Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 18:05

Flamingogirl08 · 27/01/2023 18:01

He's 12 🙄.

A telling off and maybe lose some privileges or maybe a suspension.

Expelled for being silly at 12 yrs old?

Being ‘silly’ resulted in a broken arm for an elderly lady. Not silly for her is it ? The punishment should teach him that actions have consequences and should match the consequences that that lady has to suffer.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 18:05

FriedEggChocolate · 27/01/2023 17:01

@SnarkyBag but "he hit her hard enough to break her arm" sounds like there was great impact which, with underlying conditions, there may not have been. It's just that the end result was the arm being broken.

Yes, he still skateboarded, yes, he still lost control of it.

You can break an arm on falling without being hit at all, simply by virtue of putting a hand out to save yourself.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 18:03

FriedEggChocolate · 27/01/2023 16:54

Are there any mitigating factors for the victim e.g. osteoperosis? Would his mother have broken her arm had the same thing happened with her as the victim?

I'd focus on banning the skateboard, a letter of apology to the victim, and maybe something like cleaning the entrance hall weekly for a month, not banning him completely.

Since when is a medical condition a mitigating factor ? The skateboard had already been banned - he was told not to ride inside the building, ignored it and then caused a serious injury. This was entirely avoidable if he’d done as he was told and understood why he was told not to do it - because it’s dangerous. What health conditions his victims suffers from are entirely irrelevant - and if she had osteoporosis she would have been advised to be careful, but would she really be expecting a kid who is old enough to know better, to come barrelling through a reception area on a skateboard ?

Actions have consequences and at 12 he’s old enough to understand that. A letter of apology is easy, so is making him clean the entrance for a month. Banning him completely takes away something of value to him and sends the message that what he did was unacceptable, so he has to suffer the consequences, just as his victim does.

PriamFarrl · 27/01/2023 18:01

ancientgran · 27/01/2023 17:08

If you were there picking up your nephew you'd be referred to as an aunt, or picking up your own child you'd be a mother. This lady happened to be a grandmother picking up her grandchild.

Woman can exist as independent people and not just in relation to other people.

She could have just been referred to as ‘a woman’.

Ottil · 27/01/2023 18:01

He's lucky to have your support OP.

I'm on the side of some form of consequence, maybe a suspension, but ultimately not expulsion. He was in the wrong, but he did not mean to hurt anyone. This is very different to starting a fight or causing trouble with deliberate intent.

If expelling him could have a disproportionately negative effect on his life as he grows into a teenager and young adult, then that should be a factor. 12 year old boys can be thoughtless, careless, etc. but the OP has repeated that he's a nice kid and not malicious.

I'm all for giving kids - especially those who really do need them - the opportunity to do better.

Flamingogirl08 · 27/01/2023 18:01

IDontCareMatthew · 27/01/2023 17:38

No

It was always an accident waiting to happen hence the 'no skateboard' rules

He chose to break the rules

No accident

He's 12 🙄.

A telling off and maybe lose some privileges or maybe a suspension.

Expelled for being silly at 12 yrs old?

SnarkyBag · 27/01/2023 18:00

SmartHome · 27/01/2023 17:56

oh FGS, it was an accident, he's a kid. He should be heavily reprimanded, say sorry to the lady and not do it again. He was presumably just leaving th ebuilding and got on it oo early - much lik epeople that light up their fags as they are leaving a building and blow it back into my face. Annoying, but not malicious.

So much irrelevant detail, the age of the woman and the fact that she is a Grandma is completely irrelevant, as is the eliteness of the club, or not. I am a woman in my fifties, not a Grandmother but what difference does that make. If a 12 year old accidentally banged into me, doing something he shouldn't really have been doing and coused me to fall awkwardly and break my arm - after all, that was unlucky, most people would just be bruised - then I would be annoyed but would be perfectly happy with a card, bunch of flowers maybe and an apology. he shouldn't be kicked out for an accident.

Ahh yes I’ve lost count of the amount of times I’ve been bowled over by premature fag smoke and broke arm.

thegreatestshowww · 27/01/2023 18:00

What sport is this OP? I can’t find anywhere you’ve mentioned it so not sure I’ve missed it but that makes a big difference in my opinion. For some sports it is crucial that players can be trusted to follow the rules and do what they are told. Things like- gymnasts not being allowed to do huge tumbling passes unless in the gym with the proper safety equipment, karate athletes not being allowed to do tricks outside of karate, rugby players not being allowed to do big rugby tackles outside of rugby. For some sports there’s an element of discipline and trust involved and a 12 year old who can’t follow a basic instruction and ended up hurting someone wouldn’t be trustworthy enough in some peoples opinions. I know it’s not horse riding, but that’s a sport I’m directly involved in and can be dangerous if children don’t do what they are told and follow the rules. A child who continually did something they are old enough to know is dangerous and were also told not to do, but did it anyway, would absolutely be asked to leave the riding school as it’s a dangerous enough sport never mind when you can trust the child not to follow instructions. Harsh, but got to think of everyone’s safety.

I think permanent exclusion is quite harsh and providing there hasn’t been prior trouble before this; it would be better to temporarily exclude and give him the chance to win the trust back. But I don’t know, maybe there’s other stuff before this and maybe this is the straw that broke the camels back (or the grandmas arm) and they just don’t want him back. It’s a tough lesson but he shouldn’t have been behaving dangerously and a broken arm in an older person is an awful injury.

Psychonabike · 27/01/2023 18:00

@ancientgran

I'm sorry that you've had long term pain.

Doesn't change the fact that it's a 12 year old boy who made a mistake.

Expelling him is disproportionate to his actual crime. We don't sentence adults based on the outcome of the crimes; we take account of intent. Which often means a sentence is spent before the victim has stopped suffering. Not only was the intent lacking here, but it's a child of only 12. Expelling him (or in your case helping with chores for 35+ years) means he would be punished more than an adult for a similar type offence.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 17:59

Notjusta · 27/01/2023 16:53

Honestly amazed how many people are saying it's an accident. I am sure he didn't mean to do it, but I am not sure it counts as a genuine accident if you are doing something as stupid as skateboarding inside a reception area!

If he didn't intend it, it's an accident. However, it's up in the recklessness/gross negligence category and not just "one of those things" so repercussions are justified.

FrostyNethers · 27/01/2023 17:59

Disgusting of the parents to organise a protest over an accident caused by a 12 year old boy.

A fixed term suspension is entirely appropriate due to the fact that an avoidable injury was caused but it was still accidental and not deliberate. It’s not like he physically attacked someone. OP said he was scooting on the skateboard (my DS boards so I know what that looks like) so hardly speeding along on it at 20 mph per hour. Of course he shouldn’t have been hence the punishment.

I take he may be from a different social demographic from the other elite parents. Could that be the reason for the protest? If do, I’d make sure whoever was in charge with the club had very strong words with the protesting parents and made it clear the police would be called if there was any public disorder or intimidation.

diddl · 27/01/2023 17:59

How is it an accident?

If he hadn't been doing what he had been told not to do it wouldn't have happened.

AnotherSpare · 27/01/2023 17:58

"leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building"
"several minor reprimands."

I think he should have been expelled from the club. If he had no previous reprimands perhaps it would be different.

StormSeason · 27/01/2023 17:58

Right?!
These comments are absolutely blowing my mind.And people wonder why kids today are so disrespectful,it's because they have no boundaries or consequences at home.😳

IDontWantToBeAPie · 27/01/2023 17:58

He's a child. They make mistakes. I'd expect and apology to the woman and for him to not be allowed his skateboard ever at practice.

SmartHome · 27/01/2023 17:56

oh FGS, it was an accident, he's a kid. He should be heavily reprimanded, say sorry to the lady and not do it again. He was presumably just leaving th ebuilding and got on it oo early - much lik epeople that light up their fags as they are leaving a building and blow it back into my face. Annoying, but not malicious.

So much irrelevant detail, the age of the woman and the fact that she is a Grandma is completely irrelevant, as is the eliteness of the club, or not. I am a woman in my fifties, not a Grandmother but what difference does that make. If a 12 year old accidentally banged into me, doing something he shouldn't really have been doing and coused me to fall awkwardly and break my arm - after all, that was unlucky, most people would just be bruised - then I would be annoyed but would be perfectly happy with a card, bunch of flowers maybe and an apology. he shouldn't be kicked out for an accident.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 17:56

Lockheart · 27/01/2023 16:45

I've never heard of anyone being expelled from anywhere for an accident.

The use of grandmother is irrelevant, unless she's his grandmother.

He shouldn't have had the skateboard but that's a separate thing to the accident. He should be reprimanded for having the skateboard, not punished for the accident.

Clearly the fact that he shouldn't have had the skateboard is in no way a separate thing from the accident. It wouldn't have happened if he hadn't been on the skateboard, and presumably one of the main reasons for the rule is the risk of accidents.

That said, I don't think expulsion is warranted, though something like a 3 month ban could be appropriate.

diddl · 27/01/2023 17:56

It doesn't really set a good example does it-skateboard inside the building even though you've been told not to.

Knock someone over & injure them but you're still welcome.

Sounds like a shit club to me!

StormSeason · 27/01/2023 17:55

12!
He is not a toddler!
If he can't follow rules by that age then Idk what.And to top it off he injured another person in the process.She even required surgery!
This right here is the reason children act the way they do today,there are ZERO consequences for there behavior.
I'm absolutely SHOCKED at these comments.
What if it was your parent or grandmother?You would be cool with a little "2 minute time out" and that's all?Or is that even too harsh??

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 17:50

Cileymyrus · 27/01/2023 16:46

Was he in the building or outside it leaving? It’s not clear.

he’s 12. I wouldn’t be kicking him out. Written warning with expulsion if he’s caught again.

possibly a skateboard ban for him anywhere on the grounds.

Leaving the main entrance, so I took it that it was inside the building.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/01/2023 17:50

I'd focus on banning the skateboard, a letter of apology to the victim, and maybe something like cleaning the entrance hall weekly for a month, not banning him completely

He'd already been told not to use the skateboard and took no notice, a letter of apology means nothing, and since OP's said some of the family are troublemakers I can almost guarantee an excuse would be produced for him not to do the chores

The strong views of the other parents may suggest they're pretty fed up of the boy already, so it may be best for everyone if he leaves

AdventFridgeOfShame · 27/01/2023 17:48

You have a boy over the age of legal responsibility, skateboarding inside a building, I'm sure this could be argued to be reckless behaviour. He knocks over a woman in their sixties, occasioning actual bodily harm, a broken arm is neither transient or trifling.

I hope the club has excellent insurance.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 27/01/2023 17:48

Oh is this allowed then? I didn’t realise you could skate inside a building, injure someone and then it all be ok if you’re a nice boy/bit sorry. Gosh he must be suffering terribly from the guilt eh? Bet the lady with the broken arm will be over the moon with an apology. Its great that you can just say it’s an “accident”. After all, it wasn’t his fault was it … oh, hang on 🤔

pocketvenuss · 27/01/2023 17:47

@Yeahrightthen You are comparing a 12yo riding a skateboard indoors to someone driving along a pavement?

Ok if my previous example didn't meet your approval how about "if you yeeted stones off a bridge and they smashed a windscreen, it's not ac accident. It's a crime.

IsItThough · 27/01/2023 17:46

He should have a reprimand that is appropriate to the transgression and sincerely apologise to the person concerned. Suspension for a couple of games and blanket skateboard ban on grounds. Part of the culpability for the accident lies with the organisers for not enforcing the no skateboard policy more effectively.

Other "boycotting parents" need to have it made clear to them that their interference will not be tolerated - ie their children could face sanctions for not turning up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread