Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the opposite of woke, is asleep?

265 replies

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 12:04

Following on from a conversation with my elderly (but very with it) Aunt the other day.

She stated that she was anti-woke and I asked her if that just meant that she wasn't interested in equality, social justice any more. Being literally "asleep" to this sort of thing, as opposed to being awake or "woke". She definitely is not asleep to that stuff.

Another conversation with a (middle aged like me) friend and we agreed that when woke is used as an insult, it's no different to the old "political correctness gone mad" cry.

So, is anti-woke to be willingly asleep to stuff?

OP posts:
QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 16:34

Where did I say that she was anti-equality or anti-social justice?

If by "word salad" you mean big words that you don't understand, dictionaries are available.

1984 is much misused. Try reading down and out along with it

OP posts:
Underanothersky · 27/01/2023 16:33

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 27/01/2023 16:30

But is calling her being anti equality and social justice any different?

Nothing to say about the rest of my post? Where did you think women’s rights came from?

Im sure you think k you’re so very right-on now OP but give it a few decades before young people are telling you that you don’t know a thing about equality. Because, culturally, the world will be somewhere else

PS you aren’t fooling anyone with your word salad.

And you’ve completely missed the point of 1984.

You are making some enormous and patronising assumptions that are not borne out by OP's post.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2023 16:33

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 15:32

To give a specific person example, incel "philosophy".

Do we allow that to spread?

No.

But do you believe the answer is to not let them speak their thoughts and then counter them?

If they are posting hate, they need to have that deleted. If they are engaging with people, then allow people with different views to speak their thoughts to counter those extremists.

Yes, shut down radicalisation avenues. But the answer is to let them engage and to have people to engage with them.

Again, it is the very definition of 'hate' that is also at the core here.

When 'hate' can be described as 'misgendering' or 'by not recognising someone's identity', where do we go from there?

The framing of things as 'hate' when they are not hateful or motivated by hate is damaging and needs to be addressed. I read another study very recently that said that 'content warnings don't actually help those who are distressed by the content'. I will see if I can find it too or maybe it was an interview and the study has yet to be released.

It was interesting, because the researcher said that creating a 'safe space' for reading something that was considered triggering, in the end left the person distressed and as anxious anyway.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 27/01/2023 16:31

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 15:30

@TreadLight

Even if the views are objectively wrong?

I'm talking something like eugenics or sexism?

Do we allow those views to be aired?

Those views are not justifiable in anyway.

As much as we like to think, opinions are NOT objective therefore cannot be objectively wrong.

That also conflates with facts.

A man cannot be a woman. That is a fact. It’s also seen by many as being ‘objectively wrong’.

Laws protect vulnerable people from hate and violence but they don’t stop individual opinions and nor should they.

Im not sure why people are keen to be in a world where one opinion on each subject rules all.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 27/01/2023 16:30

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 15:31

She isn't a bigot and I did not imply she was.

But is calling her being anti equality and social justice any different?

Nothing to say about the rest of my post? Where did you think women’s rights came from?

Im sure you think k you’re so very right-on now OP but give it a few decades before young people are telling you that you don’t know a thing about equality. Because, culturally, the world will be somewhere else

PS you aren’t fooling anyone with your word salad.

And you’ve completely missed the point of 1984.

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 16:28

No, I'm not reading 184 bad power point slides on my phone.

What you've got there is some data.

A study, has a hypothesis, RQ's, methodology, analysis, conclusions and peer review.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 27/01/2023 16:19

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 15:49

That frank luntz chap needs to step away from power point, totall unreadable

So, you didn't read it?

Ok. here are some other highlights. Remember this was a study that was investigating 'woke' and 'cancel culture' by political segmentation.

Is Cancel Culture a Good Thing:

Totally Agree 25%

The break down:
men 18-39 44%
Labour mums 44%
Ages 18-29 42%
Labour/work heart 40%
Living month to month 38%

Describing Cancel Culture

It's a bad thing. It enforces a "thought and speech police" that shuts down free speech, diverse opinions, and honest discussion. It can even ruin lives.

40% total
34% Labour
and 48% Tory

It's a good thing. If you have said or done something that is obviously sexist, racist, or hurtful towards marginalised communities, you should face the consequences.
.
25% total
33% Labour
and 18% Tory

Which statement about "Woke culture" comes closest to your view?

I reject and oppose Woke-ism strongly. It is just a new form of discrimination that shuts down alternate opinions and voices. It is not about true equality; it is about dividing us further.

30% total
15% Labour
and 43% Tory

I believe in the objectives behind the word Woke, but the term is a problem, and I don't like some of what it represents. Woke principles are about correcting the historic injustices that fill our society - which is necessary. However, I believe the word Woke has been politicised.

27% total
35% Labour
and 20% Tory

I am proud to be Woke, because it means I care about injustices like systemic racism, classism, sexism, and bias against the LGBTQIA+ community. To me, it's a compliment.

15% total
27% Labour
and 7% Tory

I don't know what Woke means

29% total
23% Labour
and 30% Tory

AllTheAll · 27/01/2023 16:12

The belief that there are systemic injustices in society and the need to address them.

I guess the opposite is not thinking there are these injustices and/or not thinking they need to be addressed.

That said, vocal people who identify as "anti-woke" really mean anti-pc, anti-cancel culture, not going to state pronouns, etc. So it really is muddled and people need to define what they mean in a better way. I think the anti-wokers ruined it because they didn't do a better job defining what they are specifically against.

(and it's okay to think society is moving too far into this narcissistic offended at any and everything and shut it down if I think it's offensive view. But calling that 'anti-woke" is sloppy.

DeidreData · 27/01/2023 16:03

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 15:30

@TreadLight

Even if the views are objectively wrong?

I'm talking something like eugenics or sexism?

Do we allow those views to be aired?

Those views are not justifiable in anyway.

Incels are a great example. They gather strength of attitude and opinion by being isolated alongside only with those who agree with them.

There is not a single person in the world with whom you will have exact matching opinions, and even those with the closest matches will probably not prioritise "most important issues" the same way as you.

By engaging in conversation, opening yourself and others up to connection, asking questions, listening to answers, you may - may - reduce these extremist opinions. You might change your mind; I know I have plenty of times over my lifetime. You might change their mind.

The point is, deciding someone holds utterly intolerable views and refusing to maintain any connection with them doesn't benefit anyone. It fragments society and allows toxic views (however you define them) to ferment with other toxic views, encouraging them into real world actions and behaviours. If those incels were sitting around in a pub with friends who might be able to engage in conversation with them, along with playing darts or whatever, maybe they wouldn't feel so angry and isolated that it meant those incel groups were their only space to exist.

It's not always nice talking to people with views we don't like, but it is what participating in the human race is about.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2023 16:02

This is a pdf version of "YouGov - Defining 'Woke'"

docs.cdn.yougov.com/xu2oj6jxzz/YouGov%20-%20What%20is%20woke.pdf

Aarohi · 27/01/2023 15:57

rumship · 27/01/2023 15:52

@Aarohi Sorry but I choose not to debate with someone who thinks that you can Insult others based on their skin colour no matter which side of the coin your on and If hiding behind a culture of woke that empowers you to do so, then I have zero time for you or your fight.

Then good day to you, sir. No need to be sorry. I think I have made it very clear where I stand and your misrepresenting my position does you no good.

You gamble on the idea that people are inherently arsenals. I disagree, and will continue to disagree.

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 15:56

The Dark Ages didn't happen.

1984 is interesting, in respect of the controlling of history.

The UK has taught an almost antiquarian view for years and the recent decolonisation of history is actually the reverse of what 1984 was talking about. It's revising history as written by the victors - ie western elite.

I think Brave New World is more relevant to society now. The mandatory fun and increasing hierarchical society we live in scares me

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 27/01/2023 15:53

TreadLight · 27/01/2023 15:26

Dare I say it, by listening to them. Find one thing you and they can agree on. It could be a favourite song or a holiday destination you both enjoyed. Once you have started a conversation, found some common ground, you may find they start listening to you, maybe agreeing in some way with your tolerant point of view and the world becomes fractionally more tolerant.

Shouting and screaming at someone and telling them they are wrong only entrenches their views.

So if you want the world to be more tolerant, start by listening.

It is remarkable, isn't it, that you have to say this TreadLight!

rumship · 27/01/2023 15:52

@Aarohi Sorry but I choose not to debate with someone who thinks that you can Insult others based on their skin colour no matter which side of the coin your on and If hiding behind a culture of woke that empowers you to do so, then I have zero time for you or your fight.

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 15:49

That frank luntz chap needs to step away from power point, totall unreadable

OP posts:
JoonT · 27/01/2023 15:48

Read Orwell's 1984. So many of the things he warned about are coming true: the re-writing of history, the narrowing of human thought and imagination, the removal of books, the control of language, the way people are being forced to pretend to believe things they know aren't true, etc. Or think of that sinister phrase "cancelling someone". Jesus, that could have been invented by Orwell himself.

