Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the opposite of woke, is asleep?

265 replies

QuertyGirl · 27/01/2023 12:04

Following on from a conversation with my elderly (but very with it) Aunt the other day.

She stated that she was anti-woke and I asked her if that just meant that she wasn't interested in equality, social justice any more. Being literally "asleep" to this sort of thing, as opposed to being awake or "woke". She definitely is not asleep to that stuff.

Another conversation with a (middle aged like me) friend and we agreed that when woke is used as an insult, it's no different to the old "political correctness gone mad" cry.

So, is anti-woke to be willingly asleep to stuff?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 16:35

“I'm not exactly clear what point you think these statistics prove. Maybe I'm missing the point but if I was asked to vote whether my workplace should have a free speech champion I would say no - not because I am against free speech, but because I would be against the idea of one person being in charge of it. I would also consider it a waste of resources in the current economic climate but that's a separate issue.”

Is this a post for me or for the OP?

Because I am again agreeing with you in the respect that I, too, would be against one person being in charge. And I think it much more important to change the attitudes that are underlined by intolerance of concepts that are considered ‘not to be tolerated’.

I am very happy to have conversations about issues and listen to reasoned opinions that don’t rely on emotional manipulation in an attempt to convince people.

howmanybicycles · 29/01/2023 16:12

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 10:47

He's a commentator for hire (I work in a related field and would be loathe to pass his stuff).

Academic studies are done the way they are for a reason: centuries (literally) of scrutiny, experimentation, discussion, wrong turns, back tracking, direction changes and relentlessly pushing the limits of reason and understanding.

They're also sometimes paid for by people with money and power, e.g. food and nutrition research. They are affected by societal power relationships and are not above scrutiny. Nor are they the only source of truth. They can sometimes highlight the assumptions and errors we make but they can also be used to entrench bigotry and justify oppression.

Calphurnia88 · 29/01/2023 16:11

Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 15:05

great, what do you think is the relevance of that particular point out of all the rest of the points that I posted from that source.

And yeah… righto… plonking it down is ‘engagement’ to you?. A very high bar for ‘study’ and a very low bar for ‘engagement’.

Good to know

How have you engaged with it, a point about ‘free speech’? Tell us, in your words how does this point work with the rest of the findings of that study?

”In response to a new question, around one-half of students (48%) support the Government’s proposal to establish a ‘free speech champion’ for universities in England. Around one-quarter (23%) disagree and the rest are uncertain (29%).”

Because to me, and maybe others, it seems like it is a ‘lip service’. Like either those students like to think they support ‘free speech’ when they don’t support it, they support their version of free speech.

Like applying the label of ‘tolerant’ when they will exhibit ‘intolerant’ behaviours when they disagree. All while upholding their interpretation of ‘tolerance’.

Particularly when you consider the other points, including this one;

“When asked what rights students and staff should have to respond to an event they dislike, 39% of students say they should be able to ‘hold a protest outside’, 20% say they should be able to ‘stop the event from happening’ and 12% say they should be able to ‘disrupt the event’ (all up since 2016).”

and this one:

“-61% of students say ‘when in doubt’ their own university ‘should ensure all students are protected from discrimination rather than allow unlimited free speech’ (up from 37% in 2016).”

and this one:

“-79% of students believe ‘Students that feel threatened should always have their demands for safety respected’ (up from 68% in 2016) while 4% disagree (down from 10% in 2016).”

I'm not exactly clear what point you think these statistics prove. Maybe I'm missing the point but if I was asked to vote whether my workplace should have a free speech champion I would say no - not because I am against free speech, but because I would be against the idea of one person being in charge of it. I would also consider it a waste of resources in the current economic climate but that's a separate issue.

This thread has been interesting.

I won't pretend to be active on every Mumsnet thread, but I visit most days and would say it's my social media channel of choice.

