Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers strike

62 replies

PaTCh64355 · 27/01/2023 15:04

I appreciate this has probably been covered a lot in here but I can’t find a good summary. please could some teachers explain why they are striking.

my natural instinct is not to support the strikes. Children have been put through so much over the last few years, not to mention the impact on working parents. I’ve never worked in the public sector so have no understanding of unions.

this is honestly not meant as a goady post - I really want to understand the teachers position so I can be informed.

OP posts:
PyjamaFan · 31/01/2023 09:37

I'm a former primary teacher and am furious about what is happening to my profession and to schools to in general. If it was possible to do the job in a normal working week, ie say 40 hours rather than 70 or more, I would be back like a shot.

I also really struggle with the terrible attitudes people in the media, government and even some parents have about teachers. It massively affected my mental health. That combined with the work load pushed me out.

Blagdoon · 31/01/2023 09:21

School conditions are dreadful. Energy bills have gone up. Teacher salaries have gone up. Prices have gone up. But schools haven’t received any extra money to cover it. So the money has had to come from sacking support staff, not buying resources, sharing teachers between classes and putting TAs at the front of the class, and cutting everything to the bone.

But the only thing teachers can legally strike about is pay. Your kids are having an absolutely shit time at school, I don’t know why parents aren’t up in arms?

Dinosaurpoopy · 31/01/2023 09:15

I truly loved teaching, but I'm pregnant with my second and I'm done. It's exhausting, behaviour is shocking, the amount of work I need to do and think about isn't manageable and last week a parent had a go at me for removing their child who shoved another student over in lesson..

ClassroomRunaway · 31/01/2023 09:13

It is sad. I really wasn't enjoying my job at all by the end, which is how I knew it was time to move on asap.

BusyMum47 · 31/01/2023 08:59

@ClassroomRunaway

It's sad, isn't it? I used to love my job... still do at times, to be honest. I went into it fully aware that the pay wasn't great but the hours suited my family & I genuinely felt like I was making a difference on a daily basis.

Over the years, however, it's just become soul destroying. Trying to do too much with too little, failing kids left & right, through no fault of our own, working way too many extra, unpaid hours, stressing out about the workload, acting as a social worker, mental health support, untrained 1st aider, covering the teachers for ALL absence & PPA because there's no money for supply teachers...all whilst regularly facing off the scale disrespect, rudeness & dodging flying furniture! It's fucking exhausting.

ClassroomRunaway · 31/01/2023 08:42

@BusyMum47 I've just left my TA role. Behaviour is appalling in primary and secondary schools. Primary is actually worse in my recent experience as there are no consequences for bad behaviour. Children who have no idea how to behave but do know the full lexicon of swear words and know how to make racist comments under their breath. No support for staff / consequences for poor behaviour (I know it's all natural consequences these days, but even those don't happen consistently or at all).

Pay is low, low, low. I took home £1000 per month and I'm a graduate who speaks two additional languages (languages taught in schools).

I'm off to find something else. Even working in a supermarket or cafe. I've done high end hospitality and yes, it's hard, but it's nothing compared to having to somehow prevent aggressive big lads from beating the crap out of each other without any training. Oh, for fun, in my last school the first aid was all done by the TA in the class whether they had training or not. On the face of it that's all fine, but if you do the wrong thing or don't record everything meticulously you can lose your job or worse if parents complain. TAs and 1:1s live in constant fear of an "allegation".

I don't think teaching is the hardest job in the world either though. There are clearly harder jobs out there. But I personally find classrooms more depressing and emotionally draining than every other type of work I've personally done, including high stress office jobs and high end hospitality with long hours and extremely high standards and arsey customers. If people think otherwise, you only need to look at stressed parents who are only responsible for a few children. If it's that easy looking after 30 kids, then parenting must be so easy (it isn't though. Kids are lovely, but being responsible for them is hard work).

Anyway, good luck to us both in our job hunts!

BusyMum47 · 31/01/2023 08:22

Chickenly · 27/01/2023 15:17

There have been huge numbers of threads on this.

  1. Teachers have had a pay rise but the government aren’t funding it. It’s a pay raise in name only and means schools have no money
  2. Conditions are fucking awful in schools
  3. OFSTED are completely unfit for purpose - they rated a school as “good” even though they locked a child outside naked as a punishment and yet schools are still held to ransom by them
  4. Teachers have to work stupid hours and through their holiday to meet expectations
  5. Schools have no money, they will go bust. They can’t afford support staff, they can’t afford books, they can’t afford glue…
  6. Parents are a nightmare, it’s a minority but if you teach 100 children then even 1% being awful is a difficult situation to deal with every day. Look at the threads on here about teachers shouldn’t be allowed to vape or a teacher called my kid “bossy” etc.
  7. Teacher recruitment and retention is dire. We will have none left.

But this thread will descend into chaos like the others with arguments about getting 13 weeks paid holiday (forgetting that the holidays are unpaid), that you’re guaranteed £40,000 after 6 years (absolutely untrue), that the pension is 27% (you don’t actually get that money, it’s essentially hypothetical money)…

Teachers can’t strike except on a few, very narrow reasons. So, technically it’s to increase pay. But the negotiations and the aim is to raise awareness for the fact that we need the government to fund schools appropriately and allow them to actually do their job of educating children rather than be bound by restrictions and red tape that make schools unsafe for children and teachers, and mean no one is getting the opportunities and education that they deserve.

I used to be a teacher. I wouldn’t send my children to a state school if you paid me. I feel sorry for parents who have no choice and even more sorry for the parents who don’t know how awful conditions are now.

This! ⬆️ With bells on!!

I'm a long serving TA & I'm finally broken & reluctantly looking for other jobs. Our pay is an utter joke & is so far out of line for what's expected of us these days. Restraining violent children, getting abuse from parents & being regularly sworn at is, sadly, a pretty 'normal' occurrence.

Chaotica · 31/01/2023 01:05

Just stopping by the thread, OP, to say that I'll be supporting the teachers (for reasons given by others already). In fact, I'll be out demonstrating with them on Wednesday when the university staff will be on strike too. We all worked through covid etc, only to get lower pay, pensions destroyed and an increased workload. On the whole, we like our jobs and don't want to disrupt anyone's education, but management and the government have stopped listening to us. Striking is the only way.

DONTMESSWITHMEDARNA · 31/01/2023 00:54

on a personal note i have zero interest either way as i chose to opt my kids out of the schooling system as we home educate so it don't effect us either way(not did online learning through lockdown we carried on as normal)

but the system has been failing for years,
this is why millions have turned to(ie taken kids out)or chose from day 1 to home educate.the system is no longer equipt and traditional schooling no longer works

its even worse for SEN kids,there are millions in between, with no where to go

take my son hes 12 should be y7 but because of numerous disabilities on the 7-8 mark.
if he was in school mainstream wouldn't be suitable and hes not "disabled enough" for special schools.(i had a friend told exactly this from her la)
but where im from(rural south wales, im 40 minutes from cardiff)they dont exist anyway,the nearest is Bristol which in a car would take 50-60 mins and technically thats england so wouldnt be accepted anyway.

Littlebluedinosaur · 31/01/2023 00:29

Did you know that Ofsted and the DfE will also be on strike?

leccybill · 31/01/2023 00:23

dutysuite · 28/01/2023 18:23

Why do academy schools need such a huge SLT? My child’s school has 9 head and assistant head teachers, surely this needs looking into?

Because they can get away with it.
Academies are all about directing funds to 'leadership.'

Katiejane19 · 31/01/2023 00:04

For context: I work in a large comprehensive-I am in my 20th year of teaching-7 different schools and this head is the best I have worked for.when the school found out they had to fund the pay rise out of the already agreed budget the head said-we will have to make cuts somewhere but it will not be to staff. So she kept us all on-teachers, support staff, everyone.many schools in the area did the opposite and either made staff redundant or didn’t replace people leaving. The downside is we have very little heating-most days, most children sit in their coats most of the day.and no money for maintenance. The two classrooms across from mine cannot be used when it rains heavily as water comes through roof and there is no money in budget to fix it. And parents don’t realise this. No one would work in an office that was unheated in winter and with water pouring through the roof. And yet we expect our children to.For me, as for so many others, this is not just about pay. And it’s not just about conditions. It’s also about the crap deal that this generation of children are getting.

blueskylie · 28/01/2023 18:46

Pay for teachers has fallen in real terms over the last 12 years. Public sector pay freezes, or capped to 1% mean that pay has not kept up with inflation. And the worst hit have been the more experienced teachers. As a result, there's a massive recruitment and retention crisis, been going on for years, and the wheels are falling off.

Conditions in schools are utter shit and many teachers are leaving, because the money is not worth it.

You may also see that teachers are asking for fully funded pay rise. Currently, schools are given a budget roughly according to how many students they have, and the school pays everything, including teacher wages, out of that budget. If employer costs rise (NI changes for example, pay rises) the school has to absorb that. As school budgets have been squeezed so much in the last 12 years, you often see schools that can't afford more experienced staff (as they are more expensive). They have made class sizes larger, got rid of support staff, chosen less experienced staff over those with experience. You can imagine the problems that brings to schools, where support staff are slashed, budgets slashed, class sizes maximised, and run by new teachers. Teachers don't want a wage cut in a cost of living crisis, and neither do they want the school budget to have to absorb the cost of a pay rise.

dutysuite · 28/01/2023 18:23

Why do academy schools need such a huge SLT? My child’s school has 9 head and assistant head teachers, surely this needs looking into?

RaraRachael · 28/01/2023 11:20

@Fairislefandango that is so true on every level. I wish somebody would actually do a reality thing about what being a teacher is really like.
However we'd probably still not get a lot of public support. All the public seem to see are the long holidays.
I don't know what can be done to change the public perception of the job.

June2008 · 27/01/2023 20:45

I have been teaching secondary for 24 years and at times still love it. Those wow moments are what keeps me in it for now. (I gave up all extra responsibility when I had my children.)
However, I am given 5 hours per fortnight to plan 45 hours of lessons. That includes the prep, the resources and the subsequent marking follow up for each lesson. Therefore like all other teachers I have to work before and after school hours, evenings and weekends to ensure it is all done. Usually somewhere between 100-120 hours a fortnight.

We are also dealing with an incredible amount of need from our students and sometimes from the parents. And behaviour is declining all the time. (Last year I was assulted, hit in the face, mainly due to lack of support for the student.) We simply do not have the support staff to cope with it so much falls on form tutors or heads of year. Trying to balance the needs of my own children and those of the job is heartbreaking at times.

My wages have 20% less purchasing power than they did 10 years ago as we have had either nothing or inadequate pay rises. My pension scheme was changed and is not what I signed up for when I joined the profession.

At my school we have a number of vacancies we cannot fill, therefore lesson are taught by supply who can be any specialism not ideal for GCSE classes. I hear in other schools of exam classes of up to 90 students being taught in school halls by the only subject specialist available. No school is going to advertise this but its becoming the reality.

Conditions in schools are rapidly declining and striking is the only way of bringing attention to the dire straights we are in. Teachers and leaders trying to make their voices heard has not worked. What else can we do to?

Quite simply schools need to be adequately funded and teachers pay needs to be more in line with where it should have been if the government had treated us fairly. Conditions now are not what I signed up for.

Personally, I'm not sure how much more my family can take so something is going to have to give.

HereBeFuckery · 27/01/2023 19:41

@Chickenly

I've been attempting to find this out online but not found the answer.

"Teachers can’t strike except on a few, very narrow reasons."

What are the reasons and why are we so limited in what we can strike on? I've read a few government guidance docs but they all focus on how to strike not reasons why you are allowed to strike as a teacher. I'm intrigued and want to be able to answer questions from family and on the picket line as to why we haven't called a strike about working conditions?

Thank you!

PumpkinDart · 27/01/2023 18:42

I support the teachers/ teaching staff striking. My children's school remains open as usual on Wednesday but whilst it would inconvenience me if they were I think it's for the benefit of our children in the long run.

Long term investment is needed in schools but an immediate "plaster" for the issue would be to make sure teachers/ school staff are adequately paid to try and stop so many experienced teaching staff leaving and making the situation worse. It would also hopefully entice others back to the career or those with an interest into it. The strikes are highlighting the huge issues in the profession and the impact this will have on our children's education if things aren't improved is likely to be grim.

