Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to have asked for a favour?

288 replies

NothingOnTopButABucketAndAMop · 27/01/2023 07:31

My car failed it’s MOT on Tuesday, I could not afford the repairs so it’s off the road basically.
I don’t go many places anyway but I did need shopping so I messaged a friend telling her my car was off the road and could she take us shopping sometime this weekend.
Initially she said she would then a few hours later (when her husband got home if that means anything!) she messaged back saying actually she had too much on. It would have taken her an hour and a half max.
Now I’m thinking WIBU to have even asked at all??!

OP posts:
Bananagirl23 · 27/01/2023 15:28

WeepingSomnambulist · 27/01/2023 14:16

I drove someone home from Tesco on boxing day. I heard them on the taxi phone saying "45 minutes?" So it sounded like theyd been told they had to wait 45 minutes for a taxi. I asked if they wanted a lift, they said and off we went. Very bad snow so quite a bad drive!

Didnt even give it a second thought. If another mum from school messaged and asked if I could get them some shopping or take them, I would do it and they would and have done it for me.

But there are also risks of giving a lift to a total stranger…

NickyNackyNoodles · 27/01/2023 15:27

I actually would prefer to pay for your taxi.

NickyNackyNoodles · 27/01/2023 15:26

That’s two hours. The thought of spending one hour doing my own shopping is usually too much to bear, and I generally do an online shop even if I had good intentions about going to Aldi.

Johnnysgirl · 27/01/2023 15:00

WeepingSomnambulist · 27/01/2023 14:16

I drove someone home from Tesco on boxing day. I heard them on the taxi phone saying "45 minutes?" So it sounded like theyd been told they had to wait 45 minutes for a taxi. I asked if they wanted a lift, they said and off we went. Very bad snow so quite a bad drive!

Didnt even give it a second thought. If another mum from school messaged and asked if I could get them some shopping or take them, I would do it and they would and have done it for me.

That's nice of you. It doesn't mean other people are remotely unreasonable for not wanting to do likewise, though.

WeepingSomnambulist · 27/01/2023 14:16

R0ckets · 27/01/2023 11:27

Honestly you're town is an anomaly. Would you genuinely give several hours of your weekend to take a stranger shopping for not even petrol money? You must realise that's unusual.

I drove someone home from Tesco on boxing day. I heard them on the taxi phone saying "45 minutes?" So it sounded like theyd been told they had to wait 45 minutes for a taxi. I asked if they wanted a lift, they said and off we went. Very bad snow so quite a bad drive!

Didnt even give it a second thought. If another mum from school messaged and asked if I could get them some shopping or take them, I would do it and they would and have done it for me.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/01/2023 14:13

She's not exactly local is she?!
It's a big ask I think
If you're only 15 minutes away, get a bus or Taxi
The obvious answer is order online
I'd look at these before I even asked
However I don't drive and have a disability

starfishmummy · 27/01/2023 14:07

£5 doesn’t sound much to most of us. We don’t know her finances.

I agree with that totally, but to be honest we don't know the friend's either. A total of 90 minutes driving is extra petrol that perhaps the friend has realised she can't afford either. (As well as the time, and waiting while the OP shops).

Choconut · 27/01/2023 14:06

So you didn't want to pay £5 for delivery so you thought you'd get your friend to spend her money on petrol and her time on chauffeuring you around instead?

The levels of entitlement in this world never fail to amaze me.

MaryMcCarthy · 27/01/2023 14:03

I have a friend without a car who occasionally asks if she can come to the supermarket with us but she lives less than half a mile away and only comes if we were going shopping anyway.

The idea I'd take the time out to drive to someone's house, drive them to the shops, wait while they shop, then take them home, is absolutely hilarious. I'd do anything for friends, etc but if they proved themselves incapable of doing their shopping I'd worry what had gone wrong for them.

xogossipgirlxo · 27/01/2023 13:47

butterpuffed · 27/01/2023 13:37

I don't drive so catch the bus to do my shopping . If I know I'll have to much to carry to the bus stop then I either get a taxi home or do an online shop and pick a cheap slot .

Isn't that what most non drivers do ?

I chose the cheapest slots when I was without car for 6 weeks. Not sure about other shops, but evening delivery in Asda was 1.50-2 quid. Much cheaper than car fuel.

LovePoppy · 27/01/2023 13:43

NothingOnTopButABucketAndAMop · 27/01/2023 08:23

Delivery would add at least £5 to my shopping which I can’t really afford but I’ll have to do that now. Just wish she hadn’t initially agreed.

Nearest shop is 15 minute walk away which is difficult for me as I have health issues.

So you werent actually going to offer her anything for taking 3 hours out of her day? no petrol money?

Dude.

You were not unreasonable to ask. you WERE unreasonable to think its a small favour and that you were not going to offer her anything for it.

Get over yourself.

Lenald · 27/01/2023 13:39

It’s not unreasonable that you asked but it IS unreasonable if you’re pissed that she’s changed her mind.

WombatChocolate · 27/01/2023 13:38

Okay. Op has said she doesn’t want to pay the delivery charge. £5 doesn’t sound much to most of us. We don’t know her finances.

We also don’t know about how she’s feeling, her MH etc. Perhaps the car failing it’s MOT and the looming costs have really thrown her. Perhaps she doesn’t cope well. Some people in life need favours or ask for favours from friends, that seem intrusive or too large and unreasonable to many of us.

However, it’s all about context isn’t it.

We don’t know the exact context. I suspect that all is not rosy if OP is asking her friend to do this driving and take this time, rather than get a delivery. There’s probably more going on than just wanting to get a load of shopping.

I’d also suggest that many in this thread seem very harsh and to struggle with the concept of putting yourself out for someone. Of course, it’s totally fine that the friend said she couldn’t take OP shopping. Someone doesn’t have to give a favour and often there can be good reasons not to and it’s fine to say ‘no’. But equally, it’s fine and good to say ‘yes’ too - even if OP could have spent £5 on delivery. Even if it will cost money and take up valuable time. Being a bit self-sacrificing is what lots of people do for their friends when they seem in need, and even for people they don’t really know. Perhaps that’s an alien concept to some people.

The thing is, someone doesn’t have to be desperate and have zero alternative options for someone to ask for help, and those asked should feel they can consider saying yes, and that they’re not being taken huge advantage of, by saying yes, to anything which is less than a desperate plea. It’s a mindset - to either be generous or stingy in our willingness to help others.

Again, it’s fine that the friend said no. But if she had said yes and incurred the cost of petroleum and loss of a couple of hours, that wouldn’t have made her a mug, or OP a CF for asking.

Most of us wouldn’t have responded to the situation by asking the friend to give the lift. Most of us would have organised a delivery or got a taxi or gone to a local shop. The fact OP didn’t do these things, possibly tells us something about her situation not being quite usual and her needing more support than might be initially obvious. I think it’s hard for people to imagine that too, or to not have a reaction of shying away from it, or thinking it’s simply an outrageous ask.

butterpuffed · 27/01/2023 13:37

I don't drive so catch the bus to do my shopping . If I know I'll have to much to carry to the bus stop then I either get a taxi home or do an online shop and pick a cheap slot .

Isn't that what most non drivers do ?

1FootInTheRave · 27/01/2023 13:30

90 minute round trip, not including the actual shopping time.

So you can save a few quid on delivery/taxi.

You're taking the piss.

xogossipgirlxo · 27/01/2023 13:29

knittingaddict · 27/01/2023 13:24

The op has said that she can do an online shop, so people have considered that in their replies. She just doesn't want to spend money on the delivery charge.

Huh. Petrol isn't free too, I'm wondering if she considered this factor she'd have to reimburse friend for this.

knittingaddict · 27/01/2023 13:24

WombatChocolate · 27/01/2023 12:24

People forget that the ‘obvious’ solutions aren’t available to everyone.

Not everyone can get an internet delivery shop….might not have a bank card, or bank account. Might shop with cash only. Might not be able to use internet.

Most people would easily find a solution to this, but some would struggle. If OP couldn’t afford MOT she might have serious financial struggles. We don’t really know.

