Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scottish rapist’s crime to be recorded as female

89 replies

HermioneKipper · 27/01/2023 00:00

mobile.twitter.com/TomSwarbrick1/status/1618739887687204865

Reported via the BBC that Police Scotland have said:

“Isla Bryson’s offences will not be recorded in the official crime statistics as offences perpetrated by a man”

So will be recorded as a woman’s crime.

NO. Not our crimes.

This cannot stand.

I’m beyond angry. I don’t know what to do, I don’t know how to protest.

HELP

OP posts:
Deathbyfluffy · 27/01/2023 09:11

Celia24 · 27/01/2023 00:46

So wait a minute. He isn't going to be in a woman's prison but will be recorded as a woman? What an effing joke.

Not sure what you mean 'slow hand clap Scotland' @AndyWarholsPiehole - most of us are against it as polls show.

It’s probably more of a slow clap for your First Minister, who once again shows how inept she is.

NoDairyNoProblem · 27/01/2023 09:10

The entire terminology surrounding crime against women needs to be changed.

X amount of women were raped in January - No, X amount of men raped women in January.

lifeturnsonadime · 27/01/2023 09:08

This is what happens when language is muddled.

In the UK the crime of rape is defined as penetration with a penis. Only a person with a penis (we used to have a word for that) could commit the crime of rape.

Now that people with penises can be women, which is the end game for gender ideology, rape can be a crime committed by a woman in the UK.

This is why many feminists on these boards are objecting to changing language.

It was interesting the other day because a women (the cervix kind) in the US was flabbergasted that there is no word in the US for rape by penetration of a penis as that doesn't exist as a crime in it's on right in the US. Rape can be penetration by penis or by insertion of an object.

Either way this whole thing is disgusting and only benefits penis people.

Wouldn't it be great to get our words and our rights to be treated as separate from the penis people back?

Isthisexpected · 27/01/2023 09:01

So mad I tried to sign the petition not recalling I already did it a couple of days ago! We just can't stand for this.

TreadLight · 27/01/2023 08:53

KangarooKenny · 27/01/2023 08:16

But women are incapable of rape, so it’s impossible that it’s a female crime.

There have been various women convicted of rape over the years

www.theguardian.com/uk/2001/mar/17/sarahhall

www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/woman-jailed-life-rape-and-sexual-abuse-young-girl

They are few, but they do exist.

I also have a male friend who has had a women force herself on him, but as the definition of rape is a legal definition, that was not considered rape.

SauMore · 27/01/2023 08:24

Surely an offence has to be recorded as committed by the gender the person was at the time they committed the offence?
The rape was committed by a man. He subsequently "decided" he was a woman but he identified as a man when he committed the rape

FrancescaContini · 27/01/2023 08:23

Shona Robinson is a disgrace. I don’t know what mental gymnastics she puts her brain through to concoct such outrageous word salad. I don’t know how she sleeps at night.

If the police record this crime as being committed by a woman, they will be lying. How can the public trust the authorities if they don’t tell the truth?

Whoopsmahoot · 27/01/2023 08:23

FFS 🤦‍♀️ Scotland has gone nuts- pity I live here.

Anyotherdude · 27/01/2023 08:20

Hang on a minute…
If a crime is committed by a child, at an age that they are below the age of criminal responsibility, then they are tried as a child.
This ruling means that if it takes enough time to get to court and the child is no longer below the age of criminal responsibility, then surely they should be tried as an adult? No - that’s not what happens…
It doesn’t make any sense at all. At the time the rapes were committed, the defendant was a MAN so should be tried and imprisoned as a man.
Then they can find out first hand their error in their attempted manipulation of the justice system, and discourage those who try to pervert the course of justice in future.

KangarooKenny · 27/01/2023 08:16

But women are incapable of rape, so it’s impossible that it’s a female crime.

Tileuh · 27/01/2023 08:13

ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2023 00:44

This in itself is a crime.

He is not only a man now, he even called himself a man when he did it. He did it with a penis.

Then once this crime is recorded as being a woman’s, they’ll say there is ‘no evidence’ to suggest that men who say they are women commit crimes. What’s to see? ‘No man did that’. ‘What are you talking about? ‘

This is living under a dystopian totalitarian system.

Please would all you angry people sign this petition to Update the Equality Act to make clear that the protected characteristic ‘sex’ means biological sex?

This man is not and never will be a woman by sex and no man will ever be. Men commit 98% of violent crimes. Men who say they are women have the same offending rates as ordinary men. Most men who say they are women retain their penis.

Let the Government start with making the language about what sex means - pure biology male and female - absolutely clear.
⬇️
petition.parliament.uk/petitions/623243

They already responded and said...

The Government's response
Under the Equality Act 2010, providers are already able to restrict the use of spaces/services on the basis of sex and/or gender reassignment where justified. Further clarification is not necessary.

The Equality Act 2010 provides protection against discrimination, harassment and victimisation across a number of grounds, including sex. We are committed to upholding Britain’s long-standing record of protecting the rights of individuals against unlawful discrimination.

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) have published guidance on the existing legislation which provides much needed clarity to those offering single-sex spaces. It does not change the legal position or the law.

