Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Beauty students asked to strip in front of trans rapist at college AFTER sex attacks

957 replies

scratchedbymycat · 27/01/2023 12:42

My AIBU title taken from this news article:

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/beauty-students-asked-strip-front-29063499

This whole 'Isla Bryson' cluster-fuck has me angrier than I can describe.

These girls had to accept and trust this vile individual in their beauty course on the basis of Isla's claim to be a woman, nothing more. They even tolerated abuse from Isla.

They were not told this individual was facing charges of rape. The college claim they didn't know either. Because 'Isla' said he was a women, these young women felt they had no choice but to strip to virtually naked in front of him. Failing to do so would be 'bigoted'.

But he also happens to be a serial rapist. Young women, some possibly aged 16 or so, stripping to virtually naked while a serial rapist watches. If this was my daughter I would be going mad.

Where is the safeguarding?

AIBU to feel viscerally angry with all our politicians about this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 10:03

I don’t accept naivety as an excuse from anyone anymore.

If you can’t see what the issues are and what the very simple and straightforward solution is, you’re part of the problem - directly involved in perpetuating it - so why don’t you just go elsewhere while the rest of us sort this shit out.

It makes me so angry.

Emotionalsupportviper · 28/01/2023 09:58

JudgeRudy · 28/01/2023 03:21

I agree the whole thing is upsetting but I'd say the main factor was that this was a rapist rather than their gender/sex/transidentity.
I'm not sure quite how safeguarding could be applied. They were a student, not a member of staff so their criminal record would be their own business surely. I'm sure there are many students with convictions. Also, the nature of the course surely involves seeing people in states of undress, rather like a nurse.
Just to be clear, I'm really not implying that some of the female students might understandably feel sickened, I'm just not sure if anyone has done anything wrong...other than them of course. Let's say it wasn't a trans person but a cis male or even a female with an unknown pending case for a sex crime. What should have been done differently?

Are you really so naive?

Emotionalsupportviper · 28/01/2023 09:56

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 09:40

For those of you who are aghast at this, now would be a good time to look into Girl Guides.

You're not kidding!

That's a safeguarding horror just waiting to happen.

They sacked every woman who spoke out against men/boys sharing intimate spaces with girls, and put obviously dangerous men into positions of power and responsibility.

If my DD had been still in Brownies/ Guides I would have withdrawn her straight away.

Emotionalsupportviper · 28/01/2023 09:54

DdraigGoch · 27/01/2023 22:01

For that matter, the beautician is pretty vulnerable too. Wasn't there a legal case in Canada revolving around a male client (identifying as a "woman") who wanted to force migrant female beauticians to perform intimate waxes?

You are right, of course - I was so busy concentrating on the thought of this bloke as a beauty therapist giving massages etc to women, I totally forgot that a female therapist could end up with a Jessica Yaniv.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 09:52

I’m getting sick of the disingenuous ‘oh but what could have been done differently?’ comments.

What could have been done differently is what we’ve done differently for hundreds if not thousands of years - keeping the sexes apart in some important aspects! That is and has always been done for reasons of privacy, dignity and protection.

This MALE should not have been training on a course with young women whilst being FALSELY called a woman with the threat that if any of them was uncomfortable or raised safeguarding concerns around it they would be bigots. He should have been treated like a MAN whose presence while they were in states of undress was entirely inappropriate and absolutely WRONG.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 28/01/2023 09:44

The problem is that women were being asked to pretend that the person enrolled on their course was definitely not a man

@HufflepuffRavenclaw Yes, and that's a safeguarding risk. If female students aren't expected to strip off with a bloke then there should be no pressure to "be kind" by stripping off with a trans woman - not from staff, not from the trans student, not from other students, and not even from themselves.

@Sugarfree23 Then colleges need to think harder about how they manage trans inclusion safely, what expectations they've been setting and what messages they've been giving to the students.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 09:40

For those of you who are aghast at this, now would be a good time to look into Girl Guides.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 28/01/2023 09:37

Sugarfree23 · 28/01/2023 09:31

They definitely said on the radio its normally a single sex course.

Well yes. Because 99% of beauty therapists are women. Things like midwifery are probably normally a single sex course too. By convention and practise, not law.

Again, I am not defending the actions of this man in enrolling on the course knowing it would be full of 16/17 year old girls and then making them feel uncomfortable. Any decent man wanting to train as a beauty therapist would have the self-awareness to step out of the tanning, or speak to the college in advance to find another male student to buddy up with.

The whole issue here was that neither the college nor the students were even allowed to go there, question or raise issues, because they were told they had to deny reality and pretend the muscular person with the face tattoo was a woman called Annie.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 09:37

THIS IS WHAT WE TOLD YOU WOULD HAPPEN!!

As SOON as you say, oh but a man can actually be a woman if he says so. And if he says so then he is, and you can’t have any boundaries around it because that would be hateful/bigotry/phobia...

THIS IS WHAT WILL HAPPEN.

It has never been ‘hate’. It has been women desperately warning, desperately telling you that this is FALSE, it is WRONG, it is DANGEROUS.

Rainbowshit · 28/01/2023 09:33

SinnerBoy · 28/01/2023 09:30

Rainbowshit · Today 07:41

The fact is that any male who is using areas where females are undressing is a predator. They know it will make the females uncomfortable and they do it anyway.

They don't do it "anyway," they do it precisely because women and girls are uncomfortable an frightened and that's what they get off on.

Agreed.

Sugarfree23 · 28/01/2023 09:31

They definitely said on the radio its normally a single sex course.

SinnerBoy · 28/01/2023 09:30

Rainbowshit · Today 07:41

The fact is that any male who is using areas where females are undressing is a predator. They know it will make the females uncomfortable and they do it anyway.

They don't do it "anyway," they do it precisely because women and girls are uncomfortable an frightened and that's what they get off on.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 28/01/2023 09:26

@Sugarfree23 Blimey, was that official? That the course was supposed to be for women only but by gender not sex? If so I'm not sure if that's even legal, that could be discriminatory against other men who want to beauticians.

For safeguarding purposes a single gender course needs to be treated as a mixed sex course. Even if it is mostly single sex.

Sure, the legal position is complicated and I'm not sure everyone gets it. There's been a lot of confusion about sex and gender and this case highlights where the confusion can end up.

I was mostly trying to make the point that it very much is about sex and gender.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 28/01/2023 09:20

The course is women only, but the TWAW movement means they can not discriminate.

I don't think it is though. I have had a look on the website for the college under discussion and there is no mention of women only - but there is no mention of spray tanning either, just waxing. The larger college in Glasgow which offers similar courses has a wide range of courses, and features a young man promoting its spa therapy course, which includes body massage.

www.cityofglasgowcollege.ac.uk/courses/nq-complementary-and-spa-therapies-scqf-level-6-2023-08-28

The issue here isn't men on these courses. If we're widening the bandwith of what it means to be a man then of course men should be free to get their waxes or eyelashes tinted and have other men trained to perform those services. No problem with any of that. The problem is that women were being asked to pretend that the person enrolled on their course was definitely not a man, despite the penis and sexual offending. And that voicing their discomfort about having "Annie" participate in all aspects of the class made them transphobic. Because Annie's feels are more important than the dignity and safety of a class of 20 odd teenage girls.

YouJustDoYou · 28/01/2023 09:12

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 28/01/2023 08:35

Men don't have helpful signs attached telling women which ones are rapists or which ones are going to be rapists.

95% of sex crimes are committed by men.

Women don't have penises. Penises are what men rape with.

Women don't continually remind other women of their place in society through catcalling etc.

Women aren't inherently physically stronger than other women. Women don't hold structural power over other women.

The EXTREMELY UNLIKELY scenario of being on a beauty course with a female sex offender of the same seriousness as a male rapist still doesn't hold the same gravity as being on a beauty course with a rapey man.

We safeguard by not admitting men to various spaces for women. We safeguard by not elevating some people to special status above suspicion ( trans, police, priests, celebrities).

"We safeguard by not admitting men to various spaces for women. We safeguard by not elevating some people to special status above suspicion ( trans, police, priests, celebrities)".

Thank you. This. It's the only way, the ONLY WAY, to try and guarantee female safety as much as is possible.

YouJustDoYou · 28/01/2023 09:11

Rainbowshit · 28/01/2023 07:39

There's also the wispa incident where a mother complained about an erect penis in the female area.

She was called a bigot, told it was a female penis and that she should have taught her 9 year old daughter it was rude to look.

The transwomen turned out to be a sex offender and has subsequently been arrested.

www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/exclusive-transgender-fugitive-who-spurred-wi-spa-riots-bares-all/

They all championed him and called her a transphobic bigot, until it turned out he was a sex offender and was erect at the time with the little girl there. Then the community did what it always does when a transwoman is caught out and turns "transwoman" into "man in a dress".

Sugarfree23 · 28/01/2023 09:10

@AmaryllisNightAndDay
It wouldn't be a mixed sex class, it was a single gender course, him going trans caused the college to throw their safeguarding out the window.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 28/01/2023 09:07

First you say this:

The main factor was that this was a rapist rather than their gender/sex/trans identity.

And then you say this:

I'm not sure quite how safeguarding could be applied.

Safeguarding requires treating them like any other male student when it comes to getting undressed in class. And making sure the same rules apply in a mixed sex class regardless of trans identity. So if there are safeguarding differences between what men can do among women students and what women can do among women students then those differences still apply. No cheeky pushing the limits for a trans student.

There are basically two practical ways to do safeguarding: either a trans student has to disclose their status and is treated as their birth sex for all mixed-sex activities and is excluded from an activity that is only safe as single-sex; or no-one has to disclose and all activities are treated as mixed sex no matter what sex or gender people say they are or appear to be - which means any activity which can't be made safe as a mixed-sex activity has to stop for the whole class.

Safeguarding adults doesn't mean knowing if any individual student was accused of rape or not. No-one has a duty to inform the college.

Safeguarding doesn't assume that anyone is a rapist. It protects against the people who might be. Trans identity doesn't change that.

Which is a longwinded way of saying, yes it is about their sex and gender and trans identity and it's not about whether the college found out that one person is accused of rape or not.

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 28/01/2023 08:35

JudgeRudy · 28/01/2023 03:21

I agree the whole thing is upsetting but I'd say the main factor was that this was a rapist rather than their gender/sex/transidentity.
I'm not sure quite how safeguarding could be applied. They were a student, not a member of staff so their criminal record would be their own business surely. I'm sure there are many students with convictions. Also, the nature of the course surely involves seeing people in states of undress, rather like a nurse.
Just to be clear, I'm really not implying that some of the female students might understandably feel sickened, I'm just not sure if anyone has done anything wrong...other than them of course. Let's say it wasn't a trans person but a cis male or even a female with an unknown pending case for a sex crime. What should have been done differently?

Men don't have helpful signs attached telling women which ones are rapists or which ones are going to be rapists.

95% of sex crimes are committed by men.

Women don't have penises. Penises are what men rape with.

Women don't continually remind other women of their place in society through catcalling etc.

Women aren't inherently physically stronger than other women. Women don't hold structural power over other women.

The EXTREMELY UNLIKELY scenario of being on a beauty course with a female sex offender of the same seriousness as a male rapist still doesn't hold the same gravity as being on a beauty course with a rapey man.

We safeguard by not admitting men to various spaces for women. We safeguard by not elevating some people to special status above suspicion ( trans, police, priests, celebrities).

Boiledbeetle · 28/01/2023 08:23

Women are women just women.

Men can never be women.

We are not cis women we are just women.

FOJN · 28/01/2023 08:18

Let's say it wasn't a trans person but a cis male or even a female with an unknown pending case for a sex crime. What should have been done differently?

Let's stop with the cis nonsense. It's used to make women a subset of their own sex class and confers victim status on anyone "claiming" a trans identity which is exactly how a man was accepted onto a beauty training course which would ordinarily have been sex segregated.

You are part of the problem so please stop coercing women with language because it leads, as it did in this case, to abuse.

Boiledbeetle · 28/01/2023 08:17

Rainbowshit · 28/01/2023 07:41

This will be deleted but I don't care.

The fact is that any male who is using areas where females are undressing is a predator. They know it will make the females uncomfortable and they do it anyway.

It's not that they do it anyway.

It's they do it for this exact reason.

people should ask themselves honestly why would a man be so desperate to be in the female changing room. It's a because he wants to look at naked women if possible AND because they get a sexual thrill from knowing we are uncomfortable. I'd go as far to say the uncomfortable feelings they know they cause in women is more of a sexual turn on for them than those just wanting to oggle tits.

Sugarfree23 · 28/01/2023 08:08

JudgeRudy · 28/01/2023 03:21

I agree the whole thing is upsetting but I'd say the main factor was that this was a rapist rather than their gender/sex/transidentity.
I'm not sure quite how safeguarding could be applied. They were a student, not a member of staff so their criminal record would be their own business surely. I'm sure there are many students with convictions. Also, the nature of the course surely involves seeing people in states of undress, rather like a nurse.
Just to be clear, I'm really not implying that some of the female students might understandably feel sickened, I'm just not sure if anyone has done anything wrong...other than them of course. Let's say it wasn't a trans person but a cis male or even a female with an unknown pending case for a sex crime. What should have been done differently?

This is where the college has been thrown under a bus along with the girls safeguarding

The course is women only, but the TWAW movement means they can not discriminate.

Even doing background checks they couldn't discriminate because of innocent until proven.

I am curious as to what eventually caused the college to throw him off the course after 3 months.

Wilkolampshade · 28/01/2023 07:46

JudgeRudy · 28/01/2023 03:21

I agree the whole thing is upsetting but I'd say the main factor was that this was a rapist rather than their gender/sex/transidentity.
I'm not sure quite how safeguarding could be applied. They were a student, not a member of staff so their criminal record would be their own business surely. I'm sure there are many students with convictions. Also, the nature of the course surely involves seeing people in states of undress, rather like a nurse.
Just to be clear, I'm really not implying that some of the female students might understandably feel sickened, I'm just not sure if anyone has done anything wrong...other than them of course. Let's say it wasn't a trans person but a cis male or even a female with an unknown pending case for a sex crime. What should have been done differently?

What would have been different is that a 'normal' man wouldn't have been in there. The activity was intended to be sex segregated. The issue is a trans one because the girls were told by those in authority and by Isla that he was a woman, and they had to accept that. When they were uncomfortable about it, because they could plainly see it was bollocks, they were labelled bigoted.

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 28/01/2023 07:45

Rainbowshit · 28/01/2023 07:39

There's also the wispa incident where a mother complained about an erect penis in the female area.

She was called a bigot, told it was a female penis and that she should have taught her 9 year old daughter it was rude to look.

The transwomen turned out to be a sex offender and has subsequently been arrested.

www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/exclusive-transgender-fugitive-who-spurred-wi-spa-riots-bares-all/

Gosh they were a sex offender? I’m shocked I tell you, shocked 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread