Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scottish rapist’s crime to be recorded as female

89 replies

HermioneKipper · 27/01/2023 00:00

mobile.twitter.com/TomSwarbrick1/status/1618739887687204865

Reported via the BBC that Police Scotland have said:

“Isla Bryson’s offences will not be recorded in the official crime statistics as offences perpetrated by a man”

So will be recorded as a woman’s crime.

NO. Not our crimes.

This cannot stand.

I’m beyond angry. I don’t know what to do, I don’t know how to protest.

HELP

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Failingatthemoment · 18/05/2023 15:46

Surely common sense states if a "woman with a penis" ( ridiculous term but there you go) commits the crime then it's rape??!!!!

SammyScrounge · 18/05/2023 15:29

Celia24 · 27/01/2023 00:46

So wait a minute. He isn't going to be in a woman's prison but will be recorded as a woman? What an effing joke.

Not sure what you mean 'slow hand clap Scotland' @AndyWarholsPiehole - most of us are against it as polls show.

True.but too any keep voting Sturgeon and her merry band in.power. For that, Scots deserve the slow hand clap.

Untitledsquatboulder · 02/03/2023 07:43

KangarooKenny · 27/01/2023 08:16

But women are incapable of rape, so it’s impossible that it’s a female crime.

If men can legally become women (which they now can) and do so without changing their genitals (this is not necessary under the law to change sex 🤔 ) then voilà - women can have penises and can commit rape. Progress innit.

watcherintherye · 27/01/2023 13:13

sst1234 · 27/01/2023 07:53

Next time you are told to follow the science, show them this. These people don’t want you to follow science, they want you to follow propaganda.

Yes, we were told to be guided by the science (until it stopped being convenient) all through Covid. Why aren’t politicians being guided by the science now? You can change your identity all you like, in ways as extreme as you like, but you cannot, ever, change your sex.

kagerou · 27/01/2023 13:09

They should make a separate category for recording crimes of trans men and trans women. I don't think anyone would have a problem with that (would still be recording people's preference for gender and accurately recording their lived existence while also providing some very useful statistics)

ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2023 13:07

And it is important to remember the very great difference in the percentage of crimes committed by men compared to those committed by women.
(Please would someone fill that in?)

So those women convicted of rape because they aided and abetted it, vile as they are, can’t really be used as an example of ‘but women rape too’ except as an interesting fact.

And that men who believe or say they are women have the same offending rate as ordinary men or possibly higher.

Waitwhat23 · 27/01/2023 13:02

This thread is a good starting point -

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3145470-Break-it-down-for-me

BlueBooh · 27/01/2023 12:55

This and much more has been discussed on the feminism board for years.

Can you now see why we are so angry?

It's not all about being kind and letting people use any toilet they want.

Got to the board have a read. Most of it will sadly shock you even more.

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 12:53

Abitofalark · 27/01/2023 12:48

The poster was correct in that rape is defined in law as penetration by a penis. A woman does not rape.
However, a woman can procure or participate in or encourage an attack on a woman that constitutes rape or involves rape and be found guilty of the offence of rape by reason of being involved in joint enterprise.

Thanks for posting this, clearly any discussion of/requests for information on women convicted needs to allow for this.

hryllilegur · 27/01/2023 12:52

It’s the whole ‘make the statistics meaningless and then claim there’s no evidence’ trick.

MichaelFabricantWig · 27/01/2023 12:50

Heard this last night on the news, I was appalled.

Winebeckons · 27/01/2023 12:49

If anyone's up for starting a petition about this for it to be discussed in parliament , please see my post on the Feminism discussion board. Your name will be published with the petition and mine is too unusual and would be completely outing. If there are any people with not so unusual names who would be willing to take the baton, please do. I've supplied the link and all the answers to what they ask.

Abitofalark · 27/01/2023 12:48

TreadLight · 27/01/2023 08:53

There have been various women convicted of rape over the years

www.theguardian.com/uk/2001/mar/17/sarahhall

www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/woman-jailed-life-rape-and-sexual-abuse-young-girl

They are few, but they do exist.

I also have a male friend who has had a women force herself on him, but as the definition of rape is a legal definition, that was not considered rape.

The poster was correct in that rape is defined in law as penetration by a penis. A woman does not rape.
However, a woman can procure or participate in or encourage an attack on a woman that constitutes rape or involves rape and be found guilty of the offence of rape by reason of being involved in joint enterprise.

tuvamoodyson · 27/01/2023 12:45

His crime is being recorded as committed by a man since it happened before ‘he transitioned’ Daily Record.

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 12:40

Has anyone already done a freedom of information request to see how many women were convicted of rape in 2022?

I was thinking of doing one, but not sure how to word it without them going "shields up!"

Sugarfree23 · 27/01/2023 12:36

“There’s just no evidence of that.”

Well there is now a woman with a penis has been convicted of rape.

Definitely keep it in the woman crime stats don't get it buried in with male crimes the more women with penis crimes are listed as that the harder it becomes for people to say women with penii should be allowed to share women with vaginas spaces.

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 12:33

ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2023 12:21

ConcordeOoter · Today 12:13

Also, we should leave it as it is because changing the language will actually serve to HIDE the reality that is going to be clearly detectable by looking at crime statistics.

I thought that at present, under our current use of language, males who commit a crime who say they are women have their crime recorded as a woman’s crime. So the crime statistics are hidden.

At the moment there is no codified concept of women raping, so all instances of females convicted are obvious.

Once we introduce the idea of women raping, we will see many of the sex offences committed by women categorized as "rape" and the problem will disappear in a puff of statistical fuckery as so many other serious sex crimes have before.

ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2023 12:21

ConcordeOoter · Today 12:13

Also, we should leave it as it is because changing the language will actually serve to HIDE the reality that is going to be clearly detectable by looking at crime statistics.

I thought that at present, under our current use of language, males who commit a crime who say they are women have their crime recorded as a woman’s crime. So the crime statistics are hidden.

ConcordeOoter · 27/01/2023 12:13

NoDairyNoProblem · 27/01/2023 09:10

The entire terminology surrounding crime against women needs to be changed.

X amount of women were raped in January - No, X amount of men raped women in January.

I disagree.

Firstly because it is redundant: every rapist is a man. Nobody should need to state this.

Secondly "men" is an immutable characteristic of many innocent people and explicitly stating "they" do it like it is done collectively is prejudice: not all men are rapists

Explicitly prejudiced language in public life, grounded in truth or not, becomes self-fulfilling prophecy.

Also, we should leave it as it is because changing the language will actually serve to HIDE the reality that is going to be clearly detectable by looking at crime statistics.

C8H10N4O2 · 27/01/2023 10:51

IDontCareMatthew · 27/01/2023 00:14

Is there a link?

I've only seen the article about going to a men's prison not women's

Worth noting that Sturgeon very carefully said this predator would not now go to Cornton Vale along with lots of performance shock horror that rapists don't belong in women's prisons.

She did not say that the rapist would not be housed in a women's unit. Women's units exist in men's prisons.

This is exactly what Sturgeon, SNP and Greens and far too many on both sides at Westminster insist would never happen because predators wouldn't do nasty things like take advantage of any gaps in safeguarding. Apparently none of these people have any knowledge of history.

yetanotherusernameAgain · 27/01/2023 09:40

I've searched 'Police Scotland' and 'transgender' to see if there's anything on whether Bryson's crimes will be recorded as committed by a man or woman but didn't find anything. However there were articles in February last year (2022) saying Police Scotland were reviewing their policy of recording people by how they self-identify their gender. An article by The Ferret in April 2022 said that the Scottish Policy Authority had upheld the policy.

www.lbc.co.uk/news/police-scotland-launch-review-of-policy-which-lets-male-rapists-identify-as-wome/

theferret.scot/trans-victims-of-crime-still-self-id-home-office/

So maybe it is true and the media haven't twigged yet.

Meanwhile, the front pages of Scottish newspapers today is a sight to behold, especially The Scottish Sun:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-64422632

As for what TRAs think of Bryson, they'll probably rely on the fact that he decided to transition after being charged, suggesting it was a deliberate ploy and therefore he isn't a 'real' TW. Even Nicola managed to weasel out of it in her radio interview this week by referring to a situation where someone misuses transitioning, rather than saying a transwoman rapist shouldn't be in a women's prison.

TreadLight · 27/01/2023 09:37

Toadybum · 27/01/2023 09:26

A quick read says that the woman in Cheshire was not convicted of rape.

She was convicted of 34 offenses, one of which was rape.

Oysterbabe · 27/01/2023 09:28

If there's any silver lining, it's that this whole thing has shon a big bright light on the issues. People who hadn't given the matter any thought are now talking about it.

Toadybum · 27/01/2023 09:26

TreadLight · 27/01/2023 08:53

There have been various women convicted of rape over the years

www.theguardian.com/uk/2001/mar/17/sarahhall

www.cps.gov.uk/mersey-cheshire/news/woman-jailed-life-rape-and-sexual-abuse-young-girl

They are few, but they do exist.

I also have a male friend who has had a women force herself on him, but as the definition of rape is a legal definition, that was not considered rape.

A quick read says that the woman in Cheshire was not convicted of rape.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 27/01/2023 09:23

NoDairyNoProblem · 27/01/2023 09:10

The entire terminology surrounding crime against women needs to be changed.

X amount of women were raped in January - No, X amount of men raped women in January.

Although I agree in theory, in practice that can't be done (unless you have a 100% clear up rate for all rapes).

10 women raped could mean 1 man raping, or 10, or more ....

Swipe left for the next trending thread