Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:23

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:12

That doesn't say he was reprimanded for skateboarding in the building. It says he turned up on the skateboard and was reminded that he couldn't ride on it in the building. If the club had any sense, they would have taken the skateboard off him.

Not ‘reminded’ told that there was no skateboarding inside the building. He ignored it, and the fact that the club didn’t take it off him is not the point. They assumed that as he’d been told not to do it (and presumably why he shouldn’t do it) then he wouldn’t. Niave I grant you, but not the point.

EsmeSusanOgg · 27/01/2023 19:23

Lockheart · 27/01/2023 16:45

I've never heard of anyone being expelled from anywhere for an accident.

The use of grandmother is irrelevant, unless she's his grandmother.

He shouldn't have had the skateboard but that's a separate thing to the accident. He should be reprimanded for having the skateboard, not punished for the accident.

It isn't an accident though, it was carelessness. He was aware he could not use the skateboard inside the building because it could lead to accidents, he then did so. Whilst he obviously didn't intend to hurt someone he was aware that by ignoring the rules he could hurt someone. If someone runs a red light in their car, and hits another car they are at fault and face the consequences even if it is clear they didn't intend to cause harm.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:22

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:19

Well he didn’t learn anything from the warning not to skateboard inside the building the first time he did it, so it’s unfortunate that his lack of respect for the rules resulted in someone getting badly hurt. Not sure whether that counts as not intentional.

There is no statement that he has skateboarded inside the building before

Ottil · 27/01/2023 19:22

magicthree · 27/01/2023 19:07

I totally agree with the course of action taken. Yes, he was doing something he was told not to - but don't all kids at some stage? - and it was a genuine accident. He sounds like a nice boy and hopefully has learned something from this. He does need to be able to remain engaged with his sport if he has the potential to go off the rails without direction - anyone with half a brain can see which is the best option there.

The other parents are being dicks.

This. Compassionate common sense.

There are some bloodthirsty dicks on this thread as well.

ChillysWaterBottle · 27/01/2023 19:21

Tbh if it was my mum or nan whose arm he broke I would want him expelled. A broken arm at that age is no joke. I think downplaying it like some people are doing is awful.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:21

I cant say too much about his family, incase anyone reading this recognises the situation and the boy. They dont attend or support him

That's quite important. If he's found an activity where he has good role models and can learn from the discipline of the sport, and is away from his family's influence, it would be a shame to drive him back to them.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:21

BlueBellIris · 27/01/2023 19:19

@TheBigWangTheory you cause a car accident, you might be held responsible, but in most cases that just means your insurer pays out the othersides damage.

Doctors make mistakes (clinical negligence), many professionals do, they are accidents caused by their mistakes with civil consequences (insurers pay out), but we don't say they are suspended/lose their jobs/get criminal records.

Fair enough if your driving is criminally wrong (dangerous driving), but most accidents, even if your fault, will be considered a civil matter.

If you injure someone as a result of careless or dangerous driving, it won’t be a civil matter, so that argument doesn’t stand up.

OhmygodDont · 27/01/2023 19:20

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:00

Not really. The poster assumes this child has learnt nothing from the fact that the club has already punished him, sneers at the fact that he is "troubled", and wants to demonise and punish him further. If you sanctify compliance with the rules, you need to ensure you comply yourself.

Maybe it was my own troubled upbringing that meant I missed out on certain education such as English means I know how important it is for their to be consequences for actions regardless of the background because just letting children get away with more and more because issues or an or else they might end up even worse doesn’t always help.

Sometimes we need punishments that actually hit our favourite thing rather than pandering too because or else.

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/01/2023 19:19

I think it's one of those situations where objectively it's easy to say he should be forgiven etc but if you know the grandma personally and she's a nice person and the injury has caused her serious problems then it would be easy to think it was a stupid accident that never should have happened what on earth was he doing skateboarding when he'd been told not to .

However....if he gets excluded this might be really bad for him long term and seems disproportionate. Whereas if he makes reparations to the woman that might have more of a positive effect for both in the longer term

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:19

TheGoogleMum · 27/01/2023 19:14

It wasn't intentional and it was unlucky that the grandmother got so hurt. I think he should be punished but not expelled, perhaps with the threat of future expulsion if caught skateboarding inside again (as that suggests he didn't learn anything from the incident)

Well he didn’t learn anything from the warning not to skateboard inside the building the first time he did it, so it’s unfortunate that his lack of respect for the rules resulted in someone getting badly hurt. Not sure whether that counts as not intentional.

Zosime · 27/01/2023 19:19

What happens when a kids running a bit fast and knocks over someone - will they be expelled?

If he's running somewhere he's been told not to run, possibly, depending on the potential consequences.

BlueBellIris · 27/01/2023 19:19

@TheBigWangTheory you cause a car accident, you might be held responsible, but in most cases that just means your insurer pays out the othersides damage.

Doctors make mistakes (clinical negligence), many professionals do, they are accidents caused by their mistakes with civil consequences (insurers pay out), but we don't say they are suspended/lose their jobs/get criminal records.

Fair enough if your driving is criminally wrong (dangerous driving), but most accidents, even if your fault, will be considered a civil matter.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:19

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/01/2023 19:13

What is expelling him going to achieve???

Keeping others at the group safe from someone who's repeatedly chosen ("previous reprimands") not to do as he's told, to the point where someone's now been seriously injured?

It's noticeable that OP's said nothing about the lad's reaction at the time, whether he stopped to help the injured lady, etc.. I'm assuming nothing, but given her preference for him to remain in the group I'd have expected that to be included if it happened

Previous reprimands have been in relation to minor issues on the pitch. I suspect most of the members of the team have attracted minor reprimands, they're teenage boys, after all. There is no suggestion that that he has chosen to disobey outside that context, whether repeatedly or at all.

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 19:18

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/01/2023 19:13

What is expelling him going to achieve???

Keeping others at the group safe from someone who's repeatedly chosen ("previous reprimands") not to do as he's told, to the point where someone's now been seriously injured?

It's noticeable that OP's said nothing about the lad's reaction at the time, whether he stopped to help the injured lady, etc.. I'm assuming nothing, but given her preference for him to remain in the group I'd have expected that to be included if it happened

His reaction would be best described as shocked, but he was actually whisked off by club officials into the office immediately, as in within seconds, so he didn't really have any time to respond beyond that. I haven't had any contact with him personally this week, so again, I cant really say. I hear he has accepted his punishment. I hope I will see him tomorrow

I cant say too much about his family, incase anyone reading this recognises the situation and the boy. They dont attend or support him

OP posts:
godmum56 · 27/01/2023 19:18

TheBigWangTheory · 27/01/2023 19:12

An accident he caused by doing something he shouldn't be doing, that he knew he shouldn't be doing.

Accident doesn't mean you're not responsible. You and I may be in a car accidemt, but if it happened because I was driving my car where I shouldn't, and I knew it, wouldn't I be responsible for that accident?

responsible means an appropriate consequence though, not overkill. I think @Ponderingwindow has nailed it....and its one of the resons we don't allow 12 yo's to drive cars. I do think though that there is a lot of irrelevant detail in the OP that is obscuring the facts....I mean should the penalty be less if the boy had bounced off a 17 stone rugby player?

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:16

Idontgiveagriffindamn · 27/01/2023 19:04

So you don’t think competitive parents demanding a 12 year old is excluded is OTT? I bet the motivation behind it is so their precious child doesn’t have as much completion.
And yes some of the post are ridiculous - like the one comparing it to drink driving 🙄

I think the notion that competitive parents may have ulterior motives should be moved to the back burner in view of the fact that an elderly lady has been injured severely enough to warrant surgery. The boy’s punishment should reflect the seriousness of what he did, and be enough to make him understand that he put other people at risk by ignoring the warning and using his skateboard inside after he’d been told not to. It needs to be reinforced that actions have consequences and that rules are there for a reason. There may well be ulterior motives to the actions of other parents, but this shouldn’t be used to minimise what he actually did.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:16

As the parents concerned ought to know, the club would be skating on very thin ice if it responded to pressure from them. It has to be seen to be capable of making its own decisions in accordance with all the facts, which after all the parents won't be fully aware of. If it's seen to bow down to pressure, it will keep happening and the club will lose control. What happens if they organise a boycott because they don't approve of team selection or some kid being sent off by the ref?

