Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Beauty students asked to strip in front of trans rapist at college AFTER sex attacks

957 replies

scratchedbymycat · 27/01/2023 12:42

My AIBU title taken from this news article:

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/beauty-students-asked-strip-front-29063499

This whole 'Isla Bryson' cluster-fuck has me angrier than I can describe.

These girls had to accept and trust this vile individual in their beauty course on the basis of Isla's claim to be a woman, nothing more. They even tolerated abuse from Isla.

They were not told this individual was facing charges of rape. The college claim they didn't know either. Because 'Isla' said he was a women, these young women felt they had no choice but to strip to virtually naked in front of him. Failing to do so would be 'bigoted'.

But he also happens to be a serial rapist. Young women, some possibly aged 16 or so, stripping to virtually naked while a serial rapist watches. If this was my daughter I would be going mad.

Where is the safeguarding?

AIBU to feel viscerally angry with all our politicians about this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
Boiledbeetle · 28/01/2023 12:51

CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · 28/01/2023 12:21

Ooh boiled us using the bigly words, she means business today methinks.

I will admit there has been rather a lot of things that require those just scrolling to notice. And of course there's been a lot of things to be very angry about.

I was on the phone yesterday to my sister and she was obviously distracted she was reading a thread on here..her baby sister was using the bigly letters a lot to admonish an 80s actors tweet.

Outed! (If she hadn't have already known my username!)

😁

Rafferty10 · 28/01/2023 12:49

Of course this sort of thing, is exactly what all sensible women knew was going to happen, whilst we were being shouted down and called vile and anti trans and evil.
If it has a penis it is a man.

scratchedbymycat · 28/01/2023 12:44

@Emotionalsupportviper

If my DD had been still in Brownies/ Guides I would have withdrawn her straight away.

My DD has never had the pleasure of experiencing Brownies / guides because I am not willing to expose her to potential risk.

OP posts:
scratchedbymycat · 28/01/2023 12:40

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 28/01/2023 09:07

First you say this:

The main factor was that this was a rapist rather than their gender/sex/trans identity.

And then you say this:

I'm not sure quite how safeguarding could be applied.

Safeguarding requires treating them like any other male student when it comes to getting undressed in class. And making sure the same rules apply in a mixed sex class regardless of trans identity. So if there are safeguarding differences between what men can do among women students and what women can do among women students then those differences still apply. No cheeky pushing the limits for a trans student.

There are basically two practical ways to do safeguarding: either a trans student has to disclose their status and is treated as their birth sex for all mixed-sex activities and is excluded from an activity that is only safe as single-sex; or no-one has to disclose and all activities are treated as mixed sex no matter what sex or gender people say they are or appear to be - which means any activity which can't be made safe as a mixed-sex activity has to stop for the whole class.

Safeguarding adults doesn't mean knowing if any individual student was accused of rape or not. No-one has a duty to inform the college.

Safeguarding doesn't assume that anyone is a rapist. It protects against the people who might be. Trans identity doesn't change that.

Which is a longwinded way of saying, yes it is about their sex and gender and trans identity and it's not about whether the college found out that one person is accused of rape or not.

Totally this ...

OP posts:
ThreeblackCats · 28/01/2023 12:35

Women are no longer second class citizens, we now rank third after men then trans! What would the suffragettes make of the state of things.

scratchedbymycat · 28/01/2023 12:31

@@JudgeRudy I’m replying to you but I suspect many will have this thought so I am really writing a very long response for the benefit of all women who do not lurk or read the demise sections of MN, or who don’t know the ins and outs of the issue.

I agree the whole thing is upsetting but I'd say the main factor was that this was a rapist rather than their gender/sex/transidentity. I'm not sure quite how safeguarding could be applied.

At face value, I can understand why you and possibly most of the public would think this, but it is more complex and nuanced than that.

It is incredibly important that women understand the nuance and how this event happened because the fact that it was able to happen at all reveals why self-id identity politics is a serious threat to women and girls. So I'm going to try spell it out as straightforwardly as I can.

