Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers strike

62 replies

PaTCh64355 · 27/01/2023 15:04

I appreciate this has probably been covered a lot in here but I can’t find a good summary. please could some teachers explain why they are striking.

my natural instinct is not to support the strikes. Children have been put through so much over the last few years, not to mention the impact on working parents. I’ve never worked in the public sector so have no understanding of unions.

this is honestly not meant as a goady post - I really want to understand the teachers position so I can be informed.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 02/02/2023 07:11

spanieleyes · 01/02/2023 20:17

We are the same. Just had an email to say we have now run out of money and so nothing more until April, no resources, no supply staff, no school trips, nothing except pure essentials. This because we have had to find the extra pay rise from existing budgets that were already at stretching point.

It's insane we are in this situation, and you know some teachers will end up funding resources out of their own pockets. And of course then the classes where teachers don't have spare cash are effectively missing out.

spanieleyes · 01/02/2023 20:17

We are the same. Just had an email to say we have now run out of money and so nothing more until April, no resources, no supply staff, no school trips, nothing except pure essentials. This because we have had to find the extra pay rise from existing budgets that were already at stretching point.

nodtik · 01/02/2023 20:09

Teachers are striking as the non funded pay rise for teaching and non teaching staff cost my school close to £500k.

Money that should be spent on the students. The pay rise was announced after the budget was set and heads were expected to just 'find' the money!

The only way to do it, was to use money designed to improve the school buildings, buy resources and buy in extra support services for the most needy.

This is why it's a problem!

Welshmonster · 01/02/2023 20:02

More so in secondary schools that subjects like maths and science are being taught by unqualified staff. So not even qualified teachers of a different subject. My kids secondary has an 18 year old cover supervisor teaching maths on minimum wage and that will be a term time only contract. This will mean high turnover of staff.
this is what teachers want to strike about but are limited to pay and a couple of other reasons.

the switch to academies means that education will become the Wild West once all academies as the school will be able to say we can’t meet their needs and move SEND kids on elsewhere because they want to free up space for high achieving pupils to make league tables look good

Welshmonster · 01/02/2023 19:58

I’m leaving teaching at Easter and I’m taking a £10k pay drop because I would rather make significant sacrifices and be happy rather than feeling like I want to crash into a tree every day. Behaviour is awful. I teach in primary and the disruption is ridiculous.
I don’t have any support from a TA. The special needs kids are ignored due to poor behaviour of some who have no excuse other than they think it’s funny.

I can’t wait to leave and I’m going to be working from home alone with peace and quiet.

timetorefresh · 01/02/2023 08:26

Some info attached

Teachers strike
Teachers strike
Teachers strike
RaraRachael · 31/01/2023 22:56

Agree too re @Mrsmarula's post.
Would teachers be included in your plan so that they can have a nice cheap term time break too? 🙄

Fairislefandango · 31/01/2023 22:52

@Mrsmarula One of the most stupid posts I have ever read on here!

Agreed. Some people clearly don't follow their thoughts through as far as considering the actual consequences, do they?

SeanMean · 31/01/2023 22:25

@Mrsmarula One of the most stupid posts I have ever read on here!😂

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/01/2023 22:23

Fairislefandango · 27/01/2023 17:35

I doubt I know a single teacher who would choose a payrise above a reduction in workload. Instead of worrying about the lost learning caused by a few days of (some teachers) striking, parents should be worrying about the huge amounts of lost learning caused by massive staff absences and failure to recruit or retain teachers, resulting in kids across the country constantly being stuck with ad hoc supply teachers and non-subject-specialists. Sometimes for months. This happens week-in week-out across the country. A few days' strike is a drop in the ocean by comparison.

In any case, it makes no difference whether your instinct is to support the strikes or not!

You may doubt it, but there are schools in many parts of the country that can't recruit teachers in part because the rent in the local area isn't affordable for a single, young teacher.

I know ECTs who have opted out of the pension because it's the only way they can pay their bills.

In terms of recruitment, we need to offer a salary that is competitive with grad jobs in science and maths especially, which currently, the salary isn't, especially early career.

A reduction in workload would be nice, if you're comfortable, but I think economic factors play a big part in people leaving the profession early on, and choosing where to teach.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 31/01/2023 22:20

Unions aren't just for those in the public sector... If you have a job, you honestly ought to educate yourself about unions.