BakedBear · 27/01/2023 18:32

Teacher pay has been cut by between 13-20% in real terms since 2010. This means that teachers are now working one day per week unpaid compared to 2010.

School budgets have been depleted and destroyed, there is no money left for basics including stationery, the job is dreadful and the children are suffering from the lack of resources and staff. If your child has any kind of special educational need or disability then they almost certainly will not receive the support that they are entitled to.

PennyRa · 27/01/2023 17:59

Makes me laugh watching people get all angy over a couple days of no one wanting to teach their kids when there are thousands of us who have had years of it 😂

Your kids are your responsibility 🤦

Jedsnewstar · 27/01/2023 17:36

Social attitudes are that it’s a teachers job to get children the grades they want and not a pupils job to actually earn the grade

This is a massively important point. There is almost zero responsibility on children and young adults to engage in lessons and ‘try’. The attitude is ‘you are not making it fun enough’.

Fairislefandango · 27/01/2023 17:35

I doubt I know a single teacher who would choose a payrise above a reduction in workload. Instead of worrying about the lost learning caused by a few days of (some teachers) striking, parents should be worrying about the huge amounts of lost learning caused by massive staff absences and failure to recruit or retain teachers, resulting in kids across the country constantly being stuck with ad hoc supply teachers and non-subject-specialists. Sometimes for months. This happens week-in week-out across the country. A few days' strike is a drop in the ocean by comparison.

In any case, it makes no difference whether your instinct is to support the strikes or not!

Changechangechanging · 27/01/2023 17:34

You don’t want to be goody but couldn’t be bothered to read the other threads on this? Th ones that explain in detail what is happening in schools?

Thedogscollar · 27/01/2023 17:33

Chickenly · 27/01/2023 15:31

As a frame of reference, when I was a teacher:

  • I’d get to school around 6am to get all my printing and resources sorted for the day. I was a science teacher so I needed to prep my practical equipment myself because we had no budget for technicians. Things often can’t be prepped the night before due to health and safety and leaving things too long.
  • My form group would arrive for breakfast club from around 7.30 so I’d be “babysitting” them and dealing with arguments and upsets and who didn’t have a tie and who was wearing trainers etc.
  • Then, I’d have a briefing with my department, the whole school, my year group tutors etc.
  • Then I’d teach lessons all day. If I had a “free” then it’d always be used to cover someone else because of shortages.
  • Break times and lunchtimes, I’d have duties or detentions - every day.
  • After school under 4.30, I’d have science club, teaching PE staff science so they can teach, intervention to help GCSE classes revising, a department meeting.
  • After 4.30, I’d need to do all my marking, planning, making resources, as well as doing those for the PE staff who were teaching science. I’d reply to emails, I’d log behaviour and call parents, I’d make my classroom displays, I’d go to the shops to buy things that were needed for practicals or stationery that had run out, upload homework to online classrooms… I’d usually leave around 7pm but that’s because I personally preferred to get my work done at work.
That doesn’t take into account Parents’ Evening, restorative justice meetings, open evenings…

In an appropriately funded school, teachers wouldn’t be babysitting breakfast club, we wouldn’t be doing technician’s work, we wouldn’t be covering through all our free periods, we wouldn’t be doing the entire pastoral role too. Admin would cover behaviour logging and emailing parents about lateness or wearing trainers.

But, aside from the funding, pupils are violent and the parents aren’t much better. Social attitudes are that it’s a teachers job to get children the grades they want and not a pupils job to actually earn the grade. I’m happy to work long hours, I work longer hours now but working those hours whilst being repeatedly told you’re not doing your job well enough by people who have no concept of what you actually do is simply not worth doing. That’s why I left…it’s why everyone else is leaving.

Before everyone comments with “if you don’t like it then leave” - EVERYONE IS LEAVING!

Brilliant post. Spells it out clearly. A day in the life of a teacher. Definitely not worth the money or stress.
I'm a midwife in the NHS it's much the same our numbers are down students leave soon after qualifying. The stress is huge to keep everyone safe with little staff.
Every shift is a slog.
I'm 100% behind the teachers their conditions for pay do not equate.

MinceandMash · 27/01/2023 17:25

‘Impact on working parents’?! You are aware that school isn’t child care aren’t you?🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread