Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Patineur · 29/01/2023 23:08

ButterCrackers · 29/01/2023 23:00

He was told that skateboard use on site is against the rules and he used his skateboard and injured a person who needed an operation. If I was that person I would be taking action against the club and the child’s parents, who are responsible for their child. The injured person might need further treatment, physiotherapy, might not be able to work, drive a car, ride a bike, use their arm. It’s obvious that this sports club member broke the rules and there must be sanctions listed in the membership contract.

Do RTFT. It's been explained rather often why suing is probably not going to get this person anywhere.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 23:05

@Fuckthatguy, you're making things up. Again. You will not find one single post of mine that suggests the boy should be excused for the consequences of his actions.

For what it's worth, I've expressed absolutely no view on the colour or class of the boy's family.

I for one, am an advocate of consequences, and as the OP asked, I as did many others on this that expulsion is an acceptable one, considering the minimal context provided.

You're going to have to translate that.

WinterFoxes · 29/01/2023 23:05

What's the 'silent' generation @Mark19735 ?

It's not about ill intent. It's about arrogance and flouting rules after being asked not to, and having caused serious problems to someone else because of this. So there should be consequences, not just a 'shucks, it was an accident.' 12 year olds in other countries work to keep their families fed. He's not 2. If we don't teach young people at a very impressionable age that their actions have consequences, we are raising an entitled generation who think they should be exonerated and never face any unpleasantness at all. Unfair on society and unfair on them.

I would be furious if my DC had skateboarded in a building after being told not to, and done it so close to an elderly person coming in that they knocked her over. I rekekber a teenager skating a hair's breath from me when I was pregnant and it felt bloody aggressive.

ButterCrackers · 29/01/2023 23:00

He was told that skateboard use on site is against the rules and he used his skateboard and injured a person who needed an operation. If I was that person I would be taking action against the club and the child’s parents, who are responsible for their child. The injured person might need further treatment, physiotherapy, might not be able to work, drive a car, ride a bike, use their arm. It’s obvious that this sports club member broke the rules and there must be sanctions listed in the membership contract.

Mark19735 · 29/01/2023 22:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 29/01/2023 22:02

so that excuses the consequences, because ‘boys will be boys’. Ok
Nobody is saying there shouldn’t be consequences, just that expulsion would be a disproportionate one.

People, especially preteens, make mistakes (which sometimes involve breaking rules). This is the child’s first off-pitch offence and was entirely without malice.

A lot of kids, probably the majority, break similar rules from time to time, be it no running in school corridors or no diving/bombing at a swimming pool. 99 times out of 100 there is no resulting accident or injury and the child just gets a telling off, at most.

Yes the consequences here were serious, but expelling the child is far outside the range of normal responses for this type or rule-breaking (particularly a one-off).

He’s 12 and an elite athlete who could very well go on to have a career in sport. Elite sports clubs aren’t ten-a-penny. Kicking him out could significantly affect the rest of his life. It wouldn’t be good for him, wouldn’t benefit the club, and doesn’t benefit the victim. It would be draconian and possibly counter-productive.

We have the facts as the OP presented them and majority agree that expulsion is outside of the range of reasonable responses. The club have all of the relevant facts and also elected against expelling him (or, by the sounds of things, temporarily suspending him). Losing his skateboard and having to partake in some sort of restorative justice is far more appropriate.

Fuckthatguy · 29/01/2023 21:01

@Patineur so that excuses the consequences, because ‘boys will be boys’. Ok

Yes, that assumption was pointed out. And it was also said that these parents must be white middle class without any actual evidence of this, is that not prejudice? It’s not about attributing blame, for his troubled family, if you’d read my post, I clearly stated, ‘through no fault of his own’, that doesn’t detract for the fact, that certain learned behaviours, can be extremely detrimental. And no, for clarity I’m not only referring to this child’s situation. It’s unfortunate but that’s life, it’s not fair.

I have no opinion on that as again, I don’t have the facts, that’s not to say the club had made the correct decision, and who know if we are speculating, maybe they want to be the best so certain behaviours are condoned. Who knows, I certainly don’t. It wouldn’t be the first time.

Or they don’t want the child to miss out because of something nothing to do with said child.

The outcome is of course speculative at this point, however, I for one, am an advocate of consequences, and as the OP asked, I as did many others on this that expulsion is an acceptable one, considering the minimal context provided.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 20:49

Fuckthatguy · 29/01/2023 18:39

@Patineur

Enormous difference between ‘being stupid’, and deliberately defiant though. Stop minimising.

Like I said, and it’s very relevant, we don’t know why the other parents were boycotting but there will be a reason. If the boy is from as it’s stated, a troubled family, who knows what learned behaviours have been displayed, we do not have enough of the facts.

Why should the child of the injured grandmother not return? That’s ridiculous.

If you know anything about 12 year olds, you would know that, for them, being defiant and being stupid are very much intermingled. At that age, boys never think that the bad things will happen to them, and half the fun of skateboarding indoors lies in the fact that it's forbidden.

Does it occur to you that one factor behind some of the parents' actions might be that this kid is a better player of whatever sport it is than their child? Or simple prejudice? Or perhaps, like you, they are blaming him for what he can't help, namely his family.

We don't have enough of the facts, but do you accept that the people who run the club do? Why should the opinion of a couple of lynch mob members outweigh that?

I didn't say that the grandchild shouldn't return. I said I was glad that he had, that is an indicator that he and his family aren't among the boycotters and presumably accept the verdict of the club

NoBoatsOnSunday · 29/01/2023 19:43

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 19:32

Quite the opposite - it's their best defence against a claim, if the claim depends on negligence on their part

Did they warn visitors that there was a possibility of skating children in the corridors so they knew to avoid the risk?

Unless people were permitted to skateboard in the club, they would not need to. In assessing negligence, the accident would have to have been reasonably foreseeable by the club. You are not required to warn attendees of each and every type of accident that could possibly occur.

As it stands, one child turned up on a skateboard on one occasion and was promptly told that skateboarding indoors is not allowed.

There really is nothing to suggest negligence on behalf of the club, so it’s unlikely that the injured woman had a valid claim against them.

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 19:32

Quite the opposite - it's their best defence against a claim, if the claim depends on negligence on their part

Did they warn visitors that there was a possibility of skating children in the corridors so they knew to avoid the risk?

Fuckthatguy · 29/01/2023 18:39

@Patineur

Enormous difference between ‘being stupid’, and deliberately defiant though. Stop minimising.

Like I said, and it’s very relevant, we don’t know why the other parents were boycotting but there will be a reason. If the boy is from as it’s stated, a troubled family, who knows what learned behaviours have been displayed, we do not have enough of the facts.

Why should the child of the injured grandmother not return? That’s ridiculous.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 17:52

Fuckthatguy · 29/01/2023 12:25

For all the posts complaining about the lack of compassion and the hardships this child has had to endure through no fault of his own, there are multiple parents being put through hell because of other children who think they can get away with literal murder. Yes, blame the government, blame the lack of community programmes and argue that this child should stay in the programme because he may do worse, but where is the line. Maybe he grows up with a sense of entitlement worse that he has has now and ends up killing someone because there were few repercussions.

We still don’t know why the other parents boycotted, other than they assumptions they’re white and middle class (unless I’ve missed some updates), and therefore it must be for malicious reasons. Maybe the other children are have a particular view of him which is valid, who knows, the the statements about how the boycotting parents were just ignored, doesn’t sit right either.

This matter feels indicative of the behaviour of many children in the UK. I’m no draconian disciplinarian however, there is a fundamental lack of proper guidance across the board in my view for many children.

It's perfectly easy to see where the line is, and it comes some way away from accidentally knocking someone over by being stupid on a skateboard. Honestly, the suggestion that failing to throw this kid out forever is going to lead him to become a murderer is verging on laughable.

The club, which knows all the background facts,a has decided on what is a suitable punishment, and from what OP says it seems to have been pretty effective. It seems reasonable for them to ignore the views of what seems to be a small minority of parents working themselves up into a froth without benefit of that knowledge.

It also seems pretty signficant that the family of the woman in question are OK with her grandchild going back to the club. If the punishment is OK with them, what business do the other parents have trying to push the boy out?

pocketvenuss · 29/01/2023 17:37

Mark19735 · 29/01/2023 14:52

We don't punish people for what might have happened. We don't even punish them for what actually happened. We punish them for their behaviours, not the consequences of those behaviours. If their behaviour is unlawful, then the law prescribes the appropriate punishment. If it is not unlawful, then there is no requirement, or justification, for any punishment whatsoever.

Er no. We punish fir both the behaviours and the consequences. Dangerous driving and death by dangerous driving carry different sentences.

daisytumble · 29/01/2023 17:13

This is surely just a horrible accident.

Mandyjack · 29/01/2023 16:12

He's a child who did something silly that caused an accident. Unfortunately these things happen. Has he even been warned before not to use the skateboard there?
It's not like he did it deliberately so no he shouldn't be.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 15:27

GoldilockMom · 29/01/2023 09:49

The club is not liable.

The club is liable

They have public liability insurance for this reason. The lady was not safe on the property - where the accident happened. She could ask for their liability policy details and claim. No solicitor needed.

Having public liability insurance doesn't make the club automatically liable for every injury that happens on the premises. If, for instance, this kid had fallen over and broken his arm whilst skateboarding on the premises, he would have no claim. Likewise if an adult club member trips over their undone shoelace inside the club,, the insurance won't pay out. Despite the blurb in that insurance publicity you have quoted, it only covers the club for what it's actually or potentially liable for.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 15:11

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 29/01/2023 08:47

The ‘and rightly so’ rather implies that there is debate over whether or not the boy should be punished, which there isn’t.

