the referee on the pitch, which although it’s not the same thing, does demonstrate an unwillingness to accept authority, which did play a part in the accident otherwise he wouldn’t have been back on the skateboard after being told not to ride it inside the building.

Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 22:07

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 21:49

I did some training on unconscious bias recently

did you notice that in all your examples the actors you chose are white?

Yes I did. And it was quite deliberate. Because race does not appear to be the issue here. And I didn't want to derail the thread by allowing some gammon to leap all over that particular aspect when it's not about that.

It is about a child. Not a teenager. A child. Being hounded out of a club by parents of other kids, who dislike him because of his background. And by extremely judgmental internet posters making a whole bunch of assumptions about that child, his motives, and ascribing culpability based purely on those prejudices. Makes me absolutely sick.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 22:06

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:00

Just re-read your post - apologies, I misunderstood. Yes, I don’t understand this either. A lot of posters are effectively saying that people are ‘cancelling’ this boy by expelling him from the club, but they have no problem with cancelling the protestors and interfering with free speech.

You’re the one who started moaning about cancel culture, whilst being entirely on board with a child being permanently excluded and expressing support for the mooted protests calling for that.

I don’t tend to decry ‘cancel culture’, because I think it’s a simplistic buzzword thrown around by the hard of thinking.

I have, however, used it in this specific context to highlight your hypocrisy.

MsStyles · 28/01/2023 22:01

disobey

MsStyles · 28/01/2023 22:00

Glad he wasn’t expelled. He’s 12, it was an accident. No intention to hurt and yes, he did obey the rule (as most of us do at one point or another despite knowing the possible consequences) and on this occasion it went badly. Therefore I would expect him to miss out on some sessions or have to sit on the sidelines and help out rather than play. But not be expelled.

I have a son a little younger than that boy. Football is life to him. He lives for his football sessions, it’s all he talks about. I hope he’d listen and not use a skateboard when told not to (he’s never been interested in them anyway) but kids aren’t perfect and I couldn’t imagine the impact on him if he was expelled for a mistake, albeit a big one. But I know he would be devastated, incredibly upset and sad. I expect/would hope the child if he’s a decent child, is already feeling pretty rubbish for causing the accident. And I expect he already knows the club are disappointed in his behaviour and that’s one of the worst things to know someone feels about you imo.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:00

SherlockStones · 28/01/2023 20:59

Oh I don't mind the explusion, that post was aimed at the poster who said the protestors themselves should be banned from the club if members themselves.

Just re-read your post - apologies, I misunderstood. Yes, I don’t understand this either. A lot of posters are effectively saying that people are ‘cancelling’ this boy by expelling him from the club, but they have no problem with cancelling the protestors and interfering with free speech.

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 21:56

Virtually every teenage boy caught up in his sport argues with the ref occasionally

he isn’t a teenager

in one year he has argued with the referee “several times” - not occasionally.
thats something no decent club would have any truck with.

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 21:49

I did some training on unconscious bias recently

did you notice that in all your examples the actors you chose are white?

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 21:46

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:13

OP says they don't attend or support him, and that members of his family are troublemakers. It would be incredibly unlikely that supportive parents would never turn up.

Why are you so determined to put this boy in the worst possible light, even to the point of being so selective about the information available?

It is unlikely from her posts that OP is so close to the parents to know what they do and do not support in their child’s life, or if their working lives mean they cannot attend. Many parents are struggling in low paid jobs, juggling their schedules and family priorities and some things simply can’t be accommodated if there is to be food on the table and heat in the house.

why are you so determined to paint them in the worst possible light as uncaring parents?

GUARDIAN1 · 28/01/2023 21:22

I don't think he should be expelled altogether, but I do think there should be consequences. Firstly a ban on him bringing his skateboard to the club - he can't follow the rules around using it, so should forfeit the ability to flout the rules. I think he should also write a letter to the person he hurt, expressing remorse and offering to do whatever he can to help (maybe get her shopping, tidy her garden etc).

I agree that sport can be really important in giving young people focus and keeping their energies channelled in a positive way. If his family don't offer him much positivity, the club may make the difference between him turning out OK or getting sucked into negative activities. This wouldn't just impact on him but the general community.

His attendance rate is another matter. I'd expect 95% attendance to be required if a team sport.

Chiccaletta · 28/01/2023 21:12

Short suspension with skateboard ban and final warning if I was in charge

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 21:07

purpledalmation · 28/01/2023 21:00

they would sue the sport centre who legally must have public liability insurance. Probably win as they are responsible for the safety of the public on their property. Easiest target rather than the child or his parents. Probably why he's been expelled. Its going to be expensive.

Assuming this happened in the UK, there is no legal requirement for public liability insurance.

On the facts presented, a claim would be unlikely to be successful. Even if it were, a claim for a broken arm is unlikely to be very costly or have a significant impact on the premiums of any insurance policy in place.

And the child has not been expelled.

Otherwise, great post.

purpledalmation · 28/01/2023 21:00

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:51

No win no fee solicitors don't take on cases unless there is a decent chance of actually recovering some money.

they would sue the sport centre who legally must have public liability insurance. Probably win as they are responsible for the safety of the public on their property. Easiest target rather than the child or his parents. Probably why he's been expelled. Its going to be expensive.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 21:00

KettrickenSmiled · 28/01/2023 19:57

I'm not disputing whether punishment is appropriate or not, I'm disputing that it was purely an accident.

