Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
saraclara · 27/01/2023 21:29

Blufelt · 27/01/2023 21:23

Age hasn’t been mentioned. Grandmother could be 45-50! So not necessarily old and doddery. Not that it’s relevant.

The question is whether a 12yo could reasonably be expected to foresee that this accident might happen. Obviously he knew he wasn’t supposed to skateboard indoors, but I’d argue that he’s still a child so couldn’t be expected to realise his actions would lead to this accident.

The age has been mentioned. OP originally thought she was around 70, but she workds, so more likely mid 60s probably.

Unlikely to be doddery (says this 67 year old) and vanishingly unlikely to be wearing slippers, but all the same, will probably not mend fast after a fracture that's required surgery

Blufelt · 27/01/2023 21:29

kingtamponthefurred · 27/01/2023 21:26

Amazing how many people on this thread are soft as shit. I would have no problem with permanently excluding him from the club and no problem with suing the fuck out of his parents.

Parents aren’t legally liable for accidents or damage caused by their child.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 21:28

AdventFridgeOfShame · 27/01/2023 20:59

@Patineur from the OP leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building he has been told previously not to take his skateboard.

Although he no doubt intended no harm, he was behaving recklessly and he did cause injuries that are legally described as actual bodily harm.
A possible charge if he was older would be: assault occasioning actual bodily harm. Generally a fine or community service but up to 6 months jail. I'm not suggesting this is a path to follow but the woman injured and her family might.
Best to put in a community based punishment and a suspension, demonstrating that the matter has been addressed seriously.

The club are going to get flack, they need to show that they are in control of the situation and keeping everyone safe.

Why is that directed at me? At no point have I ever suggested what he did was OK.

No-one would be charged with assault on the basis of what we have been told happened. There is no indication whatsoever of the requisite intention.

Blufelt · 27/01/2023 21:28

the club need to make the punishment appropriate to the seriousness of the incident, or risk the family of the injured woman taking it further
Take it further how? The club isn’t legally responsible. Parents aren’t legally responsible for an accident caused by their child. The child might be held responsible in court but it depends whether the judge thinks he should have foreseen that his actions would lead to this accident, which is debatable. Even if the injured woman wins, she can’t be awarded damages because the child has no assets so can’t pay.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/01/2023 21:28

Thanks for clarifying, Nimbostratus100
So since the club have already decided on a punishment short of expulsion and nobody else seems to know what the lad's attitude now is, I guess a lot will depend on how he presents when he returns - whether in the words of many he's "learned his lesson" or regards the lesser action taken as licence

I’m quite shocked at the ease with which a lot of posters are ignoring the serious injury to a woman in her 60s

Sadly I'm not; ageism is rife on Mumsnet, and too often tolerated in ways other discrimination (quite rightly) wouldn't be
It would be interesting, though, to hear what the club has done to reach out to the injured lady ...

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 21:27

Mark19735 · 27/01/2023 21:21

Why thank you! I love winning the internet.

I'm just highlighting the dissonance between people coming down hard on a 12 year old kid with no evidence of intent, or of circumstance, or of mitigation ... and yet jumping to the defence of a senior citizen with ... no evidence of other mitigating factors.

If a dog had run in front of her, she'd have probably fallen too. Would you want the animal destroyed? If a sudden gust of wind had blown a door shut creating a loud bang, she'd have probably been startled and maybe fallen too. Who would you blame then?

Like I said - if I was defending the kid, I'd absolutely monster this old lady, her faculties, her judgment, and I'd be demanding disclosure of medical records and looking for evidence of pre-existing medical conditions. Anything to cast doubt in the mind of the decision-maker that this kid is as evil and blameworthy as many of the posters on this thread seem to think. That's how an adversarial system works. Seems some people only approve of it when it is used against the poor and vulnerable.

A dog is no more sentient than a gust of wind so there wouldn’t be anyone to blame. They would be accidents. This boy is over the age of criminal responsibility, sentient and had been told not do ride the skateboard in the building. He ignored it and someone got hurt as a consequence. Not saying it’s evil but definitely blameworthy, and victim blaming as you have outlined here, is batshit.

kingtamponthefurred · 27/01/2023 21:26

Amazing how many people on this thread are soft as shit. I would have no problem with permanently excluding him from the club and no problem with suing the fuck out of his parents.

GrantShappsAteMyBrain · 27/01/2023 21:24

The quality of his playing, the quality of the club and his attendance shouldn't be a factor. What matter is that he was told not to skateboard in the building but he did and now someone got hurt. A fractured arm can be pretty serious especially for someone elderly. I think he should be suspended for a long time if not expelled.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 21:24

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 20:52

But do you not think that having been told not to ride a skateboard inside the building, it would dawn on him that this is because it’s dangerous ? Testing the theory has cost this lady dearly - a fact that a lot of posters are trying to minimise.