OhmygodDont · 27/01/2023 19:15

If you want to play sport at an elite level you abide by their rules and the fact that your actions outside of the actual sport can and will also get you punished by the sport.

There is a certain level of behaviour and expectations on your behaviour and conduct when playing at a higher level. The club ultimately has its reputation to protect and its other members and guests.

TheGoogleMum · 27/01/2023 19:14

It wasn't intentional and it was unlucky that the grandmother got so hurt. I think he should be punished but not expelled, perhaps with the threat of future expulsion if caught skateboarding inside again (as that suggests he didn't learn anything from the incident)

Flamingogirl08 · 27/01/2023 19:14

TheBigWangTheory · 27/01/2023 19:12

An accident he caused by doing something he shouldn't be doing, that he knew he shouldn't be doing.

Accident doesn't mean you're not responsible. You and I may be in a car accidemt, but if it happened because I was driving my car where I shouldn't, and I knew it, wouldn't I be responsible for that accident?

Yes but it doesn't mean you'd automatically be banned from driving

EpicChaos · 27/01/2023 19:13

Kangarude · 27/01/2023 17:12

I'm a grandmother and I'm 100% certain that I would return to my 'previous independence and function' I'm 58 Hmm

I accept that there needs to be consequence but I wouldn't want the boy expelling from the club

How can you be so sure? At your age, you will either have gone through/will be going through/about to go through the menopause, this might have affected your bone density, ( osteoporosis possibly ) have you had your bone density measured? If so and all was good, that's great but a bad break could still cause you problems in the future.
As it is, where the situation this thread is about is concerned, we don't even know the exact injury to the arm, only that it's broken, well which bone? How many breaks, just the one, or a number of fractures? What did the surgery entail precisely, has the bone been wired, for instance?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/01/2023 19:13

What is expelling him going to achieve???

Keeping others at the group safe from someone who's repeatedly chosen ("previous reprimands") not to do as he's told, to the point where someone's now been seriously injured?

It's noticeable that OP's said nothing about the lad's reaction at the time, whether he stopped to help the injured lady, etc.. I'm assuming nothing, but given her preference for him to remain in the group I'd have expected that to be included if it happened

DanceMonkey19 · 27/01/2023 19:13

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 18:47

But this is a repeat. He’s been warned and chose to ignore the warning. Whichever way you look at this there are no mitigating circumstances. He ignored the warning and hurt someone. If he was warned previously that any repeat would result in expulsion, then that’s what should happen. Otherwise you’re teaching the child that he can do anything he likes because the adults won’t follow through.

If he had been told that he would be expelled from the team for using his skateboard in or around the entrance to the building then fine. But I highly doubt this is what was said. A reminder not to use the skateboard is more likely, which is why to jump straight to permanent expulsion is way OTT imo.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 19:13

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 19:06

I didn’t say punish him severely, I said find a punishment that teaches him that his actions have consequences, for himself as well as his victim. And whether he has a reputation for bad behaviour or not is irrelevant. He had been warned, ignored it, and injured someone as a result. And a lot of people on here are trying to find any excuse to minimise that.

Then we don't necessarily differ about the sanction. I was responding to a poster who wanted him to be permanently expelled.

Mabelface · 27/01/2023 19:13

Bloody hell, he's 12 and was thoughtless, not malicious, and I can imagine he feels bloody awful, as he should. He'll have learned a harsh lesson already. I'm actually astounded that a bunch of parents are going to stage a protest to bully the child out of the club.

A short suspension, grounded for a short time at home and a sincere letter of apology would be enough here.