Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Beauty students asked to strip in front of trans rapist at college AFTER sex attacks

957 replies

scratchedbymycat · 27/01/2023 12:42

My AIBU title taken from this news article:

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/beauty-students-asked-strip-front-29063499

This whole 'Isla Bryson' cluster-fuck has me angrier than I can describe.

These girls had to accept and trust this vile individual in their beauty course on the basis of Isla's claim to be a woman, nothing more. They even tolerated abuse from Isla.

They were not told this individual was facing charges of rape. The college claim they didn't know either. Because 'Isla' said he was a women, these young women felt they had no choice but to strip to virtually naked in front of him. Failing to do so would be 'bigoted'.

But he also happens to be a serial rapist. Young women, some possibly aged 16 or so, stripping to virtually naked while a serial rapist watches. If this was my daughter I would be going mad.

Where is the safeguarding?

AIBU to feel viscerally angry with all our politicians about this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 28/01/2023 15:31

If organisations want to hide behind data protection then they need to ensure that it does not compromise safeguarding.

This isn't just ordinary data protection though, the legal protections around disclosing someone's transgender status and especially disclosing that someone has a GRC are draconian. There are only very limited circumstances where that's allowed and woe betide an organisation that gets it wrong.

Anyone still for 3 months and then self id to a GRC?

(After all, that's why this case is so big in the news right now.)

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 15:29

He’s not ‘claiming to be trans’.

HE IS TRANS.

He is trans AND a predator.

And even if he WASN’T a predator he should not have been present when young women were required to be in a state of undress.

It is very simple and straightforward.

FOJN · 28/01/2023 15:26

None so blind than those who will not see!

Nothing new for that particular poster. Their head must be about to explode with the cognitive dissonance.

lifeturnsonadime · 28/01/2023 15:25

being trans has nothing to do with it. It seems he was a thourghly nasty individual but being trans is a distraction.

None so blind than those who will not see!

It's everything to do with being trans. That's how he got to gaslight everyone involved and got to accuse the young women who were uncomfortable being in partial states of undress bigots.

If they'd have said no to a man he wouldn't have had such power over them.

334bu · 28/01/2023 15:24

MALES also do the course. ...... That's my point
It's the same

So all the men on the course get to strip off with the girls
or in this case get to watch the girls strip off? Aye right!

FOJN · 28/01/2023 15:24

MALES also do the course. ...... That's my point
It's the same

being trans has nothing to do with it. It seems he was a thourghly nasty individual but being trans is a distraction.

No it's not. He would have been training with the male students if being trans had nothing to do with it but he wasn't, instead he was able to abuse teenage girls BECAUSE he said he was trans. Claiming to be trans has everything to do with it.

Rainbowshit · 28/01/2023 15:23
  • MALES also do the course. ...... That's my point
    It's the same

    being trans has nothing to do with it. It seems he was a thourghly nasty individual but being trans is a distraction.*

NO. It's NOT the same because the girls would not be coerced into getting naked in front of a male who isn't claiming a female identity.

nilsmousehammer · 28/01/2023 15:22

Tim Minchin nailed it.

"If the facts don't fit my narrative
I'll just invent alternatives
cos otherwise my brain will blow up..."

They are entirely stuck in the mire of sex offenders and male people with TQ+ identities are two totally separate groups.

Which leaves them either fumbling at 'well Bryson isn't truly TQ+ or Bryson would not have sex offended and been convicted for it' (however Bryson got to do Bryson's thing on the women on this course because TQ+ male, and the women were scolded for their transphobia in being upset by this...)

So does this mean anything a male with a TQ+ identity is ok and women shouldn't mind or have boundaries because TQ+ negates other people's rights and boundaries? Is inappropriate behaviour not inappropriate behaviour when it's being done by a male claiming a TQ+ identity (which may or may not be sincere, no one but the male will ever know), until the male a) has a conviction as a serial serious sex offender and b) it's escaped into the press and the public are bloody furious?

