Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/01/2023 10:20

This is more like a thread of spot the parents of badly behaved children

Illuminating isn't it? Sad

GabriellaMontez · 28/01/2023 10:18

Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 09:22

Everyone muttering about ageism should ask themselves who, if anyone, is suffering discrimination because of their age? It is not the victim.

The fundamental issue the OP raises is totally about the class and family background of the child. The scenario portrayed is of a 'wrong side of the tracks' kid with talent being 'allowed' to play at an 'elite' club, and other kid's parents being up in arms about this, and trying to use a minor misdemeanour as a pretext to exclude this kid. The fact that it was one of their own (the posh ones) who got hurt is neither here nor there.

The only prejudice apparent at this club, and on this thread, is towards the kid. There's absolutely nothing wrong with 12 year olds, or skateboards. If it had been a gymkhana and one of the posh kids' ponies had reared up or snorted and someone elderly had fallen over, no-one would be batting an eyelid or blaming the kid. There is however plenty wrong with the presumption that scapegoating a child for the inconveniences suffered by an adult who should have taken more care is in any way fair or reasonable.

I think you'll find gymkhanas/stables take safety very seriously.

A repeated rule breaker whose behaviour eventually caused an injury wouldn't be welcome to participate.

But nice reverse snobbery and victim blaming.

Ottil · 28/01/2023 10:13

I've mentioned this upthread, but having been injured by an older kid doing something daft, I would be fucking furious if a bunch of baying parents (some of whom sound like outright bullies) got that child expelled from the opportunity that might keep his life on the right track.

He did wrong. There should absolutely be consequences, but the torch-waving on this thread is insane and somewhat unnerving.

GabriellaMontez · 28/01/2023 10:13

Quia · 28/01/2023 09:30

Are you saying he received a serious reprimand before someone was injured? When? It obviously wasn't when he was reminded that he couldn't use the skateboard within the club.

I literally said minor reprimands.

The OP doesn't specify when.

But clearly he doesn't pay attention to club rules. Despite previous reprimands. And now he's hurt someone.

Regardless of the parents feelings I wouldn't want him at my club. He sounds like a liability.

Blufelt · 28/01/2023 09:50

GoldilockMom · 27/01/2023 23:20

Claim from who? 12 year olds aren’t known for having deep pockets!

The club. They will have public liability insurance. They failed to keep her safe resulting in an injury. That’s how insurance works.

The club is not at fault. They took reasonable steps to prevent an accident, they banned skateboarding indoors and when someone broke the rules in the past they spoke to him about it. There are no further steps they could or should have taken, so the club bears no liability for the accident. The sole responsibility lies with the 12yo who broke the rules. Therefore the only party who could possibly be sued is the 12yo, who has no money.

Quia · 28/01/2023 09:30

GabriellaMontez · 28/01/2023 08:42

Several minor reprimands. Escalated to a serious one. Someone is injured.

There is no sign of him learning his lesson.
Serious consequences are the best thing that could happen to him.

Are you saying he received a serious reprimand before someone was injured? When? It obviously wasn't when he was reminded that he couldn't use the skateboard within the club.

Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 09:22

Everyone muttering about ageism should ask themselves who, if anyone, is suffering discrimination because of their age? It is not the victim.

The fundamental issue the OP raises is totally about the class and family background of the child. The scenario portrayed is of a 'wrong side of the tracks' kid with talent being 'allowed' to play at an 'elite' club, and other kid's parents being up in arms about this, and trying to use a minor misdemeanour as a pretext to exclude this kid. The fact that it was one of their own (the posh ones) who got hurt is neither here nor there.

The only prejudice apparent at this club, and on this thread, is towards the kid. There's absolutely nothing wrong with 12 year olds, or skateboards. If it had been a gymkhana and one of the posh kids' ponies had reared up or snorted and someone elderly had fallen over, no-one would be batting an eyelid or blaming the kid. There is however plenty wrong with the presumption that scapegoating a child for the inconveniences suffered by an adult who should have taken more care is in any way fair or reasonable.

Sugarfree23 · 28/01/2023 08:47

The woman will most likely be fine in 6-8 weeks. Why should the boy have a lifetime ban?

People have accidents in cars all the time few end up with a life time ban.

GabriellaMontez · 28/01/2023 08:42

Several minor reprimands. Escalated to a serious one. Someone is injured.

There is no sign of him learning his lesson.
Serious consequences are the best thing that could happen to him.

EasterIsland · 28/01/2023 08:11

This is more like a thread of spot the parents of badly behaved children.

Indeed. And the ageism which is just typical of MN.

DaveyJonesLocker · 28/01/2023 04:13

So long as he has received a punishment then OK. Sports does keep kids on the right tracks but doing something this bad then getting to Swan about with your life unchanged would not

Sugarfree23 · 28/01/2023 00:55

It's also worth noting if the lady hadn't broken her arm or the boy had hurt himself, nobody would really think much more off it.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 00:10

It's worth noting that she said he had received several minor reprimands. And that he's 12.