My observation about the word 'woke' is that it tends to have two main use cases on Mumsnet:

1: As a term to describe people who are (aggressively) pro-trans rights. Given some of the commentary on this thread, I would hazard a guess that several of you use the word to mean this
2: As a shiny, new (and more succinct) way of saying It's PC gone mad! You can't say anything these days! This, if I understood correctly, is the 'dog whistle' that PP referred to earlier. It's no coincidence that Piers I'm-a-victim-of-cancel-culture-but-please-tune-into-my-brand-new-television-show Morgan writes for the Daily Mail and is vehemently anti-woke (he probably coined the vom-inducing 'wokerati' which I've seen used in a recent thread about racial stereotyping)

And there are more definitions outside of Mumsnet, ranging from someone who would consider themselves enlightened and opposed to discrimination, to someone who considers themselves judge, jury and executioner of anyone who has or has had what might be considered an impure thought.

It's a shame because the original meaning of the word (not literally to wake, but the AAVE term originating from the 30s to mean alert to racial prejudice and discrimination), has been totally lost.

Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 15:16

twitter.com/gbnews/status/1619661336505360384?s=46&t=wGPF5dc1ootVJuf2lRdZ8g

Here is Julie Bindel, she is now a ‘GB News commentator’. Want to use it to denounce the work of Julie Bindel too?

Just for consistency.

I think this thread has been very enlightening to those who have not previously noticed how some
people have redefined words to mean the opposite to fulfill their need to be seen as the right side of history. And how some people use terms like ‘dog whistle’ and ‘[supposedly not worthy media source] commentator’ to dismiss people’s work.

Not necessarily the same people, but they may well be overlapping motives if you look further into it. To shape the discussion happening in society and discredit people for ‘wrong think’. Some people use emotive terms, some people scream Fascist at babies. They seem to call themselves tolerant.

Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 15:05

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 14:08

@Helleofabore engage with stuff!

Querrygirl engages

@Helleofabore not that bit!

great, what do you think is the relevance of that particular point out of all the rest of the points that I posted from that source.

And yeah… righto… plonking it down is ‘engagement’ to you?. A very high bar for ‘study’ and a very low bar for ‘engagement’.

Good to know

How have you engaged with it, a point about ‘free speech’? Tell us, in your words how does this point work with the rest of the findings of that study?

”In response to a new question, around one-half of students (48%) support the Government’s proposal to establish a ‘free speech champion’ for universities in England. Around one-quarter (23%) disagree and the rest are uncertain (29%).”

Because to me, and maybe others, it seems like it is a ‘lip service’. Like either those students like to think they support ‘free speech’ when they don’t support it, they support their version of free speech.

Like applying the label of ‘tolerant’ when they will exhibit ‘intolerant’ behaviours when they disagree. All while upholding their interpretation of ‘tolerance’.

Particularly when you consider the other points, including this one;

“When asked what rights students and staff should have to respond to an event they dislike, 39% of students say they should be able to ‘hold a protest outside’, 20% say they should be able to ‘stop the event from happening’ and 12% say they should be able to ‘disrupt the event’ (all up since 2016).”

and this one:

“-61% of students say ‘when in doubt’ their own university ‘should ensure all students are protected from discrimination rather than allow unlimited free speech’ (up from 37% in 2016).”

and this one:

“-79% of students believe ‘Students that feel threatened should always have their demands for safety respected’ (up from 68% in 2016) while 4% disagree (down from 10% in 2016).”

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 14:08

@Helleofabore engage with stuff!

Querrygirl engages

@Helleofabore not that bit!

OP posts:
TreadLight · 29/01/2023 13:46

"The Popper issue, is that you cannot have absolute tolerance as the intolerant will naturally overwhelm. That's something which human history demonstrates." @QuertyGirl

I get the feeling that the intolerant are trying to overwhelm this thread.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 29/01/2023 13:10

To me woke is a post feminist movement as it prioritises men's rights.
Feminism has been more and more diluted since the 1980's and has been taken over by men's rights to prostitution rights and trans rights.

This article by Abigail Shrier sums up some of this, as it shows how the extremes of woke politics damage women.

abigailshrier.substack.com/p/a-predators-paradise

Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 12:25

CountZacular · 29/01/2023 12:10

Popper states that unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. However he also says quite clearly that he does not think we should stop people speaking. Rather than we should we able to discuss with rational thought and logic. We should only use force to ‘silence’ the intolerant if followers refuse to listen to rational argument and engage.

It’s rather interesting actually that you, OP, have refused to engage with one poster and discuss with any rationality what’s actually wrong with the data and instead refuse to engage because you don’t like the person who has collated the data.

I would have said it was hypocritical, but I don’t quite understand OP’s intent, hence I think I said it was irony…

Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 12:10

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 11:50

Here's something you posted:

"
-In response to a new question, around one-half of students (48%) support the Government’s proposal to establish a ‘free speech champion’ for universities in England. Around one-quarter (23%) disagree and the rest are uncertain (29%)."

Less that a quarter object to the "free speech champion". Some of the uncertain group will actually be, don't care.

The Popper issue, is that you cannot have absolute tolerance as the intolerant will naturally overwhelm. That's something which human history demonstrates.

Anyway, I'm an old bag who's got gardening to do and a bike to fix.

And out of all that… you picked one thing? About free speech.

And not about people’s perceptions.

For all your quibbling about ‘your’ field using study to only ever mean peer reviewed research. ‘My’ field of qualifications use ‘study’ to describe research projects such as the one done by Luntz. “4,500 interviews, more than 200 questions, and two focus groups.”

As I said before, in ‘my’ field this is a ‘study’.

Crack on. We obviously work in different fields.

Enjoy your garden.

CountZacular · 29/01/2023 12:10

Popper states that unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. However he also says quite clearly that he does not think we should stop people speaking. Rather than we should we able to discuss with rational thought and logic. We should only use force to ‘silence’ the intolerant if followers refuse to listen to rational argument and engage.

It’s rather interesting actually that you, OP, have refused to engage with one poster and discuss with any rationality what’s actually wrong with the data and instead refuse to engage because you don’t like the person who has collated the data.

Teateaandmoretea · 29/01/2023 11:53

Yabu and it is as simple as that.

Woke is about ‘kindness’ always being right. It is about cancelling those who disagree even though the wokes are often naive in the extreme with their viewpoints and blind to their own privilege.

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 11:50

Here's something you posted:

"
-In response to a new question, around one-half of students (48%) support the Government’s proposal to establish a ‘free speech champion’ for universities in England. Around one-quarter (23%) disagree and the rest are uncertain (29%)."

Less that a quarter object to the "free speech champion". Some of the uncertain group will actually be, don't care.

The Popper issue, is that you cannot have absolute tolerance as the intolerant will naturally overwhelm. That's something which human history demonstrates.

Anyway, I'm an old bag who's got gardening to do and a bike to fix.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 11:49

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 11:42

@Helleofabore

You can find people on the internet to agree with almost any standpoint. You can also find extremists in any large group of humans.

That is why I'm asking for something more balanced from a credible source.

Nope

You simply refuse to engage with it and the points raised.

And wonder why no one will engage with Popper.

Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 11:43

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 11:19

Look,

You state there are studies that support a particular position on a subject.

It is entirely logically to then be asked to produce them.

I have produced them.

You don’t seem to be able to engage with them at all.

You are showing your own intolerance over my use of the word ‘study’.

Crack on. I am here still engaging.

All you have done is not engaged by discussing the substance of what I linked at all.

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 11:42

@Helleofabore

You can find people on the internet to agree with almost any standpoint. You can also find extremists in any large group of humans.

That is why I'm asking for something more balanced from a credible source.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 11:39

And… again. You seem to refuse to engage with what has been posted.

Why? Because you don’t believe they reach the bar for the meaning of the word ‘study’ in your mind.

If I had posted just that one, I would have said.. ok. Whatever. But I posted others too with various sponsors and various intentions. There is plenty of anecdotal evidence too.

Shall I start posting more videos of ‘tolerant’ people who are proudly intimidating others as a ‘protest’ when the people they are intimidating are women? Many of which are survivors of male violence in its many guises. I don’t want to, because it is all out there and easy to find. I can start with the males who chalked ‘suck my dick‘ outside a women’s conference and tried to shout down a roll call of women murdered by males. Those male people were celebrated as the very height of tolerance by their group. I mean, it is anecdotal.

But pretty much indisputable.

Yet, you have simply doubled down on ‘it is not a study’ and not engaged with the purpose for which it was posted.

And you still wonder why people won’t engage with you on Popper’s , despite you seeming to not acknowledge there has been a shift where ‘tolerance’ has now been shown to be used as a self-described label by those who are intolerant?

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 11:19

Look,

You state there are studies that support a particular position on a subject.

It is entirely logically to then be asked to produce them.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 11:13

Whatever you think you are achieving through your denouncement of his work, I don’t think you will be convincing many.

Yes, he is a ‘commentator for hire’. He is an expert on studying changes in public opinion…. and he discusses public opinion for public consumption.

The point remains he and others have been attempting to point out is that ‘tolerance’ is now not recognisable as ‘tolerance’.

You seem unable to engage with his work and others that have pointed to the same trend.

Or maybe the example of Carly May Kavanagh screaming fascist at a baby is how people who pride themselves as ‘tolerant’ want to define themselves.

I look forward to seeing how people discuss Popper with you, while considering that fact.

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 10:47

He's a commentator for hire (I work in a related field and would be loathe to pass his stuff).

Academic studies are done the way they are for a reason: centuries (literally) of scrutiny, experimentation, discussion, wrong turns, back tracking, direction changes and relentlessly pushing the limits of reason and understanding.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 10:45

Or would you like to discredit Dr Luntz some more.

Shall we call him a ‘Washington Post’ commentator or a ‘New York Time commentator’. Or a ‘Harvard Lecturer’. Or an ‘Oxford doctorate holder’?

Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 10:42

I stand corrected.

Maybe you can answer the questions in my post above this one ?

Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 10:41

Dr Frank Luntz is a US political polling expert. This is what he does for a living.

“Luntz has appeared as a consultant or panel member on a number of television news shows, including The Colbert Report, Capital Gang, Good Morning America, Hannity, Hardball with Chris Matthews, Meet the Press, PBS NewsHour, Nightline, The O'Reilly Factor, Real Time with Bill Maher, and The Today Show. He has written op-eds for publications such as The Financial Times, The Los Angeles Times, The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and The Washington Post. In addition to his work in the United States, Luntz also provides analysis for British news programmes such as Newsnight.”

“He was an adjunct professor at the University of Pennsylvania from 1989 until 1996[13] and also taught at George Washington University and Harvard University.”

Normally I don’t post stuff from Wikipedia, but I can no longer be arsed to post other sources.

Feel free to discredit his work other ways.

However, you are claiming you want ‘peer reviewed study’ yet you have repeatedly tried to denounce an academic’s work that was posted as support of A trend because? Why?

Would you like to comment on whether you think there is now an issue of people’s perception on what is ‘tolerant’ and what is not?

And how some people who call themselves ‘tolerant’ seek to prevent those who have legitimate concerns from discussing them in public through deplatforming, preventing access or just through intimidation?

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 10:37

@Helleofabore

I didn't say he was a presenter.

www.gbnews.uk/shows/wokeism-culture-wars-britains-cultural-divisions-will-soon-catch-up-with-those-in-the-usa-says-dr-frank-luntz/110736

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 29/01/2023 10:30

QuertyGirl · 29/01/2023 10:20

The bloke who in the link.

Anyway, I would genuinely be interested in any actual studies that suggest that young people are less tolerant.

And for those pouring scorn on him, Poppers theory is still very relevant.

All of this to me feels like an attempt to throw out the entire, academic paradigm out of convenience

Please post your evidence that Dr Frank Luntz is ‘a GB presenter’.