Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boy breaks grandmother's arm by accident

807 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/01/2023 16:41

I am not going to say what happened next and what I think until I have heard a few objective opinions on here

The facts of the case

12 year old boy in sports club, leaving the main entrance on his skateboard, which he has been told is not allowed in the building, knocks over the grandmother coming to collect another child. The grandmother has a broken arm and needed an operation

This is a fairly elite sports club, you need to be able to play to a certain standard to by allowed to join. This boy has played there for a year. No serious trouble, several minor reprimands. Reasonably good player. Turns up for the team probably 80-90% of the time.

This happened last weekend. The sports club is meeting tomorrow. The parents have just heard that this boy has/has not been expelled and will/will not be there.

What do you think should happen? why?

I am allocating the voting by a toss of a coin to be random!

YABU - the boy should be expelled
YANBU - the boy should not be expelled

also, what else should happen, as well as/ instead of being expelled?

Thank you

OP posts:
Mark19735 · 28/01/2023 19:56

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 18:48

I wonder if the (already a minority) of posters reaching for their pitchforks would have such a strong reaction if the offender had been a young girl and the injured party a 20-something.

^^ This! Best post on this thread.

I did some training on unconscious bias recently. A trainer gave a scenario, said it was a script for a play, and asked us to write down who we would cast as protagonist, antagonist etc. Turned out there were some very apparent biases that became quite obvious when the actors/actresses faces were pasted onto a storyboard.

If the OP is the casting director, the notes we have so far are:
Protagonist: 12 year old kid. Parents not interested. Skateboards. Minor rule-breaking.
Antagonist: Grandmother. Still working, so in her sixties but looks closer to 70. Suffers broken arm.

Now, who are you casting in these roles?
Is the kid a Harry Potter 1 era Daniel Radcliff? A Billy Elliott era Tom Holland? A Home Alone era Macaulay Culkin? Or are you imagining someone else ... someone older, edgier, more 'delinquent' and less cute? If so, who would you get to play this kid, based on what you know from reading this thread? Does the story change if the Grandmother is played by June Whitfield, or Dame Maggie Smith, or Catherine Tate?

If you dismiss this as irrelevant, then you are arguing from a perspective clouded by unconscious bias.

KettrickenSmiled · 28/01/2023 19:51

My personal feeling is that is is right that he shouldn't be expelled for a stupid childish act when he didn't mean to harm anyone. But I seem to be in the minority out of the adults associated with this club.

Yes, I think he is a basically good hearted boy, who has the potential to go off the rails without direction in his life, and I am very much in favour of keeping him engaged with his sport

I agree - he is only 12 years old, hardly the optimum age for impulse control & thinking ahead.

Confiscating the skateboard for a specified period would be a proportionate response, but as the lad's family don't seem to support him at the club, that might be difficult to co-ordinate with a parent/guardian.

AutumnCrow · 28/01/2023 19:51

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/01/2023 19:16

I'm assuming in theory the lady in question could sue for her injuries.

I think she'd have to sue Club (and its insurers) as the incident took place on Club premises; and as she did nothing wrong, i.e. no contributory negligence, she might have a case.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 19:51

SammyScrounge · 28/01/2023 19:45

He should be expelled. He obviously can't take a telling and persists in ignoring safety rules and now someone has been seriously injured.
He should be expelled and he should lose his skateboard too - He is so badly behaved that he should not be trusted with it.

To be clear, he has ignored safety rules on precisely one occasion, and now he is being punished for that.

Flamingogirl08 · 28/01/2023 19:49

KettrickenSmiled · 28/01/2023 19:45

It's not an accident when you are deliberately flouting permission to do so, ignoring previous warnings & all common sense H&S.

If I drove my car on the pavement & knocked you off your feet, would you plead with your insurance company, the police, jury & judge - "It was an accident, of course she shouldn't be punished"?

Who said anything about no punishment?

If you did something in your car deliberately like speeding and caused an accident then you would receive punishment but wouldn't necessarily be banned from driving forever!

KettrickenSmiled · 28/01/2023 19:45

Flamingogirl08 · 27/01/2023 16:45

It was an accident of course he shouldn't be expelled

It's not an accident when you are deliberately flouting permission to do so, ignoring previous warnings & all common sense H&S.

If I drove my car on the pavement & knocked you off your feet, would you plead with your insurance company, the police, jury & judge - "It was an accident, of course she shouldn't be punished"?

SammyScrounge · 28/01/2023 19:45

He should be expelled. He obviously can't take a telling and persists in ignoring safety rules and now someone has been seriously injured.
He should be expelled and he should lose his skateboard too - He is so badly behaved that he should not be trusted with it.

Supersimkin2 · 28/01/2023 19:35

The kid’s 12 not 4 - too big in every sense to injure someone that badly without comeback.

He’s too old and too told about the rules to claim oblivious innocence for what’s not so much an accident as neglect.

Expulsion’s fine, needs an apology and restitution too.

Shell4429 · 28/01/2023 19:33

If it was my arm expulsion wouldn’t go far enough for me.

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/01/2023 19:32

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:29

Theoretically, but it would be expensive and financially probably wouldn’t be worth it unless she has legal insurance to pursue through a solicitor, or on a no win no fee basis. Realistically I don’t think she’d get very far with it.

Well if she did find a no win no fee solicitor then she'd have absolutely nothing to lose and potentially something to gain.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 19:30

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:27

And if I were a member of that club and threatened with cancellation of my membership for speaking my mind, I would resign it anyway.

I think that would be a good outcome. It would be best if people participating in the harassment of young children didn’t attend youth clubs.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:29

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/01/2023 19:27

She could sue the child himself, but any reparation wouldn’t be payable until he turns 18.

So you confirmed in theory she CAN sue..

Theoretically, but it would be expensive and financially probably wouldn’t be worth it unless she has legal insurance to pursue through a solicitor, or on a no win no fee basis. Realistically I don’t think she’d get very far with it.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:27

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 19:15

Surely the ‘cancel culture’ here is from those who want to ban a child from a sports club, over an accident that has already been dealt with by the club.

I think a group of adults harassing pre-teen a child is wrong and, if I operated the club, I would not tolerate it.

And if I were a member of that club and threatened with cancellation of my membership for speaking my mind, I would resign it anyway.

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/01/2023 19:27

She could sue the child himself, but any reparation wouldn’t be payable until he turns 18.

So you confirmed in theory she CAN sue..

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:24

SherlockStones · 28/01/2023 19:19

They should be banned for what exactly?

What utter rubbish

Most posters are making the point that the punishment should fit what he did. Did you miss the fact that he’s been reprimanded several times for arguing with the referee, and had been asked not to skateboard in the building ? So he has an unwillingness to accept authority which has now resulted in him disobeying the request not to skateboard in the building, thus causing significant injury to someone. So what punishment do you think he should face ?

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/01/2023 19:23

She can’t sue the parents, they’re not responsible for the actions of the child.

That's a shame.

EasterIsland · 28/01/2023 19:21

no, she deserves the sympathy of someone knocked over by a kid who was doing something he was expressly told not to do a short time before

Quite!

No wonder the Relationships and AIBU sections here are full of stories of careless and thoughtless men.

12 years old is old enough to understand that there can be serious consequences from reckless and rule breaking activities.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:20

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/01/2023 19:16

I'm assuming in theory the lady in question could sue for her injuries.

She can’t sue the parents, they’re not responsible for the actions of the child. She could sue the child himself, but any reparation wouldn’t be payable until he turns 18. It wasn’t a criminal act so she can’t claim criminal injuries, and she’d have a hard time trying to prove that the club was in any way negligent. So no, nowhere to go with it, despite the fact that she will be incapacitated for some time and that will have a negative impact on her mobility and possibly her finances.

SherlockStones · 28/01/2023 19:19

They should be banned for what exactly?

What utter rubbish

Toomuchtrouble4me · 28/01/2023 19:18

Accidents happen. The security in our local supermarket stop kids on their scooters and the yummy mummy’s truly shocked that their kids can’t do exactly as they please have to carry scooters and comfort screaming sophia or Sebastian. The ‘elite’ sports club should have a doorman/security to make sure there are no breeches of rules. But really he could have ran and knocked her over, he’s a kid and shit happens. He should be told there will be a ban if he rides inside again and that’s it. The club should up their game.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:17

Nameneeded · 28/01/2023 19:06

He's 12 !!!!!! They do dumb things. It's part of growing up and unfortunately sone one got hurt. Stop demonising children.

Have you read the full thread ? Some people are so hell bent on excusing what this boy did, that they’re actually blaming the victim. Wanting a child who has caused serious injury to someone to be punished in a way that allows them to learn, recognise the seriousness of what they’ve done and understand that their actions have consequences is not ‘demonising children’.

sunnydaytoday0 · 28/01/2023 19:16

I'm assuming in theory the lady in question could sue for her injuries.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 19:15

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:14

Why ? Do they not have the right to free speech, or is this just another example of cancel culture if you dare to disagree with something ?

Surely the ‘cancel culture’ here is from those who want to ban a child from a sports club, over an accident that has already been dealt with by the club.

I think a group of adults harassing pre-teen a child is wrong and, if I operated the club, I would not tolerate it.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:14

NoBoatsOnSunday · 28/01/2023 19:08

I agree with whoever it was upthread that said adults participating in this ‘protest’ should be banned from the club (assuming they get a warning first).

OP, you should let the club know of the apparent protest in advance, so that it can be nipped in the bud.

Why ? Do they not have the right to free speech, or is this just another example of cancel culture if you dare to disagree with something ?

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 28/01/2023 19:12

Sugarfree23 · 28/01/2023 18:27

So a kid who's doing well at his sport, playing at an elite level, with little interest from his parents. We don't know what else is going on in the kids life. Are they interested in anything he does?

We can assume there is only one place locally he can do the sport at elite level (elite places tend to be few and far between), needs to be local so he can get there himself.

It might have been stupid and careless but it wasn't intentional. Banning him seems really extreme.
What would the consequences be if he hadn't actually hit anyone or only hurt himself would you still be giving him a ban?
The crime is the same

Why are you assuming that he has little interest from his parents ? They may work, they may have other children to look after - any number of things. We can’t assume anything to the point where we excuse what he did. And whether or not he hit anyone or only injured himself is irrelevant. He has been reprimanded several times for arguing with the referee and he ignored being asked not to use the skateboard in the building. This demonstrates an unwillingness to accept authority, and he badly injured someone as a result. That seems to be a fact that few people seem to want to focus on.