Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Seeingadistance · 27/01/2023 19:13

DaveyJonesLocker · 27/01/2023 16:49

He was doing something dangerous and against the club rules. Someone got seriously hurt as a direct result. He should be expelled.

This.

TheBigWangTheory · 27/01/2023 19:12

Flamingogirl08 · 27/01/2023 16:45

It was an accident of course he shouldn't be expelled

An accident he caused by doing something he shouldn't be doing, that he knew he shouldn't be doing.

Accident doesn't mean you're not responsible. You and I may be in a car accidemt, but if it happened because I was driving my car where I shouldn't, and I knew it, wouldn't I be responsible for that accident?

Ponderingwindow · 27/01/2023 19:12

Reprimands for arguing with the referee are not relevant. That happens in sport. Nor is level of play.

since there was no ongoing behavioral issue, it is hard to see this as more than a one time incident of a 12yo being a 12yo, not listening and ending up with bigger consequences than they realized possible. I would expect most of the punishment to be coming from the parents. Given the positive value of having an activity for a teen, expulsion for a single episode does seem harsh.

BlueBellIris · 27/01/2023 19:12

Wow some of the comments on here - I waiting for posters calling for public flogging to be reintroduced...

He's 12. He did something stupid, but not criminal (for those saying akin to driving offences, if the police had been called to this incident they would have said it was a civil matter).

I am sure he feels bad. Everyone in this club knows about this so he's already been publicly embarrassed.

What purpose does expulsion serve? "Sends out the message if you do something wrong you'll be out", but what sort of "wrong" will that equate to:

  • What happens when a kids running a bit fast and knocks over someone - will they be expelled?
  • What about if that's during the sport itself?
  • What level of injury is going to be the threshold? Broken bone out - sprain suspension?

A suspension is more than adequate - possibly suspended for good behaviour (no minor reprimands for the next 6 months).

Then it's up to the parents how to discipline this child.

The club will be insured and if the lady wants to bring a compensation claim she can (although she may struggle to prove the club was negligent, I think a lot of judges would say this was an accident).

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 27/01/2023 19:12

Some of these replies are incredibly harsh. Do you not have a 12yr olds? Were you never 12yrs old yourselves? 12yr olds do all sorts of silly things and are learning the boundaries of authority all over again as their independence increases.

So, this kid does something silly and impulsive that's in line with things most 12yr olds do and you're all calling for a pretty extreme punishment.

Sure, this time it ended about as badly as it could with someone sustaining a nasty injury but would you all be calling for him to be expelled if he hadn't hit anyone?

strawberry2017 · 27/01/2023 19:12

Shouldn't have been on the skateboard inside.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:12

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:10

He arrived and left the club alone, he was told no skateboarding in the building when he arrived on it.

from the OPs third post.

That doesn't say he was reprimanded for skateboarding in the building. It says he turned up on the skateboard and was reminded that he couldn't ride on it in the building. If the club had any sense, they would have taken the skateboard off him.

AIMummy · 27/01/2023 19:10

His family don't attend the club and are presumably disinterested in his achievements or progress. Perhaps he has no responsible adult fighting his corner and the other parents know this, hence their confidence in being able to get him banned if they make a big enough fuss.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:10

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:05

Where does it say he has done this before and been warned for it?

He arrived and left the club alone, he was told no skateboarding in the building when he arrived on it.

from the OPs third post.

WhereYouLeftIt · 27/01/2023 19:09

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 17:13

wow, you are posting so fast I cant get to the end before adding mine

Here is the current situation

He has been punished - the punishment is not common knowledge, so I wont write it here

He has not been expelled

There is a certain number of parents who are not happy, and are intending to protest, boycott tomorrow

My personal feeling is that is is right that he shouldn't be expelled for a stupid childish act when he didn't mean to harm anyone. But I seem to be in the minority out of the adults associated with this club.

Yes, I think he is a basically good hearted boy, who has the potential to go off the rails without direction in his life, and I am very much in favour of keeping him engaged with his sport

I don't feel I have enough information to say whether I think expulsion would be the appropriate punishment or not. For me, his response would be key - is he genuinely remorseful?

I do think though, that at 12 and having been told no skateboarding in the building, he should have been capable of inferring that the prohibition was safety-related and not just the adults being fun-sponges.

Given that his previous reprimands have been for arguing with the ref (on the pitch) it could be a good lesson for him that rules are for reasons, and are therefore to be followed. But whether he's capable of 'getting' that lesson is likely to be closely tied to genuine remorse, which is why his response to this incident is so important.

ChaToilLeam · 27/01/2023 19:08

If he has been told many times then expulsion is appropriate. He caused serious injury.

If that’s not the case then there should at least be consequences or sanctions. He needs to understand the severity of the situation.

magicthree · 27/01/2023 19:07

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 17:13

wow, you are posting so fast I cant get to the end before adding mine

Here is the current situation

He has been punished - the punishment is not common knowledge, so I wont write it here

He has not been expelled

There is a certain number of parents who are not happy, and are intending to protest, boycott tomorrow

My personal feeling is that is is right that he shouldn't be expelled for a stupid childish act when he didn't mean to harm anyone. But I seem to be in the minority out of the adults associated with this club.

Yes, I think he is a basically good hearted boy, who has the potential to go off the rails without direction in his life, and I am very much in favour of keeping him engaged with his sport

I totally agree with the course of action taken. Yes, he was doing something he was told not to - but don't all kids at some stage? - and it was a genuine accident. He sounds like a nice boy and hopefully has learned something from this. He does need to be able to remain engaged with his sport if he has the potential to go off the rails without direction - anyone with half a brain can see which is the best option there.

The other parents are being dicks.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:06

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:03

Neither, as I've made clear more than once on this thread. Why does it have to be one extreme or the other with nothing in between? We punish him severely but short of outright expulsion, and we make it clear that if there is any repetition he will be out. This is not a child who has a reputation for bad behaviour off the pitch within the club.

I didn’t say punish him severely, I said find a punishment that teaches him that his actions have consequences, for himself as well as his victim. And whether he has a reputation for bad behaviour or not is irrelevant. He had been warned, ignored it, and injured someone as a result. And a lot of people on here are trying to find any excuse to minimise that.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:05

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 18:47

But this is a repeat. He’s been warned and chose to ignore the warning. Whichever way you look at this there are no mitigating circumstances. He ignored the warning and hurt someone. If he was warned previously that any repeat would result in expulsion, then that’s what should happen. Otherwise you’re teaching the child that he can do anything he likes because the adults won’t follow through.

Where does it say he has done this before and been warned for it?

harrassedmumto3 · 27/01/2023 19:05

People going on about it being an accident. Yes, he hadn't knocked into her deliberately, but he had been given prior warning not to skateboard in the lobby.
I wouldn't lose any sleep over him being expelled.

Idontgiveagriffindamn · 27/01/2023 19:04

pocketvenuss · 27/01/2023 18:57

So everyone agrees the lad ignored the rules. Breaking the rules resulted in an unfortunate and entirely preventable incident. The question is what the appropriate sanction should be. No one is 'baying for blood'. They are arguing over suspension, expulsion, apology, and rather bizarrely 'gardening'.

So you don’t think competitive parents demanding a 12 year old is excluded is OTT? I bet the motivation behind it is so their precious child doesn’t have as much completion.
And yes some of the post are ridiculous - like the one comparing it to drink driving 🙄

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:04

autienotnaughty · 27/01/2023 18:58

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy yes an accident because he did not intend to hit someone. He's 12 , very normal to not understand consequences/risk take. Yes there should be a consequence but my point was expulsion is extreme.

Depends on whether the risks and possible consequences were explained to him when he was warned not to ride the skateboard inside the building the first time. If it was, and he ignored it, then it wasn’t an accident, it was a wilful disregard of the safety of others because it interfered with what he wanted himself.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:03

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 18:38

FFS !! No one is demonising children. If a child is reckless (and skateboarding inside a building was recklessness) and seriously injures someone to the point where they need surgery after ignoring warnings about his behaviour, what do you think should happen ? Do we pat him on the head and say ‘run along son, we know you didn’t mean it’. Or do we find a punishment that teaches him that actions have consequences, and that goes for him as well as his victim. What I find disturbing is the amount of support for the child at the expense of the victim.

Neither, as I've made clear more than once on this thread. Why does it have to be one extreme or the other with nothing in between? We punish him severely but short of outright expulsion, and we make it clear that if there is any repetition he will be out. This is not a child who has a reputation for bad behaviour off the pitch within the club.

Rosie492 · 27/01/2023 19:02

It all hinges on: "...was told he is not allowed skateboard in the building" and "has had several minor reprimands," which I understand as: "he ignores instructions and does what he likes!" In other words, he was being disobedient, and not giving a toss about his actions. He should be punished for this, and if that means expulsion, so be it. And why did his parents allow him to take his skateboard there in the first place?! Presumably they have allowed / enabled his seemingly cocky attitude thus far?

saraclara · 27/01/2023 19:01

While I think that a suspension is called for, I am wary of pandering to a WhatsApp baying mob. I would definitely not give in to their demands, so expulsion would not by on my list of punishments.

Do the main players in the WhatsApp group have a connection to the injured woman? Why are they kicking off and thinking that they should be listened to?

BadNomad · 27/01/2023 19:01

autienotnaughty · 27/01/2023 18:58

@Lovelysausagedogscrumpy yes an accident because he did not intend to hit someone. He's 12 , very normal to not understand consequences/risk take. Yes there should be a consequence but my point was expulsion is extreme.

If someone intentionally drinks and drives then hits someone, is that just an "accident" too because they didn't intend to hit someone?

Accidents are unexpected outcomes. Hitting someone while skating on a skateboard in a building is not an unexpected outcome.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:01

DaisyDarker · 27/01/2023 18:56

It was an accident. He was stupid and careless. He should be punished for that but he did not deliberately hurt anyone. He should be expected to feel remorse and to try and make amends to the victim. He should never take his skateboard in the building again.

Beyond that, the only justification for the other parents response is if this is the only part of his behavior that has been caught. We all know of the kids that have done many, many horrible things but they aren't proved etc.

Or the other alternative is that in a sports setting they are deliberately trying to get rid of competition for their kids . I'm assuming from the team description that this is football? If this is the case the coaches need to stamp down hard on the behaviour from other parents now.

I disagree that he didn’t deliberately hurt anyone. He was reprimanded for riding his skateboard inside the building. Presumably it was explained to him how dangerous that could be, and at the age of 12 he should have some appreciation of that. But he chose to ignore the warning, did it again and injured someone badly as a result. So no, not an accident. Not stupid either - I’d use the word ‘wilful’.

Psychonabike · 27/01/2023 19:01

@ancientgran

"I disagree that we don't sentence based on outcome. If you punch someone only intending to give him a bloody nose but he falls, bangs his head and dies you won't be sentenced for giving him a bloody nose."

That's nonsense.
A punch to the face is an intent to cause harm.
Scooting on a skateboard is an intent to ignore a rule he probably (wrongly) thought a bit petty or unimportant. That's the intent. Quite separate from the outcome.
And you're wrong anyway, intent is very significant in law and sentencing.
And as for your comments are making amends by offering some sort of service -that's the basis of community service and restorative justice.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:01

OhmygodDont · 27/01/2023 18:39

She cares more about bad grammar punctuation and incorrect usage of words than a women being actually hurt so I wouldn’t expect her to care for the actual injured women.

Maybe she has one of those children.

And all of that is an outright lie.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:00

Johnnysgirl · 27/01/2023 18:37

Jesus, Patineur there are rules and rules Confused. Bit below the belt.

Not really. The poster assumes this child has learnt nothing from the fact that the club has already punished him, sneers at the fact that he is "troubled", and wants to demonise and punish him further. If you sanctify compliance with the rules, you need to ensure you comply yourself.