First: I'm going to reply using Stonewall's position on self-id. Stonewall lobbies heavily and uses all their power and resources to get politicians, organisations, government departments, schools etc to adopt this view. This is very very important to understand.

ISSUE #1

Stonewall's position is that if a biological man says they are a women, then that is what they are. No debate. ("No debate" is stonewalls actual slogan). Further, that that biological male's 'woman' status is exactly equal to biological woman's status irrespective of everything.

Very very important: He may have a beard, male genitalia, never ever take hormones etc, but Stonewall's position is that he is as much a woman as I am. There are men who will apply lipstick amongst their male stubble and beard, and that may be their only nod towards 'womanliness'. But they are - according to radical trans activists - as much a woman as a biological woman.

On the basis of self-id, he now has the absolute right to enter all women's spaces: hospital wards, changing rooms, female prisons, girls toilets at school etc. He has a right to compete against women in sport. He can win female awards, and join in on female short lists. He can demand that he is searched by women police officers etc etc. He IS a woman. No debate.

This logic means: a woman can have a penis; rape is no longer a male crime, it can be committed by women too etc

So understanding all that ...

Isla Bryson is a woman, according to Stonewall. So is Katie Dolatowski (transgender paedophile who targets young girls); Paris Green (murderer); Charlene aka Jonathan Mallon (serial rapist); Sophie Eastwood (murderer who identifies as a baby); Karen White (rapist who went on to rape two more inmates when put in a female prison); there’s another serial rapist as well, whose name I’ve forgotten … these are UK cases. Internationally there are more.

ISSUE #2

Biological natal ‘xx’ women (I have to clarify which women I’m talking about here - normally I’d just say women) have been flagging that self-id presents a safety risk to women and girls. They have been saying that male predators will exploit self-id and use it to harm women and girls. The issue is that every time they say this, they are accused of being transphobic, of being hateful and cruel. Google ‘Lloyd Russell-Moyle’: he literally accused a female parliamentarian of dog-whistle transphobia and bigotry in parliament when she flagged concerns about risks to women. The following week Isla Bryson made the news.

Women are NOT allowed to discuss this; we are not allowed to speak up for our daughters; we are being silenced and refused the right to campaign or mobilise for the safety of women and girls. This is why J.K.Rowling is described as hateful and transphobic. The ONLY thing she has done is use her voice to consistently speak up for women and girls. This is ‘evidence’ of transphobia. Female academics have been hounded out of their jobs for daring to research this subject; women have been fired or ‘cancelled’ if they do the same. Careers have been destroyed. The campaign to prevent women from speaking out is very real, nasty and quite effective at silencing us.

ISSUE #3:

The Equality Act enshrines protections for women and even specifically refers to transgender women. For example, it acknowledges that in rape crisis counselling, it might be necessary to exclude transgender women because their presence might be distressing for victims of rape.

The EA implicitly recognises that while transgender women with a GRC are legally female, there is still a ‘difference’ between them and natal women, which relates to biology. Stonewall does not recognise this difference or any difference at all. Stonewall and radical activists consider biology to be totally irrelevant.

However, the EA is a useful deflection point for transgender activists, the Scottish government etc, who will point to the Equality Act as proof natal women are still being protected.

In practice, on the ground, it’s all Stonewall’s rules and it’s a completely different story. Organisations are too fearful to use their right to legally segregate spaces because of allegations of transphobia. Stonewall would consider a safe space for natal women as unfairly excluding some women - transgender women - who by their rules are exactly the same as natal women. In practice, Stonewall and trans radical activists would lobby for that organisation to have funding withdrawn, activists would vilify the employees, they would be targeted on social media, their reputations careers destroyed.

For example, there’s an extremely brave case going to court soon where a natal female is suing a rape crisis centre for NOT providing a single space sex. They provide segregated spaces for men, trans, etc … but not for women. Another example, JK Rowling has recently set up/funded a single sex space because women can’t access one - this is apparently motivated exclusively by pure hate for transgender women. Third example, Edinburgh Rape Crisis is headed by a trans woman who believes that natal rape survivors need to “reframe their trauma” to accommodate male bodies voices etc in their healing spaces.