YES, I think all of that. With the slight caveat that 12 year olds can be bloody stupid and always think that bad consequences can't possibly happen to them. None of which means that they shouldn't suffer appropriate punishment for their stupid actions when they do what they're told not to do.

Yet again, you seem to be looking for an argument and/or making up the facts. I have made it clear several times that I think this was a serious offence that merits a serious punishment. I just don't think it merits permanent exclusion.

Blufelt · 27/01/2023 21:23

Age hasn’t been mentioned. Grandmother could be 45-50! So not necessarily old and doddery. Not that it’s relevant.

The question is whether a 12yo could reasonably be expected to foresee that this accident might happen. Obviously he knew he wasn’t supposed to skateboard indoors, but I’d argue that he’s still a child so couldn’t be expected to realise his actions would lead to this accident.

AdventFridgeOfShame · 27/01/2023 21:23

@Mark19735 you need to remember the egg shell skull stuff.

Also coming across as a misogynistic twat is never a good look.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 21:22

Patineur · 27/01/2023 21:12

He was told not to skateboard. The likelihood is that someone saw him with his skateboard and reminded him of the rule.. That is not a reprimand.

Yes, of course he knew it was wrong. That isn't the same of repeating something he has already been told off for.

I have to admit I don't know what you're arguing about. You've suggested that you accept that any punishment could be less than expulsion, which roughly agrees with what a lot of the people you are arguing with are advocating. Or do you in fact think he should be chucked out?

I don’t necessarily think he should be expelled, but that’s down to the club. I do think is that there should be a punishment that teaches him it’s not acceptable to ignore rules and do as you like, because obeying those rules interferes with your enjoyment. As I said, actions have consequences and the punishment should teach that those consequences will affect the wrongdoer as well as the victim. There is also the small matter of him being over the age of criminal responsibility, so the club need to make the punishment appropriate to the seriousness of the incident, or risk the family of the injured woman taking it further.

Ottil · 27/01/2023 21:22

lljkk · 27/01/2023 21:13

I'm not far off grandmother age (very plausible now, easily). I'd be furious if the boy was 100% expelled on my behalf. I could shrug about a brief suspension. Accidents happen. Live & let live.

Yes, it's good to consider this angle.

I was injured by someone - slightly older than this child - doing something daft. It was supposed to be a joke, it went wrong, and I ended up with a year or two or symptoms. He'd been warned to do daft stuff like this, but he did it anyway.

Like you, I would be livid if his life was upended and changed for the worse as a punishment. Completely disproportionate. There's nothing I'd want less.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 27/01/2023 21:21

The 'crime' is not huge (skating on board a few metres from where this is allowed). He was certainly wrong to do what he had been told not to.

If he had been seen and stopped before the crash, would he have been expelled for his actions? Would it have seemed so serious an offence?

How have other 12 year olds been treated for breaking similar rules?

The consequences of his action this time were much larger than they might have been. This was the unlucky/accident part.

It doesn't seem fair to punish him more severely because his impulsive (wrong) behaviour had such a bad result.

Mark19735 · 27/01/2023 21:21

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 21:01

This thread has become ludicrous - so many people trying to defend the indefensible and this, below, wins the internet today for the stupidest, most inane comment and possibly the most insulting to older people.

Doddery old people should take more care around kids - the gran needs to take some responsibility too. She's the adult in this scenario and it seems she didn't properly appraise all the risks and hazards she encountered.

No evidence she was doddery, and no evidence that she was wearing slippers as this poster theorised. To intimate that all older people are doddery and should take responsibility for an inconsiderate youth bowling around a building on a skateboard, after being told not to, is beyond ridiculous. She might be the adult in this situation, but she’d have to be fucking clairvoyant to have seen this coming.

Why thank you! I love winning the internet.

I'm just highlighting the dissonance between people coming down hard on a 12 year old kid with no evidence of intent, or of circumstance, or of mitigation ... and yet jumping to the defence of a senior citizen with ... no evidence of other mitigating factors.

If a dog had run in front of her, she'd have probably fallen too. Would you want the animal destroyed? If a sudden gust of wind had blown a door shut creating a loud bang, she'd have probably been startled and maybe fallen too. Who would you blame then?

Like I said - if I was defending the kid, I'd absolutely monster this old lady, her faculties, her judgment, and I'd be demanding disclosure of medical records and looking for evidence of pre-existing medical conditions. Anything to cast doubt in the mind of the decision-maker that this kid is as evil and blameworthy as many of the posters on this thread seem to think. That's how an adversarial system works. Seems some people only approve of it when it is used against the poor and vulnerable.

TrashyPanda · 27/01/2023 21:17

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 18:52

Well, no - if you look at the original post the OP did ask what else she thought should happen, so it’s logical that the victim and the consequences to her should be considered. And no, I don’t think it’s up to the lady who was injured to come to his defence. She’s possibly facing serious consequences as a result of his thoughtlessness, so why would she ?

