Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
ancientgran · 29/01/2023 13:25

WendyAndClyde · 29/01/2023 09:38

If it was my child I wouldn’t make him apologise either, or send flowers, or have any contact at all, because that’s admitting liability.

But if, as you say, the child won't be paying compensation, then why on earth would you not, at the very least, make him apologise?

Children can pay compensation, I know a teacher who was hurt by a child who "lost it" and the school policy was to call the policy, it went to court and the child is paying compensation. He loses his pocketmoney but it will take years to pay it all off.

pairofrollerskates · 29/01/2023 12:53

He was told he shouldn't have the skateboard in the building. He broke that rule. Then, instead of carrying it safely out of the building, he skated it out. That deliberate act is why the woman (irrelevant how old she is) was knocked over. So, even though it was an accident, there was contributory negligence at the very least. Expel him.

Mark19735 · 29/01/2023 12:49

No. There is a fundamental basis for assigning culpability and administering justice - it is called the rule of law.

The child, who has not committed any criminal offense, has no case to answer to any prosecuting authority, court, or tribunal. Anyone suggesting that he should suffer punitive sanctions beyond those required by the law are engaging in harassment, and the boycotting parents who cannot accept that the law works as it does are nasty bullies. We don't need lynch mobs deciding they understand the law and are better placed to administer justice than the professionals who actually do this.

The injured party may be able to claim for her losses against an insurance policy, or she may not. That is a private matter for her to argue. If she does, then it will involve an investigation of her basis for a claim, which includes an examination of any pre-existing medical conditions to establish the reasonableness of her conduct, and whether there is any contributory negligence on her part. Based on what the OP has said, she may indeed succeed in such a claim. But whether she does or not is a private matter between her and the club and its insurers. The skateboarding boy has no role in this matter, other than that of an eyewitness.

Fuckthatguy · 29/01/2023 12:25

For all the posts complaining about the lack of compassion and the hardships this child has had to endure through no fault of his own, there are multiple parents being put through hell because of other children who think they can get away with literal murder. Yes, blame the government, blame the lack of community programmes and argue that this child should stay in the programme because he may do worse, but where is the line. Maybe he grows up with a sense of entitlement worse that he has has now and ends up killing someone because there were few repercussions.

We still don’t know why the other parents boycotted, other than they assumptions they’re white and middle class (unless I’ve missed some updates), and therefore it must be for malicious reasons. Maybe the other children are have a particular view of him which is valid, who knows, the the statements about how the boycotting parents were just ignored, doesn’t sit right either.

This matter feels indicative of the behaviour of many children in the UK. I’m no draconian disciplinarian however, there is a fundamental lack of proper guidance across the board in my view for many children.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 12:13

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 22:07

And rightly so, because that one occasion resulted in serious injury for someone. Had he not ignored the safety rules on that one occasion, it wouldn’t have happened. I think the poster was referring to the occasions he was reprimanded for arguing with the referee on the pitch, which although it’s not the same thing, does demonstrate an unwillingness to accept authority, which did play a part in the accident otherwise he wouldn’t have been back on the skateboard after being told not to ride it inside the building.

Yet again, no-one argues that he shouldn't be punished, so why do you keep labouring this point?

Patineur · 29/01/2023 12:10

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 21:56

Virtually every teenage boy caught up in his sport argues with the ref occasionally

he isn’t a teenager

in one year he has argued with the referee “several times” - not occasionally.
thats something no decent club would have any truck with.

The fact that he's not a teenager makes it even more excusable - he's still learning.

This is obviously a pretty successful club, given that it at elite levels and can pick and choose who it accepts. On what basis are you claiming it isn't decent? Perhaps they've worked out that children don't come to them with perfectly formed sporting manners and that their job is to teach them? After all, too many people actually reach professional adult levels in sport still arguing with referees.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 12:06

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 21:46

It is unlikely from her posts that OP is so close to the parents to know what they do and do not support in their child’s life, or if their working lives mean they cannot attend. Many parents are struggling in low paid jobs, juggling their schedules and family priorities and some things simply can’t be accommodated if there is to be food on the table and heat in the house.

why are you so determined to paint them in the worst possible light as uncaring parents?

I don't think you've read OP's posts properly. Amongst other matters, she's mentioned that some members of the family are troublemakers who thankfully don't come to the club. On any interpretation, she knows more about it than you do. I'm not painting them in any light, I'm simply going on the evidence, rather than following your path in speculating.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 12:02

purpledalmation · 28/01/2023 21:00

they would sue the sport centre who legally must have public liability insurance. Probably win as they are responsible for the safety of the public on their property. Easiest target rather than the child or his parents. Probably why he's been expelled. Its going to be expensive.

Being responsible for safety on the premises does not make the owner of the premises automatically liable for everything that takes place there It is still necessary to prove an element of negligence or fault on their part.

And the boy hasn't been expelled.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 12:00

purpledalmation · 28/01/2023 20:56

I don't know how many 12 year olds you know, but they most certainly should know not to do something they've been told not to do. 6 year olds maybe, but 12 year olds need to be held accountable. He was told clearly not to do it, but did so anyway. When does personal responsibility kick in ?

Has anyone said th3e 12 year old should not be held accountable? It's simply logical that, in deciding on a sanction, you take into account both the consequences of his action AND his age. Which is what the club seems, sensibly, to have done. They don't need to be second guessed.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 29/01/2023 11:25

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 11:16

They are liable - they knew the boy used his skate board in the premises - they have admitted this by telling him not to use the board. They knew it was a possibility that a 12 year old wouldn’t adhere to the rules. See how many posters belive he’s impulsive and argues with the red! Did they watch him? Did they issue a warning about him doing so and the consequences if he didn’t? Is it part of their club rules?
Have they taken all steps to prevent injury to visitors?

