Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Blufelt · 29/01/2023 09:34

SkippyKangeroo · 29/01/2023 08:22

I wouldn't class a person being in hospital having an operation on a broken bone, as 'nothing '.

If my mother landed in hospital due to the careless, dangerous actions of a 12 year old who refused to listen to people in charge, I certainly wouldn't be going down the 'Ah well, boys will be boys' route.

But the question is what you could do about it. Which is pretty much nothing. The club is not liable. The parents are not liable. The police won’t get involved as it’s a civil case where no laws have been broken.

You would have to scrape together the money to pay a lawyer to sue privately, the judge would have to agree that the 12yo could have been expected to anticipate the accident and was neglectful, and the punishment would be extremely minor. You wouldn’t get any compensation because the 12yo has no money. And it would cost you a fortune in legal fees.

If it was my child I wouldn’t make him apologise either, or send flowers, or have any contact at all, because that’s admitting liability. If the injured party did decide to sue the apology would be used as evidence to prove it was the 12yo’s fault. Frankly the injured party needs to claim on her own insurance.

Sugarfree23 · 29/01/2023 09:21

Yes the outcome could have been worse banged her head or been carrying a baby but it could also have been a lot less, not hit anyone, stopping in time, her stepping out the way, came away with a slight bruise. Or it could have been him who was hurt.

He appears to have lost his skateboard which I think kind of fits. But I'm hoping that someone eventually relents and gives it back especially if that's how he normally gets back and forward

You wouldn't have your car confiscated for speeding or an accident resulting in a broken arm

bellabasset · 29/01/2023 09:07

I think that if the injured woman needed an operation then it isn't a simple break. Whilst it was an accident it was avoidable. OP has said that skate boards aren't allowed in the club so in that case it should have been taken from the boy. So I think the club possibly has a responsibility. What is a good thing is that the boy has obviously realised the seriousness of his actions by being hesitant of going back. He's also learnt that some people are critical of the club's ruling so he's caused controversy and hopefully he will repay the club by being a hard working team member.

I have been concerned by the posters who minimise the effect on the injured woman as no-one visiting the club would expect to br knocked over by a skateboard, could have been a young child or a parent carrying a child

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 08:47

The ‘and rightly so’ rather implies that there is debate over whether or not the boy should be punished, which there isn’t.

No - I was simply stating that he had been rightly punished for ignoring the safety warning and going on to injure someone as a result. Nuance is always a problem with written posts and I have misunderstood a couple of posters and apologised to them. You on the other hand, seem to have scrutinised my previous posts looking to criticise, and have misinterpreted my replies to other posters. The difference is that you have resorted to insults like ‘hard of thinking’ and ‘hypocrisy’, and at one point accuse me of harassment of a child because I don’t agree with the suggestion that the protestors are a ‘baying mob’ and should have their memberships cancelled. If, as seems to be the case, the boy has had a fair hearing and a suitable punishment, then surely the club can at least take the time to explain that to any parents who still have concerns. I have a much right as anyone else to express my opinion on a public forum without having my posts trolled.

Sugarfree23 · 29/01/2023 08:46

Nobody is saying that the broken bone is 'nothing' but his crime is skateboarding where he should not have been.

That doesn't change, regardless of the outcome, and the punishment has to fit the crime. His crime is no different, if he hadn't hit anyone, if he or other person managed to avoid the collision, or he knocked her over only causing a bruise.

SkippyKangeroo · 29/01/2023 08:22

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:18

What a bizarre post. 12 year olds sometimes do utterly stupid things. That doesn't make them entitled . No-one is suggesting this boy needs mollycoddling. He simply needs a punishment that is actually proportionate to all the circumstances, and it's reasonable to believe that that is what the club has imposed. You've whipped yourself up into a pretty ludicrous froth out of, really, nothing.

I wouldn't class a person being in hospital having an operation on a broken bone, as 'nothing '.

If my mother landed in hospital due to the careless, dangerous actions of a 12 year old who refused to listen to people in charge, I certainly wouldn't be going down the 'Ah well, boys will be boys' route.

Sugarfree23 · 29/01/2023 07:03

@Nimbostratus100
Glad he and the grandson were both there yesterday.

I just hope the boycotters kids never do anything to let them down. The words of a wise woman 'never criticise anyone else's kids, because you never know what your own will do'

Sugarfree23 · 29/01/2023 06:38

Patineur · 28/01/2023 20:38

I doubt that @Sugarfree23 is assuming anything, it's the rather obvious interpretation of the information we have been given that "they don't attend or support him".

How many supportive parents of children with a particular interest or talent never turn up to support them?

Yet again, you are attributing statements to people you disagree with that they haven't made. I can't see @Sugarfree23 or anyone else saying this excuses what this boy did. The post you are responding to simply says that a ban is too extreme.

Virtually every teenage boy caught up in his sport argues with the ref occasionally, indeed plenty of adult professional sports players do. On one occasion this one didn't do what he was told in the building. We're told there have been no other similar incidents in the period since he joined the club. That does not amount to proof of unwillingness to accept authority.

Thank-you @Patineur

That was exactly what I was thinking. The Op states his parents 'don't attend or support him' which is a very unusual stance for interested parents. Even if they do work, like most parents, you'd still expect them to turn up occasionally or even for grandparents to turn up and show a bit of interest.

autienotnaughty · 29/01/2023 06:09

Thanks for the update @Nimbostratus100 glad to hear common sense prevailed. And good on the boy for coming back.

Shocked at the harshness of some of the posts on hear and the reaction of done of the parents. It shows if your face doesn't fit.....

Zvifflemeyer · 29/01/2023 04:21

he needs to have SOME for of punishment, but expulsion seems a bit extreme. But we are also lacking details that COULD warrant it. How fast was he going? did it happen on a blind turn? I would need to know more than "he was riding his skateboard when he has been told not to.
Based on the information you have given, he should be suspended from the club. Maybe made to sit out for playoff games.

Stewball01 · 29/01/2023 00:25

Maybe not expelled. But he should be doing hard labour. Shopping for grandma, helping her at home or in the garden. He has to pay for what he did out of stupidity.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 23:34

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 23:18

I think the last sentence in my post makes it clear that I am for appropriate punishment. And on page 9, I was arguing the merits or otherwise of a letter of apology or being made to clean the entrance to the building, which doesn’t really teach him anything, as opposed to banning him from the club, which does. I may have worded it badly, but I was not advocating for this, I am simply advocating a punishment which is appropriate to the seriousness of the incident, that will actually teach him something, rather than a token gesture.

You also responded to my post, on this page, as follows:

Other poster: “He should be expelled. He obviously can't take a telling and persists in ignoring safety rules and now someone has been seriously injured. He should be expelled and he should lose his skateboard too - He is so badly behaved that he should not be trusted with it.”

Me: “To be clear, he has ignored safety rules on precisely one occasion, and now he is being punished for that.”

You replied:
“And rightly so, because that one occasion resulted in serious injury for someone. Had he not ignored the safety rules on that one occasion, it wouldn’t have happened.”

The ‘and rightly so’ rather implies that there is debate over whether or not the boy should be punished, which there isn’t.

Anyway, although we don’t have particulars of the punishment, it sounds like he’s doing “community service” type work and has had his skateboard permanently taken off him. For me, that seems reasonable, and is more likely to be a productive punishment for a child than a lengthy suspension or expulsion.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 23:18

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 23:04

“Agree. This attitude seems to be more and more prevalent in society. No one is prepared to take personal responsibility for their actions and there is always a queue of people willing to find any excuse to blame someone other than the person who is actually responsible - in this case the child. Yes, he’s 12, yes he was careless and didn’t actually mean to hurt anyone. And probably, hopefully, he will learn from this experience. But I think the point is that if he had done as he was told in the first place no one would have been hurt. But hey - better to blame the victim for not expecting a skateboard to come at her inside a building, than actually apply a punishment to the child that actually teaches him something.”

I think the last sentence in my post makes it clear that I am for appropriate punishment. And on page 9, I was arguing the merits or otherwise of a letter of apology or being made to clean the entrance to the building, which doesn’t really teach him anything, as opposed to banning him from the club, which does. I may have worded it badly, but I was not advocating for this, I am simply advocating a punishment which is appropriate to the seriousness of the incident, that will actually teach him something, rather than a token gesture.

Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 23:12

Indeed. Lol. TrashyPanda just doesn't like me or the fact that I shone a light on the bigotry, I guess. Don't wanna derail the thread.

Am very happy with the OP's update. And also with the fact that 1,900 people (64%) who voted agreed that it is not unreasonable. Seems like a sane outcome is occurring in real life, too and I'm glad that there are kind people like the OP looking out for kids. Common sense prevails.

AdventFridgeOfShame · 28/01/2023 23:07

Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 22:55

Go on then ... which three non-white child actors in blockbuster films that everyone knows without having to think too hard would you have chosen then?

Heck Mark, this may be the first time I agree with you.

Why are young, non-white actors not getting decent roles and publicity for them? They have the talent. We are off on quite a detour.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 23:06

Nimbostratus100 · 28/01/2023 22:48

updating, because I always want to know what happens next myself, when I have got involved in a thread. But there is not much to report

The boy was there today, he took some encouraging to come in, he is doing a punishment along the lines that have been suggested in the thread. He is very subdued. He no longer owns a skateboard.

A couple of the whatsapp parents who said they were going to boycott, did in fact boycott, and their absence was just ignored. One family pointedly walked out and went home having seen the boy there, and they were ignored too. If there was any other hostility, I didnt see it

The grandmother is out of hospital, and the grandson was there today, playing as normal. I do want to know how is grandmother is, but didn't want to question him, so no doubt I will hear in the fullness of time

A good update all around (well, shame about the boycotters, but at least they’re being ignored).

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 23:04

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:27

Yes, every single poster appears in agreement that there should be a punishment, I don’t know why you keep seeming to suggest otherwise.

Where have I suggested otherwise ?

“Agree. This attitude seems to be more and more prevalent in society. No one is prepared to take personal responsibility for their actions and there is always a queue of people willing to find any excuse to blame someone other than the person who is actually responsible - in this case the child. Yes, he’s 12, yes he was careless and didn’t actually mean to hurt anyone. And probably, hopefully, he will learn from this experience. But I think the point is that if he had done as he was told in the first place no one would have been hurt. But hey - better to blame the victim for not expecting a skateboard to come at her inside a building, than actually apply a punishment to the child that actually teaches him something.”

Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 22:55

Go on then ... which three non-white child actors in blockbuster films that everyone knows without having to think too hard would you have chosen then?

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 22:52

Yes I did. And it was quite deliberate. Because race does not appear to be the issue here

why deliberately assume those involved are white?

Using the names of non-white actors would not make race “the issue here”.

seems ironic to post about bias and then suggest only white actors, thus demonstrating bias!

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 22:49

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:24

I didn’t say I was on board with him being permanently excluded. I was against those who were trying to excuse what he’d done - one or two of whom were actually blaming the victim. I have said repeatedly that the punishment should be something to make him understand that actions have consequences and that he can’t pick and choose which rules he obeys and which ones he ignores. And it isn’t ‘hard of thinking’ to be concerned that the same people who are criticising others for effectively ‘cancelling’ this boy by advocating his expulsion, are advocating doing exactly the same thing to the group of parents who are protesting.

You posted, back on page 9.

”Actions have consequences and at 12 he’s old enough to understand that. A letter of apology is easy, so is making him clean the entrance for a month. Banning him completely takes away something of value to him and sends the message that what he did was unacceptable, so he has to suffer the consequences, just as his victim does.”

and have persistently argued with anyone who seems to think anything short of permanent expulsion would be appropriate.

I’ve only been able to spot one poster in this thread who seemed to raise the possibility that the woman may be partially at fault, and that was ~10 pages ago.

If your argument isn’t that he should be excluded, then it’s hard to work out what point you’re trying to make, particularly in the context of a thread which is solely about whether permanent expulsion is proportionate or not.

Nimbostratus100 · 28/01/2023 22:48

updating, because I always want to know what happens next myself, when I have got involved in a thread. But there is not much to report

The boy was there today, he took some encouraging to come in, he is doing a punishment along the lines that have been suggested in the thread. He is very subdued. He no longer owns a skateboard.

A couple of the whatsapp parents who said they were going to boycott, did in fact boycott, and their absence was just ignored. One family pointedly walked out and went home having seen the boy there, and they were ignored too. If there was any other hostility, I didnt see it

The grandmother is out of hospital, and the grandson was there today, playing as normal. I do want to know how is grandmother is, but didn't want to question him, so no doubt I will hear in the fullness of time

OP posts:
Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:27

Yes, every single poster appears in agreement that there should be a punishment, I don’t know why you keep seeming to suggest otherwise.

Where have I suggested otherwise ?

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:24

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 22:06

You’re the one who started moaning about cancel culture, whilst being entirely on board with a child being permanently excluded and expressing support for the mooted protests calling for that.

I don’t tend to decry ‘cancel culture’, because I think it’s a simplistic buzzword thrown around by the hard of thinking.

I have, however, used it in this specific context to highlight your hypocrisy.

I didn’t say I was on board with him being permanently excluded. I was against those who were trying to excuse what he’d done - one or two of whom were actually blaming the victim. I have said repeatedly that the punishment should be something to make him understand that actions have consequences and that he can’t pick and choose which rules he obeys and which ones he ignores. And it isn’t ‘hard of thinking’ to be concerned that the same people who are criticising others for effectively ‘cancelling’ this boy by advocating his expulsion, are advocating doing exactly the same thing to the group of parents who are protesting.

Cileymyrus · 28/01/2023 22:21

PoppyTries · 28/01/2023 22:10

I’m 53 and keep an active lifestyle. Two years ago had a surgery which involved the breaking of a bone & I’m still healing and have stiffness, pain, limited movement, etc. You won’t know for certain unless it actually happens to you. The OP stated that the grandmother in question is probably a decade older than you.

I still wouldn’t want a child thrown out of an activity which is likely a stabilising effect on his life and could possibly keep him out of serious trouble.

ok so my life is affected for the worse. But no need to take away a positive influence away from a child so he may end up causing other people harm.

I had an accident when I was young. I sustained a fairly serious injury. However I did not blame the person who caused it, it was a second of misjudgement. She was punished appropriately and then should be allowed to move on.

tbh, i would much rather be the “victim”
than the person who caused an accident. Physical injury I can cope with, the mental torture of knowing my own stupidity cause someone long term pain not so much.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 22:18

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:07

And rightly so, because that one occasion resulted in serious injury for someone. Had he not ignored the safety rules on that one occasion, it wouldn’t have happened. I think the poster was referring to the occasions he was reprimanded for arguing with the referee on the pitch, which although it’s not the same thing, does demonstrate an unwillingness to accept authority, which did play a part in the accident otherwise he wouldn’t have been back on the skateboard after being told not to ride it inside the building.

Yes, every single poster appears in agreement that there should be a punishment, I don’t know why you keep seeming to suggest otherwise.

Out of interest, how do you perceive the boys ‘unwillingness to accept authority’ as being different from the would-be protestors, who will not accept the sport’s club’s decision making authority when it comes to selecting an appropriate punishment for one of their members?

You seem very against ‘cancel culture’ and ‘questioning authority’, except where it aligns with your personal opinions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread