Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Cocobutt · 28/01/2023 18:10

leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building,

several minor reprimands.

Yes he should be removed because he continues to not follow the rules.

He was told no skateboarding and then carried on doing it.
He should be punished for this reason alone.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 18:10

Expulsion would be extreme over an accident, even an accident that could have been avoided if the child had adhered to the ‘no skateboarding’ rule.

Everyone hates ‘cancel culture’ until they get the opportunity to join the mob.

Funpixie · 28/01/2023 17:58

growgrowinggrown · 27/01/2023 16:50

Are his parents involved in this conversation and 'private punishment' implemented by them already?

I think expelled is a fair shout, he's been told multiple times not to do something that has now resulted in a serious injury.

He clearly can't be trusted to listen and amend his behaviour so now has to face the repercussions.

An operation for any older person isn't taken lightly and can have awful side effects, I'd be worried sick and really angry if I was a relative of 'grandma' and found out the boy could carry on as is.

This! 12yo would not do this at school and can’t do at sports club. Parents have to take this seriously and personally a big consequence would be appropriate. His recklessness caused injury. He should know better and this incident may be a good time to teach consequences and personal responsibility

jtaeapa · 28/01/2023 17:32

ForestofD · 27/01/2023 20:37

Any teacher will tell you that at the age of 12, teenage boys, on the whole, have a very poor perception of future consequences. It is because their brains aren't fully developed yet.

And before anyone leaps in and starts tell me their child was so wise at 12 that they could practically see the future- yes, fine. However, on the whole, boys start puberty later. And puberty also means brain development as well as body.

I haven't got a massive opinion either way- however, it strikes me that aged 12, he is neither one nor the other- not a child, yet certainly not even a teenager; and that should be considered. There should certainly be consequences but his age should also be considered. If he is, as you say, basically a good kid, this will have given him a good fright.

If the brain isn't fully developed enough to perceive consequences, then the child shouldn't be out unsupervised without an adult. Otherwise, as shown, he's a danger to others. Lucky the woman didn't hit her head and die.

paintitallover · 28/01/2023 16:43

I broke my own arm (shoulder) early autumn. A man accidentally tripped me. I didn't know him. It wasn't his fault either-it was an accident-as I told the poor guy at the time, despite nearly fainting.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 28/01/2023 15:50

PriamFarrl · 27/01/2023 22:38

The thing is that there are accidents and there are accident.

If someone trips over and spills a cup of tea over the sofa, then that is a complete accident. The person who spilled the tea isn’t at fault.

If a child has been told not to kick their football towards the greenhouse and then does so, smashing a window, that is also an accident. But it’s not without blame.

Where did I say the child wasn't to blame!? I even said it was caused by recklessness. I just think it's weird how many people are claiming this isn't an accident at all. It's not like he saw the woman and decided to ride at her at full pelt.

FuzzyPuffling · 28/01/2023 15:07

Mark19735 · 27/01/2023 21:21

Why thank you! I love winning the internet.

I'm just highlighting the dissonance between people coming down hard on a 12 year old kid with no evidence of intent, or of circumstance, or of mitigation ... and yet jumping to the defence of a senior citizen with ... no evidence of other mitigating factors.

If a dog had run in front of her, she'd have probably fallen too. Would you want the animal destroyed? If a sudden gust of wind had blown a door shut creating a loud bang, she'd have probably been startled and maybe fallen too. Who would you blame then?

Like I said - if I was defending the kid, I'd absolutely monster this old lady, her faculties, her judgment, and I'd be demanding disclosure of medical records and looking for evidence of pre-existing medical conditions. Anything to cast doubt in the mind of the decision-maker that this kid is as evil and blameworthy as many of the posters on this thread seem to think. That's how an adversarial system works. Seems some people only approve of it when it is used against the poor and vulnerable.

I have never heard such twaddle in my life!

We have no evidence of her age or "dodderiness" at all.

And even if we did,
I have a 12 year old grandchild so am likely to be a similar age to the broken armed woman, and have never yet tripped over a dog or fallen over because a door slammed.

You are making points that have absolutely no basis in fact (or indeed, reality)

Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 15:03

To be clear, I don't think anyone is suggesting the injured person is culpable for her misfortune. It is a wretched thing to have happened to her. She deserves the exact same level of sympathy as would have been afforded to her had she slipped on an icy footpath, or fallen in her own home.

But there are seemingly a great many people willing to pile on to a vulnerable 12yr old kid, demanding all manner of sanctions for something that is clearly not a criminal act.

Thankfully, our criminal justice system is more nuanced that this, as are nearly 2/3rds of the 2200 people who have voted in the poll, overwhelming taking the view that the OP is not being unreasonable and saying that the child should not have been expelled. The will'o'the people is clear on this one. For those who don't like it - time to move on.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 14:49

Would this make undo any of the results of the injury or feel more like revenge…. An eye for an eye etc?

Funny, I always thought that an eye for an eye meant justice, not revenge.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 14:45

Blufelt · 28/01/2023 09:50

The club is not at fault. They took reasonable steps to prevent an accident, they banned skateboarding indoors and when someone broke the rules in the past they spoke to him about it. There are no further steps they could or should have taken, so the club bears no liability for the accident. The sole responsibility lies with the 12yo who broke the rules. Therefore the only party who could possibly be sued is the 12yo, who has no money.

He was caught riding the skateboard inside the building. I would have thought the sensible thing to do would have been to confiscate the skateboard while he was in building and tell him to collect it from reception when he left.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 14:13

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 28/01/2023 13:30

Was on here yesterday, amazed to come back and see its now moved on to blaming the victim. Its literally a free pass for anyone to injure anyone else and just say oh well I'm a nice person and nothing is my fault. WTAF. And then people wonder why kids are bullies, anti-social behaviour etc

Funny thing is on MN if this was a poster saying her 12 year old son had hoped for a 5 mile lift home from the club in the snow he'd be an entitled little shit who needed to get a job and earn pocket money for the bus. But knock a woman over her and break her arm, christ what a careless bitch, poor lad he's just a cheeky loveable urchin. FFS.

Agree. This attitude seems to be more and more prevalent in society. No one is prepared to take personal responsibility for their actions and there is always a queue of people willing to find any excuse to blame someone other than the person who is actually responsible - in this case the child. Yes, he’s 12, yes he was careless and didn’t actually mean to hurt anyone. And probably, hopefully, he will learn from this experience. But I think the point is that if he had done as he was told in the first place no one would have been hurt. But hey - better to blame the victim for not expecting a skateboard to come at her inside a building, than actually apply a punishment to the child that actually teaches him something.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 14:06

There's absolutely nothing wrong with 12 year olds, or skateboards. If it had been a gymkhana and one of the posh kids' ponies had reared up or snorted and someone elderly had fallen over, no-one would be batting an eyelid or blaming the kid. There is however plenty wrong with the presumption that scapegoating a child for the inconveniences suffered by an adult who should have taken more care is in any way fair or reasonable.

What utter nonsense. Completely ignores the fact that he was on a skateboard in the building. And he had been told no skateboarding inside the building. He ignored that and injured someone as a result. How is it scapegoating the child ? To my mind you are scapegoating the old lady by asking us to accept that she should have expected a child to come barrelling out of a building on a skateboard !!

Ottil · 28/01/2023 13:33

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 28/01/2023 13:30

Was on here yesterday, amazed to come back and see its now moved on to blaming the victim. Its literally a free pass for anyone to injure anyone else and just say oh well I'm a nice person and nothing is my fault. WTAF. And then people wonder why kids are bullies, anti-social behaviour etc

Funny thing is on MN if this was a poster saying her 12 year old son had hoped for a 5 mile lift home from the club in the snow he'd be an entitled little shit who needed to get a job and earn pocket money for the bus. But knock a woman over her and break her arm, christ what a careless bitch, poor lad he's just a cheeky loveable urchin. FFS.

Yes, yes, SO MANY posters are saying that. Or two. Maybe even no one. But whatever, eh? 🙄

Ottil · 28/01/2023 13:30

For clarity, my comment is to the author of that profoundly intelligent comment, Puzzledandpissedoff

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 28/01/2023 13:30

Was on here yesterday, amazed to come back and see its now moved on to blaming the victim. Its literally a free pass for anyone to injure anyone else and just say oh well I'm a nice person and nothing is my fault. WTAF. And then people wonder why kids are bullies, anti-social behaviour etc

Funny thing is on MN if this was a poster saying her 12 year old son had hoped for a 5 mile lift home from the club in the snow he'd be an entitled little shit who needed to get a job and earn pocket money for the bus. But knock a woman over her and break her arm, christ what a careless bitch, poor lad he's just a cheeky loveable urchin. FFS.

Ottil · 28/01/2023 13:28

Quia · 28/01/2023 10:35

All these passive aggressive posts are so silly. If you want to draw conclusions that people who disagree with you must have badly behaved children, at least have the courage to name names.

...and while you're explaining that exceptionally foolish remark, you could also 'illuminate' the thread on how you know which of the posters are even parents.

EasterIsland · 28/01/2023 13:28

There is however plenty wrong with the presumption that scapegoating a child for the inconveniences suffered by an adult who should have taken more care is in any way fair or reasonable.

Good Lord @Mark19735 are you ths child's parent?

The child deliberately ignored the requirement that he not scoot his skateboard inside a building.

No-one walking along a hall or corridor should be required to look out for a rule-breaking child doing something unsafe and stupid. It is outrageous to reprimand the woman and say she should have taken more care when she is injured by a child deliberately doing something he was told - only that day - that he should not

And breaking an arm is not an "inconvenience." I broke my arm (in an accident not caused by anyone else) in my early 50s. I have an extremely demanding & high-pressure job, and I'm expected to perform at the top of my game. I had to have two operations, 6 weeks' sick leave (in total around the 2 ops), and an 18 month period of quite painful rehabilitation. I was on strong painkillers for about 6 months because of the damage to my nerves & muscles as a result of the fracture.

Luckily, my employer paid me my full salary for my periods of sick leave. However, many people aren't so fortunate in their working contracts.

And managing for over 6 weeks without the use of one easily working arm - difficulties in getting dressed, difficulties in brushing my hair & my teeth ... the list goes on.

And for all the reasons vfrious PP have srt out, she has NO recourse to compensation for pain or loss of earnings, or added costs to her in going about her ordinary life.

Your post is pretty despicable.

Zosime · 28/01/2023 13:26

The woman will most likely be fine in 6-8 weeks. Why should the boy have a lifetime ban?

who has said anything about a lifetime ban? The boy can still play football, or whatever the sport is. The question is whether he should be allowed to continue to play it at this particular club.

TrashyPanda · 28/01/2023 12:45

The only prejudice apparent at this club, and on this thread, is towards the kid. There's absolutely nothing wrong with 12 year olds, or skateboards

no, there isn’t.
but there is plenty wrong with a 12 year old who has been told not to use his skateboard indoors but decides to so anyway and seriously injures someone.

There is however plenty wrong with the presumption that scapegoating a child for the inconveniences suffered by an adult who should have taken more care is in any way fair or reasonable

you are scapegoating the victim who was seriously injured, through no fault of her own.
she required an operation. That is much more than an inconvenience and by downplaying it thus you are denying the pain and upset she will have been through.
how should the victim have taken more care?
and why?
nobody expects to be knocked over by a kid on a skateboard indoors

the injured lady is suffering much more than the kid.

Rhaych2003 · 28/01/2023 11:11

GabriellaMontez · 28/01/2023 11:06

Kicked out of school?

Did anyone suggest that?!

Sorry I meant to say get kicked out of the sports club not school, especially if you have to be of a certain standard to play there, could totally jeopardise a future career in sports if that’s what he wanted. I don’t think he should be kicked of the team given he’s been in no previous trouble xx

GabriellaMontez · 28/01/2023 11:06

Rhaych2003 · 28/01/2023 10:34

Fair enough he broke the rules bringing the skateboard in, which resulted in an accident. But are we really going to potentially jeopardise a young lads future by getting him kicked out of school over an accident? If he gets kicked out of school, higher chance he’ll turn to crime etc, end up in the system. What would you want to happen if it had been your son that had hit the lady, would you be so harsh?

what does the old lady, the victim want to happen to the lad??

Kicked out of school?

Did anyone suggest that?!

maddy68 · 28/01/2023 10:36

He shouldn't have been on a skateboard indoors. But expecting a kid to be "expelled". Don't be ridiculous. It's an accident

Quia · 28/01/2023 10:35

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/01/2023 10:20

This is more like a thread of spot the parents of badly behaved children

Illuminating isn't it? Sad

All these passive aggressive posts are so silly. If you want to draw conclusions that people who disagree with you must have badly behaved children, at least have the courage to name names.

Rhaych2003 · 28/01/2023 10:34

Fair enough he broke the rules bringing the skateboard in, which resulted in an accident. But are we really going to potentially jeopardise a young lads future by getting him kicked out of school over an accident? If he gets kicked out of school, higher chance he’ll turn to crime etc, end up in the system. What would you want to happen if it had been your son that had hit the lady, would you be so harsh?

what does the old lady, the victim want to happen to the lad??

Quia · 28/01/2023 10:32

GabriellaMontez · 28/01/2023 10:13

I literally said minor reprimands.

The OP doesn't specify when.

But clearly he doesn't pay attention to club rules. Despite previous reprimands. And now he's hurt someone.

Regardless of the parents feelings I wouldn't want him at my club. He sounds like a liability.

You said "...minor reprimands. Escalated to a serious one. Someone is injured. That sounded as if you were saying that the serious reprimand happened before the skateboarding incident, but it wasn't 100% clear, hence my query.

The OP says the minor reprimands were for stuff on the pitch. I suspect most teenage boys incur those. If that makes players a liability who should be expelled, the club would end up rather short of players. There is no suggestion of a history of failing to pay attention to any club rules off the pitch.