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 00:06

OP - you say the boy has several reprimands for his behaviour on the pitch - arguing with the ref.

what is the club’s position on this? When players do not show sportsmanlike behaviour, is there a consequence?

in my youth, I played a sport with a captain who later played for her country. So definitely an elite player. After some shouting in one match, the school benched her for the next two matches. I’m presuming your club has similar standards?

Patineur · 28/01/2023 00:05

GoldilockMom · 27/01/2023 23:20

Claim from who? 12 year olds aren’t known for having deep pockets!

The club. They will have public liability insurance. They failed to keep her safe resulting in an injury. That’s how insurance works.

You can't claim simply because you have an accident on their premises. You have to show fault on their part, and that injury was a reasonably foreseeable result of their fault. I can see some areas where they could be criticised, but I suspect this isn't the sort of claim a no-win no-fee lawyer would want to take on because the chances of winning are too low.

I really sympathise with the victim, not least because we're of a similar age, but it wouldn't help her to spend the next five years pursuing a hopeless claim.

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 00:02

Blufelt · 27/01/2023 21:23

Age hasn’t been mentioned. Grandmother could be 45-50! So not necessarily old and doddery. Not that it’s relevant.

The question is whether a 12yo could reasonably be expected to foresee that this accident might happen. Obviously he knew he wasn’t supposed to skateboard indoors, but I’d argue that he’s still a child so couldn’t be expected to realise his actions would lead to this accident.

OP did mention age

I would guess 70 - but she is still working, so maybe late 60s?

Patineur · 28/01/2023 00:01

GoldilockMom · 27/01/2023 22:43

Or he's a silly little 12 year old chancing his arm. I'm going for that explanation, personally

He chances someone else’s.

I wonder how much this accident will affect granny financially?

Can’t drive for 6 weeks?
Pay for a Cleaner?
Can’t work?
Weeks of pain?

I hope she puts in a claim - she would have every right to do so.

Against whom?

Patineur · 27/01/2023 23:59

OhmygodDont · 27/01/2023 22:30

This is more like a thread of spot the parents of badly behaved children.

Ultimately he technically injured someone else, accident with intent or not. Abh or gbh don’t actually have to be intended but just a consequence of something you have done. Including where you’ve made a situation dangerous for someone else to harm themselves by your actions.

I have a teen a pre teen and an infant school aged child. Babying a 12 year old does the no favours when it comes to harming others or breaking rules. If the grandmother wanted she could press charges however small they might become.

If you want to charge someone with ABH or GBH, you absolutely have to prove intent.

Patineur · 27/01/2023 23:57

saraclara · 27/01/2023 22:24

The club certainly needs to look at the level of supervision and enforcing safety rules.

No club is going to escort each indivdual out of the building when they leave. They're teenagers,

As stated, there's an argument they should have told the boy to leave the skateboard at reception if he wanted to go in.

GoldilockMom · 27/01/2023 23:32

I’ve just looked it up - she can claim between £40 and £60,000 dependent on recovery.

GoldilockMom · 27/01/2023 23:20

Claim from who? 12 year olds aren’t known for having deep pockets!

The club. They will have public liability insurance. They failed to keep her safe resulting in an injury. That’s how insurance works.

Blufelt · 27/01/2023 22:49

I'm not surprised that some parents are angry, especially if they know the woman, and what consequences this has on her family- which if she's working could be a serious loss of income. A wee oops sorry doesn't cut it then.
Being injured by a child is like being crashed into by an uninsured driver. You can’t get any money from them because they don’t have any, so you have to claim on your own insurance.

Blufelt · 27/01/2023 22:47

GoldilockMom · 27/01/2023 22:43

Or he's a silly little 12 year old chancing his arm. I'm going for that explanation, personally

He chances someone else’s.

I wonder how much this accident will affect granny financially?

Can’t drive for 6 weeks?
Pay for a Cleaner?
Can’t work?
Weeks of pain?

I hope she puts in a claim - she would have every right to do so.

Claim from who? 12 year olds aren’t known for having deep pockets!

Ottil · 27/01/2023 22:45

This is more like a thread of spot the parents of badly behaved children

What absolute crap.

SD1978 · 27/01/2023 22:43

There should be some kind of reprimand/ punishment within the club, benches for a few weeks or whatever. He was explicitly told not to do something, which several hours later he did again and has caused someone an injury- with a potential ongoing health issue which they don't get to juts get over. I'm not surprised that some parents are angry, especially if they know the woman, and what consequences this has on her family- which if she's working could be a serious loss of income. A wee oops sorry doesn't cut it then.

Swipe left for the next trending thread