Bertrand Russell once said that we must always be wary of fanatics. Fanaticism is the greatest enemy civilization has. We've had religious fanatics, nationalist fanatics, communist fanatics...now we've got woke fanatics. Some people are drawn to extremes. They love the idea of provoking and upsetting others. And they love the idea of smashing things up.

Plus, of course, it appeals to bullies, who can use it to attack and control. Then you get the narcissists and show-offs who see it as a chance to get attention (we've all read social media posts by people who couldn't care less about the cause they are backing).

What terrifies me most are the attacks on the canon. Harold Bloom came up with a list of the greatest books written over the last 3,000 years – the best that has been thought and expressed in human history. But the woke bullies (like all bullies they just become more and more extreme) are now trying to 'cancel' many of these great writers. It's even happening in the universities. Once you do that, you're in the Dark Ages again.

Aarohi · 27/01/2023 15:48

rumship · 27/01/2023 15:40

It just shows how the "WOKE" agenda works now days and why so many people object. If it had been worded to include the word white it would have been deleted by now and had everyone jumping on to get the user banned.

You think that if I had written "Stop. Read this. If you are someone who is not WHITE and has no WHITE ancestry, please butt the fuck out and get your own word" MNHQ would have deleted it?

What word do you think could have been substituted for "woke" here, keeping all of the connotations, so that MNHQ would have done that?

If there is a word that is used for white people that is racist and discriminatory, I will also say that I do not think that people should use that word. Try me - I'll either debunk your assumptions or tell you your word is OK. Go on.

FourTeaFallOut · 27/01/2023 15:47

Helleofabore · 27/01/2023 15:45

Those links ok @QuertyGirl ? Can you access them.

😁

SheSeemsToHaveAnInvisibleTouch · 27/01/2023 15:45

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 27/01/2023 15:28

You also want to remember OP that the reason girls can go to school, vote, have equal rights, maternity leave, be protected from DA and have laws to protect them as a characteristic isnt because those things fell out the sky.

The now-elderly women before us - like your ‘anti equality’ aunt - fought bloody hard so your generation could enjoy equality. Rather than being insulting you could maybe reflect on that rather than writing them off as bigots.

Absolutely 👏👏👏 some people seem to have very very short memories

Helleofabore · 27/01/2023 15:45

Those links ok @QuertyGirl ? Can you access them.

Helleofabore · 27/01/2023 15:44

Another yougov poll.

yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2021/12/22/cancel-culture-what-views-are-britons-afraid-expre

A majority of Britons (57%) say they have, at least sometimes, found themselves stopping themselves from expressing their political or social views for fear of judgement or negative responses from others.

Women are also more likely to have held their tongue than men (62% vs 52%).

29% of those who disagree with the statement “a transgender woman is a woman” feel they have to frequently keep bottled up.

Only 10% of respondents agree with the statement "a transgender woman is a woman"

This contains a very interesting chart at the bottom that shows ‘conservatives more inclined to have concerns about free speech and labour being more concerned about protecting peoples feelings and sensitivities.

rumship · 27/01/2023 15:40

JudgeJ · 27/01/2023 15:37

Stop. Read this. If you are someone who is not black and has no black ancestry, please butt the fuck out and get your own word.

Is that the acceptable face of racism?

It just shows how the "WOKE" agenda works now days and why so many people object. If it had been worded to include the word white it would have been deleted by now and had everyone jumping on to get the user banned.

Aarohi · 27/01/2023 15:39

JudgeJ · 27/01/2023 15:37

Stop. Read this. If you are someone who is not black and has no black ancestry, please butt the fuck out and get your own word.

Is that the acceptable face of racism?

How?

5128gap · 27/01/2023 15:39

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 15:32

To give a specific person example, incel "philosophy".

Do we allow that to spread?

As oppose to what?
Challenging it, or censorship?

SheSeemsToHaveAnInvisibleTouch · 27/01/2023 15:38

SlightlyJaded · 27/01/2023 12:08

No. It's an anti-willingness to be outraged at everything and jump on every bandwagon and cancel everything that doesn't immediately sit well with your immediate and current school of thinking.

I am probably in favour of the same things as most woke young people: equality/social and racial justice and human rights, but I am not in favour of refusing to entertain an alternative view and give someone who disagrees with me airtime. I am also not going to jump on every campaign and hashtag bandwagon without considering the flip side or the deeper consequences of that campaign.

To be the opposite of Woke is 'Open'.

Oh my god YES! @SlightlyJaded you've nailed it

Swipe left for the next trending thread