Pulling all these threads together now:

BACK TO ISLA BRYSON USING STONEWALLS RULES

These young girls were watched getting naked by a serial rapist because

1: He IS a woman. He is no different to them except maybe in age. He is a woman. End of.

2: Women can have penises and rape can be a female crime

3: The girls have zero grounds to refuse to undress in front of him because that makes no sense at all - he IS a woman.

4: If they, or the college, or the teachers asked him to leave the room while they undressed on the basis of his generalist they would be transphobic, hateful and guilty of excluding a WOMAN from a WOMENS SPACE. Genitalia difference is no more important than eye colour difference. This is gross discrimination. (Genitalia and biology is irrelevant).

5: If Isla had been offended by this gross discrimination and shared it with her trans allies, the college, students and teachers would all have been targeted en masse, aggressively and quickly become known as unkind and transphobic and hateful. People would have turned up holding banners describing them as hateful, maybe even calling for death. Very very bad for business.

This is how a serial rapist gets to very easily sit and watch young girls strip to almost naked.

Had he tried all of the above WITHOUT declaring himself a women, the college would have taken sensible measures to protect the girls and the girls would have felt OK to refuse to undress in front of him, and no one would have blinked an eye at this. Had they been able to do this, a serial rapist would have been denied the opportunity to watch young girls strip. But they were not able to do this at all.

He got away with this, and the fact it happened at all, has EVERYTHING to do with trans identity politics and activism. Everything.

It is so important women understand what is happening, put to one side any worries about being transphobic, and just carefully think it through. We are not safe.

OP posts:
Tygger · 28/01/2023 12:29

👌

Tygger · 28/01/2023 12:26

WTF is a college doing by asking and/or allowing girls to get virtually naked as a part of the beauty course. Sounds to me like the lecturers are also perverts.😡

CryInToYourCornflakesNicola · 28/01/2023 12:21

Boiledbeetle · 28/01/2023 08:23

Women are women just women.

Men can never be women.

We are not cis women we are just women.

Ooh boiled us using the bigly words, she means business today methinks.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 11:14

Lack of common sense, lack of commitment to truth and what is right, lack of integrity, lack of any substance and fortitude. And that’s being kind!

It’s safe to say there are more than a few who’ve directly facilitated predators/abusers and/or are potentially predatory/abusers themselves. Talk about the dark underbelly.

They ought not be unchallenged any longer. They ought all to be quaking in their boots right now for being part of this.

As I said, despicable actions by despicable people.

IcakethereforeIam · 28/01/2023 11:07

It's the lack of common sense that I find troubling.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 11:01

It’s such a shit show. Just so infuriating.

In my view these organisations all need disbanding. They’re no longer fit for purpose; the people at the top have demonstrated that they have absolutely no integrity, nor moral fibre.

Boiledbeetle · 28/01/2023 10:59

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 09:40

For those of you who are aghast at this, now would be a good time to look into Girl Guides.

I'm not sure anybody is going to be ready for that shit show of how not to keep young girls safe!!!!!

blubberyboo · 28/01/2023 10:52

Boiledbeetle · 28/01/2023 10:51

So...you're JK Rowling!

Well If you are JK I started following you yesterday as a direct result of this shit, so a million down and one up!

Boiledbeetle · 28/01/2023 10:51

TheShellBeach · 28/01/2023 10:43

I said it on Twitter yesterday and a million people unfollowed me.
Well, maybe not a million...

.

So...you're JK Rowling!

TheShellBeach · 28/01/2023 10:43

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 10:40

Do you know what? I’m going to say it here:

Trans women ARE NOT women.

They just aren’t. Saying so is a statement of actual fact, nothing more.

I will not shy away from it. I don’t care how angry it makes some people, it needs to be said.

I said it on Twitter yesterday and a million people unfollowed me.
Well, maybe not a million...

.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 10:40

Do you know what? I’m going to say it here:

Trans women ARE NOT women.

They just aren’t. Saying so is a statement of actual fact, nothing more.

I will not shy away from it. I don’t care how angry it makes some people, it needs to be said.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 28/01/2023 10:34

Yes I agree, @AmaryllisNightAndDay . But in Sturgeon's Scotland, Annie is a woman. A woman just like you and just like me and just like my 17 year old daughter. Any inference that Annie was not a woman is horrid transphobia. TWAW, remember?

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 28/01/2023 10:33

It's such horrible thing to happen but it was bound to happen sooner or later and at least now far more of the public know about it. Prisons and colleges. I expect a lot of organisations will be taking an anxious look at themselves.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 28/01/2023 10:32

Any decent man wanting to train as a beauty therapist would have the self-awareness to step out of the tanning, or speak to the college in advance to find another male student to buddy up with.

And any decent college would have insisted that he did. I hadn't clocked that the girls were under 18 so not adults. So it's not optional, not for the trans students, not for the female students.

Safeguarding doesn't say "oh it's fine if no-one complains" because students try to be nice and inclusive and victims don't complain til the damage is done.

Rheia1983 · 28/01/2023 10:25

FOJN · 27/01/2023 20:48

The girls I know who chose to do beauty courses all started around 16, straight out of school, instead of pursuing advanced highers. When I read this I imagined them standing virtually naked while an adult menacing serial rapist watched. It is completely unforgivable.

And the girls and college said and did nothing because anyone who does pays a heavy price. There would have been rape and death threats, risks to the students future employment, the college would have been hounded by transactivists.

The lovely women on the feminist board believe in golden bridges and welcoming people when the light finally dawn's about what a bad idea self ID has always been but I'm not one of those women.

If you've ever posted on a thread about what a transphobic place MN is and how TERF's are all full of hate then you have contributed to the climate of fear which kept both the students and college silent and threw safeguarding out of the window.

YOU SHOULD BE FUCKING ASHAMED OF YOURSELVES, YOU ARE A VIRTUE SIGNALLING, DICK PANDERING DISGRACE.

If I have to be nice and forgiving of your utter stupidity to get you to support the rights of women and safeguarding then we don't need you in the fight, you are too easily influenced by absolute bollocks and represent a liability not an asset.

I too was live and let live but the instant I became aware of tension between women's rights and self ID (about 5 years ago) the problems were as obvious as the nose on my face, I didn't need persuading.

I don't care what you think about my anger, I cannot forgive the people who have played a part in engineering a situation where teenage girls are forced into a situation where they are nearly naked in front of an adult male, sexual predator or not, and where their right to refuse consent has been taken away by people who think they are fucking kind.

All of this!

I will not forgive any of the virtue signalling dick-panderers who carry responsibility for the undermining of womens' and childrens' rights, saftey and dignity under the guise of gender ideology.

FOJN · 28/01/2023 10:18

I’m getting sick of the disingenuous ‘oh but what could have been done differently?’ comments.

Well quite. Not allowing a man on the course would have prevented the bullying, abuse and exploitation of teenage girls, pretty simple really. But "oh, it's complicated". No it's not, it really isn't.

The hand wringing now just pisses me off. Women have been saying for years that this sort of thing would happen and the "be kind" crew on mumsnet were happy to see the conversation shunted off to the naughty step. Well here is the reality and I'm not going to refrain from saying, "I told you so".

WednesdaysNameIsFullOfWoe · 28/01/2023 10:13

Rainbowshit · 28/01/2023 07:41

This will be deleted but I don't care.

The fact is that any male who is using areas where females are undressing is a predator. They know it will make the females uncomfortable and they do it anyway.

As I’ve seen it put; good men stay out so that predators stand out.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 10:12

And stop it with the c**. It’s a stupid, nonsensical term which is incredibly offensive.

There are men (males) and women (females). That is all.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 10:09

Worth a gander at the NSPCC too.

Also certain rape crisis organisations and Women’s aid, certainly in Scotland.

Oh and hospital trusts. Lying about men on women’s wards and deliberately deceiving a woman who had been raped by saying, ‘oh no, there were no men present.’ For more than a YEAR they carried on that lie to the police, and to the raped woman, IIRC.

Despicable people.