Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if manager did this deliberately

182 replies

Eastie77Returns · 26/01/2023 22:38

I had my annual pay review today over a call. My manager opened the document up on a shared screen and began talking me through it. It was immediately clear to me I was looking at someone else’s document and the base pay was completely different to mine. Overall this person is paid £80k more than me. I was so stunned at this discrepancy I could not register what my manager was saying to me. After a few minutes she ‘realised’ the mistake and shut down the document.

She is usually meticulous and can’t believe this was an error so I think for some reason she wants me to know. She made a point of telling me at the start of the call that she had just finished ‘Jane’s’ pay review (my colleague) so I don’t know if I’m suppose to conclude this is Jane’s pay.

Needless to say I am job hunting.

I am so confounded by this whole situation, I am just in a daze. I knew people in my team were paid different amounts but never dreamt the discrepancy could be so wide. I think I am probably the lowest paid member of the team.

OP posts:
ChilliBandit · 28/01/2023 13:59

EthicalNonMahogany · 28/01/2023 13:15

Don't think there's a problem with the CV updating question - my cv is up to date but I still wouldn't have exact achievements and their impacts recorded, that is something you do to punch it up at the moment you're thinking of applying for something.

I am interested in why OP thinks she hasn't been promoted or progressed. Your managers may be crap and just listening to who shouts loudest - that could well be true.

But there's something about knowing what your manager's problems are and how you can help to solve them- thinking up a level- that people need to do who want promotion. It's different from doing your own specific job and it is a bit networky I'm afraid.

Exactly! Mine is up to date in that it has my most recent employments/qualifications listed but I add more around the time of looking for new jobs, swap out previously listed experience for more recent projects I’ve done. I don’t tend to update it in real time.

What does it matter though, some posters seem to think it’s a “gotcha” moment but I can’t see the relevance to what the OP is asking about.

StalkedByASpider · 28/01/2023 13:46

Eastie77Returns · 26/01/2023 23:49

To clarify, the £80k difference is total pay including commission and a specific allowance we get. So the base pay was £30k more than mine. Then the Commission (not guaranteed but we usually get close to 100%) plus the allowance took this persons pay to £80k more.

Pay rises only take place once a year and managers have made it clear they receive a set budget and have to split it amongst their teams so no room for manoeuvre.

Even if I received another rise it’s not going to be anywhere close to this persons pay and it will gnaw away at me, hence looking for another job. I feel embarrassed and demoralised.

I work in IT.

I used to be a manager running a technical team (not IT). It was the same for us - we had a budget that us managers had to split between everyone and even if someone really, really deserved a huge pay rise, if it wasn't in the year's budget, then there was absolutely nothing we could do. And someone being paid less than others wouldn't be seen as a reasonable excuse to blow the budget and hand out a big pay rise.

I worked for a very large company, which was probably half of the problem. Everything was planned so far ahead and budgeted meticulously. The company is ridiculously successful but everything is kept so stripped back there's not a spare penny to be found anywhere.

So I totally sympathise OP.

Also, your later comments regarding networking - I can't imagine anything worse. Balls to that. Go and find somewhere that values you for doing the excellent job you very clearly do.

ps - I remember the gratitude journal thread, and I have to say, I don't think it would be a bad thing to escape your manager either! 😅

Plbrookes · 28/01/2023 13:41

CappuccinoFace · 28/01/2023 11:42

Hope you took a screenshot! (always be ready to screenshot 😂)

Working with multiple screens, it is easy to share the wrong thing so I wouldn't assume it was deliberate. But now you know so you can do something about it (internally or leave for a new job) or you need to forget and move on. It's going to be turbulent times in IT (esp sales) ahead though.

You would have taken a screenshot of someone's personal data that you had been shown in error? It's clear the sort of person you are ...

EthicalNonMahogany · 28/01/2023 13:15

Don't think there's a problem with the CV updating question - my cv is up to date but I still wouldn't have exact achievements and their impacts recorded, that is something you do to punch it up at the moment you're thinking of applying for something.

I am interested in why OP thinks she hasn't been promoted or progressed. Your managers may be crap and just listening to who shouts loudest - that could well be true.

But there's something about knowing what your manager's problems are and how you can help to solve them- thinking up a level- that people need to do who want promotion. It's different from doing your own specific job and it is a bit networky I'm afraid.

Trez1510 · 28/01/2023 12:59

ChilliBandit · 28/01/2023 12:44

Is there any post, no matter how innocuous, that is immune from the wannabe Sherlocks on here?

Sorry, I must have missed the 'critical thinking' check-in booth as I arrived.

ChilliBandit · 28/01/2023 12:44

Is there any post, no matter how innocuous, that is immune from the wannabe Sherlocks on here?

Trez1510 · 28/01/2023 12:30

There are quite a few elephants in this room, not least the OP cannot be certain the details were Jane's details.