People are different about favours and friends. Some do live in communities where people ask and give help and it’s totally normal to out yourself out. Others wouldn’t piss on someone burning to death in the gutter.

Often someone only asks an extreme favour or to really out someone out if they don’t have many other options. That’s worth considering in responses.

The op has said that she can do an online shop, so people have considered that in their replies. She just doesn't want to spend money on the delivery charge.

ImmigrantAlice · 27/01/2023 13:22

User367259791 · 27/01/2023 13:19

On MN the rule is that all favours are unacceptable, no one helps each other out. On MN anyone supporting others is a mug, anyone getting a favour is a CF. So, yes, on MN you are a massive CF for even having asked.

In real life then only you know whether it was the kind of thing you do for each other, or not. The fact that you asked and she said no (via a yes, but she was able to say no) suggests you have an honest relationship where these things are normal. In that case, you are not wrong to ask, but she wasn’t wrong to decide it wasn’t possible for her.

Given that the OP has never driven to the friend’s house I’m going with no, it’s not the sort of thing that they do for each other.

I’m thinking that it’s more likely that the OP is always asking for favours and rarely returns them.

User367259791 · 27/01/2023 13:19

On MN the rule is that all favours are unacceptable, no one helps each other out. On MN anyone supporting others is a mug, anyone getting a favour is a CF. So, yes, on MN you are a massive CF for even having asked.

In real life then only you know whether it was the kind of thing you do for each other, or not. The fact that you asked and she said no (via a yes, but she was able to say no) suggests you have an honest relationship where these things are normal. In that case, you are not wrong to ask, but she wasn’t wrong to decide it wasn’t possible for her.

PayPennies · 27/01/2023 13:17

SO many questions -

  1. How much would the petrol money have been? more than a fiver surely? How would you have paid that?
  2. What would happen next week?
  3. What would happen the week after next week?
  4. And the week after? And after?
  5. You really asked someone who lives 20 minutes drive away to come and take you to Tescos and back? The cheek.
redskydelight · 27/01/2023 13:15

WeepingSomnambulist · 27/01/2023 11:20

I think mumsnet is odd sometimes. Or the town I live in is.

Around here, people do this for other school mum's even if we barely know them. If you need a lift somewhere, someone will do it. The town is still using the covid support Facebook page we set up and people will ask for help and strangers will give them a loft for shopping or to an appointment or whatever.

It's lift. it is a couple hours out of your life max. Who cares?

I hope you people never need a favour from your fellow man.

I'd happily take a neighbour or a friend that lived close by shopping (and do my own at the same time).

I'd happily pick up a school mum's child from school if they were running late or had an appointment (even if I barely know them).

If someone had something more serious like a hospital appointment and needed transport, I'd help, even if I barely knew them.

I wouldn't drive 45 minutes (each way) to help a close friend with their shopping unless they were really stuck and had exhausted all other options.
I certainly wouldn't do it for someone I barely knew.

45 minutes drive takes me from the far end of the town and back again and leaves time left over. I struggle to believe that people in your town are regularly doing this for strangers ...

JennyJenny8675309 · 27/01/2023 13:10

I’m glad your friend came to her senses and said put an end to this cheeky request.

thisusernameisnotavailablepleasetryanother · 27/01/2023 13:06

You can't afford the £5 delivery charge but expect your friend to find the fuel money for a 40 minute round trip from hers to you, to Tesco then to yours to drop you home, then back to hers? YABU

MRex · 27/01/2023 12:54

NothingOnTopButABucketAndAMop · 27/01/2023 08:23

Delivery would add at least £5 to my shopping which I can’t really afford but I’ll have to do that now. Just wish she hadn’t initially agreed.

Nearest shop is 15 minute walk away which is difficult for me as I have health issues.

Nonsense, if you see flexible with slots it will cost £1 maximum. It would cost your friend much more than that in petrol and it's disgraceful you thought she should pay for the petrol to drive you around.

If she was your neighbour and going anyway, you might ask to get a lift. Anything else and you're being unreasonable.

JennyJenny8675309 · 27/01/2023 12:48

@FatAgainItsLettuceTime

LOL at your username. I’ve been thinking the same. 😆