No - I was simply stating that he had been rightly punished for ignoring the safety warning and going on to injure someone as a result. Nuance is always a problem with written posts and I have misunderstood a couple of posters and apologised to them. You on the other hand, seem to have scrutinised my previous posts looking to criticise, and have misinterpreted my replies to other posters. The difference is that you have resorted to insults like ‘hard of thinking’ and ‘hypocrisy’, and at one point accuse me of harassment of a child because I don’t agree with the suggestion that the protestors are a ‘baying mob’ and should have their memberships cancelled. If, as seems to be the case, the boy has had a fair hearing and a suitable punishment, then surely the club can at least take the time to explain that to any parents who still have concerns. I have a much right as anyone else to express my opinion on a public forum without having my posts trolled.

The problem is that there are limits to how far the club can discuss the personal affairs of a child member and their decisions with regard to that child with other adults, particularly people who seem to think they know better than those in charge at the club despite not knowing the facts. If these particular club members have made an assumption that the club hasn't followed a fair process and won't accept that fact without having it explained to them, there does have to be a question mark about whether their continued membership is appropriate. After all, this is a sports club which needs to teach people that they don't argue with the ref.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 15:02

SkippyKangeroo · 29/01/2023 08:22

I wouldn't class a person being in hospital having an operation on a broken bone, as 'nothing '.

If my mother landed in hospital due to the careless, dangerous actions of a 12 year old who refused to listen to people in charge, I certainly wouldn't be going down the 'Ah well, boys will be boys' route.

You do, of course, know perfectly well that "nothing" did not relate to the injury but to the lack of evidence for your assertions that the boy was entitled or selfish, or that anyone on this thread wants him to be mollycoddled. This boy ignored what he was told on one occasion in a year. He did a stupid, careless thing and deserves to be punished. But none of that justifies you making up the facts about him.

Mark19735 · 29/01/2023 14:52

We don't punish people for what might have happened. We don't even punish them for what actually happened. We punish them for their behaviours, not the consequences of those behaviours. If their behaviour is unlawful, then the law prescribes the appropriate punishment. If it is not unlawful, then there is no requirement, or justification, for any punishment whatsoever.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 14:52

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 23:04

“Agree. This attitude seems to be more and more prevalent in society. No one is prepared to take personal responsibility for their actions and there is always a queue of people willing to find any excuse to blame someone other than the person who is actually responsible - in this case the child. Yes, he’s 12, yes he was careless and didn’t actually mean to hurt anyone. And probably, hopefully, he will learn from this experience. But I think the point is that if he had done as he was told in the first place no one would have been hurt. But hey - better to blame the victim for not expecting a skateboard to come at her inside a building, than actually apply a punishment to the child that actually teaches him something.”

What queue of people? I think there has been one person on this thread who suggested there could be an element of blame from the victim, and even then it's only on a possible contributory negligence basis. One person doesn't constitute a queue. And no-one has suggested the child should not be punished.

So what is your excuse for making up the facts to suit your prejudices?

Letti9 · 29/01/2023 14:40

I would like to put this into perspective: "he was skateboarding knowing it wasn't allowed, knock the grandma down, she fell on the head creating injury which lead her to pass away later in the hospital " I know that is not luckly what happened but could have been the outcome, and people would ve answer differently in this thread. For me it's YABU.

WendyAndClyde · 29/01/2023 14:34

Probably even more annoying for the child concerned as he is apparently paying money to more than one teacher.

So did their pocket money go up in order to pay this second teacher, or did the other teacher get less in order for the child to pay off two compensation claims now? Or did he get a really big allowance each week that enabled him to be able to pay out compensation? Do the parents keep topping up his pocket money in order to fulfil their child's compensation debts? Sorry, but this makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. 🤷‍♀️

WendyAndClyde · 29/01/2023 14:25

So what if the parents decide to no longer give the child pocket money. Or they can't afford to. Or the child misbehaves and they withhold it. I'm not saying you're lying, justice is increasingly more illogical these days, but there's more holes in this idea of justice than a watering can. Some sort of community work, that's logical and makes sense. Or being suspended, expelled, all those options that can be used. Or if the teacher needs compensation, then it comes out of the schools insurance.

ancientgran · 29/01/2023 13:38

WendyAndClyde · 29/01/2023 13:30

So in that case, it's really the parents that are paying it, as the givers of pocket money. Sounds a bit weird.

If they give the child pocketmoney I suppose it becomes the child's money. All I know is that is what happened, I have no reason to suppose the teacher was lying. He was complaining about how pathetic it is that he will be getting pence per week for years and then presumably a higher amount when the child starts work. Probably even more annoying for the child concerned as he is apparently paying money to more than one teacher.

WendyAndClyde · 29/01/2023 13:30

ancientgran · 29/01/2023 13:25

Children can pay compensation, I know a teacher who was hurt by a child who "lost it" and the school policy was to call the policy, it went to court and the child is paying compensation. He loses his pocketmoney but it will take years to pay it all off.

So in that case, it's really the parents that are paying it, as the givers of pocket money. Sounds a bit weird.