Beyond that, everyone saying the manager did this deliberately, on what are you basing that? That the OP said the manager is meticulous? Meticulous people are 100% error-free, 100% of the time? An off-hand remark that the manager had just concluded Jane's review? Really?

Let's hypothosise - the details were Jane's. Jane 'recently' promoted to the identical job as OP has already outearned OP by some £50k in commission. What does that tell us? It actually tells us nothing concrete. We don't know just how 'recently' Jane was promoted, whether she's been given or earned 'juicier' contracts or whether she's just worked a damned sight harder than OP. What it does tell us is Jane is almost certainly hungrier for the job than OP i.e. £50k hungrier. It also tells us that, most likely, those 'recently' appointing Jane to the identical job as OP were very astute in recognising the potential in Jane and offered her a higher basic salary on that potential. Potential which, on the face of it, has materialised into productivity.

Let's hypothosise - the details were not Jane's. To whom else could they belong? Someone more senior to both Jane and OP within the manager's team? The manager's own details? In fact they could be anyone's because, and we're back to the first elephant here, the OP cannot be certain they were Jane's details.

Oh, and I'm with @Aprilx in being confused by OP's posts about having her CV up to date because (ironically) the manager insisted this was a good thing to do (11:19 post) and her having just trawled through her emails etc. to 'update' her CV with many (until that morning) forgotten about accomplishments and achievements (14:43 post).

MN at its finest. Chasing ghosts and making up a narrative based on zero facts.

WithSympathies · 28/01/2023 11:52

Hey @Eastie77Returns , this sounds rough.

I've left jobs before because I felt it undignified to get into negotiations over pay discrepancies. They had already lost my trust and damaged my self- worth. It sounds like you feel the same?

Have you considered getting some professional coaching? It would help you kick your job search off properly, and when you do get another job, help you present the face the company needs to see in order to invest in you. It sounds like you have all the skills, but lack confidence.

Not everyone is naturally magnetic. Some people are great at schmoozing, and this appeals to certain people, but doesn't necessarily mean they're technical experts.

However, if you are indeed an expert in your field, learning to schmooze could be your next step in professional development. It sounds disingenuous, but if you want to work in large corporations, you need to find some way of making yourself stand out in a crowd.

CappuccinoFace · 28/01/2023 11:42

Hope you took a screenshot! (always be ready to screenshot 😂)

Working with multiple screens, it is easy to share the wrong thing so I wouldn't assume it was deliberate. But now you know so you can do something about it (internally or leave for a new job) or you need to forget and move on. It's going to be turbulent times in IT (esp sales) ahead though.

Chaz5rascals · 28/01/2023 11:20

You genuinely sound lovely and as much as I believe you should bring this up so it’s out in the open it may not get you far especially as you may want a reference from her when you look for a new job (which sounds like something you want to do anyway!)

ChilliBandit · 28/01/2023 11:19

Why is it that across three companies I’ve worked for, the Mental Health first aiders are normally the ones causing the environment that fosters poor mental health. Maybe I’ve been unlucky, but it definitely seems to attract a certain type of person.

ChilliBandit · 28/01/2023 11:16

Blisterinthe · 28/01/2023 10:19

I read the “mental health first aider” comment you made, and it’s really neither here nor there. It just means that a person has been trained to be there for a person in crisis, get them water, make sure they are safe before they get professional help (In very simple terms, I’m a MHFA trainer).

Second, internal brand is so important in certain roles unfortunately. It’s easy enough to do even without working overtime or going to every work event. And a lot of mums overlook the importance of this. It’s about making yourself seen and heard, making it clear what your objectives are and where you want to be in the future. If the answer is same job with better pay why bother? Go apply somewhere else. Most companies unfortunately just don’t care about people who have stalled and have no intention to grow.

Just Mums eh?

I find your post really condescending. No internal brand is not that, I think most women can do those things, even with their silly baby brains. It’s a corporate buzz word and basically means nothing in my experience.

justasking111 · 28/01/2023 10:54

I've had friends leave jobs for this reason. Further down the road they've been approached by old company for a more senior role. It's time to move forward @Eastie77Returns

Silverd83 · 28/01/2023 10:44

I had something similar fairly recently when a colleague told me what she was being paid and it was almost 50% more than me in a role I had been promoted from. She had been recently employed at the market rate, I'd been in the business years and was clearly having the p*ss taken out of me and it made me feel sick and completely undervalued. I was honest with my manager and told her how it made me feel and salary was increased to match and I was given some other benefits. However, it has changed my view of the business forever and they have lost my loyalty. Do whats right for you.

