Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Patineur · 30/01/2023 09:56

ancientgran · 30/01/2023 09:40

More ridiculous exaggaration. Do you know what a lynch mob is? How insulting to people who have been murdered by lynch mobs to compare them to a disobedient child getting appropriate consequences for causing a serious injury.

Don't be silly. No-one for one moment believes I thought the adults literally wanted to kill the boy.

Tell me, if you're talking to someone who is in a hurry and they say "I really must fly", do you say to them "Don't be ridiculous, you can't fly, you haven't got wings"? Or if they say "It's blowing a gale out there", do you say "Nonsense, it's only 38 km per hour, it's got to be 62 before it's a gale"?

If you can't deal with the use of metaphor and figurative speech in language, maybe discussion forums aren't for you.

ButterCrackers · 30/01/2023 09:55

Patineur · 30/01/2023 09:46

It has been explained a number of times on this thread. Parents can't be liable for the actions of their children, the boy himself could be liable but there is no point in suing someone who has no money. The club has discharged its duties by having a rule against this conduct, reminding the boy of the rule, and sanctioning him when he disobeyed it. The best lawyer in the world can't change the law.

Parents aren’t liable but the boy is because he is 12years. His parents might have insurance that includes their son. The Injured lady has three years to claim and the ruling can be made for six years against the minor so at the minimum when the child is 18 years and liable. The club told the boy of the rules but the accident took place on their property. They will have insurance. There is a lot a lawyer can look at. Think if it was you and you couldn’t work and had medical costs and couldn’t drive or cycle and had to adapt your house (even with the nhs there are costs). You would look to get compensation because you’d be out pocket and suffering. A compensation lawyer is the way to go for checking all of this.

Patineur · 30/01/2023 09:49

ancientgran · 30/01/2023 09:37

Cast into the darkness? Seriously not being able to play a sport is not being cast into the darkness.

At the moment it seems like he hasn't even had to miss one session of this sport, it would be interesting to know what the consequences have been for him. We know what they are for the innocent victim

OK, it's flowery language, but the parents want him chucked out of the club and away from their cherubs. There's nothing indicating that he hasn't had to miss any sessions.

People seem to be reluctant to answer the question why other parents are deemed to know more about what is appropriate than the people who actually run the club.

Patineur · 30/01/2023 09:46

ButterCrackers · 30/01/2023 09:38

Do point out why legal action would be doomed. The kid is 12years- I suppose that he lives with his parents. The lady was injured and required an operation . I suppose recovery is unknown and could be less than 100% m. Perhaps she won’t be able to do her job and/need medical care isn’t all off the nhs. All adds up to a claim. A compensation lawyer would be able to determine what to do.

It has been explained a number of times on this thread. Parents can't be liable for the actions of their children, the boy himself could be liable but there is no point in suing someone who has no money. The club has discharged its duties by having a rule against this conduct, reminding the boy of the rule, and sanctioning him when he disobeyed it. The best lawyer in the world can't change the law.

JusteanBiscuits · 30/01/2023 09:46

The owners of the building will have Public Liability insurance, whether the building is owned by the club or not.

It sounds like this kid doesn't come from a good, supportive background, and isn't being taught the greatest lessons at home. Many MANY studies have shown how good club sports are, especially for young men / boys, in preventing future law breaking and similar issues. He is 12. A child. Children don't always make the best decisions. Yes, somewhere in the world a 12 year old will be out working to support his family - that is an awful, and horrible position and should not, ever, be held up as a positive thing. 12 year olds make stupid decisions. They are not adults. There is a reason they're not considered adults. Their decision making processes are, frankly, pretty terrible at that age still. That's why as parents we feel like we're constantly reminding them to shower, do their home work, make sure they go to bed on time etc etc etc. In any other thread here we would be constantly reminded that their decision making processes aren't fully formed - they don't, by law, have capacity and there is a reason for that.

Some of you all need to stop and remember this is a CHILD. A child.

ancientgran · 30/01/2023 09:40

Patineur · 30/01/2023 09:31

I think it's pretty obvious. However:

I posted something that said, in summary, that 12 year olds can be both defiant and stupid and don't think through the consequences of their actions. I also answered your question about the possible reasons why some parents might want this one expelled permanently. And I pointed out that the club had known all about the relevant facts in on the punishment and asked why the opinion of a very small number of parents should outweigh that.
he opinion of a couple of lynch mob members outweigh that?