As the guidance makes clear, it is entirely acceptable for providers of single-sex services to take account of the biological sex of their service users. Where it is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim, the Equality Act 2010 is clear that service providers can exclude, modify or limit access for transgender people, even where they have a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC). This includes where a service provider has concerns that the presence of individuals who are biologically male could prevent them from meeting their aims, such as in the example below, included in the guidance:

“A group counselling session is provided for female victims of sexual assault. The organisers do not allow trans women to attend as they judge that the clients who attend the group session are likely to be traumatised by the presence of a person who is biologically male.”

It is important that providers of single-sex services are clear that biological sex can be taken into consideration when providing services.

The Government is committed to maintaining the safeguards that allow organisations to provide single-sex spaces. It is important that the principle of being able to operate spaces reserved for women and girls is maintained. Government is committed to tackling harassment and abusive behaviours by all individuals, and ensuring single-sex spaces are safe for those using them.

Waitwhat23 · 27/01/2023 08:13

RebeccaCloud9 · 27/01/2023 08:07

Surely, SURELY he was just trying to get away with pretending to be a woman to get access to female prisons/get away with it? Why are people calling him a woman at all? It's a total f-ing farce.

To quote Scotland’s social justice secretary Shona Robison (my bolds) -

“The first thing I would say is to point again to the evidence given by the Scottish Human Rights Commission where they were very clear that there is no body of evidence, at least in the countries that have now got a system of statutory declaration, that points to bad faith actors trying to use this process in order to abuse women and girls,” she said.

“All of the evidence really points that the abuse of women and girls comes from predatory men who there’s no evidence of them using a system of statutory declaration for gender recognition in order to abuse women and girls.

“There’s just no evidence of that.”

They are head in the sand, fingers in ears ignoring the issue of violent men in women's prisons and have allowed the Scottish Prison System to set policy, advised by a political lobby group who said - ‘We strategized – we strategized – that by working intensively with the Scottish Prison Service to support them to include trans women as women on a self-declaration basis within very challenging circumstances, we would be able to ensure that all other public services should be able to do likewise’.

KangarooKenny · 27/01/2023 08:11

Please tell me that Scottish women are protesting against this and demanding Sturgeon’s resignation ?

Workerbeep · 27/01/2023 08:09

@RebeccaCloud9 Ah but SNP Shona Robison and her pal NS said that would NEVER happen.

RebeccaCloud9 · 27/01/2023 08:07

Surely, SURELY he was just trying to get away with pretending to be a woman to get access to female prisons/get away with it? Why are people calling him a woman at all? It's a total f-ing farce.

Workerbeep · 27/01/2023 08:06

@DoughnutDreams It has everything to do with scotland because it has happened in Scotland.

it happens in England? Ok, Aunt Nicola and her cronies could have been different; they keep harping on about how bloody unique, righteous and much better Scotland is.

how is this falsifying of records be allowed to happen? Where are the gate keepers? No better than flat Earthers, except their opinions are really quite inconsequential.

Well we the electorate allowed it to happen and yes I am Scottish and live on Scotland.

Toadybum · 27/01/2023 08:04

ClaudeMyWinkleman · 27/01/2023 07:56

I would love to know the transgender communities respond/opinion on this. Surely they can see this isn't right as well and isn't how they want their cause highlighted.

I would also like to know this.

BabyStopCryin · 27/01/2023 08:03

If he was a woman he could not have committed these crimes.

What am I missing?

RudsyFarmer · 27/01/2023 08:01

I’m reading through the comments and you can see the Penny starting to drip with some of these TWAW activists. It’s a movement that seemed initially to be exactly the same as gay rights but it’s very slowly dawning on naturally left leaning, educated people that this cause ISN’T quite the same (which is what we’ve been saying for years).

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 27/01/2023 08:01

I’ve never protested against anything in my life but since seeing this on the news last night I am fully prepared to go and super glue myself to whatever needed.
I can’t describe the anger and utter bewilderment! How fucking DARE they!?!?!?

Waitwhat23 · 27/01/2023 08:00

Spambod · 27/01/2023 07:44

Calling him a woman is gaslighting and like a coercive control of the victims. Calling him a woman is a crime against the victims. It’s abusive.

Up until recently the judicial system required victims to use preferred pronouns in court, under the Equal Treatment Bench Book. A woman violently attacked by a transwoman was forced to refer to her attacker as her in court and iirc had her compensation reduced by the judge as punishment for not doing so. A recent amendment thankfully (hopefully) has changed that -

www.legalfeminist.org.uk/2022/01/03/the-new-interim-version-of-the-equal-treatment-bench-book/

murrayblackburnmackenzie.org/2022/03/23/update-petition-on-accurately-recording-the-sex-of-people-charged-or-convicted-of-rape-or-attempted-rape/

Women are still having to hear their attackers referred to by their preferred pronouns by the media due to IPSO rules -
fairplayforwomen.com/ipso/

piedbeauty · 27/01/2023 07:58

I heard that in the news and was shouting at the tv. Stupid, stupid.

#notourcrimes

Sugarfree23 · 27/01/2023 07:58

As always I wonder how any of this got any traction at all. What agenda is pushing this?

I've two thoughts on that, it's either predatory males who want to open the door to all female spaces, or it's someone attacking Western Society.

I can't imagine the trans movement has much traction in the likes of China or Russia.

ClaudeMyWinkleman · 27/01/2023 07:56

I would love to know the transgender communities respond/opinion on this. Surely they can see this isn't right as well and isn't how they want their cause highlighted.