But if you don't get the analogy, no worries, I'm sure there's going to be quite enough nasty-minded comment on this thread without me adding to it by needling a perfectly sensible PP. 😀

NB the fact I don't consider it an accident doesn't make me one of the "hang draw & quarter" brigade that will inevitably be calling for frothing vengeance.

Obviously it's an accident. No-one is suggesting that he aimed the skateboard at the woman with the intention of knocking her over.

Yes, it's at the reckless end of the scale, and yes, it should attract a penalty. But it's still an accident.

SherlockStones · 28/01/2023 20:59

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:24

Most posters are making the point that the punishment should fit what he did. Did you miss the fact that he’s been reprimanded several times for arguing with the referee, and had been asked not to skateboard in the building ? So he has an unwillingness to accept authority which has now resulted in him disobeying the request not to skateboard in the building, thus causing significant injury to someone. So what punishment do you think he should face ?

Oh I don't mind the explusion, that post was aimed at the poster who said the protestors themselves should be banned from the club if members themselves.

purpledalmation · 28/01/2023 20:56

Cileymyrus · 28/01/2023 20:04

The driving analogies don’t work.

there’s a reason we don’t allow 12 year olds to drive. They don’t have the emotional and intellectual maturity to control several tons of metal.

if you are driving, you are deemed old enough to make adult decisions and be able to foresee the consequences of speeding, or reversing without looking, or whatever. Punishment is based on the driver having the competency to make those decisions.

a 12 year old doesn’t have the same maturity. As in this case, he knows he shouldn’t be skating indoors, but would a 12 year old think it through past smooth floors and not consider if someone popped up or stepped into their way? Probably not.

a skateboard is not a car. We don’t licence skateboard or restrict their use to adults because they aren’t the same.

I don't know how many 12 year olds you know, but they most certainly should know not to do something they've been told not to do. 6 year olds maybe, but 12 year olds need to be held accountable. He was told clearly not to do it, but did so anyway. When does personal responsibility kick in ?

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:55

SammyScrounge · 28/01/2023 19:45

He should be expelled. He obviously can't take a telling and persists in ignoring safety rules and now someone has been seriously injured.
He should be expelled and he should lose his skateboard too - He is so badly behaved that he should not be trusted with it.

What on earth do you base that on? OP has said he's never been in trouble for misbehaviour in the club off the pitch, this seems to have been a one-off incident and there is no suggestion that he "persists" in ignoring safety rules.

ZiriForEver · 28/01/2023 20:54

It was an older woman, but it could had been anyone else in his way. The crash was result of his intentional action.

I would expect some active punishment (costing him time) and safety management for the future (conditional expulsion - with clear part of the condition being not stepping on the skateboard ever again on the premises).

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 20:54

you are arguing from a perspective clouded by unconscious bias

the fact you describe the victim as the antagonist shows your bias very clearly.

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 20:51

Antagonist: Grandmother. Still working, so in her sixties but looks closer to 70. Suffers broken arm

the lady is not an antagonist.

she is neither “a person who is opposed to, struggles against, or competes with another; opponent; adversary” nor is she
“the adversary of the hero or protagonist of a drama or other literary work”

most people do not have to retire at a set age, so you cannot determine her age based on this.

she suffered a serious break to her arm that required surgery.

she is the victim here.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:51

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/01/2023 19:32

Well if she did find a no win no fee solicitor then she'd have absolutely nothing to lose and potentially something to gain.

No win no fee solicitors don't take on cases unless there is a decent chance of actually recovering some money.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:47

She could sue the child himself, but any reparation wouldn’t be payable until he turns 18

Not strictly true. The problem is not his age but the fact that he is unlikely to have any money with which to satisfy any judgment.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:38

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:12

Why are you assuming that he has little interest from his parents ? They may work, they may have other children to look after - any number of things. We can’t assume anything to the point where we excuse what he did. And whether or not he hit anyone or only injured himself is irrelevant. He has been reprimanded several times for arguing with the referee and he ignored being asked not to use the skateboard in the building. This demonstrates an unwillingness to accept authority, and he badly injured someone as a result. That seems to be a fact that few people seem to want to focus on.

I doubt that @Sugarfree23 is assuming anything, it's the rather obvious interpretation of the information we have been given that "they don't attend or support him".

How many supportive parents of children with a particular interest or talent never turn up to support them?

Yet again, you are attributing statements to people you disagree with that they haven't made. I can't see @Sugarfree23 or anyone else saying this excuses what this boy did. The post you are responding to simply says that a ban is too extreme.

Virtually every teenage boy caught up in his sport argues with the ref occasionally, indeed plenty of adult professional sports players do. On one occasion this one didn't do what he was told in the building. We're told there have been no other similar incidents in the period since he joined the club. That does not amount to proof of unwillingness to accept authority.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 20:33

Talapia · 28/01/2023 20:27

I agree with this.

The club may have no choice but no expel him due to insurance or potential litigation.

I would think at the very least, suspension for a set time, some kind of work to support the he injured.

Actions have consequences. He now knows why that rule is in place and has to accept the appropriate consequence.

Yes this is sensible - it’s just like how when a child runs in the corridors at school, against the rules, they are immediately expelled to protect the school from liability.

Swipe left for the next trending thread