In response, you said:

"@Patineur so that excuses the consequences, because ‘boys will be boys’. Ok"

Thus stating that I though all of that meant that this boy should be excused of all consequences. Which isn't remotely a logical conclusion from my post, nor is it substantiated by anything else I have written on this thread. Your statement that I had said all of that excuses the consequences was fictional, so you were making things up.

HTH.

More ridiculous exaggaration. Do you know what a lynch mob is? How insulting to people who have been murdered by lynch mobs to compare them to a disobedient child getting appropriate consequences for causing a serious injury.

ButterCrackers · 30/01/2023 09:38

Patineur · 30/01/2023 09:33

It has been pointed out numerous times on here that any legal action against the club is likely to be doomed to failure.

The club didn't excuse this boy for his misdemeanours. Have you not read OP's posts?

Do point out why legal action would be doomed. The kid is 12years- I suppose that he lives with his parents. The lady was injured and required an operation . I suppose recovery is unknown and could be less than 100% m. Perhaps she won’t be able to do her job and/need medical care isn’t all off the nhs. All adds up to a claim. A compensation lawyer would be able to determine what to do.

ancientgran · 30/01/2023 09:37

Patineur · 29/01/2023 23:12

@WinterFoxes, I don't understand why you and others disagreeing with OP persist in banging on with "there should be consequences". Of course there should. Neither OP nor anyone else suggests otherwise, so I'm not sure who you think you are arguing with on that. The question was whether the club should give in to what ultimately turns out to be a tiny number of vociferous parents who want a 12 year old child to be cast into outer darkness.

Cast into the darkness? Seriously not being able to play a sport is not being cast into the darkness.

At the moment it seems like he hasn't even had to miss one session of this sport, it would be interesting to know what the consequences have been for him. We know what they are for the innocent victim

Patineur · 30/01/2023 09:33

Ifeelsuchafool · 30/01/2023 00:33

I think grandmother should sue club for failing to enforce health and safety rules, thus allowing the incident to occur; perpetrator should be expelled.
Sorry, but an old lady has suffered a serious injury which, as someone pointed out, could very well alter the quality of an elderly person's life significantly.
I'm fed up of the amount of leeway youngsters are given these days. They need to learn to behave and obey rules and they won't if they're forever being excused for their misdemeanours.

It has been pointed out numerous times on here that any legal action against the club is likely to be doomed to failure.

The club didn't excuse this boy for his misdemeanours. Have you not read OP's posts?

Patineur · 30/01/2023 09:31

Fuckthatguy · 30/01/2023 00:12

@Patineur

Your unsubstantiated statement of course:

’you're making things up. Again’

I think it's pretty obvious. However:

I posted something that said, in summary, that 12 year olds can be both defiant and stupid and don't think through the consequences of their actions. I also answered your question about the possible reasons why some parents might want this one expelled permanently. And I pointed out that the club had known all about the relevant facts in on the punishment and asked why the opinion of a very small number of parents should outweigh that.
he opinion of a couple of lynch mob members outweigh that?

In response, you said:

"@Patineur so that excuses the consequences, because ‘boys will be boys’. Ok"

Thus stating that I though all of that meant that this boy should be excused of all consequences. Which isn't remotely a logical conclusion from my post, nor is it substantiated by anything else I have written on this thread. Your statement that I had said all of that excuses the consequences was fictional, so you were making things up.

HTH.

ButterCrackers · 30/01/2023 09:17

Cileymyrus · 30/01/2023 09:07

The best place for these kids to “learn to behave and obey rules” is in organised activities such as sports clubs.

so removing that from this child means he is less likely to be exposed to an environment where he learns how to work within behaviour boundaries.

it’s well known that kids who participate in sports are less likely to get into trouble. So he should be punished, but allowed to continue.

Well the sports club membership he has now hasn’t taught him respect for rules. Once the injured person sues for compensation if they can’t work or if they won’t recover full mobility and if they have medical expenses I doubt the club will want him.

Mark19735 · 30/01/2023 09:09

Not nice, is it @EasterIsland - when people make broad-brush assumptions with limited information and very little nuance? Now perhaps try and apply that insight to the child. For anyone upset by the thought that behaviours don't appear to have consequences, I wonder why it's never their behaviours that should be subject to scrutiny? Far too many people preferring to participate in a pile-on to vilify a child, rather than providing a positive example by showing empathy for an injured person. Disgusting.

Cileymyrus · 30/01/2023 09:07

Ifeelsuchafool · 30/01/2023 00:33

I think grandmother should sue club for failing to enforce health and safety rules, thus allowing the incident to occur; perpetrator should be expelled.
Sorry, but an old lady has suffered a serious injury which, as someone pointed out, could very well alter the quality of an elderly person's life significantly.
I'm fed up of the amount of leeway youngsters are given these days. They need to learn to behave and obey rules and they won't if they're forever being excused for their misdemeanours.

The best place for these kids to “learn to behave and obey rules” is in organised activities such as sports clubs.

so removing that from this child means he is less likely to be exposed to an environment where he learns how to work within behaviour boundaries.

it’s well known that kids who participate in sports are less likely to get into trouble. So he should be punished, but allowed to continue.

WhatNoRaisins · 30/01/2023 08:13

To be fair I'd imagine the older you get the more aware you are that broken bones aren't always something you just bounce back from.

EasterIsland · 30/01/2023 08:09

But then, I wonder how the AIBU voting splits by age. I'd hazard a guess that there would be a fairly clear delineation by year-of-birth, with the 36% baying mob being disproportionally made up of the age group sometimes known as boomers, or gammons. The tendency to vilify the vulnerable, and blame others for any setbacks, runs strong in that cohort.

Well, ageism is rife - pretty normal in fact - on MN, but this takes the biscuit. Nasty and invoking offensive stereotypes. Congratulations @Mark19735 you‘ve raised the bar!

Ifeelsuchafool · 30/01/2023 00:33

I think grandmother should sue club for failing to enforce health and safety rules, thus allowing the incident to occur; perpetrator should be expelled.
Sorry, but an old lady has suffered a serious injury which, as someone pointed out, could very well alter the quality of an elderly person's life significantly.
I'm fed up of the amount of leeway youngsters are given these days. They need to learn to behave and obey rules and they won't if they're forever being excused for their misdemeanours.

Fuckthatguy · 30/01/2023 00:12

@Patineur

Your unsubstantiated statement of course:

’you're making things up. Again’

Patineur · 30/01/2023 00:04

@Patineur would you care to elaborate?

Elaborate what?

Patineur · 30/01/2023 00:03

ButterCrackers · 29/01/2023 23:18

It’s what I would do so that as my future medical costs/equipment were covered and in case of not being able to work.

Would you do it even if it was explained to you (as it has been on this thread) that you probably wouldn't win anything and risked having to pay the other side's costs?

If you're in the UK, there's no reason to think medical costs won't be covered anyway.

Blufelt · 30/01/2023 00:03

ancientgran · 29/01/2023 13:25

Children can pay compensation, I know a teacher who was hurt by a child who "lost it" and the school policy was to call the policy, it went to court and the child is paying compensation. He loses his pocketmoney but it will take years to pay it all off.

I’ll take “things that never happened” for ten points please. Children don’t pay compensation. They certainly don’t get an order for compensation enacted against their future earnings!

Blufelt · 29/01/2023 23:56

If I was that person I would be taking action against the club and the child’s parents, who are responsible for their child
It’s been pointed out several times that the club isn’t liable, parents aren’t liable for their child’s actions, the legal fees for the case would be huge and the only compensation anyone is likely to get is whatever the kid has in his piggy bank.

Fuckthatguy · 29/01/2023 23:30

@Mark19735 for the purposes of your straw poll - you’re way off by several generations actually. Assume as I consider expulsion acceptable, I fall into the ‘baying for blood’ category.

You have me mildly curious now too.

@Patineur would you care to elaborate?

I for one, would like to understand why these parents are boycotting.

As for your translation request, please do excuse me, I meant to say:

‘I for one, am an advocate of consequences, and as the OP asked, I as did many others on this thread felt that expulsion is an acceptable one, considering the minimal context provided.’

No need for rudeness.

Sugarfree23 · 29/01/2023 23:28

@ButterCrackers well best of luck.

Highly unlikely that the clubs PI insurance would pay out. Although it happened on club premises its unlikely anyone could prove the club were negligent.

And taking a 12 year old to court, would probably be laughed out the court, there is the sum of his GoHenry card £10.50

ButterCrackers · 29/01/2023 23:18

Patineur · 29/01/2023 23:08

Do RTFT. It's been explained rather often why suing is probably not going to get this person anywhere.

It’s what I would do so that as my future medical costs/equipment were covered and in case of not being able to work.

Patineur · 29/01/2023 23:12

@WinterFoxes, I don't understand why you and others disagreeing with OP persist in banging on with "there should be consequences". Of course there should. Neither OP nor anyone else suggests otherwise, so I'm not sure who you think you are arguing with on that. The question was whether the club should give in to what ultimately turns out to be a tiny number of vociferous parents who want a 12 year old child to be cast into outer darkness.