Bryson is as TQ+ as anyone else.
Bryson used the licence of TQ+ to harass and distress the women in this class
Bryson is a convicted sex offender and TQ+
Inappropriate and unacceptable behaviour from a male towards women is inappropriate and unacceptable however the male defines their identity.
Otherwise we are saying that inappropriate and unacceptable behaviour is not a bug in TQ+ access to female spaces: it is a feature.
In which case, yes, TQ+ access to female spaces is very definitely the problem.

Wtf is going on that people's thoughts about women's boundaries and about sexual harassment of abuse of women goes 'but what exactly was going on in the male's head at the time?' as if that makes a bloody difference!

lljkk · 28/01/2023 15:21

all down to Nicola Sturgeon

what did NS do (by 2021) that made it possible for "Annie"/IB to be on that course in 2021?

The story seems to say that IB hadn't been investigated yet by police, or that college did not know IB was under investigation.

Are PP saying that no person who ever identified as transWoman should have been allowed to take the course as classmate of biological females?

maddy68 · 28/01/2023 15:20

FOJN · 28/01/2023 15:08

This man would never have been allowed in a position to bully, exploit and abuse the female students had his gender identity not been accepted. The students were told they would be transphobic to refuse to participate in practical sessions with him but he was exempt from removing his own clothes because he claimed he was trans and did not feel comfortable.

The asymmetry in rights and respecting one person's discomfort over that of a whole group makes it perfectly clear everyone knows who the man is.

Would you expect a paediatrician to be allowed to continue working with children if they had been accused of child sex offences? Of course you wouldn't, you would expect them to be suspended until legal proceedings had concluded.

If organisations want to hide behind data protection then they need to ensure that it does not compromise safeguarding.

It is not fucking tricky and pointing out the obvious is not transphobic.

You know this is wrong which is why you haven't used female pronouns for this arsehole in your post. I don't care about his gender identity epiphany, which only happened after he'd been charged with rape, I care about his sex, which is MALE.

MALES also do the course. ...... That's my point
It's the same

being trans has nothing to do with it. It seems he was a thourghly nasty individual but being trans is a distraction.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 15:19

It’s not cognitive dissonance. They’re well aware of what they’re doing/saying and the inherent contradictions and inaccuracies.

WednesdaysNameIsFullOfWoe · 28/01/2023 15:19

TimandGinger · 27/01/2023 20:10

I really hope it’s a turning point. I’m not seeing it though. The only reference on SM amongst friends is one woman saying he’s ‘not a real trans woman’. So that’s ok 😕

The “no true Scotsman” fallacy being used about a true Scotsman.

Boiledbeetle · 28/01/2023 15:15

OneMorePlant · 28/01/2023 15:04

For those who don't do Twitter

Beauty students asked to strip in front of trans rapist at college AFTER sex attacks
Beauty students asked to strip in front of trans rapist at college AFTER sex attacks
334bu · 28/01/2023 15:09

Cognitive dissonance of our politicians can be mind blowing.
If trans women are not a danger to women and children why are so many of them in prison for sex offences ?

FOJN · 28/01/2023 15:08

maddy68 · 28/01/2023 14:52

It's not that they are transgender. And that alone makes this transphobic. Males also do the courses and they practice on each other. It's a tricky one. As until proven guilty should a student be kicked off a course , they may not be guilty.?

The college was correct in not disclosing to other students. That would be a massive breach of data protection

I totally understand how those students feel

This man would never have been allowed in a position to bully, exploit and abuse the female students had his gender identity not been accepted. The students were told they would be transphobic to refuse to participate in practical sessions with him but he was exempt from removing his own clothes because he claimed he was trans and did not feel comfortable.

The asymmetry in rights and respecting one person's discomfort over that of a whole group makes it perfectly clear everyone knows who the man is.

Would you expect a paediatrician to be allowed to continue working with children if they had been accused of child sex offences? Of course you wouldn't, you would expect them to be suspended until legal proceedings had concluded.

If organisations want to hide behind data protection then they need to ensure that it does not compromise safeguarding.

It is not fucking tricky and pointing out the obvious is not transphobic.

You know this is wrong which is why you haven't used female pronouns for this arsehole in your post. I don't care about his gender identity epiphany, which only happened after he'd been charged with rape, I care about his sex, which is MALE.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 15:07

Of course they knew. They just don’t give a single shit.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 15:06

(Above quoted from @lifeturnsonadime)

ABSOLUTELY CORRECT.

lifeturnsonadime · 28/01/2023 15:06

OneMorePlant · 28/01/2023 15:04

JFC.

How many violent men have to identify as women to make Sturgeon see sense?

They MUST have known about these men when they said there was no evidence.

Fucking liars.

TangledWebOfDeception · 28/01/2023 15:05

Any trans woman who imposes their male sexed body on woman is a predatory man.

Women should not have to put up with this shit.

They don't need to be a rapist to be predatory.

OneMorePlant · 28/01/2023 15:04

twitter.com/jk_rowling/status/1619297365479010304

lifeturnsonadime · 28/01/2023 15:04

As women, unfortunately, we still need to look out to be safe from predatory men. Predatory men are a threat to women, but trans-women are not.

Any trans woman who imposes their male sexed body on woman is a predatory man.

Women should not have to put up with this shit.

They don't need to be a rapist to be predatory.

mrshoho · 28/01/2023 15:04

Women and girls are not even an afterthought in this trans ideology. I'm reminded of the despicable posters put up in so many toilets in universities, colleges and other institutions. Putting women and children in potentially very harmful situations.

Beauty students asked to strip in front of trans rapist at college AFTER sex attacks
OneMorePlant · 28/01/2023 15:04

Has anyone seen JK Rowlings tweet about the new dangerous bloke that is going to be moved to women's prison?

Vebrithien · 28/01/2023 15:02

I have posted this on another thread, but I feel it bears repeating.

I wrote to my MP, about this case.

This is her reply. I have highlighted two key things she said in bold, and put my thoughts about it, at the bottom.

//

Thank you for your further email.

I completely agree with you that women need protection from sex offenders and from predatory men.

As women, unfortunately, we still need to look out to be safe from predatory men. Predatory men are a threat to women, but trans-women are not.

We need to do a lot more to bring rapists to justice. We also need to do a lot more to support victims of rape and ensure that they can recover from their trauma. Additionally, we need to ensure that rape victims are believed when they first report a crime against them. I am actively campaigning on all those issues.

The GRR is a separate issue. It is separate because the vast majority trans-gender people are not rapists or sex offenders. Like in the general population you wouldn't deny rights to all women or all men because some men and some women are criminals.

The Scottish GRR law will allow transgender people to live their lives according to who they are and to have their trans identity acknowledged by making the process of receiving a gender recognition certificate easier. It doesn't change who is trans or who becomes trans. Transgender people are who they are, men who want to live as women and women who want to live as men. They do this anyway and they are no threat to you and me anymore than other people are.

The Equality Act 2010 is not affected by GRR nor is the requirement in law that prison services must ensure that their male and female inmates are safe.

If a transgender woman commits a crime, she will be punished as other people are. It is for individual prisons to decide on a case-by-case basis where prisoners are placed in order to ensure the safety of all inmates.

You will have heard in the news that the convicted rapist you have been referring to will not be held in a women's prison.

//

But with self ID, any man who says he is a woman, is a transwoman. She seems to be denying that Adam the rapist is a transwoman

And

Surely, this is the whole point of safeguarding. Not all people who apply to teach are paedophiles, but all teaching applicants must have a DBS check

lifeturnsonadime · 28/01/2023 15:00

Imagine if that creep had finished the course and then was performing intimate treatments on women who would be bigots if they declined his services.

This gaslighting of women has got to stop.

Men are not women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread