Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
NameChange005 · 27/01/2023 18:39

bossyrossy · 27/01/2023 18:28

Referring to the woman as a grandmother is relevant as it shows that she is of mature years and possibly elderly. Broken bones when you are old can be very serious and even fatal in some cases. The boy should be made to understand the seriousness of his actions, made to apologise to the woman and given a six month suspension from the club.

I know someone who became a grandmother at 39....
Although that is on the very young end of Grandmother spectrum, admittedly! (I'm only pointing this out to say that it's a bit irrelevant, as she could have been 40 or 80 and we can't assume that this person was frail)

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 18:38

Patineur · 27/01/2023 18:31

Why would he learn that a rule doesn't apply to him if he's been punished for breaking the rule?

Some of the posts on here are quite disturbing in the way they demonise children.

FFS !! No one is demonising children. If a child is reckless (and skateboarding inside a building was recklessness) and seriously injures someone to the point where they need surgery after ignoring warnings about his behaviour, what do you think should happen ? Do we pat him on the head and say ‘run along son, we know you didn’t mean it’. Or do we find a punishment that teaches him that actions have consequences, and that goes for him as well as his victim. What I find disturbing is the amount of support for the child at the expense of the victim.

Asurvivor · 27/01/2023 18:37

I voted YANBU from your first post OP, but with the latest posts am beginning to change my mind.

I think you are downplaying the seriousness of the accident because you are fond of the kid - a broken arm for an older person is a big deal, it may not ever heal properly as for younger person and being knocked over like that may lead to a loss of confidence / fear of future falls.

I think that is why parents are reacting - and not because of any competitiveness towards him compared to their own children. You don’t do him any favours by dismissing their concerns.

HashtagShitShop · 27/01/2023 18:37

The boy should not be expelled, he has learnt a hugely graphic lesson about consequences. He should in my opinion make a face to face heartfelt apology and give up his half term to help the lady who is in pain and has restricted ability to use her arm doing jobs for her

Johnnysgirl · 27/01/2023 18:37

OhmygodDont · 27/01/2023 18:35

Well done. I’ll give you a slow hand clap for that.

The important things are how somebody write or types clearly not how they behave.

Jesus, Patineur there are rules and rules Confused. Bit below the belt.

PriamFarrl · 27/01/2023 18:36

lieselotte · 27/01/2023 18:29

My mum is in her 80s and can outpace most people Grin

My mum is 70 and runs 7 miles a day. She’s not a grandmother though.m, so who knows how we would know how to feel about her if she broke an arm.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 18:36

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 27/01/2023 17:48

Oh is this allowed then? I didn’t realise you could skate inside a building, injure someone and then it all be ok if you’re a nice boy/bit sorry. Gosh he must be suffering terribly from the guilt eh? Bet the lady with the broken arm will be over the moon with an apology. Its great that you can just say it’s an “accident”. After all, it wasn’t his fault was it … oh, hang on 🤔

Obviously it isn't allowed. Did you miss the bit where OP said the club had punished the boy?

saraclara · 27/01/2023 18:35

lieselotte · 27/01/2023 18:25

It was a broken arm. Not a hip fracture.

It required an operation so was clearly a complex fracture. I'm her age and despite being fitter than most, annoyingly, I find it takes a lot longer to get over the simplest of injuries. I would feel very pessimistic about a complex arm fracture resolving completely, now.

OhmygodDont · 27/01/2023 18:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Well done. I’ll give you a slow hand clap for that.

The important things are how somebody write or types clearly not how they behave.

BellePeppa · 27/01/2023 18:34

Why do news reports always call someone a grandmother as if it automatically means something age wise even if it’s completely irrelevant to the story. I have a relative who was a grandmother at 38 and I’m sure there are lots of ‘grannies’ in their 40s. I don’t mean specifically this article but it does annoy the hell out of me.

barms90 · 27/01/2023 18:33

What is expelling him going to achieve??? He got on his skateboard probably a fraction too soon at the entrance. What if he had been told no running and had run into her??? Not sure what the sport is but he should be made to come to trainings and matches and have to sit and watch for a period of time.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 18:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EpicChaos · 27/01/2023 18:33

picklemewalnuts · 27/01/2023 16:57

At 40, and knocked off my feet and a broken arm, I'd be feeling pretty damn vulnerable.

The 12 yr old could also be taller than the 40 year old, if we're stretching possibilities to see what happens.

Indeed so.
If a fully healthy 40 year old breaks a bone, then it's been a very bad collision with the skateboarder/floor and depending on what surgery was necessary, the after effects such as arthritis/limited/restricted movement, etc., could be felt for very many more years than they would in an older person, so any compo paid out will reflect that.

NameChange005 · 27/01/2023 18:33

Was he using the skateboard inside (or literally out the door to outside) or out? Not clear from the post.

My initial reaction was that permanent expulsion is harsh for an accident but suspension from the club for x amount of time may be fair. It was an accident, although caused by what sounds like reckless behaviour.

ancientgran · 27/01/2023 18:32

Psychonabike · 27/01/2023 18:00

@ancientgran

I'm sorry that you've had long term pain.

Doesn't change the fact that it's a 12 year old boy who made a mistake.

Expelling him is disproportionate to his actual crime. We don't sentence adults based on the outcome of the crimes; we take account of intent. Which often means a sentence is spent before the victim has stopped suffering. Not only was the intent lacking here, but it's a child of only 12. Expelling him (or in your case helping with chores for 35+ years) means he would be punished more than an adult for a similar type offence.

I disagree that we don't sentence based on outcome. If you punch someone only intending to give him a bloody nose but he falls, bangs his head and dies you won't be sentenced for giving him a bloody nose.

Do you seriously think going along and tidying up her garden for spring is appropriate? His intent was to do what he wanted without regard to the rules or the outcome, for his sake he needs to learn this can't go on or he will end up in serious trouble.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 18:32

lieselotte · 27/01/2023 18:25

It was a broken arm. Not a hip fracture.

A family member broke her wrist at age 63 and not only did the bones take far longer to knit, she developed arthritis in the joint and has suffered pain ever since. My next door neighbour, in her early 70s fell and broke her shoulder before Christmas. She died a couple of weeks ago from pneumonia which set in as a result of being immobilised while it healed. Broken bones have more serious consequences the older you get, and their ability to heal is affected by underlying health conditions.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 27/01/2023 18:31

I can’t get over the contempt for the injured woman here. What do she just needs to suck it up? Maybe she’s working a minimum wage job and is now out of work? Maybe that arm will play her up for years? Or maybe she thinks he’s a lovely cheeky young’un doing hi jinks how jolly?

Patineur · 27/01/2023 18:31

OhmygodDont · 27/01/2023 17:41

If his allowed to stay what does he learn that another rule doesn’t apply to him. Not only can he skip lessons, not only can he mouth off at refs, he can also actually cause real harm to someone and yet his still allowed because his troubled.

Why would he learn that a rule doesn't apply to him if he's been punished for breaking the rule?

Some of the posts on here are quite disturbing in the way they demonise children.

thegreatestshowww · 27/01/2023 18:31

Patineur · 27/01/2023 18:23

If he's adequately punished and given a tough warning, then it's reasonable to believe that is enough to enable him to learn his lesson; especially if he's a good kid who is already shocked and mortified by the results of his actions. If you always rush to the ultimate sanction, you leave yourself with nowhere to go and and a disaffected child who has lost a chance to learn how to behave properly.

I agree and disagree with you.

I wouldn’t say expulsion is the ultimate sanction- he has already been warned not to do this because it’s dangerous so he had the opportunity to learn not to do something, after being told off.

I think the type of sport matters hugely here like i said in a previous comment. Some sports are dangerous and rely on good behaviour, discipline and trust. At the riding school at our stables he would be asked to leave on the basis of a child who has shown he won’t do what he’s told and caused an injury is simply too much of a liability and risk of causing future injuries. He might learn from this and never do it again, but the risk that he doesn’t and can’t follow instruction again and causes another accident is too dangerous in an already risky sport. A 12 year old is more than old enough to understand this. But in a less risky sport expulsion is perhaps harsh and he should be given another chance to prove himself.

it’s a complex situation for sure!

DanceMonkey19 · 27/01/2023 18:30

I think there should definitely be a consequence, but expulsion is OTT. A suspension plus some other punishment would be appropriate I would think, with it being made clear that any repeat would result in expulsion.

CrapBucket · 27/01/2023 18:29

What does the club code of conduct say?

I am on Team Boy - he should not be expelled and parents shouldn't be able to bully him out.

lieselotte · 27/01/2023 18:29

LadyMary50 · 27/01/2023 18:26

Why presume a “grandmother”was walking slowly.I’m 72 and can out pace people half my age…

My mum is in her 80s and can outpace most people Grin

Everyonehasavoice · 27/01/2023 18:29

LeCarre · 27/01/2023 18:26

Boy should have his skateboard given to a charity shop and be forced to write a handwritten apology to the lady and send her 6 months of his pocket money to buy something. Boy should also spend some of his free time volunteering at something relevant eg care home / Age UK etc.

Not sure kicking him out of the activity helps.

Don’t think a 12yr old will be allowed to volunteer in a care home….I could be wrong…but there are a whole loud of safety issues here

Patineur · 27/01/2023 18:28

Johnnysgirl · 27/01/2023 17:37

Well, he's had several reprimands already, so he clearly doesn't learn from his mistakes very quickly.

He hasn't had reprimands for this sort of behaviour.

Fernie6491 · 27/01/2023 18:28

The OP seems to think the boy shouldn't be expelled. Sounds like other instances of sports people getting done for e.g. drink-driving, drugs or getting into fights.
If they might win trophies for their club, the misdemeanor gets conveniently forgotten, and they are allowed back into the sport for the cachet of winning 'for the club' . It sickens me.