Exactly

some people just enjoy attacking those with different views.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 21:16

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 20:48

In the original post the OP clearly says he was leaving the building - the main entrance - on his skateboard. Having been told when he came into the building on his skateboard, that he should not ride it in the building.

Yet again, it does not say that he came into the building on his skateboard. It says he arrived at the building on it.

TrashyPanda · 27/01/2023 21:15

Really, some people on MN take their desperation to attack others to fairly ridiculous lengths

pot: meet kettle

lljkk · 27/01/2023 21:13

I'm not far off grandmother age (very plausible now, easily). I'd be furious if the boy was 100% expelled on my behalf. I could shrug about a brief suspension. Accidents happen. Live & let live.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 21:12

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 20:46

Er, yes it does. He was told not to do it, ignored that, did it again on the way out and injured someone as a result. I’d say it was pretty clear that when he did it the second time, he was aware that it was wrong.

He was told not to skateboard. The likelihood is that someone saw him with his skateboard and reminded him of the rule.. That is not a reprimand.

Yes, of course he knew it was wrong. That isn't the same of repeating something he has already been told off for.

I have to admit I don't know what you're arguing about. You've suggested that you accept that any punishment could be less than expulsion, which roughly agrees with what a lot of the people you are arguing with are advocating. Or do you in fact think he should be chucked out?

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/01/2023 21:12

AdventFridgeOfShame · 27/01/2023 20:59

@Patineur from the OP leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building he has been told previously not to take his skateboard.

Although he no doubt intended no harm, he was behaving recklessly and he did cause injuries that are legally described as actual bodily harm.
A possible charge if he was older would be: assault occasioning actual bodily harm. Generally a fine or community service but up to 6 months jail. I'm not suggesting this is a path to follow but the woman injured and her family might.
Best to put in a community based punishment and a suspension, demonstrating that the matter has been addressed seriously.

The club are going to get flack, they need to show that they are in control of the situation and keeping everyone safe.

This put me in mind of an incident a couple of years ago. The front doors of our houses open out onto a wide pavement, and our neighbour stepped out one morning only to be knocked over by the paper boy who was riding his bike on the pavement. She was taken to hospital by ambulance and treated for a broken arm and concussion. The paper boy was 13. He had been reported to the newsagents several times for riding on the pavement, and when the ambulance was called, the police were too. I think he was charged with assault resulting in actual bodily harm, although I don’t know what the outcome was. As you say, if this isn’t dealt with appropriately, there is the possibility that this woman’s’ family may want to go down the same path, given the seriousness of her injuries.

CoffeeThisInstant · 27/01/2023 21:11

Mark19735
I've seen some ludicrous comments on this board but yours really takes the biscuit ....
"Ultimately, it is intent that matters, not consequence. If I was defending the boy, I'd be asking about CCTV and eye witnesses.
There's a world of difference between recklessly travelling at high speed without looking where you are going and in so doing hitting a person so hard they fall over, and casually scooting along a wide corridor, passing a person who is doddery, old, frail, possibly hard of hearing, potentially wearing inappropriate footwear for the environment (slippers?) and easily startled, who then stumbles and falls. Both scenarios could result in the injuries you describe, but the culpability would be very different. And in the absence of strong evidence of the former, I'd be painting the latter picture. Doddery old people should take more care around kids - the gran needs to take some responsibility too. She's the adult in this scenario and it seems she didn't properly appraise all the risks and hazards she encountered.
As an aside - it sounds like a nasty, snobby club full of ghastly people - I'd move the kid to a rival club, and have him come back and knock this club out of whatever tournaments they compete in."

EasterIsland · 27/01/2023 21:08

Testing the theory has cost this lady dearly - a fact that a lot of posters are trying to minimise.

Yes @Lovelysausagedogscrumpy I’m quite shocked at the ease with which a lot of posters are ignoring the serious injury to a woman in her 60s. Recovering from a broken bone is fucking hard work which gets tougher as you get older. Those of you saying it was an accident , try spending the next 6-10 weeks with the use of only one arm.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 21:05

EasterIsland · 27/01/2023 20:25

My personal feeling is that is is right that he shouldn't be expelled for a stupid childish act when he didn't mean to harm anyone. But I seem to be in the minority out of the adults associated with this club.

Good Lord do you not have ANY compassion for the woman who was seriously injured by this boy? At 12 he is old enough to know that he should not have been scooting his skateboard. He is old enough to take responsibility for seriously injuring someone.

And you think he’s just impulsive???

I’m with the parents who don’t want this boy around.

How on earth does not wanting the boy to be expelled equate to having no compassion for the woman? It's perfectly possible to have massive compassion for her whilst still advocating a punishment short of expulsion.

Why is expelling him the only possible response? The club which actually knows what happened, knows the woman, knows the boy, knows his record, decided against, but you know better?

Feetupteashot · 27/01/2023 21:04

If it suits the victim it would be decent of him to volunteer to help her with heavy shopping / housework until she is better.