backatchababy · 28/01/2023 10:41

why are you not addressing this head on? You have seen that someone doing the same job is being paid vast amounts more than you (bonus not included as presumably that’s performance related). I’d be requesting a meeting with boss lady for Monday morning to ask how you can work this out without involving HR/union/ACAS etc

if you’re always this passive about pay reviews TBH I’m not surprised you’re earning less than your colleagues but the figures you state a staggering
all relative of course and if you’re earning £500k then an extra £25k could just be canny negotiating

fancydressjess · 28/01/2023 10:39

I totally understand you wanting a fresh start with everything considered...
I mean yes, have the conversation with your current employers too, ideally with an offer in your hand for confidence...
And yes, to some extent you do still need to learn to promote yourself within any organisation
BUT it seems like fighting to change your work persona when you've been overlooked for a long time could be draining and demoralising and I would want to move on... If at all possible to where I already knew someone who could tell me what the workplace culture was like...
All the best x

skyeisthelimit · 28/01/2023 10:37

The manager has breached GDPR because you have seen somebody else's highly sensitive personal data. This is a huge mistake on the managers part and she should have reported the breach to higher management.

It depends how far you want to take this, but you could go to management above her, and say that you saw this document and you now know how much Jane earns and you want to know why there is such a huge discrepancy.

If they say it is because Jane does XYZ more than you, then ask how you can achieve the same level of work/pay.

Patineur · 28/01/2023 10:24

I've just been looking at your highly entertaining thread on the cringe-making gratitude journals. Does your manager still insist on these? You could get together with a friend to use them to talk each other up and campaign for wage rises. For instance friend could keep recording her gratitude for your brilliant performance on various projects, for you helping others, for the way you can always be relied on, and you could do the same for her.

Blisterinthe · 28/01/2023 10:19

I read the “mental health first aider” comment you made, and it’s really neither here nor there. It just means that a person has been trained to be there for a person in crisis, get them water, make sure they are safe before they get professional help (In very simple terms, I’m a MHFA trainer).

Second, internal brand is so important in certain roles unfortunately. It’s easy enough to do even without working overtime or going to every work event. And a lot of mums overlook the importance of this. It’s about making yourself seen and heard, making it clear what your objectives are and where you want to be in the future. If the answer is same job with better pay why bother? Go apply somewhere else. Most companies unfortunately just don’t care about people who have stalled and have no intention to grow.

Mumuser124 · 28/01/2023 10:08

But if she is earning £50k in commission more than you, does that not mean her productivity is higher than yours?

ChilliBandit · 28/01/2023 10:02

daisychain01 · 28/01/2023 08:21

It's a perfectly valid and reliable approach to use email as a way of identifying accomplishments. Work Email is full of confirmations, transactions and conversations.

Plus Calendar is a good way of flicking back through meetings that took place in the course of the review year, which will align to Annual Objectives/ Goals.

I agree, I often forget about projects I’ve worked on as they come one after another and then I look back through emails and think oh yeah!

Fruitbatdancer · 28/01/2023 09:54

I work in IT. I get it. I have a big team and several on it in your situation.
I’d never do what your boss did, but I’m suprised you didn’t alredy know/ talk with colleagues to know you’re under paid. Reality of IT these days is you make the jumps by moving. There’s a chance if you leave they’ll counter offer (it’s the only way I’m allowed to do internal salary hikes) but some companies have a policy not to, and to be honest by time someone’s resigned they checked out anyway.
use this to drive the next move and make the jump. Jobs are no longer for life. If you can’t cope and be motivated knowing what you know then time to leave. I’m sorry as I know it hurts! (I’ve been there!) 💐

nvcontrolfreak · 28/01/2023 09:42

This IS a blessing in disguise - just look for another job. I have also made a mistake of staying in the same company for too long to only find out that men in my team had much higher bonuses and salaries. I have since switched jobs several times -(not talking job hopping but switching every 3-4-5 years) rather than staying in one job for 11 years. Every time, it was a meaningful uptick in comp and job title/responsibility. I was also terrified of adjusting to a new job, how it would fit with family responsibilities etc. Guess what, it works. And the more senior you get, the more flexibility (although not hours - that often goes up, especially initially). I regret not being more proactive earlier. There’s always a risk - one workplace was an absolutely toxic cesspit which I left after three years, but it gave me a very good addition to my CV, comp bump and led me to getting my current job that I enjoy hugely and which pays even more. Just go for it!

DesertRose64 · 28/01/2023 09:39

Eastie77Returns · 27/01/2023 14:43

I think this whole situation is a blessing in disguise. I’ve spent the morning working on my CV as I haven’t looked at it in so long. I’ve had to go through my emails and files to compile a list of my achievements and actually realise how much I’ve accomplished.

I’m so glad you’ve been able to see how much you’ve accomplished.

All the best going forward.

SoulCaptain · 28/01/2023 09:29

OP your boss has done you a huge favour - it looks to me that she wants you to be aware so that you can negotiate a better package for yourself. Before you decide to leave you need to have a conversation with her about reviewing your salary to be competitive/in line with benchmarks etc etc. Good luck!

Swipe left for the next trending thread