They haven’t.

Mmm, that's not how it works - luckily. If insurance worked like this, the best way of avoiding a claim against you would be never to take any precautions or issue any warnings.

You seem to think that the fact that the club took steps to prevent an accident is somehow evidence of their liability. Quite the opposite - it's their best defence against a claim, if the claim depends on negligence on their part.

Blufelt · 29/01/2023 11:19

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 11:16

They are liable - they knew the boy used his skate board in the premises - they have admitted this by telling him not to use the board. They knew it was a possibility that a 12 year old wouldn’t adhere to the rules. See how many posters belive he’s impulsive and argues with the red! Did they watch him? Did they issue a warning about him doing so and the consequences if he didn’t? Is it part of their club rules?
Have they taken all steps to prevent injury to visitors?

They haven’t.

Some people obviously don’t know how insurance works. You don’t have to prevent accidents on your premises. You just have to take reasonable steps to prevent accidents. Which they did, by making a rule about no skateboards and disciplining him previously when he broke the rule. They aren’t responsible if someone breaks a rule - the rule breaker is.

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 11:16

They are liable - they knew the boy used his skate board in the premises - they have admitted this by telling him not to use the board. They knew it was a possibility that a 12 year old wouldn’t adhere to the rules. See how many posters belive he’s impulsive and argues with the red! Did they watch him? Did they issue a warning about him doing so and the consequences if he didn’t? Is it part of their club rules?
Have they taken all steps to prevent injury to visitors?

They haven’t.

Blufelt · 29/01/2023 11:16

WendyAndClyde · 29/01/2023 09:38

If it was my child I wouldn’t make him apologise either, or send flowers, or have any contact at all, because that’s admitting liability.

But if, as you say, the child won't be paying compensation, then why on earth would you not, at the very least, make him apologise?

Because the injured party could still decide to sue and pursue a legal punishment, which is undesirable. I wouldn’t want my child to have a criminal record or be on probation or whatever. So my child wouldn’t admit any liability which includes apologising.

Blufelt · 29/01/2023 11:10

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 09:51

Here exampl

“As a result of your work”. This accident was not a result of the club’s work. It was outside of the normal activities of the club, and while it happened on their (rented?) premises, they did not cause it and had taken reasonable steps to prevent it. They aren’t liable and their insurance won’t pay out.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 11:04

GoldilockMom · 28/01/2023 20:29

And the club, who have a safe guarding obligation towards the child, need to nip the protest in the bud
OP said the parents were protesting she didn’t say it was towards the child, it may well be towards the staff who haven’t taken this incident seriously enough. OP May not see this child’s behaviour towards other kids - he may well be upsetting more people than OP realizes.

Or he may not. Because you are making up the facts. It's reasonable to assume the club knows what level of upset he may or not be causing.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 10:41

Talapia · 28/01/2023 20:27

I agree with this.

The club may have no choice but no expel him due to insurance or potential litigation.

I would think at the very least, suspension for a set time, some kind of work to support the he injured.

Actions have consequences. He now knows why that rule is in place and has to accept the appropriate consequence.

But obviously the club has a choice not to expel him, because they had chosen not to do so before OP first posted this thread.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 10:38

SammyScrounge · 28/01/2023 20:15

It is rare for people to band together to protest about a child. They clearly know this boy and are angered by him. I suspect there is a lot more bad behaviour, whether inside or outside the club, than is being admitted.

Is a group of people banding together to protest always right? Have a look at this if that is what you believe.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 10:35

wmch · 28/01/2023 20:08

Of course he should be expelled. He could have killed her. He has persistently had to be disciplined in the past, and yet chose to ride his skateboard, when he knew it was forbidden. He's a danger to other people.

Why do people keep making up the facts? He has not persistently had to be disciplined in the past, he's had minor reprimands for disagreeing with the referee, which (as pointed out) virtually is something that virtually all teenage boys and a hefty proportion of adults do. He has never previously had to be disciplined for misbehaviour off the field. A one-off incident for which he has already been sanctioned doesn't make him a danger to other people.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 10:29

SammyScrounge · 28/01/2023 20:01

He cannot get off with saying it was unintentional because it was foreseeable, even to a 12 year old.

The fact that something is foreseeable as a possibility does not make it intentional. When I type it is definitely foreseeable that I will make mistakes, it does not mean I intend to do so.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 10:10

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 09:49

The club is not liable.

The club is liable

They have public liability insurance for this reason. The lady was not safe on the property - where the accident happened. She could ask for their liability policy details and claim. No solicitor needed.

Problem is, as has already been pointed out, public liability insurance is not compulsory and the club could argue that they are not liable because they had already warned him about using the skateboard inside the building.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 10:07

You wouldn't have your car confiscated for speeding or an accident resulting in a broken arm

If you were found guilty of causing injury by careless or dangerous driving you’d be banned from driving it though. Amounts to the same thing.

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 09:51

Here exampl

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident
GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 09:49

The club is not liable.

The club is liable

They have public liability insurance for this reason. The lady was not safe on the property - where the accident happened. She could ask for their liability policy details and claim. No solicitor needed.

WendyAndClyde · 29/01/2023 09:38

If it was my child I wouldn’t make him apologise either, or send flowers, or have any contact at all, because that’s admitting liability.

But if, as you say, the child won't be paying compensation, then why on earth would you not, at the very least, make him apologise?

WendyAndClyde · 29/01/2023 09:35

You wouldn't have your car confiscated for speeding or an accident resulting in a broken arm

But you might lose your license. Which pretty much amounts to the same thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread