Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scottish rapist’s crime to be recorded as female

89 replies

HermioneKipper · 27/01/2023 00:00

mobile.twitter.com/TomSwarbrick1/status/1618739887687204865

Reported via the BBC that Police Scotland have said:

“Isla Bryson’s offences will not be recorded in the official crime statistics as offences perpetrated by a man”

So will be recorded as a woman’s crime.

NO. Not our crimes.

This cannot stand.

I’m beyond angry. I don’t know what to do, I don’t know how to protest.

HELP

OP posts:
Clymene · 27/01/2023 07:56

At the moment there are 25 times more men incarcerated in Scotland than women. There are fewer than 300 women in prison and a very very tiny number of those have committed sexual offences.

Hideous

Scottish rapist’s crime to be recorded as female
yetanotherusernameAgain · 27/01/2023 07:55

I heard the BBC reporter say that on the BBC news last night but she was speaking so quickly I wondered if she had got the words "man" and "woman" mixed up. They certainly didn't follow up on it, which would be odd if it's true: reporting on the decision not to put him in a woman's prison but then say the crime won't be recorded as a man - a reporter would make an issue of that.

So I think she possibly made a rushed mistake and I won't believe it unless it's published in a proper article and not a transcript of the TV news report.

TheAustralian · 27/01/2023 07:54

ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2023 00:44

This in itself is a crime.

He is not only a man now, he even called himself a man when he did it. He did it with a penis.

Then once this crime is recorded as being a woman’s, they’ll say there is ‘no evidence’ to suggest that men who say they are women commit crimes. What’s to see? ‘No man did that’. ‘What are you talking about? ‘

This is living under a dystopian totalitarian system.

Please would all you angry people sign this petition to Update the Equality Act to make clear that the protected characteristic ‘sex’ means biological sex?

This man is not and never will be a woman by sex and no man will ever be. Men commit 98% of violent crimes. Men who say they are women have the same offending rates as ordinary men. Most men who say they are women retain their penis.

Let the Government start with making the language about what sex means - pure biology male and female - absolutely clear.
⬇️
petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

Signed 🤫

sst1234 · 27/01/2023 07:53

Next time you are told to follow the science, show them this. These people don’t want you to follow science, they want you to follow propaganda.

MiaMoor · 27/01/2023 07:52

I read a few weeks ago that in countries that already have self ID they are not reporting crimes as TW or male crimes, and once in female prison no sex offences are being recorded at all, so whilst statistically there are likely to be problems, they’re ignored.

No evidence = no problem.

All those times that we're told that other countries have self ID and it works fine, well we don’t know, because any poor behaviour is swept under the carpet.
I believe there are female prisoners speaking out, but those who need to listen are not.

As always I wonder how any of this got any traction at all. What agenda is pushing this?
When will more women finally stand up to this misogynistic movement?

OneFrenchEgg · 27/01/2023 07:50

I can't get my head round it. How we have arrived at a state where sex and gender (because I don't care if someone male/female wants to dress in the opposte stereotypical way, change their name etc) aren't completely separate with separate clear 'rights'.
I also feel for all those who don't want to identify as the opposite gender but others view them as doing so based on stereotypes.

Spambod · 27/01/2023 07:44

Calling him a woman is gaslighting and like a coercive control of the victims. Calling him a woman is a crime against the victims. It’s abusive.

RedHelenB · 27/01/2023 07:39

Sugarfree23 · 27/01/2023 07:29

Maybe someone actually has the right idea, if he was recorded amongst the mens crime figures it would just be lost and forgotten about.
But recording it as a 'women' crime then it becomes very obvious how many of these 'women' are dangerous to actual females.

The more that is exposed the sooner the tide turns. I don't think I'm making myself clear but I know what I'm trying to say.

You have a point.

RedHelenB · 27/01/2023 07:39

They were a man when he committed the crime and surely that's what counts even with all this transgende ideology? Same as age, you were 30 when you commented the crime, surely that's what gets put in the statistics nit the fact that you were 35 when you were caught and tried?

Waitwhat23 · 27/01/2023 07:38

A thread by For Women Scotland about the Scottish Prison Services risk assessment and the violent male criminals in the female prison estate -
twitter.com/ForWomenScot/status/1618308946523213824?s=20&t=Th6jZO-HyFJMPnioT5oNSA

Waitwhat23 · 27/01/2023 07:36

DoughnutDreams · 27/01/2023 01:25

This isn't anything to do with Scotland, or proposed changes. The case was heard under current law in line with Westminster and crime statistics have been skewed for this reason in the whole of uk for many years now.
Yes it's an issue but remain clear about which issue you are tackling.

England and Scotland now have different systems for recording statistics due to a Home Office change -

www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-news/police-scotland-continue-allow-criminals-26715364

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/home-office-trans-crime-statistics-grc-birth-sex-b2056345.html

Waitwhat23 · 27/01/2023 07:32

AngeloMysterioso · 27/01/2023 03:39

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but the response to this petition was released a few hours ago.

Long story short… the answer is no.

“Under the Equality Act 2010, providers are already able to restrict the use of spaces/services on the basis of sex and/or gender reassignment where justified. Further clarification is not necessary.”

If the signatures get to 100,000, the Government are asked to have a debate about it in Parliament which is why there is a push for more signatures.

forfuckssake23 · 27/01/2023 07:31

Insane. What has happened to the world Angry

Sugarfree23 · 27/01/2023 07:29

Maybe someone actually has the right idea, if he was recorded amongst the mens crime figures it would just be lost and forgotten about.
But recording it as a 'women' crime then it becomes very obvious how many of these 'women' are dangerous to actual females.

The more that is exposed the sooner the tide turns. I don't think I'm making myself clear but I know what I'm trying to say.

SpaceMonitor · 27/01/2023 06:20

How fucking predictable. He wasn’t even claiming to be a woman when he committing rape WITH HIS PENIS! Has anyone started a petition about correctly recording the sex of offenders?

Yousee · 27/01/2023 05:43

ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2023 00:44

This in itself is a crime.

He is not only a man now, he even called himself a man when he did it. He did it with a penis.

Then once this crime is recorded as being a woman’s, they’ll say there is ‘no evidence’ to suggest that men who say they are women commit crimes. What’s to see? ‘No man did that’. ‘What are you talking about? ‘

This is living under a dystopian totalitarian system.

Please would all you angry people sign this petition to Update the Equality Act to make clear that the protected characteristic ‘sex’ means biological sex?

This man is not and never will be a woman by sex and no man will ever be. Men commit 98% of violent crimes. Men who say they are women have the same offending rates as ordinary men. Most men who say they are women retain their penis.

Let the Government start with making the language about what sex means - pure biology male and female - absolutely clear.
⬇️
petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

I just signed the petition and this is the response. It's apparently just us little femalz getting a bit muddled again. What a farce.

Government responded
This response was given on 26 January 2023

Under the Equality Act 2010, providers are already able to restrict the use of spaces/services on the basis of sex and/or gender reassignment where justified. Further clarification is not necessary.

AngeloMysterioso · 27/01/2023 03:39

DalzielMilngavie · 27/01/2023 02:43

This!

Please support this petition, we only need 25k more people sign to trigger a debate.

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but the response to this petition was released a few hours ago.

Long story short… the answer is no.

“Under the Equality Act 2010, providers are already able to restrict the use of spaces/services on the basis of sex and/or gender reassignment where justified. Further clarification is not necessary.”

DalzielMilngavie · 27/01/2023 02:43

ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2023 00:44

This in itself is a crime.

He is not only a man now, he even called himself a man when he did it. He did it with a penis.

Then once this crime is recorded as being a woman’s, they’ll say there is ‘no evidence’ to suggest that men who say they are women commit crimes. What’s to see? ‘No man did that’. ‘What are you talking about? ‘

This is living under a dystopian totalitarian system.

Please would all you angry people sign this petition to Update the Equality Act to make clear that the protected characteristic ‘sex’ means biological sex?

This man is not and never will be a woman by sex and no man will ever be. Men commit 98% of violent crimes. Men who say they are women have the same offending rates as ordinary men. Most men who say they are women retain their penis.

Let the Government start with making the language about what sex means - pure biology male and female - absolutely clear.
⬇️
petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

This!

Please support this petition, we only need 25k more people sign to trigger a debate.

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

DulcetTones · 27/01/2023 02:23

Why do we always end up with idiots in charge, making these decisions? Stupid, spineless politicians and law-makers!

Whitefly · 27/01/2023 01:35

There is something wrong with people who vote in these laws, those demanding them and employees who carry out crimes against humanity.

DoughnutDreams · 27/01/2023 01:25

This isn't anything to do with Scotland, or proposed changes. The case was heard under current law in line with Westminster and crime statistics have been skewed for this reason in the whole of uk for many years now.
Yes it's an issue but remain clear about which issue you are tackling.

RecordsTurning · 27/01/2023 01:20

It’s disgusting.

My only hope is that cases like these bring this issue to more people’s attention. I’ve had discussions with people who were not very aware of the wider issues around trans ideology in the last couple of days, due to this case, and they’re appalled now they know. That is a good thing.

I can’t imagine how the victims of this man feel, as if they haven’t been through enough.

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 01:17

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/01/2023 01:08

If there is any small benefit to this nonsense it is that it will be really bloody obvious soon how many sex offenders are conveniently identifying as female. There will suddenly be a massive, ridiculous spike in 'women rapists' so the data will be obvious.

If you think this will definitely not get buried you have not been paying attention.

Rape and sex offenses in general don't matter to the British press if they think it might be unseemly to talk too much about who the perpetrators are. It is as true now as it was during the days of Jimmy Saville and his powerful accomplices, and sadly many things since then.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/01/2023 01:08

If there is any small benefit to this nonsense it is that it will be really bloody obvious soon how many sex offenders are conveniently identifying as female. There will suddenly be a massive, ridiculous spike in 'women rapists' so the data will be obvious.

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 01:02

Celia24 · 27/01/2023 00:46

So wait a minute. He isn't going to be in a woman's prison but will be recorded as a woman? What an effing joke.

Not sure what you mean 'slow hand clap Scotland' @AndyWarholsPiehole - most of us are against it as polls show.

Presumably imprisoning someone "not in a women's prison but a woman" also means some super expensive special arrangement tailored to one person. In the modern UK where some basic public services are so strained they often cannot respond even if your life literally depends on it.