In terms of teaching:

Right now in the county where I live, I know of schools who can't recruit teachers for science, maths, compsci, languages and geography. I know of schools who can't recruit, full stop.

This is a county where even in 2019, the teacher shortage wasn't really been felt in the same way as some other parts of the country.

The impact of this is:

  1. Rising class sizes

  2. Students not being taught by subject specialists or qualified teachers.

  3. Students being taught for long periods by short or long term supply.

  4. Schools that are stretched to breaking point with cover etc on a "normal" day, so when anything goes wrong, you end up with large groups of kids being "taught" communally in the hall etc.

You say we shouldn't strike because "children have been put through so much in the last years". The current situation in schools is not helping them catch up academically or supporting them emotionally. If anyone deserves a decent education by properly qualified teachers, then it's surely kids who have been impacted by covid. But they aren't getting it, and recruitment figures to teacher training this year suggests things will only get worse.

In terms of "the impact on working parents"- the only way this strike will be won is if the impact on the wider economy is big enough that the Tories have to negotiate properly. Being blunt, I care more about the kids I teach who don't have proper, permanent teachers in other subjects, or the kids who won't have them in the future.

Nellodee · 31/01/2023 22:10

Everyone gets to see the inside of hospitals. We can see they’re run down, under funded, under staffed. The public don’t get to see the inside of schools in the same way. People don’t die, they’re not queued up outside classrooms on trolleys, but all the same kind of problems exist. Not enough staff, not enough investment. All our services are run down into the ground. It’s not just nursing, it’s not just teaching. It’s councils and social workers and probation, libraries, roads, social care. The entire fabric of society is fraying due to the massive neglect and self interest of this corrupt government. The whole bloody lot needs sorting out, it’s more than just each area separately.

JulianCasa · 31/01/2023 22:08

Mark19735 · 27/01/2023 15:30

Strikes force governments to change their policies. One person quitting won't do that. A hundred quitting in a profession of hundreds of thousands won't do that. Striking is the only way.

For every professional that is part of a unionised, cohesive, and strong workforce, there are hundreds of others who are not. They can't strike. But they should support those who can.

Mick Lynch is an absolute hero. His union members are the vanguard - they are leading the way, and the teachers, nurses and others who are following suit and the reinforcements. But the winners will be everybody in a low/medium wage job - private sector, public sector, corporate giant, small enterprise.

We should support them all - and not fall prey to the vested interests and client media doing the Tories' devil's work pitting one group against the other.

👏👏👏👏👏

MatronicO6 · 31/01/2023 21:58

I'm striking as the state of education is currently dire and looking increasingly bleak due to being starved of necessary funds. It goes beyond offering fair and reasonable salary to make the workload bearable. We are literally begging education be prioritised the way it should be before it reaches crisis point.

The right wing media is quick to dismiss teachers as money hungry for rejecting a 5% pay increase but repeatedly fail to mention this 5% increase is not actually being funded. Schools are being asked to "find" the money in their existing budgets. Where is that coming from? The kids. It is taking away support staff and resources from pupils.

I have been teaching for over a decade and never voted in a strike action ballot. I did vote this time as I am extremely concerned about what I am seeing in schools. I am concerned that our pupils are not getting enough and that we as a society are failing them. I am very worried about the education my child will receive and unless you can afford private education, you should be very worried as well.

BibbleandSqwauk · 31/01/2023 21:28

@Mrsmarula and if you chose to take your child out on the day they covered X concept, when are you expecting the teacher to catch the child up on that? Times 30 obviously, times, say 5 days each. That's 150 lesso a you want set separately as catch-up work. Ok.

twinkletoesimnot · 31/01/2023 21:16

@Mrsmarula

How the hell would that work with 30 kids all taking different days?
Not practical at all.

Mrsmarula · 31/01/2023 21:11

Strike aside, what irritates me is the double standards.
They prevent kids from going to school for a day here and there without the kids being given work, but, if a parent does that, they are damaging their child's education.

Why not take some of the term holiday days and say to parents that they can use those days as and when required rather than being set days. The same idea as workplace holiday. I'm not say all of it, maybe just 5 days of it.
They could always say the chosen holiday days can't fall on a particular week here or there if something major is happening but it would save so much aggravation.
It allows flexibility and to cover things such as the odd childcare problem, illness, bereavement of extended family or friends.

Rant over

>misses the point of the post<

Bleese · 31/01/2023 20:53

Schools run on the goodwill of teachers. If they're not paid properly, that goodwill will dry up.

spongebunnyfatpants · 31/01/2023 20:43

This from the Times is a good visual.

Teachers strike
Greenraincoat12 · 31/01/2023 20:13

TakeNoTwitsGiveNoDucks · 27/01/2023 17:10

I fully support teachers going on strike. I think it is a joke how they are treated. It's really not a fun job. They really put the kids' needs above their own and I respect teachers a lot. (I used to work in a school but I was not a teacher).

My child is off school tomorrow due to the strike. I made a point today of walking up to the teacher striking (she looked worried like oh no not another complaint type look) and told her that I support what she's doing. She took my hand and said it meant a lot. I see how hard they work, I have nothing but respect.

neverbeenskiing · 31/01/2023 10:53

Your kids are having an absolutely shit time at school, I don’t know why parents aren’t up in arms?

Many are, but their anger and frustration is mis-directed at school staff, who are also having a shit time, and this is perpetuating the retention crisis in education.

So often I get into school at 7am, open my emails and the first thing I see is a long, 'shouty caps' ridden rant from an angry parent. These are usually fired off in the middle of the night, attacking me personally for things which are completely outside of my or the schools control and blaming me for all their non-school related problems. Often this will be a child I have spent years trying to save from permanent exclusion or becoming disengaged from school altogether, with no support from the services who are actually commissioned and funded to help them. 9 times out of 10 when I call the parent about this they're sweetness and light "oh, I wasn't angry with you, not really, you've been great, I'm just frustrated with XXX (insert general life stuff that is nothing to do with education)". In other words, I needed someone to be angry with and when I typed "if my child kills themselves it'll be your fault!!!!!" at 11pm after a few glasses of Pinot I forgot there would be an actual human being with feelings waking up to recieve it.

Parents will email my Teacher colleagues late on a Sunday night and then complain if they haven't had a response by Monday lunchtime. One of our HOY came back to their office from teaching to find they had over 20 missed calls from a parent, in the space of a few hours. Parents have also posted offensive and factually incorrect things about individual Teachers on social media, including local groups so these posts are then seen by that Teachers own family, friends and neighbours.

Behavior is getting worse as staff are too scared to challenge blatant disregard for the rules, and even behaviour that is unsafe, because they know that this will result in a huge back-lash from the parents so low level disruption is becoming normalised in many schools.

Speaking to colleagues in other schools, there is a general feeling that staff are sick of taking the hit from parent's for the government's failings. I know several Teachers who have cited this as a major factor in their decision to leave the profession over the last few years.

HipTightOnions · 31/01/2023 09:50

I will certainly not fall for the old "missing even one day can be critical to their learning" line that we would hear pre covid.

It's not "the old line".

The issue, of course, with taking your child out for a holiday is that they will be a week behind all the other children's learning and will not be able to catch this up.

Botw1 · 31/01/2023 09:48

I support the strikes because I appreciate its not really about pay.

The whole system, including teachers workload /holidays and expectations around behaviour of pupils needs an overhaul

Public perception of teachers followkng covid probably isn't the best but I hope they achieve their aims

Blagdoon · 31/01/2023 09:45

If it was possible to do the job in a normal working week, ie say 40 hours rather than 70 or more, I would be back like a shot.
Me too. I need a normal 40 hours a week job so I have time to look after my family and my health. I can’t do 70 hours like I did when I was young and single. For one thing I’m not physically capable of that amount of work any more.

Slowingdownagain · 31/01/2023 09:40

I support their right to strike.

However, I have to say the last couple of years have made me feel a lot more relaxed about the kids missing school. They have missed so much for, in hindsight, not always very compelling reasons, and we are told it's all fine and they are resilient etc etc etc. So if I want to take them out for a week to see their grandparents abroad, or a holiday, or a day off to do something we want to do that's difficult to do in school holidays then I will certainly not fall for the old "missing even one day can be critical to their learning" line that we would hear pre covid.