Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers strike

62 replies

PaTCh64355 · 27/01/2023 15:04

I appreciate this has probably been covered a lot in here but I can’t find a good summary. please could some teachers explain why they are striking.

my natural instinct is not to support the strikes. Children have been put through so much over the last few years, not to mention the impact on working parents. I’ve never worked in the public sector so have no understanding of unions.

this is honestly not meant as a goady post - I really want to understand the teachers position so I can be informed.

OP posts:
TakeNoTwitsGiveNoDucks · 27/01/2023 17:10

I fully support teachers going on strike. I think it is a joke how they are treated. It's really not a fun job. They really put the kids' needs above their own and I respect teachers a lot. (I used to work in a school but I was not a teacher).

flumposie · 27/01/2023 17:07

Education is in crisis and parents need to wake up to that. I agree with everything that has been said previously. Personally after 26 years of teaching in state schools, my goodwill has gone. We are expected to do more, for example redundancies result in us picking up more teaching as staff are not replaced. This means I'm too exhausted to offer revision sessions during my unpaid lunch, after school or unpaid holidays. The way we were vilified during the pandemic ( I was teaching live lessons with my own child sat next to me being ignored mostly). For me it's not about pay but working conditions. I'm almost 52 and wouldn't want to be starting my career now.

AutumnIsHere21 · 27/01/2023 16:35

Many teachers ARE working parents!

RaraRachael · 27/01/2023 16:30

Teaching is shit nowadays - as PPs have outlined. It's bad where I am in Scotland but 10 times worse in England. I don't know how people there can do it and why anyone would thinking of becoming a teacher.

my natural instinct is not to support the strikes. Children have been put through so much over the last few years, not to mention the impact on working parents.

People bang on about "Children having lost 2 years' education during lockdown" but they didn't. I found it more stressful doing online teaching during Covid than physically teaching. Lockdown wasn't the teachers' fault nor their choice to do online teaching.
The point of strikes is to impact people. Yes it may be difficult for working parents, but the strike would be pointless otherwise.

IhearyouClemFandango · 27/01/2023 15:56

I support all strikers tbh because unions are important. I think what is being done to education is shocking, even if I don't feel that teachers are the worst treated around.

My secondary age child will be at home, so far both primary kids will be in.

KeepingKeepingOn · 27/01/2023 15:37

Disclaimer: not a teacher, but surrounded by a lot :)

Please don’t assume this is just about teachers wanting more money, although they are right to want this given how many years they’ve been underpaid. Most of those I know that are striking are doing so because they feel that education has been systematically deprioritised by a succession of Tory governments, culminating in a genuine funding crisis right now that the govt is making no attempts to help with. Instead they’re pushing the issue to councils, who are also struggling to fund vital social care services, amongst others.

We shouldn’t, in 2022 Britain, be in a position where we have to choose between educating our kids or providing the best care for our most vulnerable - the fact that we are is due in large part to fiscal incompetence on the part of our government. That’s a core sentiment for those I know that are choosing to strike, and one that I absolutely endorse, despite the temporary childcare inconvenience.

Chickenly · 27/01/2023 15:31

As a frame of reference, when I was a teacher:

  • I’d get to school around 6am to get all my printing and resources sorted for the day. I was a science teacher so I needed to prep my practical equipment myself because we had no budget for technicians. Things often can’t be prepped the night before due to health and safety and leaving things too long.
  • My form group would arrive for breakfast club from around 7.30 so I’d be “babysitting” them and dealing with arguments and upsets and who didn’t have a tie and who was wearing trainers etc.
  • Then, I’d have a briefing with my department, the whole school, my year group tutors etc.
  • Then I’d teach lessons all day. If I had a “free” then it’d always be used to cover someone else because of shortages.
  • Break times and lunchtimes, I’d have duties or detentions - every day.
  • After school under 4.30, I’d have science club, teaching PE staff science so they can teach, intervention to help GCSE classes revising, a department meeting.
  • After 4.30, I’d need to do all my marking, planning, making resources, as well as doing those for the PE staff who were teaching science. I’d reply to emails, I’d log behaviour and call parents, I’d make my classroom displays, I’d go to the shops to buy things that were needed for practicals or stationery that had run out, upload homework to online classrooms… I’d usually leave around 7pm but that’s because I personally preferred to get my work done at work.
That doesn’t take into account Parents’ Evening, restorative justice meetings, open evenings…

In an appropriately funded school, teachers wouldn’t be babysitting breakfast club, we wouldn’t be doing technician’s work, we wouldn’t be covering through all our free periods, we wouldn’t be doing the entire pastoral role too. Admin would cover behaviour logging and emailing parents about lateness or wearing trainers.

But, aside from the funding, pupils are violent and the parents aren’t much better. Social attitudes are that it’s a teachers job to get children the grades they want and not a pupils job to actually earn the grade. I’m happy to work long hours, I work longer hours now but working those hours whilst being repeatedly told you’re not doing your job well enough by people who have no concept of what you actually do is simply not worth doing. That’s why I left…it’s why everyone else is leaving.

Before everyone comments with “if you don’t like it then leave” - EVERYONE IS LEAVING!

ManyBooksLittleTime · 27/01/2023 15:30

Some teachers who ate getting the 5 per cent pay increase will strike in aid of those not getting it. 5 per cent also does not keep up with inflation. Chickenly has outlined all the reasons thoroughly

Mark19735 · 27/01/2023 15:30

Strikes force governments to change their policies. One person quitting won't do that. A hundred quitting in a profession of hundreds of thousands won't do that. Striking is the only way.

For every professional that is part of a unionised, cohesive, and strong workforce, there are hundreds of others who are not. They can't strike. But they should support those who can.

Mick Lynch is an absolute hero. His union members are the vanguard - they are leading the way, and the teachers, nurses and others who are following suit and the reinforcements. But the winners will be everybody in a low/medium wage job - private sector, public sector, corporate giant, small enterprise.

We should support them all - and not fall prey to the vested interests and client media doing the Tories' devil's work pitting one group against the other.

Chickenly · 27/01/2023 15:17

There have been huge numbers of threads on this.

  1. Teachers have had a pay rise but the government aren’t funding it. It’s a pay raise in name only and means schools have no money
  2. Conditions are fucking awful in schools
  3. OFSTED are completely unfit for purpose - they rated a school as “good” even though they locked a child outside naked as a punishment and yet schools are still held to ransom by them
  4. Teachers have to work stupid hours and through their holiday to meet expectations
  5. Schools have no money, they will go bust. They can’t afford support staff, they can’t afford books, they can’t afford glue…
  6. Parents are a nightmare, it’s a minority but if you teach 100 children then even 1% being awful is a difficult situation to deal with every day. Look at the threads on here about teachers shouldn’t be allowed to vape or a teacher called my kid “bossy” etc.
  7. Teacher recruitment and retention is dire. We will have none left.

But this thread will descend into chaos like the others with arguments about getting 13 weeks paid holiday (forgetting that the holidays are unpaid), that you’re guaranteed £40,000 after 6 years (absolutely untrue), that the pension is 27% (you don’t actually get that money, it’s essentially hypothetical money)…

Teachers can’t strike except on a few, very narrow reasons. So, technically it’s to increase pay. But the negotiations and the aim is to raise awareness for the fact that we need the government to fund schools appropriately and allow them to actually do their job of educating children rather than be bound by restrictions and red tape that make schools unsafe for children and teachers, and mean no one is getting the opportunities and education that they deserve.

I used to be a teacher. I wouldn’t send my children to a state school if you paid me. I feel sorry for parents who have no choice and even more sorry for the parents who don’t know how awful conditions are now.

JT69 · 27/01/2023 15:14

As Sirzy says. Education is an utter bin fire. No money, over stretched staff, vacancies not filled, recruitment and retention issues. We are failing our children especially those with Send - every day we fire fight just to get through the day. I’m a TA and not striking as my Union were instructed by its members to accept the below inflation rise. Sadly It looks like TAs will be strike breaking next week and expected to cover colleagues too.

Sirzy · 27/01/2023 15:07

schools are being expected to do more on more on tighter and tighter budgets.

the pay increase given to teachers wasn’t funded so has to come out of the already very tight budget.

teacher and support staff numbers are plummeting and morale is low.

basically the system is failing children. Not because of the staff doing the job but as a result of goverment pressure and cuts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread